perm filename TIMING.MSG[TIM,LSP]15 blob
sn#635676 filedate 1982-01-18 generic text, type C, neo UTF8
COMMENT ⊗ VALID 00133 PAGES
C REC PAGE DESCRIPTION
C00001 00001
C00017 00002 ∂27-Feb-81 1334 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
C00019 00003 ∂27-Feb-81 1342 Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI> Timings
C00021 00004 ∂27-Feb-81 1354 RPG Timings
C00023 00005 ∂27-Feb-81 1412 Bruce E. Edwards <BEE at MIT-AI> Re: timings
C00025 00006 ∂27-Feb-81 1427 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
C00026 00007 ∂27-Feb-81 1502 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
C00028 00008 ∂27-Feb-81 1533 Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI> Timings
C00030 00009 ∂27-Feb-81 1616 Earl A. Killian <EAK at MIT-MC> Timings
C00031 00010 ∂27-Feb-81 1615 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> timings
C00032 00011 ∂27-Feb-81 1655 David.Neves at CMU-10A Re: Timings
C00033 00012 ∂27-Feb-81 1658 David.Neves at CMU-10A Re: Timings
C00034 00013 ∂27-Feb-81 1710 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings
C00035 00014 ∂27-Feb-81 1719 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings
C00036 00015 ∂27-Feb-81 1730 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley timings
C00038 00016 ∂27-Feb-81 1947 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> Timings
C00040 00017 ∂27-Feb-81 2002 Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC> Timings
C00041 00018 ∂27-Feb-81 2008 GYRO at MIT-ML (Scott W. Layson) Lisp timings
C00043 00019 ∂27-Feb-81 2048 PDL at MIT-DMS (P. David Lebling) [Re: Timings ]
C00044 00020 ∂27-Feb-81 2057 JONL at MIT-MC (Jon L White) Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
C00051 00021 ∂27-Feb-81 2117 Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC> Timings for LISP benchmarks
C00052 00022 ∂27-Feb-81 2131 CWH at MIT-MC (Carl W. Hoffman) Timings
C00053 00023 ∂27-Feb-81 2201 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley here's a test for you to look at/ distribute
C00062 00024 ∂27-Feb-81 2201 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
C00063 00025 ∂28-Feb-81 0916 NEDHUE at MIT-AI (Edmund M. Goodhue) Timings
C00064 00026 ∂28-Feb-81 1046 Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics> Re: Timings
C00065 00027 ∂28-Feb-81 1109 Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics> Re: Timings
C00066 00028 ∂28-Feb-81 1424 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by
C00067 00029 ∂28-Feb-81 1718 YONKE at BBND JONL's message concerning benchmarks
C00068 00030 ∂28-Feb-81 1818 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley why I excluded GC times
C00070 00031 ∂28-Feb-81 2014 Guy.Steele at CMU-10A Re: Timings
C00072 00032 ∂28-Feb-81 2016 Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A benchmarks
C00073 00033 ∂01-Mar-81 0826 PLATTS at WHARTON-10 ( Steve Platt) timing for lisp
C00074 00034 ∂01-Mar-81 1300 RJF at MIT-MC (Richard J. Fateman) more lisp mavens
C00075 00035 ∂02-Mar-81 0443 Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC> Timings
C00076 00036 ∂02-Mar-81 0543 Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC> Timings
C00077 00037 ∂02-Mar-81 0741 James E. O'Dell <JIM at MIT-MC> Timings
C00080 00038 ∂02-Mar-81 1006 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
C00081 00039 ∂02-Mar-81 1312 Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics> Re: Timings
C00082 00040 ∂02-Mar-81 1634 RPG Lisp Timings
C00087 00041 ∂03-Mar-81 1524 RPG Lisp Timing Mailing List
C00089 00042 Here's the first message, which you missed:
C00094 00043 ∂04-Mar-81 0449 Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC> Lisp Timing Mailing List
C00099 00044 ∂04-Mar-81 0957 Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A Re: Translators
C00102 00045 ∂04-Mar-81 0959 CSVAX.char at Berkeley lisp benchmarking
C00105 00046 ∂04-Mar-81 1627 HEDRICK at RUTGERS sometime of possible interest
C00110 00047 ∂06-Mar-81 1301 HES at MIT-AI (Howard Shrobe) Methodology considerations:
C00112 00048 Subject: Lisp Timings Group
C00119 00049 ∂10-Mar-81 0727 correira at UTEXAS-11 lisp timings
C00121 00050 ∂03-Mar-81 2109 Barrow at SRI-KL (Harry Barrow ) Lisp Timings
C00124 00051 ∂02-Mar-81 0004 Charles Frankston <CBF at MIT-MC> timings
C00128 00052 ∂17-Mar-81 1155 Masinter at PARC-MAXC Re: GC
C00132 00053 ∂16-Mar-81 1429 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: Solicitation
C00137 00054 ∂16-Mar-81 1433 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: GC
C00144 00055 ∂16-Mar-81 1810 Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A Re: GC
C00146 00056 ∂16-Mar-81 1934 PLATTS at WHARTON-10 ( Steve Platt) lisp -- my GC and machine specs
C00150 00057 ∂17-Mar-81 0745 Griss at UTAH-20 (Martin.Griss) Re: GC
C00151 00058 ∂17-Mar-81 0837 Robert S. Boyer <BOYER at SRI-CSL> Solicitation
C00155 00059 ∂17-Mar-81 0847 Robert S. Boyer <BOYER at SRI-CSL> LISP Timings
C00157 00060 ∂17-Mar-81 1155 Masinter at PARC-MAXC Re: GC
C00161 00061 ∂17-Mar-81 1218 RPG Bureaucracy
C00162 00062 ∂17-Mar-81 1921 Bernard S. Greenberg <Greenberg at MIT-Multics> Re: Solicitation
C00172 00063 ∂31-Mar-81 1451 RPG Timing Benchmarks
C00174 00064 ∂01-Apr-81 1550 Masinter at PARC-MAXC
C00179 00065 ∂05-Apr-81 2141 JHL via LONDON
C00180 00066 ∂05-Apr-81 2217 Carl Hewitt <CARL at MIT-AI> Lisp Timing Mailing List
C00181 00067 ∂06-Apr-81 1302 RPG Timing benchmark
C00190 00068 ∂06-Apr-81 2007 RPG
C00192 00069 ∂05-Apr-81 0208 H at MIT-AI (Jack Holloway) lisp timings
C00193 00070 ∂06-Apr-81 1410 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: Timing benchmark
C00196 00071 ∂06-Apr-81 1931 Bernard S. Greenberg <Greenberg at MIT-Multics> Re: Timing benchmark
C00199 00072 ∂06-Apr-81 2008 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: Timing benchmark
C00205 00073 ∂06-Apr-81 2007 RPG
C00207 00074 ∂07-Apr-81 0924 RPG Rules
C00211 00075 ∂07-Apr-81 1323 JONL at MIT-MC (Jon L White) Proposed ''mini'' benchmark, with interpretation.
C00224 00076 ∂10-Apr-81 1051 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: Rules
C00232 00077 ∂10-Apr-81 1205 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> Rules
C00234 00078 ∂11-Apr-81 1001 CSVAX.jkf at Berkeley result of pairs benchmark on franz.
C00239 00079 ∂13-Apr-81 1320 RPG
C00241 00080 ∂13-Apr-81 1239 RPG Groundrules (reprise)
C00246 00081 ∂13-Apr-81 1338 CLR at MIT-XX Re: Groundrules (reprise)
C00249 00082 ∂13-Apr-81 1724 YONKE at BBND Re: Groundrules (reprise)
C00251 00083 ∂13-Apr-81 1934 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> Re: Groundrules (reprise)
C00256 00084 ∂13-Apr-81 2214 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: Groundrules (reprise)
C00262 00085 ∂21-Apr-81 1316 RPG SCCPP
C00263 00086 ∂13-Mar-81 1959 MEEHAN at MIT-AI (James R. Meehan)
C00265 00087 ∂31-Mar-81 1615 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timing Benchmarks
C00266 00088 ∂21-Apr-81 1604 Greenberg.Symbolics at MIT-Multics
C00268 00089 ∂07-Apr-81 1037 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> Re: Rules
C00270 00090 ∂07-Apr-81 1107 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> Rules - GC time
C00274 00091 ∂07-Apr-81 2213 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> SCCPP on UCI-Lisp
C00277 00092 ∂21-Apr-81 2018 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> Lost mail?
C00289 00093 ∂06-Apr-81 1204 RPG
C00295 00094 ∂14-Apr-81 2031 RPG
C00321 00095 ∂22-Apr-81 1801 Bernard S. Greenberg <Greenberg at MIT-Multics> Multics Timing results vindicated
C00323 00096 ∂23-Apr-81 1232 RPG FRANZ Benchmark (FRPOLY)
C00337 00097 ∂23-Apr-81 1245 RPG Franz benchmark
C00338 00098 ∂24-Apr-81 1324 Bernard S. Greenberg <Greenberg at MIT-Multics> Re: FRANZ Benchmark, Multics Numbers
C00341 00099 ∂24-Apr-81 1414 RPG Errata
C00342 00100 ∂24-Apr-81 1608 CSVAX.jkf at Berkeley octal vrs decimal
C00343 00101 ∂25-Apr-81 1242 Greenberg.Symbolics at MIT-Multics Re: octal vrs decimal
C00344 00102 ∂25-Apr-81 1320 Vanmelle at SUMEX-AIM Re: Re: octal vrs decimal
C00345 00103 ∂25-Apr-81 1727 Greenberg.Symbolics at MIT-Multics Re: Re: octal vrs decimal
C00346 00104 ∂25-Apr-81 2210 CSVAX.jkf at Berkeley Re: Re: octal vrs decimal
C00348 00105 ∂24-Apr-81 1411 CSVAX.jkf at Berkeley franz timing results
C00350 00106 ∂28-Apr-81 1122 Vanmelle at SUMEX-AIM Re: Benchmarks
C00352 00107 ∂28-Apr-81 2115 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> Re: FRANZ Benchmark
C00356 00108 ∂02-May-81 1245 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> Re: FRANZ Benchmark
C00362 00109 ∂04-May-81 1326 correira at UTEXAS-11 UTLISP benchmarks
C00364 00110 ∂05-May-81 0643 correira at UTEXAS-11 SCCPP Timings for UTLISP
C00366 00111 ∂05-May-81 0643 correira at UTEXAS-11 FRPOLY Timings for UTLISP
C00372 00112 ∂05-May-81 0643 correira at UTEXAS-11 A thumbnail sketch of UTLISP
C00381 00113 ∂26-May-81 0916 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> benchmark.
C00398 00114 ∂09-Aug-81 1912 RPG via CMU-20C Vacation
C00399 00115 ∂20-Oct-81 1527 LYNCH at USC-ISIB Benchmarks for Interlisp-VAX
C00403 00116 ∂20-Oct-81 1614 Doug Lenat <CSD.LENAT at SU-SCORE> Save the Dolphins
C00412 00117 ∂20-Oct-81 1744 pratt@Diablo (SuNet) Benchmarks for Interlisp-VAX
C00423 00118 ∂21-Oct-81 0109 RPG Criterion 1
C00427 00119 ∂17-Oct-81 2340 pratt@Diablo (SuNet) Fairness
C00437 00120 ∂18-Oct-81 2141 pratt@Diablo (SuNet) For what it's worth
C00442 00121 ∂18-Oct-81 2254 RPG@Sail (SuNet) Several points:
C00446 00122 ∂19-Oct-81 0935 RINDFLEISCH@SUMEX-AIM (SuNet) FYI - Other Lisp Timing Thrashes
C00454 00123 ∂19-Oct-81 1045 pratt@Diablo (SuNet) Several points:
C00458 00124 ∂19-Oct-81 1143 RPG@Sail (SuNet) Long, silly response to Vaughn Pratt
C00461 00125 ∂19-Oct-81 1545 Jeff Rubin <JBR at S1-A>
C00463 00126 ∂21-Oct-81 1325 RPG Wall time
C00470 00127 ∂22-Oct-81 2009 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> timing tests and benchmarks.
C00472 00128 ∂10-Dec-81 1050 Jerry Roylance <GLR at MIT-AI> LISPM Array Timings
C00476 00129 ∂11-Dec-81 1215 David A. Moon <MOON at MIT-MC> LISPM Array Timings
C00478 00130 ∂16-Dec-81 0937 Guy.Steele at CMU-10A TAK for S-1
C00501 00131 ∂18-Dec-81 2112 Earl A. Killian <Killian at MIT-Multics> tak
C00507 00132 ∂07-Jan-82 1311 RPG
C00508 00133 ∂13-Jan-82 1015 Kalman Reti <XCON.RETI at DEC-MARLBORO> Re: Benchmarks
C00510 ENDMK
C⊗;
∂27-Feb-81 1334 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 13:32 PST
From: Deutsch at PARC-MAXC
Subject: Re: Timings
In-reply-to: RPG's message of 27 Feb 1981 1319-PST
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
cc: info-lispm at MIT-AI
Your suggestion sounds great. What we need is someone to organize the process
just a little. Such a person would do something like the following:
1) Collect the names of volunteers or contact persons at each site, to send sample
programs to.
2) Collect the sample programs from each site, and disseminate them to the
volunteers or contacts at the other sites.
3) Collect the translated sample programs (in case there was controversy over
whether the translation was "trivial", for example, and for documentation and
historical purposes).
4) Collect the results of the timings run at each site, and disseminate them.
Would you like to volunteer?
∂27-Feb-81 1342 Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI> Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 1319-PST
From: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Timings
To: deutsch at PARC-MAXC
CC: info-lispm at MIT-AI
Since everyone I know of is trying to make a decision about what
to do about Lisp computing in the next five years, perhaps we should
try to co-ordinate a test that will help everyone make a decision.
For instance, each center (PARC, MIT, Stanford, CMU, Berkeley,...)
can provide a program that is of interest to them (not too big, of course);
each test site will then provide someone to re-code (in a very trivial sense:
turning greaterp into >, adding declarations) those programs into reasonably
efficient code for their system. The authors will provide timing data and
timing points in their code.
Each center may have a few programs since they may have diverse
communities (SAIL and HPP at Stanford). I would be happy to volunteer to
test programs for SAIL MacLisp, which is a 10 version.
-rpg-
∂27-Feb-81 1354 RPG Timings
To: deutsch at PARC-MAXC
CC: RPG at SU-AI, info-lispm at MIT-AI
I will volunteer to co-ordinate the Lisp timing test. I plan to contact:
Deutsch/Masinter at Parc (InterLisp on MAXC, Dorado, Dolphin...)
RPG/ROD at SAIL (MacLisp on SAIL, TOPS-20, FOONLY F2)
VanMelle@SUMEX (InterLisp on TOPS-20)
Fateman at Berkeley (FranzLisp on VAX)
Hedrick at Rutgers (UCILISP on TOPS-10?)
Fahlman/Steele at CMU (SPICELISP on ?, MacLisp on CMU-10)
HIC at MIT (Lisp Machine)
JONL at MIT (MacLisp on ITS, NIL on VAX)
Westfold at SCI (InterLisp on F2)
Weyhrauch at SAIL (Ilisp on SAIL, LISP1.6 on SAIL)
If anyone has any suggestions about who else to contact or other Lisps
and/or machines to try, let me know soon.
-rpg-
∂27-Feb-81 1412 Bruce E. Edwards <BEE at MIT-AI> Re: timings
Date: 27 February 1981 16:32-EST
From: Bruce E. Edwards <BEE at MIT-AI>
Subject: Re: timings
To: CPR at MIT-EECS
cc: INFO-LISPM at MIT-AI, RWS at MIT-XX
As Peter Deutsch has pointed out this is a crummy benchmark, which was implemented
by relatively unenlighted programming on the CADR. I made it almost 50% faster
in 5 minutes, and the new numbers are much better. They could be made much better,
but basically people aren't interested in hacking uninteresting benchmarks. Things
like a natural language parser or an AI program is more what we are interested in.
There are some data points along this line, but I can't remember the exact numbers.
Hopefully RG has the numbers for the WOODS lunar program tucked away somewhere.
∂27-Feb-81 1427 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 14:26 PST
From: Deutsch at PARC-MAXC
Subject: Re: Timings
In-reply-to: RPG's message of 27 Feb 1981 1354-PST
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Great! Perhaps we will finally throw some light into the murk of claims and
counter-claims about Lisp speeds that have been made for many years.
You might consider sending out some kind of announcement to LISP-FORUM
and/or LISP-DISCUSSION at MIT-AI as well -- I'm not sure everyone of interest
is on INFO-LISPM.
∂27-Feb-81 1502 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 13:32 PST
From: Deutsch at PARC-MAXC
Subject: Re: Timings
In-reply-to: RPG's message of 27 Feb 1981 1319-PST
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
cc: info-lispm at MIT-AI
Your suggestion sounds great. What we need is someone to organize the process
just a little. Such a person would do something like the following:
1) Collect the names of volunteers or contact persons at each site, to send sample
programs to.
2) Collect the sample programs from each site, and disseminate them to the
volunteers or contacts at the other sites.
3) Collect the translated sample programs (in case there was controversy over
whether the translation was "trivial", for example, and for documentation and
historical purposes).
4) Collect the results of the timings run at each site, and disseminate them.
Would you like to volunteer?
∂27-Feb-81 1533 Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI> Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 1354-PST
From: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Timings
To: deutsch at PARC-MAXC
CC: RPG at SU-AI, info-lispm at MIT-AI
I will volunteer to co-ordinate the Lisp timing test. I plan to contact:
Deutsch/Masinter at Parc (InterLisp on MAXC, Dorado, Dolphin...)
RPG/ROD at SAIL (MacLisp on SAIL, TOPS-20, FOONLY F2)
VanMelle@SUMEX (InterLisp on TOPS-20)
Fateman at Berkeley (FranzLisp on VAX)
Hedrick at Rutgers (UCILISP on TOPS-10?)
Fahlman/Steele at CMU (SPICELISP on ?, MacLisp on CMU-10)
HIC at MIT (Lisp Machine)
JONL at MIT (MacLisp on ITS, NIL on VAX)
Westfold at SCI (InterLisp on F2)
Weyhrauch at SAIL (Ilisp on SAIL, LISP1.6 on SAIL)
If anyone has any suggestions about who else to contact or other Lisps
and/or machines to try, let me know soon.
-rpg-
∂27-Feb-81 1616 Earl A. Killian <EAK at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 27 February 1981 19:16-EST
From: Earl A. Killian <EAK at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
I've got a queuing simulation program in MC:EAK;SIMUL > that
while it isn't at all typical of AI, uses an interesting mix of
list and numeric computation, and also runs for a fair time while
being not overly long. I'm not sure whether its useful to you,
but if it is, let me know.
∂27-Feb-81 1615 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> timings
Date: 27 February 1981 17:35-EST
From: George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC>
Subject: timings
To: Deutsch at PARC-MAXC
cc: INFO-LISPM at MIT-MC, masinter at PARC-MAXC, guttag at MIT-XX,
RWS at MIT-XX
How about using Macsyma? It has some interesting programs in it,
and it has given the Lispmachine quite a work-out on some large
real problems (or did the Lispmachine give macsyma a work out?).
-gjc
∂27-Feb-81 1655 David.Neves at CMU-10A Re: Timings
Date: 27 February 1981 1954-EST (Friday)
From: David.Neves at CMU-10A
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Re: Timings
In-Reply-To: Dick Gabriel's message of 27 Feb 81 16:54-EST
Message-Id: <27Feb81 195427 DN10@CMU-10A>
why not also try TLC lisp on a micro. ask jra@sail
also BBN's jerico might be relevant but i don't think they
have a lisp for it.
∂27-Feb-81 1658 David.Neves at CMU-10A Re: Timings
Date: 27 February 1981 1957-EST (Friday)
From: David.Neves at CMU-10A
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Re: Timings
In-Reply-To: Dick Gabriel's message of 27 Feb 81 16:54-EST
Message-Id: <27Feb81 195751 DN10@CMU-10A>
p.s. also i believe people at BBN are trying to put Interlisp on
a Prime computer. If they do have a version up that would be a
another data point. i don't know who you would contact though.
∂27-Feb-81 1710 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 16:20:26-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: RPG@SU-AI, deutsch@PARC-MAXC
Subject: Timings
Cc: info-lispm@mit-ai
add Griss@utah-20 (standard lisp on 10, b-1700, ...)
∂27-Feb-81 1719 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 16:22:33-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: RPG@SU-AI, deutsch@PARC-MAXC
Subject: Timings
Cc: info-lispm@mit-ai
add Griss@utah-20 (standard lisp on 10, b-1700, ...)
∂27-Feb-81 1730 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 16:43:27-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: Deutsch@PARC-MAXC, GJC@MIT-MC
Subject: timings
Cc: INFO-LISPM@MIT-MC, RWS@MIT-XX, CSVAX.fateman@Berkeley, guttag@MIT-XX, masinter@PARC-MAXC
George: are you offering to put Macsyma up in Interlisp? We already
have some LM /KL-10/ VAX-11/780 benchmarks (KL-10 maclisp):
Vaxima and Lisp Machine timings for DEMO files
(fg genral, fg rats, gen demo, begin demo)
(garbage collection times excluded.) Times in seconds.
MC VAXIMA 128K lm 192K lm 256K lm VAXIMA Jul 80
4.119 17.250 43.333 19.183 16.483 15.750
2.639 7.016 55.916 16.416 13.950
3.141 10.850 231.516 94.933 58.166
4.251 16.700 306.350 125.666 90.716 12.400
(Berkeley CS.VAX 11/780 UNIX April 8, 1980, KL-10 MIT-MC ITS April 9, 1980.)
improvements due to expanding alike1 and a few odds and ends as macros;
also some improvements in the compiler.
∂27-Feb-81 1947 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 27 February 1981 22:47-EST
From: George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: deutsch at PARC-MAXC
I have a usefull benchmark which I just tried in Maclisp at MIT-MC
and on a LISPM. It is code which does line-drawing window-clipping
for arbitrary convex polygonal regions. This code is in actual use.
If you want to see it, it is on MIT-MC in
[MC:BLIS11;CLIP >]. (yes, I hack BLISS. (wow what a compiler!))
It is a nice example because it tests the speed of the FUNCALL dispatch.
The file is conditionalized to run in either LISPM or Maclisp, and
even includes the timing methods used. I would very much like it
if I could run the same (*exactly*) conditionalized source on
N different systems, that way I would have
(1) greater confidence
(2) an exact knowledged of how things are done differently on the
different systems. e.g. how much hair one has to go through to
declare things to the compiler.
-gjc
∂27-Feb-81 2002 Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 27 February 1981 23:02-EST
From: Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
I'll be happy to do the timing tests.
--Howard
∂27-Feb-81 2008 GYRO at MIT-ML (Scott W. Layson) Lisp timings
Date: 27 FEB 1981 2306-EST
From: GYRO at MIT-ML (Scott W. Layson)
Subject: Lisp timings
To: rpg at SU-AI
CC: GYRO at MIT-ML, INFO- at MIT-ML, INFO-LISPM at MIT-ML
I know this is a little silly, but if you have any REALLY tiny
benchmarks (space-wise) I would like to try them out in TLC-Lisp
and muLisp, both running on a 64K Z-80. These Lisps don't page,
so the program and data have to fit in small real memory.
(Perhaps I should call them "Lisplets"?)
Incidentally, it seems to me that GC time should be included in
the times reported. Different systems generate garbage at
different rates and deal with it at different efficiencies,
and this shows up in the user-response time of the systems
(which is, after all, what we really want to know).
-- Scott Layson
---------------
∂27-Feb-81 2048 PDL at MIT-DMS (P. David Lebling) [Re: Timings ]
Date: 27 Feb 1981 2348-EST
From: PDL at MIT-DMS (P. David Lebling)
To: rpg at SU-AI
In-reply-to: Message of 27 Feb 81 at 1354 PST by RPG@SU-AI
Subject: [Re: Timings ]
Message-id: <[MIT-DMS].187847>
You should contact either CLR@MIT-XX or myself for Muddle.
Dave
∂27-Feb-81 2057 JONL at MIT-MC (Jon L White) Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
Date: 27 FEB 1981 2352-EST
From: JONL at MIT-MC (Jon L White)
Subject: Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
To: rpg at SU-AI
CC: LISP-DISCUSSION at MIT-MC, BEE at MIT-AI, JHL at MIT-AI
CC: CSVAX.fateman at BERKELEY, RWS at MIT-XX
I notice you sent your proposal to INFO-LISPM, and thought that the
LISP-DISCUSSION community might want to be aware of it too. (Deutsch and
Masinter are, I believe, on this list, as is Griss).
Date: 27 Feb 1981 1354-PST
From: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
I will volunteer to co-ordinate the Lisp timing test. I plan to contact:
Deutsch/Masinter at Parc (InterLisp on MAXC, Dorado, Dolphin...)
RPG/ROD at SAIL (MacLisp on SAIL, TOPS-20, FOONLY F2)
VanMelle@SUMEX (InterLisp on TOPS-20)
Fateman at Berkeley (FranzLisp on VAX)
Hedrick at Rutgers (UCILISP on TOPS-10?)
Fahlman/Steele at CMU (SPICELISP on ?, MacLisp on CMU-10)
HIC at MIT (Lisp Machine)
JONL at MIT (MacLisp on ITS, NIL on VAX)
Westfold at SCI (InterLisp on F2)
Weyhrauch at SAIL (Ilisp on SAIL, LISP1.6 on SAIL)
If anyone has any suggestions about who else to contact or other Lisps
and/or machines to try, let me know soon.
The contact for Rutgers-LISP should probably be JOSH@RUTGERS-10
(John Storrs Hall) who is actively extending the formerly-called UCILISP.
Fateman's login name is CSVAX.fateman@Berkeley unless there is some
smarts to his mailer that I don't know about.
Also, I'd like to suggest the following additions
GRISS@UTAH-20 for "STANDARD-LISP" on PDP10, IBM370, etc
John Allen (who knows where?) for his "Cromemco" lisp on Z80 etc
JHL@MIT-AI (Joachim Laubsch, from Stuttgart, West Germany) who might be
able to involve the European LISP community.
I'll also send a letter of these actions to Shigeki Goto of the Nippon
Telephone Co. in Tokyo, who generated some sort of flurry last fall with his
incrediblly-simple "benchmark" function TAK. Actually, TAK may be useful as
one part of a multi-foliate benchmark, since it specifically test timings
for (1) function-to-function interface, and (2) simple arithmetic of GREATERP
and SUB1. Some of Baskett's benchmarkings score heavily on the array
capabilities, for which FORTRAN compilers "come off smelling like a rose",
and even the fast-arithmetic of MacLISP savors like a garbage dump.
At the little "lisp discussion" held in Salt Lake City, December 1980,
(attendees partly co-incident with LISP-DISCUSSION mailing list), Peter
Deutsch made a suggestion which we all liked, but for which there
has been no subsequent action (to my knowledge). Basically, in order to
educate ourselves into the consequences of the differences between LISP
dialects, and to get some experience in converting "real" code, each
dialect community should nominate a representative piece of "useful code"
from its enviromment, and the groups responsible for the other
dialects would try to "transport" it into their own. Several benefits
should accrue:
(1) If the "representative" is some useful piece of the general environment,
say like the DEFMACRO "cache'ing" scheme of MacLISP/NIL, or the
Interlisp Masterscope, or whatever, then the "transportation" cost
will be repaid by having a useful new tool in the other dialects.
(2) We should accumulate a library of automatic conversion tools, or
at least of written reports on the problems involved.
(3) Each community may be affected in a way which (hopefully) will help
reduce the hard-core interdialect incompatibilities.
(Apologies to Deutsch for any garbling of the proposal content).
∂27-Feb-81 2117 Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC> Timings for LISP benchmarks
Date: 28 February 1981 00:17-EST
From: Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings for LISP benchmarks
To: rpg at SU-AI, deutsch at PARC-MAXC
cc: Greenberg.Symbolics at MIT-MULTICS
I suggest Greenberg.Symbolics@MIT-MULTICS for Multics MacLisp.
∂27-Feb-81 2131 CWH at MIT-MC (Carl W. Hoffman) Timings
Date: 28 FEB 1981 0030-EST
From: CWH at MIT-MC (Carl W. Hoffman)
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
Date: 27 Feb 1981 1354-PST
From: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
If anyone has any suggestions about who else to contact or other Lisps
and/or machines to try, let me know soon.
-rpg-
You might also contact Richard Lamson or Bernie Greenberg for timings of
MacLisp on various Multics sites. Net addresses are "Lamson at MIT-Multics"
and "Greenberg at MIT-Multics".
∂27-Feb-81 2201 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley here's a test for you to look at/ distribute
Date: 27 Feb 1981 21:26:56-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: rpg@su-ai
Subject: here's a test for you to look at/ distribute
;; test from Berkeley based on polynomial arithmetic.
(declare (special ans coef f inc i k qq ss v *x*
*alpha *a* *b* *chk *l *p q* u* *var *y*))
(declare (localf pcoefadd pcplus pcplus1 pplus ptimes ptimes1
ptimes2 ptimes3 psimp pctimes pctimes1
pplus1))
;; Franz uses maclisp hackery here; you can rewrite lots of ways.
(defmacro pointergp (x y) `(> (get ,x 'order)(get ,y 'order)))
(defmacro pcoefp (e) `(atom ,e))
(defmacro pzerop (x) `(signp e ,x)) ;true for 0 or 0.0
(defmacro pzero () 0)
(defmacro cplus (x y) `(plus ,x ,y))
(defmacro ctimes (x y) `(times ,x ,y))
(defun pcoefadd (e c x) (cond ((pzerop c) x)
(t (cons e (cons c x)))))
(defun pcplus (c p) (cond ((pcoefp p) (cplus p c))
(t (psimp (car p) (pcplus1 c (cdr p))))))
(defun pcplus1 (c x)
(cond ((null x)
(cond ((pzerop c) nil) (t (cons 0 (cons c nil)))))
((pzerop (car x)) (pcoefadd 0 (pplus c (cadr x)) nil))
(t (cons (car x) (cons (cadr x) (pcplus1 c (cddr x)))))))
(defun pctimes (c p) (cond ((pcoefp p) (ctimes c p))
(t (psimp (car p) (pctimes1 c (cdr p))))))
(defun pctimes1 (c x)
(cond ((null x) nil)
(t (pcoefadd (car x)
(ptimes c (cadr x))
(pctimes1 c (cddr x))))))
(defun pplus (x y) (cond ((pcoefp x) (pcplus x y))
((pcoefp y) (pcplus y x))
((eq (car x) (car y))
(psimp (car x) (pplus1 (cdr y) (cdr x))))
((pointergp (car x) (car y))
(psimp (car x) (pcplus1 y (cdr x))))
(t (psimp (car y) (pcplus1 x (cdr y))))))
(defun pplus1 (x y)
(cond ((null x) y)
((null y) x)
((= (car x) (car y))
(pcoefadd (car x)
(pplus (cadr x) (cadr y))
(pplus1 (cddr x) (cddr y))))
((> (car x) (car y))
(cons (car x) (cons (cadr x) (pplus1 (cddr x) y))))
(t (cons (car y) (cons (cadr y) (pplus1 x (cddr y)))))))
(defun psimp (var x)
(cond ((null x) 0)
((atom x) x)
((zerop (car x)) (cadr x))
(t (cons var x))))
(defun ptimes (x y) (cond ((or (pzerop x) (pzerop y)) (pzero))
((pcoefp x) (pctimes x y))
((pcoefp y) (pctimes y x))
((eq (car x) (car y))
(psimp (car x) (ptimes1 (cdr x) (cdr y))))
((pointergp (car x) (car y))
(psimp (car x) (pctimes1 y (cdr x))))
(t (psimp (car y) (pctimes1 x (cdr y))))))
(defun ptimes1 (*x* y) (prog (u* v)
(setq v (setq u* (ptimes2 y)))
a (setq *x* (cddr *x*))
(cond ((null *x*) (return u*)))
(ptimes3 y)
(go a)))
(defun ptimes2 (y) (cond ((null y) nil)
(t (pcoefadd (plus (car *x*) (car y))
(ptimes (cadr *x*) (cadr y))
(ptimes2 (cddr y))))))
(defun ptimes3 (y)
(prog (e u c)
a1 (cond ((null y) (return nil)))
(setq e (+ (car *x*) (car y)))
(setq c (ptimes (cadr y) (cadr *x*) ))
(cond ((pzerop c) (setq y (cddr y)) (go a1))
((or (null v) (> e (car v)))
(setq u* (setq v (pplus1 u* (list e c))))
(setq y (cddr y)) (go a1))
((= e (car v))
(setq c (pplus c (cadr v)))
(cond ((pzerop c) (setq u* (setq v (pdiffer1 u* (list (car v) (cadr v))))))
(t (rplaca (cdr v) c)))
(setq y (cddr y))
(go a1)))
a (cond ((and (cddr v) (> (caddr v) e)) (setq v (cddr v)) (go a)))
(setq u (cdr v))
b (cond ((or (null (cdr u)) (< (cadr u) e))
(rplacd u (cons e (cons c (cdr u)))) (go e)))
(cond ((pzerop (setq c (pplus (caddr u) c))) (rplacd u (cdddr u)) (go d))
(t (rplaca (cddr u) c)))
e (setq u (cddr u))
d (setq y (cddr y))
(cond ((null y) (return nil)))
(setq e (+ (car *x*) (car y)))
(setq c (ptimes (cadr y) (cadr *x*)))
c (cond ((and (cdr u) (> (cadr u) e)) (setq u (cddr u)) (go c)))
(go b)))
!
(defun pexptsq (p n)
(do ((n (quotient n 2) (quotient n 2))
(s (cond ((oddp n) p) (t 1))))
((zerop n) s)
(setq p (ptimes p p))
(and (oddp n) (setq s (ptimes s p))) ))
(defun setup nil
(putprop 'x 1 'order)
(putprop 'y 2 'order)
(putprop 'z 3 'order)
(setq r (pplus '(x 1 1 0 1) (pplus '(y 1 1) '(z 1 1)))) ; r= x+y+z+1
(setq r2 (ptimes r 100000)) ;r2 = 100000*r
(setq r3 (ptimes r 1.0)); r3 = r with floating point coefficients
)
; time various computations of powers of polynomials, not counting
;printing but including gc time ; provide account of g.c. time.
; The following function uses (ptime) for process-time and is thus
; Franz-specific.
(defun bench (n)
(setq start (ptime)) ; Franz ticks, 60 per sec, 2nd number is GC
(pexptsq r n)
(setq res1 (ptime))
(pexptsq r2 n)
(setq res2 (ptime))
; this one requires bignums.
(pexptsq r3 n)
(setq res3 (ptime))
(list 'power= n (b1 start res1)(b1 res1 res2)(b1 res2 res3)))
(defun b1(x y)(mapcar '(lambda(r s)(quotient (- s r) 60.0)) x y))
;instructions:
; after loading, type (setup)
; then (bench 2) ; this should be pretty fast.
; then (bench 5)
; then (bench 10)
; then (bench 15)
;...
∂27-Feb-81 2201 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
Date: 27 Feb 1981 21:32:33-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: JONL@MIT-MC, rpg@SU-AI
Subject: Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
Cc: BEE@MIT-AI, JHL@MIT-AI, LISP-DISCUSSION@MIT-MC
I have sent an entry (polynomial arithmetic system) to rpg@su-ai.
He can examine and redistribute.
( fateman@berkeley is equivalent to csvax.fateman@berkeley...)
∂28-Feb-81 0916 NEDHUE at MIT-AI (Edmund M. Goodhue) Timings
Date: 28 FEB 1981 1215-EST
From: NEDHUE at MIT-AI (Edmund M. Goodhue)
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
I suggest you add Jim Meehan at UCI (maintainer of UCI LISP) who can
run benchmarks on UCILISP and MLISP on both TOP-10 and TOPS-20. UCI
is not on the net but he can be reached via MEEHAN@MIT-AI.
Ned Goodhue
∂28-Feb-81 1046 Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics> Re: Timings
Date: 28 February 1981 1343-est
From: Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics>
Subject: Re: TimiNgs
To: RPC at SU-AI
CC8 info%lIqpm at MIT-AI
I Think↓s←jAMQ←kY⊂ACYG<AG←]QCGhAM←[K←9JACH↓≠∪([5kYiS
bPAo!KeJAQQKrAIk\
∃5CG→SM`XAC1iQ←K≥PAαO4A]OH↓gkeJ↓oQ↑AβK?Uβ≡C?W3 β∂?;& ∂Q8hP4(0 ;'¬T6.%Wβ
αε∩∪βH_,↔↔↔∀ V∂⊗⎇yFNr∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧βdn≡,v}f≥`ε∂" Y∃"l↑YG&N>7bM,W"¬&≥]⊗v?1Q$&∂LW"αα∧∧β∪Bλh ,.]8<O∀ ..ε∀ ,mε59<⎇↓QQ\[mWHλλ∧∧⊂X<N<P&p\3wv )n <Margolif At EIT-H kYβ#'∂Mph ∃∨\-&.∨G$α¬⊗U$¬&Nβ:0↔→yFE*≠]⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂)∀ π at SU-AI
∃πα→`∩α∧∧ααα
_ L@5P
l@%`∂C5∧ Qα⊗M!6ε$hP4*%∧εFFNβZ`⊂≡wzP 3hkul@⊂AC@3α8 d {{] ≤⎇λ⊂→[vrw`.e a`(αα6&QlkW3SL∧75α⊂;t→y2P 4hey @Ik\4Tkπ∞M_ n¬λ_;∞M≠x
cZ⊂ 'm j`∨@ ∧π><Y(∞⎇≠h⊂≤[zP9d≠zr2 contact&
λ∞dp5
KDZβAE↓↓λεC∪ _LW/'<8
∧ =λ∀λ~Pk3(≠⊂hα*,.H∃
≥8;YnP37`2 LISP benchiarkq(λAC9HAeKαk';∪,ε"ε@yH⊂⊂H897h≠ypv⊂_<PεE⊃0z2]λ→_λ Feb !dpb@@λεC@&Lh∀
:β"QN4πm: Deutsch at PARC-H β1 ~∃'k UKGhhA%Jt↓)SKSαs⊂∨~ h n⊂ ISP beNchmarhπf@1∧∧⊗v"∞,VnNβY→.⊂7s⊂_P897\5ypvλ1<FEλ ∧eutpπGP~)∪\[e∃aY`%o#=iαTz:1∨~β7/><⊗>(≠p∪λ→≠P#⊃a⊂⊂⊃dpb@@⊂ε3+∩XZ5 @ U≠g∧≤X⊃d =λ∀jU02+∧ ∩4t¬X∩4pjZtr3i@⊂0r MIT-MA(λA¬∃
AC@ ∧∧lMEX∀J@λ∩R D_=⊂∪dj⊗`RVεE⊂⊂βSVAX,¬MCi∃[CLA¬hA¬ I↔ → dXA%/LAChA5∪ @6E@4(Q)$`9β&⊂ !ccuratedi pepreq` ]i∃HAiQ∀AG←]QK]hAα{⊂∩ε←∀ππ⊗| w<8ε↔ The q` hAα{⊂∩π∞-v >X;<aQXY0∀[3P9jX4tp∀te` f@=` βSL¬VNvtλ
↑⎇≤h
]9z≥∧
8π22Yp⊂12H0P:iYq:v⊂≤4∧acE po @MiCe@ ¬`hPβ"@↓AlN (l8K.ε∀λ ≠L\∧lgS%bP0]⊂!!'⊃⊂∧e'S&∪yP≠pyypYrP1`/ncerning benchmar`↔f@@@~) CiJh@dpA→KD@bβIaE↓⊃↓Ae6-~P4*≡+;∪↔∪Qαf>tZ∃βπ α∀∀hAPU∨\-&.∨G$∧T|iDw~ε\↑7≡∞|Tε≡}l<W⊗v≥lrε⊗]l6Fn≡-7_h(j&}k$ ∀|t8Tε∂"λ($t Q*F{Rλ*∧:ε≡D¬≥*X→∩b∧M≡7αlM≡6∨/>=⊗}r ≡B∧l~ETl_Q)V/∨<≤v*l_C"βe8($t%V'αl6\%SC
∧"βSβ↔&#αu→yd\+aQ hT∀|Bεf≥<Rπ&tλ⊗&" ≥g&/-I↔∂α
yb∧V↑-⊗≡Ft¬ε␈/$λ
-e:≠p~\pP6pXt4w2JTε¬
Also, qi`≥Gα)α
p∧εF∂4∞6/6↑,⊗bεM≤f ,<Y3ND→[⊂⊂]7y9P≠q⊂""Pβ hardsa`%∀~∃oQ%GPAeU\A)∨A&Zd`0A∩Ao=kYI\≥hA[Sαs⊃βO-βC3@≥≥f*πM W≡(→~,LY<Y-nβ"P~~vtw3\P0w2λ:42`9 would probably mgre inf@=aSCi%mJAi!C\A↔UehOf4⊂Q-C9≠KYY∀RAMe=ZA',j⊗aaQ hT\≡'&NaQ hP`@lN (l8K&ε∀λ &ε↔α0tjh6 YL≡→;8-d_=⊂⊂2y5r[2|P∧]t8 I exclu` KHαα≡
β&K7/1Q$&∂LW"β∪∧λf.∩ε⊂∞'ε(λλKN_Z]→ Vh)jβE#97[]⊂!iU h↔3_z2vp[⊂0z @erkeley
To: HES@MIT-AI
λSubject: whq I exclu` KH↓∂εAi%[@↔LhRπ
i∧~NJεBs≠πS.kπ:α⊗+C/↔d+e "
→f6z]I↔∂εX
VO"]\2bεM≡7αnM≡6∨/>=⊗}t
]↔"n\1PPH-≥f≡g\M⊗v:λx2π&≥\W~ε\≥6/~ iwαε∀λ
L↑↑(∪,↑|}(∞>_=~.>~8x-D≤z=∞\=~;meC"Qh4≥~;,T
≠|D =Y0↔λ4s⊂4]⊂40x≤2w9P_z⊂0v≠∀P4yH22x2[22w:λ7w⊂:~2P;4\::pvβE0r2≤2yyP≤x0qrH4w⊂:\rP0zλ:42P≥4vrVλ47{P≠zqt⊂≠s⊂:4→P6pq\|vpP≤|yz2[FE40\P12r[⊂67pY2r⊂∀~w⊂:4→P1pyYP7s⊂≥42P%S⊗XX∀K⊂2z1K⊂⊂$P→7P77]⊂5w7]FE0q≠zz⊂:~2P&&H34sz\2yV⊂≤tw1rH$P0vH7w6<H92x7\:4w3H9z:s→⊂9rw≥⊂:7P≠rVεE_:z⊂:~2P%f XX⊂0[2⊂:4→P+ lλ:<x4Xpv6<H9x2w→⊂→X∩H0r24]4ww0[⊂:4vYP4wεB#aV⊂_{2y0Yrr⊂7]2y⊂;_y4wz\P⊃89≠r:qz~ww⊃⊂≤:w9Wλ⊂*90Y4w3P≠s3⊂#PP:4vYFE37\⊂9|y]2vP8_stw3H:4vrH4yP0H3:w7≡P1:iZw2yyK⊂:47]st⊂$H0sy2YP4zεB4yP4[x7y:_w:↔εBεEεEβπY≤⊗Q2q⊗\ P⊂→_ Z∧cz↑W)z2Yv2P0]⊂!fjKXX Pαi2]⊂∃4vtg→yPεE⊃0z2]λ→≤⊂#→q9:`\<P_LN_P→→LYVbiU⊂∀)p]:y20↑TFE#≤5v]⊂⊃z|W)]2rv2H0z⊂!SjVXX⊂FE*7N⊂"4qZP#pq≤4rv⊂∂)(#P_z⊂)jK`d←⊂βE)zq~2qz≥λ⊂)2]λ*4vt[3yFE∩w⊗i2\6<Vj≠]⊂⊂"~quP#Xq94r[∪yP6YyypsYP7s⊂ ≠P#2X⊂≤_P [≥~Z bijεB&ryyXsrVdY≥⊂≡→∞#2q≤ P→→XLZ_P#T[X !SjVXX⊂←εEεB,wzP≠p|P;Xw:⊂*≠P3rzλ4w⊂:≠zqt⊂≥tz4⊂≥42P8→wx62H0z⊂*]0p⊂∀∀z0w2_that you are likely to get a great CACM article or
soemthing out of distilling all this stuff if you want; more power
to you. I'll coordinate running tests on SPice LISP, though that
may take some time to materialize.
--QW
xxx
--Q
∂28-Feb-81 2016 Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A benchmarks
Date: 28 February 1981 2315-EST (Saturday)
From: Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A
To: rpg at su-ai
Subject: benchmarks
Message-Id: <28Feb81 231549 SF50@CMU-10A>
Hi,
I just added my name to Lisp discussion recently and seem to have missed
something. Exactly what benchmarks are you running/getting people to
run? If there was a message that kicked all of this off, I would be
interested in seeing it.
We will be happy to add Spice Lisp on Perq benchmarks when the time comes,
but we won't be ready till summer.
-- Scott
∂01-Mar-81 0826 PLATTS at WHARTON-10 ( Steve Platt) timing for lisp
Date: 1 Mar 1981 (Sunday) 1124-EDT
From: PLATTS at WHARTON-10 ( Steve Platt)
Subject: timing for lisp
To: rpg at SU-AI
...if the systems are not *too* big, I'd like to try them on my micro
(Z80) lisp.... rough limits -- stack is a few hundred calls deep (I can
relink to change this if necessary), cell space is limited to roughly
10K cells. Most basic major lisp functions (a la maclisp, for the most
part) are implemented, others can be added.
-Steve
∂01-Mar-81 1300 RJF at MIT-MC (Richard J. Fateman) more lisp mavens
Date: 1 MAR 1981 1600-EST
From: RJF at MIT-MC (Richard J. Fateman)
Subject: more lisp mavens
To: rpg at SU-AI
Try boyer@sri-kl. They have an F2, and Boyer undoubtedly
could supply theorem-prover benchmark.
∂02-Mar-81 0443 Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 2 March 1981 07:43-EST
From: Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: deutsch at PARC-MAXC
Please add me to your timing test survey. I have several
suggestions of features that I would like to know about.
Thanks.
--Bob
∂02-Mar-81 0543 Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 2 March 1981 08:43-EST
From: Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: deutsch at PARC-MAXC
Please add me to your timing test survey. I have several
suggestions of features that I would like to know about.
Thanks.
-Bob
∂02-Mar-81 0741 James E. O'Dell <JIM at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 2 March 1981 10:40-EST
From: James E. O'Dell <JIM at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: Margolin at MIT-MULTICS
cc: RPG at SU-AI
Date: 28 February 1981 1343-est
From: Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics>
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: info-lispm at MIT-AI
Re: Timings
I think you should also contact someone at MIT-Multics, where they run
MacLisp, although I'm not sure who you should Contact.
If the timings don't take too long to work up I'd be glad to run the
MulTics Lisp tp¬SCYL\Aβf↓s←jA5SOQh↓P∂;?:β←∃βF [∃βλ∧∧n∞>?⊗n
∞.Vvv≥lrπ& Z&(h-mw:b∞lW.z;{DεL,kD =λ∃∂≡~8x-M≤∧P 2uns at .& of a↓≠εLAQQJAiISGWr↓iQS]≤ASfAQQCh~)←\Ag=[@∃α∀J≥βC⊗{ #↔o→β'Q∧ε'.w4λ↔
εl≡7"ε}$ε ,<⎇→.∧≥~_-d∪0h ,8x=.<(≠p∪λ4z1FB40q3Yy⊂0r→92yyH9x0qYW⊂$jλ9x2w→9P62\yP7`& its time collEcting garbace thaf
on MC,∧AαAα3↔↔⊃¬##πQ¬##'MεK@~ε≥`εNo
x NL9]λ @0qz7\↔εEεB z⊂ ,easton o@_AiQJ↓iS[Sαs↔Mβ≡C?W3"αε.:~βWAβλβGS?⊗i9α←*β#π[*β#π⊃¬βK? d+7L4U;'S!ε ∪∪K/≠EβO∧ ∂∃β|qβ ∨αMαπ& T∧dM: Rε∞l@λ
⎇H _ yP∞ Some Large MacsYma¬
@AeWEK5`
βW≤)βGA∧ 3 "
xbπ& Tε∞→_ 2\yP9x_qrP'[⊂:42H&$ih∪P12aXzyrP≥pP27[∪z⊂)≥wαE 7ith The gapbage colLector,∧A∂ε≥S]NA=\AiQ∀A→∪'A~AgY=ofAi!S]Of↓IWo\↓BAY←PXλ4λhR%βπg≠=βSFK;-β&CπQβ&C∃α∩M~B5βLε2ε⊗]_ LT≥;YL≥<[⊗$ {{< ≡Y9⊂_2qpz\pP7`& itc
single user natp eJ8A)QJ↓]k[E∃` Mβ&yβ;? βπ∂∂-∪πS↔dπ∩π⊗\iF.∨D
FF*∞,W>≠{\m≡Y;Y.yFE /bserve` by the user.
~∀4⊂_⊂≥A⊂j7πIhπβ
αε∩ββ0_LW/'<9αε∂D
∧
∀5YT
D4↓∃⊗+$
FNn≥lw
α↓Q$&∂LW"β∩ \↔αβ↔↔β
β⊗π#β2λ∧∀jA ¬# 2om2 DeutsCh at↓!β%ε5≠β1ε4⊃'kE)KGht↓%JtAQS[S]≥f~∃∪αq7K↔εce /Mw"¬∃λtw
ε\Z7≡∞|Tε}2∧"r∧6\ λε↔,∧⊂P YZZ-PST
To: Dick GabriEl <RPG a`(↓'*[β$|∩∃G p α↔∂≠';S/⊂4(Q*εf.≡<Rπε≥<RεnT v ,H≥~ T≠~4nD≠yH∞ 9|⊂⊗→P27`)ng L@%`∂Aβ&K7'l}2bα H↔π↔∀ V∂≡≥nF/∩
x AQ\{p⊗Yww2P→v9rP_z⊂ T!P;t≠P4yP_qz4k→v8 @]←e@/L¬f 4≠{@⊂∪4yx⊂
8πhi@
PAαAα 5β;|εBJε≡4εn␈,QP@,<≤∀M}≤Z0.L+C"AQ@ 02-Mar-`b@@bLbd∪¬¬eerA5CeO←1S\@@@@@@@@@@y≠Ce≥←YS\↓ChA≠%([≠k1iSGfx@∪%JhA)S[%]Of~) CiJh@@@@dA≠CIGP@bdpb@bXb`[Kβ≠P4(j&}k$∧αααλ,↔↔↔∀ V∂⊗⎇⎇FNr∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧βdn≡,v}f≥dε∂" Y∃"l↑]G&N>7`hU>\&V.>G"α¬,W"¬&≥]⊗v?1Q%&{$∧ααα∧∧∧TLT ↔"∧Y~Bll1Q$∞≠$∧ααα∧∧¬∃∧tλλ.D∀q+(→#"C!(Y<[M≤(⊃|L\9XY.,h~_.4_;∀L\9≡( ,9;H∞m{≥;NL9<Y,D≥≠h Mh≥~ T∪=;∞M8|h \8s~.xεE*~vtw3\V⊂0v≥47zsZ⊂ SvH9zy2H42P;[w∪z≠ts2≡wzy⊂~2v8⊗λ2yx2Xtpv6≡P;t2[⊂4zεB3rz9H:7P&Xqy|vXP:4vZw3yWβE
02-Mar-`b@@bXfh∪%A∞@@∪1Sg`AQS[S]≥f@@~))↑t@AS]Mαy73'∨β5βπ ∧∧lMEX∀Jb
M↔∂α\M↔<⎇<|m≥{H_.D∪25¬X2+β!$λλλ∧∧λHu →23Qei4qvjI3+∪
:↔(H ≡λ∀u%X2#"A_<h≠-}⎇λ∪lD≡;⎇$
{[ueD≥~→.,(≥z-Mλ_Y$ ;H_.N→;<∞D≠89 T≥≠h Mh_#!.y<Z,↑h≠qD ~<|∧∞~;:-l|h~-d≥z~,=λ≥X.-;⎇<d Y;Xm
8<Zn4≤⎇8M]=≥→,D_↑(∞M→#"IM<|λ ={;=-m=≡( ≡Y(≥ ↑⎇→9∧
{H_$∞X<Z,↑≡(∪ld→~9Ll<Y;ND∪~<n∧≤}<nL;<kAQTz;L<(≥~ ↑Y(≥m≥≠λ≠L\9λ≥
t_Y(∞={9(∞NX;\mL=~;mnh→≠ml(~3D
|Y→.$≥≠h∞.;C"NM→<y$ Y;Xm
8<Zn4~;H∞∨<⎇→-↑h→[n∧≥z~,=λ≥~ ←(≥y.,(≠[nD~;] ]Y→9¬D≥~→.,#"R.∀≥~→$∞y8p↔[20y<H∀⊂TP≤97q6→vP7`& learningwhatis really needed to do
These translations mope rea` SYdAS\AQQJAMβ+SGK*p4(Q!∀Jπ⎇→Fbε,Tε≡z]x LM9X=
≥Yh∃
<h→,L[|]∧ 8π2 widl be distriButing
the resulps when They are iN. FoR thiS purpose I havE set up #
mailing Lists at Stanford:
LISPTIMILC the list od peOple Interested↓S\Ai!SfAi=aSF~(∪→β'A)%β≥M→β)∨I&XAi!JAYSMhA←L↓aK←a1JAoQ<AQCmα)β[?e+;S↔-∪↔⊂4PH$%β&yβ∪=¬##∃β&K7'≠8βS↔O'→↓#πv!βSK∞sO3π&K?;MHh($$JβπQβ&C∃β[∂∪'?W~βG'S/_4(→I∃≥¬9zU∀≤X1∩π& TεfO>@ε}∩∞λV␈εLTπ>Ftλ
m≥≠λ⊂LT≤⎇4∞
≤:;Lq"B"!∀_Y;L=≠8<MyFEεB∧hwzH1pw MAIL th∞Ai!KgJA∃]iSi%KfACPA'β∪0@QJ]≤XA≠β%_∩¬→%'!)∪5∪∃∂↓Mβ∪_\8XR@A¬]HAi!kfACY←SHAβ≠←π7εK;≥β&C∃β7∞K3'≠8∧εfO>N2π≡QQ&F∂lTε⊗.]nW∞NβY`⊂≤wP3 \↔εEεB∧ds⊂≡wzP!Xy2P 4o be on o@9JA←L↓iQKg∀AYSgQ`
"∞ F.∂<Tπ∞∞l@λ
\ εE∀≤83` 3ai`_R↓s←kd↓YP∨∨Nqβ;πn)βπ≠ ∧π==→( ←_8u
O(_<d∂;x
yλ6ptv→y⊂;t[4∧
Understa`≥Hαβ'Qβ∞c?;≥¬;'S!¬;#'∂Bβ3'O"βg?Uπ;'O!¬#=β *β?99∧K⊃βG␈)βπK(h#OWπβ3g≥lrππ-xwε∞β<h
}H≥_-L;]β∧∞≠→0.<αP6 %t me ingw↓oQSG A→Sg@XAoQ%GP~∃αkπ∂#L¬f*B ≥f"π⎇
⊗≡B z2πN|¬( ≡Y(∀L↑≤Y4l]]~3LU@εEεB∧dw_p∧di@QS←\X↓BAYSMhA←L↓CYXA5KggC≥KfAa∃` @&≥≥fNvtλ
t≥~~.⊃"Y6∞NX=P,\9↑X$∞z;∪∧ Y(⊂↔[⊂*$fRdεG.MSG[DIM(@→'A:ACHααNε&b↓#g|¬( <9C"Hj∀λ⊃N5vP)Pdf⊂+Zz47j]⊂67sYtp∞g↓S\R\↓∪\AO∃]KeC0XAiQ%bACE∃BAoS1X∩+≤{;CπLqβπ∪bβ? β&C∃β'v3?K\≡FN}eDππ⊗|}&∞o5Dε∞vD
&/∨]JG4→[p→λ:44`3
project.
¬
I` As=jAW]=nA←L↓C]s←9JAoQ<ASfA9←hA←8AiQJ↓]KhAα ;⊃β>C=β7∂Iβ ∀hSπ ∪*βS :
VgαDλ l]Yλ⊂⊗YP0P -essage and a methodd¬P∨I∧∧v/'M→f 4~;@⊂≥4πuc@ ~∃oSβ#!β#Li0≡F↑!b∧␈lX D∞~→(
l>≥λ @2{P $ays I ho`e to @∃`∂Sπ⊗c'O!∧ε6}nTλ l@⊂:42CE0
e@QQP∨∪|c?∨'≤ 1β∂|¬g=9→0→_z4wg≤β ⊃gUGPACLAπεAβ#'7↔~Iβ≠∨⊂∧π&FT
π-zY0nEA"C!↓ "1
≤zh⊃l≤\Z1-A*⊂ (⊃`)`dS∀@
λ∧_⊂≥Aα5Tn∂%P∞ε∀λ ~L~∧i(⊃P⊂∧f~yx⊂*~vpw3H&ptf~w3P&~yzεE∃7]⊂⊂λ⊃ &)T* f@.DISKP,DGC] ∧ACHααNU6 I↓↓hP&←↔d∧6}nT
FzπM R∧f≤:α¬&≥]⊗v:
\⊗Nf≥lrεf≡:B`$⊂<h∂≥⎇(∪,∨(~_.l#"P⊂[92pr≡P3r`%pπgKHαaβS#*β@≡≡} Rε↑d
FF* I↔>λ∃~-]8π3@ Evaluation proJect is
v@∃` eβd∧↔⊗>Tλ
-d≤xsn +λ⊂-lλ~1D∞y(⊂.,(≥≠d
8:y$ (_p↔[:94q≥z4wwλ:7P 4he¬
@U]IKeQC]IS9JA←L↓Q←nAβ#=β↔4 3Gπ&)βOW≤Aβπ→∧+3@/=_
LT≥~~-lh_<d 9H⊃-n~<Y!QX{s.∞=~3LT→;]M≡Xπw6Yw:⊂ 7e wiLl neEd to consIder @5C]rA5KiQ←α#?3?>K∂π⊂hS'OO,∧W5β⊂!`)nce I a`~A9↑AKqAKehAα{9βO,∧6Bε↑h⊗g89~-⎇\h∩$ 8εP#[tp∞g↓iP≥β⊗+GWπ⊗(4+¬∧∧v}}Dλ \8ε⊂ /d∧AQKαcA1β∞s⊃βOzβ⊂⊗∂$λ -}Y(∃
8π⊂→ ⊂82`/ph JAαCπ[∃∧εf}g]nF.<Y1¬@∧@
The prgblems @]JAMC
JACE∀AU@? ∧ε@.αyz hkw @Q↑A[Kα OWK*βS#∃πβ↔K≠|ε&n∞l8 $↓ ¬7cλ842`3e LiSp syStems, but↓QWnAβ#=βS∞[∃β¬∧∧FO6↑.6*π<X
∧
yH⊂L]Xz≠,≡X¬FE≤97sy_vyP [2⊂3r]⊂:42[P:7P≤8¬f @=\AgsMiK@7~β[↔KJβ∪'≠4+@⊗.nDπ&F≥`π&F}<Rπ& X∞!Q]y0→→P;y4]8∧en↓IWd\4∀∩(LIβ#?ε)βπQ∧εFF* X LD≠yH∞M~<h∞∞[zP∩Xz⊂:7H12P X42P 4o rePort @9←h~∃=]QbAβ#'7↔~β≠ ?$λ ∞-yxX-↑hε⊂ "ut depπGeSAiS←]LA←LAβ≠gOS.kE!β'∪π;Od∧↔&N⎇aPWπ-x&f.↑5Bε∞l@λ ∀→y3L↑X;λ }:9→$∞≠h⊂~~2P;w\4∧d @=H α3M≠Aβ∂|¬Wπ∂M≥f*pQ!PPMM Rε6≡.7"π>X'∨&≥nFO6T V∞Nβ~;L@P;tf≠⊂12P_P8z`)ck l@%chA←_@∩¬[∃iQ←I=YP∨∨L≠π1β∧{';S~β←¬βv+↔⊃β&yβ∂?w≠'β↔∩qαS#M→β3'≤εBεO4
f␈" 9voεLZF*`Q(λN↑λ_:-↑h_=∧∞~→( M<Y0nM9{\d∞y(∪L\9λ⊂~≠P3wP_2s7i→P0qz≥pr⊂ 4imang runs
can be PerfoRm` H\4∀~∧∪QQCMVαβg?U∧3?IβL{WIβF+3AβLqβS#Lε2ππ-y&.∨EaPPH!⊃⊂L&≤92∧>≤.&N.D¬¬∃∧x
4 LE⊃PPh dF↑,R?~∞Mε*εm~'∨"
\W>x9y%D≥z~,=λ≡;nT≠:4n<9∞C!!lλk)\<K ≤ P⊂_K [i(⊃P⊂∧fYz47b≠v7s|H1ww9Zr2y0]4ww9N⊂⊂εE∃7]⊂⊂λ⊃ &)T*$f@.DIS[P,DOC] atSU-AI
1( A∂ AiS[∀ASfA
aSiS
CX\A∃mKer↓iS[Sαs∃βOF{W3⊃∧K;∂3.#∃α∞¬)βS'n(4+π~β7.≡>W⊗.Dλ'JπM R∧≥
Tε≡f|=2πεN↑2∧<4∞FNnUd∧N2λx2π&≥\RεO4
f␈ Q,⊗≡≡}]g&.D
⊗rπM R∧d~:αbπ|Tπ≡F}]F"ε≥l6g9→( ∀≤⎇_-l_<Y∧∞→<⎇¬D≤⎇8m↓"X<d (≤≤M||X;$∞~_=∧ |Y8.L<h_$
_8YlUλ≤⎇ ≥Y_<LD≤⎇≤N\⎇≥<LT
_X-L9Xq,A"]≤L\(≠qD∞{{9$∞{|]πu(_;LD≥~→-d_{u-nλ⊂t
T≥~;,T≠{H ∀→[tL<9λ⊃h5λ≤Y.>;≥~-lc"Z-d_(⊂→Yqww2≤Wqrf≠⊂34c]y2P3≠y⊂2`Xt⊂6pXt4w2K⊂⊂&p↑q2P;YP9t7]v2⊂"≠P:44\FE4wλ0r24]4ww⊂≥5P:4→P12w_t6py~y←P-Rw⊂3 !ct, @5KCgkIS]NA≥εAiS5JAS\↓BA[Kα ;'≠>3W04U;πeβLε2π∂\Tε&Nli⊗∨.N@ε'.T
FzεM≤f&/,]g"ε≥Lv␈⊗≤¬~
↑hπ⊂(→y00x≤P0P)_w3rP≠sεE 4p¬KJAMiekGβ#WK↔≠yα7πN∪∃β;|εBε∞MDε∞f⎇z&O&
↑2ε∂,Tπ∨N]\W'⊗≤4ε}r 8λ.%xy≤G{#"C!&KH∃∞,;\{ ≡~;Yd
[{K.>_;Y ≡Yλ⊂m⎇]≤[mD≤⎇≤N\⎇≥<L↑h_x-d_Y( ∀≤≤[l-→;#AQUz_.D_8[n↑λ≠[me;≠xl≥λ→{nMi|h ≥_(⊂l≡_zβnM≤[ugt∃~→.<(_x-d_Y(∞=;=; ≡→9β!.z=~∧λ4TSj%q4TJ8λa`→X↓ckGP↓[@↔SF{∪M|hP4)Mpαπ31∧s?96dJNAβ∨K;Cπ@∧εo/>@ε⊗*∞
&*n←∞ε∞vLXBαF∃lR`$⊂s∩*:λ(⊂~≠P0v ,ow
@QQJAYα{∂π⊃∧ε7O∨LYRπ&tλ n∞~;:/,(_<d <≤∀M}≤Z8.L+C"AQM @⊂⊂4πth↓S]iKβ∪CK↔&+⊃βπv!β∂?oβ'3↔ ∧ε≡}LTπ>Nβ≠λ ,(≥~-\αr↔εB v6⊂_wr2P≥tp l have macroq pre-expandedQChAαc?∂πbβ@≡OL↑3zJ∞9rπ& ≡@hV\hfN≡≤]f≡N↑4ε'∞T
Fzε≥l7ε.\X NL8ε⊂ $estructive expansioN can↓EJ~∃α+3'7L¬f∂&\@ D↓ C"FUH∪]-\<Z0⊃H1wr2H9t7j[2⊂40]2P0v≠⊂:<h→yP0w≠7zw1Yp⊂:7H:42P≥90w9[0z7i≤β bi the
qources sO that optimizations caf Be made wiThkutdeductigns, ∃β1XA←i!KdAgUGPASαs∪/Kn S'∨pβ7WO β ∃β∧ε&␈6≤LV"pQ!PC2d
FF*∞8
/,(≠p∪λ9zq`( pro@≥` π↑4ε≡∞dλ&*ε≤∧XM≡≤X<O∃α⊂:4≠zst≥90w9[0z4g→FE&`Pilf`H4¬ai ta`↔J↓BAoQ%YJAi<AI↑\~∀4S90∩∧≥H ∧∞≠{p⊗≤β deVelop@∃HAi↑↓CSHAβ#@⊗∞β\s ≡~;sD∞z≠p~[2⊂12H33y;Xy22bλ:7FE∀(#P 3o that they may be Evad`+¬iKHAα ;⊃β&K@∨'-_'/&\@λ
≤β⊂0x≤93x 2iate.
~∀`XA!e=H∂Kπo→βS#∂!βπK*βWO↔4εVbπMtε
π=x
.1rP!≥z⊂4`-possIbh J@!S\AB4⊃aeC
iSGC0AgK]MJRAi<AaeC9gYC@&)βO#|εVf"
\W-=λ⊂→\2qt`[⊂0r:→w:4`/n to
deCi` JA%H βSF+K∃βLε2ε
∞X l\];λ L8=≥.,(~0↔≥7v; %d.¬
λ9. (drgm↓∂⊃$R4⊃)S[%]NAm¬aS@?,ε2ππ-x n0p
s is a↓H∂?? ∧εNε\⊂ ∧ ]=⊂≥42P $ata @]SYX~)EJABαβ3'S&c∃β#∂∪⊃βSzβ↔cS⊗ C/3∂#∃ 2∧ ↔4_;↑-⎇Y(⊂∪[tp∞g↓iP≥βn+πOW⊗(4+C∂∪π7↔&+@↔~∞8
,=λ_<dλpπg)H90p∀e, ti@5JAi↑↓S]m←α[∃β¬∧επ-βqr`$ure,
λ¬C@; ∧ε∞→λ⊂~~vry←H-`∞o@PAP∨;dπ∩πε ≡Bbε,¬0~λ4εumber COL¬'S]≤AC@; ∧εO'1Q&.YY0⊃]⊂7w np @7,ε&N~ 8λ-L⎇;⊂⊂]4p∂ns sho@UYHAE∀AP↔↔∂≠WK↔ ∧ε∂~∞|Vf@λπ⊂$→y2FE∀(#P 7ill @¬aa←SαsQβO|¬V*ε←∞ε/↔L∧h¬
α4urH%'g&
P:7P≠pp e up s@=[@∀Q( m⎇yλ⊂↔≥vry4XP:2`3ti`≥Nαβ∂?∪*βS :
_ m⎇_8
2H4p
p@1K[K]QCiS←αsπ1β∧ε&}⊗β→0⊗\β
∃@>KS!β≤εε.≡≤h
,4_8 `0ect`&↓←@→αd¬↔>λ∧WεBαλ
∀bβ↓0∩¬ X n
α2P 3hh∂kYα!βOW∧εεgJ∞8 m\αP2`3ti`≠CQJA←L↓iQJAβ∪W;SL¬V*ε≥lBπ~→(∞2yz`,ts
@=H βSF+'Iβ⊗+;∂#n @⊗←5`λ
>8z≡M~;YnP0p∪ 2 mi@9kiKf↓←@→α≥αUβ?p∧ε
∧αsλ∞8¬`≥]%]N~∃Q_∞BMhε∪αε≤∧h @eP @ khAMα{@∩π]lf∞nα;⊂∀Xy⊂6pXt4w2\β(∂3Lε7π~∞MεO~
\↔Jεmx
∧ Y(⊂∪[wr⊂ %nh∂kO Xλ (αU≤O∀≥≠h ≥8εP !t so@5JAKgβ#'7παLRεNβH⊂~→y0
s o` Ai!JA]k5EKdAα{⊂∩∧9ye≡<h⊂↔\α fu@9GiS←αp4+∂∞c1β∪,επ&BβC"AQL, ↔λ ¬ve@IrAGC9ISICQJAgsβ≠S↔Tλ m
βzv $ ha`-α)β¬β&+Sπ≥H ,D→→0→Xy0 `!β#'?9∧¬v $≥~_.Aα@
depπGeSββS'⎇`λ¬λt⊂
P_y1t4]2qz:\αe, @5K[@?↔IβO'β(Rbε≤LG,<|h∞t⎇2Vλ80st[3P0v→βori@QQP∃9p¬bHhαC"@↓AβX⊂∀5≠CdZβAE↓↓αεC#Hα4[l,<X
H. Bep¬P↔πp∧βe∀λ λ ≡λ∪2*E30oD↓3~0→\⊂*4`-ing Mai`→Sαs⊂~∧β~0→]⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ~⊂&p\αch 1981 04εthpαj⊗NPhR≠K⎇P∞D
Xπq2\αpλA⊂αqα ↔⊗kπ9↓βJ$D∩ ≡B∧l~@ )XoC"J>8ZP∩Xz≥⊂⊂∪4yx⊂∃4p
i@9H
α\≥⊗fNβY`⊂∪4yzεBαTo: RPG @¬hA'*jε$Q(λl7Hλ@⊂⊂&)`⊂TIH
] %'7 Y⊃_∞∞u⊂∧ε∂"λ∧u%X2#"AQ@εE&X|P$P≤βuggepπhAi!JAM←αc3 ?⎇_ L@P0p∪ a be@9GQ[CIP
β≠|ε"ε@];9.4qpv≠<P7`2i` @;& S↔⊂hSCK|-F.o4εH∞M→(⊂~~vrP )t takes to do @∧AMC@≤εBε6βy0→~p¬r @Q` πn8 M}XεP /d∧XAgα eβ3,¬f >~β"F⊗ M⊗λ4πf @IKC@1∧¬w$_{p⊗\4∧ex↓ICiBαp4(Q!P@)(~_.l(_Y,]H_p↔[4∧ec@QS]NAα{[↔I∧∧∩πε↑-⊗}λ≠p∪λ≠⊂<bXy9P 4imangpεAM←β⊃βC#Lε0hW>L↔&O>M⊗∨~
x D (≥z,L(≤X-ly(∪l@⊂6pqZ4s2`3 (ne@¬aP∪@∀εSαJ ≥f"ε=x .
9→4NT∧
Aqsemblerc etc.↓)Qkf0AiQSβ→β ↔v≠#'π⊗Yβ←?,¬F"ε,Tπ6//∀εF.Nλ N]β"P∀[⊂92f_z4w3H&4yhλ4pqd~w2P(→y37`2mafc@∀Ai↑Aαkπ;e∧¬w&F↑ λ ≡Xz~.L8⎇≥.,<kC!↓ ¬$P~0{2P_P1v !pπfA←α1βCK|∪3↔7~βS#π ∧∧Jπ,X D∞~_=∧∞<y(∞NX;\lM|[
\αz47Y9FE &or sOlp
@'v9βCπ↔#'π1∧∧FN6lX L]]~0-D→<=,≡~;{N∀_;Y∧∞→<YM}Xεt`.g
cOvoluTions and Smoothing. Hefc@∀A[rAαK;C↔⊗+OQβL¬bε6nN2`h!Q%≡∂lX L≥λ≤≠m≥]≤h∞MβP5rYx⊂4gλ6tw2λ0q7z]⊂:44\P12w_t6py~]
λ1. On LM≥bAiQ∃eJASβ→β¬β&K∪≠↔⊗+;∂∃∧∪↔S←.+9βOn 3!β4c?;Wo→βπ; β≠#?w+7MaQ%∨/∞
w≡*
_
∧∞y<Y$ ≠{Y$∞z=~∧
88|o≥8)|d Z9yMMx=λ∞ 8zx,|(≥≠d ;≠≠nq"Y[n∧λ→>∞L;Y→,D≤≤Y,=<z3meC"C!&KH⊃L≡⎇λ⊃L↑[8=∧¬∩;] \y<J$
≤X;N<[|[.4_<Y$ ;≤{d
→;∀ n;λ∩ ↑Y+H ≥]→9l↑\c"M≥H≥~ T≤X;L|( λ∞Mh WF& λ∀l∨+λ⊂l≥H_Y$ <h≥.<9];∧ <h≤m\;≠β!,[≠{N]<kλ .=λ⊂~~2|P:\rP7g≠<P4`.tegeR arithmatic.
λ3 ≤AA←oKd↓←D@@⊂βSKπw≠∪/Ko→1βπv!βS#,¬↔$→X;-≥~94eD≤X9
∨λ C∧∞Y_:/∧
`→ εA10Y4|⊂≤
Z⊃Qελ2z1Vλ1pw→5P9w[p¬ o@_AiQK%` β JβG#'5#';≥bβ@⊗∂M WαπM ⊗ph,M↔6NM≥f:Rλ.W"ε}Mε/∩ ,↔≡∂5DεJvU`βK∩
→g∨&\≤Bε↑dεc"ε}$β ∪¬Dε≡∞dλ&*ε]x LQ Y9L@4qtb[:⊂:4_w⊂27]q64w→P:42H:90w≤s0∂rm length&
4.The Internal data repres@∃]aC@&K?9β≤∧⊗rε\≥6*ε∀λ
≤YY0→→w1rWλ&7qp[∧¬∃Mα C'π⊗c↔Mβ|¬bπ& Tπ∂&≤=2ε@yH⊂$∞⎇8\M}=~3LT_8 2H30yj→y⊂:7H92s"\αefc@∀AiQC8~∃CEICsf\αα%βWv#↔KO& ;⊃β&C↔K∃∧¬↔4_;@⊂_y1t4]2qz:\αial li`≠Sβ!β >dεc"π>L⊗≡XQ(
L≡X∧pq≠2yP /n @→~α;E 2λ¬{n]→λ⊂∀]⊂2{ %p∧Ai↑↓EJAaα{@∨≡≤-F*πMtε≡F≥lv*ε≤@∂d 8π⊂ ! 4#"
λa`→O=` 'SFi1βSF)β≠π≤εF/∨Dλ
∞0yw3≠y0
UpπS@;8∧π∂&≤92π⊗≡-⊗∞⊗LZ2ε}mH∞$ {⎇; D≥~→-a XY$ (λ 56 leNgth Tp¬C@;≡3?KUDε∞vD
FF.dλ
<Y(∞⎇⎇;⊃∧ (→→,@y0r0]4ww→5yεE≠4πngep∧Aie¬]gM←β∪7Mβ&CπQβ/≠↔⊃β∂∪@⊗∂∀λ L\Y<Y-ly<kAQ@εE~K⊂ P $on't↓QCmJ↓BAG←αkC#↔&+3eβ>{?⊃β4∧V.f≥lrπN↑@ε&@|H⊂-Mλ≠p∪λ:42FB9zq:≠2z4b\β and spe@∃I`↔C~βπ[πLcπ ∪*β∪ ?$λ -≤|[pm|~;Yd (≤⊂→≠q22fCE;9P≥y0 `)%]NASαqβ3'≤εαbε≥nF/↔∞,W&Nlp ∧ {{<
≥~;YeD≠xH ={<~-M8π3FB4s:7H4p c@I←G←I∀XA/Q∃\ABAβ≠↔∨7,¬g"ε|dε≡}LTεO~ ⎇vNvt
Fzε,Tπ/≡\@λ
}Y<@ ≥Yβ"M}Y<@ ≤βptg ⊂0w2λ:42P_wr2P~yw∪zλ3wtw→β to change( shouldn't iT be
in micrgc@=IJ}~(~∀l\↓∩AGC8A[CW∀AgKm∃` πDλ LNλ≤_,=x9y.∀_9P⊂Zpv0q≠2P4`. lisp ngw∞ One is a
naive radix 2butderfly algoRithm, desienedth∞AE∀AgQ←IhAi↑↓oe@'&)βπlAPFN↑ F.n]nBεNdλ∩εG↑.'J@H⊂
4→P9r`#ond IpεABAβ∪π&∨β"[$λλ-lλ≤X,M>λ∞&D→X;-≥~:#!
βs⊂*≤αa`≥gα3?K↑4π&F≤@λ∞|αy2P≥y0 den fo@HABAmα+∂S?⊂βπK∂FKS↔∂,ε&*εM→6*πM R∧∨,∨∩`@ ¬1:]⊂:10[9v0z→p∧ near`→@Jβ3'S,ε&∞fO∀εNwMtεfO>¬b∧⊗\8λ.↑y(⊂~~2P!`2ay e@9G←ke¬H∂/1Q'&.β<⊂↔\αar`2↓mKGi=` MDλ
<h⊂→_p∧ihhVdAα 3∨?⊗KS#5∧εW<αyP ! h ←Hαβ?2∞8
}X9y%Aα@
`%¬iQKdαβS#πp∧π'⊗≥n6 -βy6yH4p∞ @AYCGJ8A∩AQ¬mJA]=hA`',εBεF⎇x
l\α⊂4`.th∞Ai!JAS@≤ε7.<c"I∀≤X:.p¬d @%\@h]=` ↓Up¬Bε↔↑@λ∞M→<p∩H4εee@⊂ACi@&+;@&≥x D <h⊂≠Yv6↔εB∧¬∀Zαi↓α |∧"∧⊗↑-V∞r∧¬π-_P⊂⊗XT@
λ∧_⊂≥Aα@ )\<K ≤ P⊂_≤M[Dia[z:↔#_t66p[⊂0r @π⊂⊗Uhε∪∧
↓~&+Rλ¬≤L≥\{⊂⊂]4πrs
Date: 4 Marchbr`!λ↓EIE⊂j⊗NQαBWπ∪v+O&≤ε*!QQ\[mWH⊂ `#ott.Fahlman at↓∞ -UP &λ!"U
wH⊃~,=h⊃x,.X93∧π∀T⊃d =λ∀jU02/D↓ ¬)zX52qj∞α Re8∧A)E¬]gYCQ←ef~)βεtAα;We;∨#↔πLTε∂"λ9U*k⊗λ⊂hT≥aU⊗/
H∞%Z≠nH∧λ~8rdλx8\M≤8ε∪yH4ryyXpπe @=H ↓M∧kπI↓@ε∩β ↔&#∩lX:@hT\Z7∞∞|UTN#$πCβ$\≡#C
∧∧ → Y~S⊂∀c~P ⊂βH *ZDaα`8hP4(Q(FN≡5APDJ
mw&N<TεNr ≥bε.≡-FN∂$λ ,↑|x9lT≥~_.D~8
⊂≥pyP #ontemph C@&+⊃βSF Qβ¬∧∧g.fDλ l↑λ≠p∪βE:4fZw3yP_2P27[2P7`. CEE'pεA[←⊃SMCK⊂A)∨!LZb`AMsgiK4Aek]9S]NA5βπ2M~A9↓∧ @~ε∀↓PGε⎇→g"ε|dεNvmx M\=~3meλ_;
D≤y0→~wzyP∪pqv ) andI would prefer
that theY cabry a @≥←←HAα#↔π1∧¬v $≥~→$
≠x9∧
{H≥
<kC!!"Uy$ <Y(∞⎇9≠~-lkλ⊂∩]2w⊂2Xpπer, to @≥KhAi%[SMOLAMOdααOC'≤)α3'∨↓β?9¬##∃β,ππ&.lLV"¬λZ%λh%
vv≡Tλ
lT→y5∧ 9H⊃/∞α2w2→p∧ @ERQ), bqt @QQSfA∃H ≠?↔!β←'d¬Bε@_9`⊂≥42P']42y9H1<P≠λ4p∂nths
@=H βOzβ←#'d)β@>Tλv/"
zWαε≤:Bπε||W&F↑ D∧⊂(⊂≠[zv2 pref@∃` βSzβGπ[*β?WI∧εG,8π9v_z4wgβE0w2λ4¬easuremenp c@eGYKf↓H ?$λ
=λ⊂~_yuV⊂≤βi`≥Gα)β#?'→β >d
εf∞<X d x;@⊂_t2q`+ kuta
∃≠¬GYSG@Xλ$!Q$∞fD v $≥~~.P67`/hπfAM¬Se@3β∀εNwLX L↑⎇~3LUβ⊂⊂$]⊂6p|H3rw2\αate more headthanlight, ∃EUhACHαβ3↔π≤εBπ& X LT≥z3
D_Y(∞wvrP→0z0@ th∞AE¬g@∃β&C∃β≠d∧⊗n<h∪meλ_;LD≥~→$∞α90w≤v0r4[wεE !i`s Shh∂kYα!β ∃∧ βK↔↔Iβ@/<X N]λ≤r,L(→0∪→αect∞
--↓'G←iP~∀4P0 ;∧ATn∂%P∞ε∀λ ∞&W 0tjh6 Xm <H⊂⊂]⊂!2i~βadeY liSp beNchmarhπS@;8∧ααα↓Q$&∂LW"β" \↔αβ↔↔β
β¬↔#ββ&Frm¬8APT↔-⎇SB∧::d
Bl9ε∂∩ ≡B∧⊗↑-6.f←⊃PU&w$π↔εxλ l≥8εεE∀zq5"Xz≥⊂&~yx⊂1→w1t6Xy0 i@9N~∃πα→`∩ε≥mF∞o4≤&␈NLX∧⊗/-<Vf/∃D∧:uP6¬@1t0y⊂!2y5Yv2|Vλ!i`⊗AX.fateman@@¬KeW∃YKr~(~∃%S
QCeH↓
CiK5C\AQ¬`
β'v3?K\X ∧
9(⊂↔Yα the eff@=` @"∂→w*?,Tε␈⊗|≥fOV≥lrπ&qQ&≡}↑ ↔⊗* I↔>λ≤v.>→;<eDλ∩P-\αyP!≠|r2P
1y{ ↑↔0w6_vyPq≠|r2`⊂ ¬RKELEP∩R↓C]HA$~∀QGβ≠[πav ; &≥↑2∞≡ ≡$∧∀X)4,@⊃6*$∞{⎇3 D≠~2lT≥≠h ,(≤≥.D≠{@∂≥⎇<@
\8;⊂∀[3P6 )pπh~∃α3?Iβd¬↔>λ_Y-lz≠8.
z;YeDλ∃y$
_=P∩H0P8 2ocram, part of a prodπeCZ4⊃`∪K∞sO≠|-V∂&≥⎇bπ∨≡8
]+λ⊂≠Z4qt≡wzP6X|P12H4w:2\2yz2Y⊂4w~w1v*Y4s3@ in the
αbenchmapking, IT currently runs on Fpa`≥t0AC@; ∧ε}r∞Mε*∧_)S≠≠∧ FO∨↓Q&∂6≥→F∞⊗LTε∂"λ≡&.}mlR`$λ∃y$ {y3 D_|Y,≡→(⊂$∞|→0⊃Zpr⊂ 6ersi@=\A←L↓iQJAα≠?β∀hSS#π ∧ππ⊗\LV -8π2`3 p
Ce%CEIKβ→β'≠≥#↔π⊃∧¬v $≤Y0⊂Y4p∞g↓iQKSβ⊃β@6≥H
,↑h≠p∪→α of d¬S@3,ε3@1 R+i@P;pyH842P≠w20→ p¬KCX↓ae@?⊗c↔5αJβ#π⊃∧¬⊗rε=x Nl<Y~-lh≥~ T≤≤[l@y0v@ th∞A
β∪π;hhSS#'~βCπO ∧ε ,8ε6↔λ⊂ `(αβ'Mβ∞qβ'≠&+C↔O&K;≥β∧ε&}|X;$
9H⊂~~0z⊂ )t is a "beal"
appl@%GCiSα{9β?2α3'Oα↓5 *∞λ -}≠→(
=Y(∞↑y9⊂≥42P 4p¬C@;≤3?K\≡FN}d
7O∨LX $ XπqεB22{ %lh∂a[∃]`⊃β|∧bεN≤Mαπ≡|h
∞|<Y(
<Y( ≡λ⊂<L⎇{[Y%D_8h∞∞Y<⊂→≠qryi[y⊂:7H0@
@QQK@?⊗+5βC⊗{[↔Ibβ↔S
p∧α∧ODλ
.P77`4 so @%]`∪↔⊗+@∨&≥lrε7-yRπε Tπ6N↑}ε}Nn@λ
|A"P∩↑2y1`)pπS@;8∧ε
εMx
∧
βs⊂ $i`
MKβ∪↔;Q∧c'OA∧∧f.∂LX L↑h ⊗H⊂6pt[4∧p∩Aαc'OQ∧∧⊗≡≡↑8 d 8π2εBαcre@¬iS@?p¬Bε∞βY⊂⊂βH∂:&K;≥→αα+'Tλ&␈Nβ→( ↑⎇~0⊗Xz2yP≥40p∀↓C\ASαsS↔K,ε7&NβYc!12w1Z4¬a`%,Aek\αβ←?Wd∧Bπ_:y$εl ≠ ⊂6t`.,∧A←L↓( πa∧∧7π(≥~-\αP9:[4εang p @;&+@∩∧n,⊗wPβ"J
≥]→0→≤92z2Y∀W⊂⊂∃44qP≠tst:λ12P 4oo l@=]NAMα{@∩ε,X L=≠8<Mtp∞g0ASLAβ#↔OSL¬f(hαX 2\βources are expensi@YJT4Ph ⊂`@lλ
-Mar-`b@@@λεc∪8→λT%∀_92ε∂D
%-⊃q4J4α8p↔[p¬ti@5JA←L↓aP∨O≤¬⊗⊗@→(⊂∀[8∧ereqt
Date: 4 Mar "βIaE↓α⊂∞&↔+14jAα@
F@I←Z`)∧B⊗∩JL~-βπα@λ
*5⊃q**c"Tn\X¬2`#t: s@=[@↔SL¬V*ε|dπε@||p∀X4∧e @%]`∪↔⊗+@∨ Q*F{R∞.ε 4_8
SQ-AI
~∃$AC@5∧¬f␈" X NM<Y0⊗≡P1v %ar what i@LAO←Sαs⊂~ε⎇`λ∞⎇=~⊂≡wzy lisp ti`≠Sαs⊂∨_Q( ,≥8ε4`.dεAYSβ≠Q9↓∧C?←↔4∧W$≤∧w`5 h CR↓aP∨O≤¬⊗⊗@≤∧P "e interes@QK@⊃βL¬`hVβ≠p↔Zβi`≥NαβπQβ&C∃β≠L¬F*¬>.W&>↑.5kf X ∞4qu@>newl@%`∂Ad∧¬N␈Tλλl≥H⊃U
∧~8
εBαp∂S@&C?WQ∧¬F}yz0↔→β in↓∩AiQ%]V@9αα%β@≥x
$
_8 % p ↑Aαc?:
x D
β{2`2 @
) 0~∃gaα+∂'≠JβWO↔⊂∧εv∞β9(λ→SsV)Yβj`∪ and @¬]rAaα @∨∨⎇x LEHλ∃
<h⊂∩→yqy4X2yFE≥42P 6ar`∪←U`
βS,ε7'~ ∀εF∂lTε&↑lTε'<Z3LT→→0→Zqw⊂ /d∧A →%' @1∧εFF*
lW8h,[π&.βY→,D_9→∞,<|p∀[3P; %p¬gS←αqβ >d
T J H
.x⊂3 /p∧A)←A`
+&¬bα∧α(⊂~~4p∞k
λ¬β→∪M AoSαc1β;|εBεF≤¬P∩H4¬uc@ AS@9∧εFF*∞|↔Jε|dεNvβ[p≠_z4wg≤Tε It in
λ¬S@;&+;∪↔ ∧π&@h_Y$∞=:0~→P⊃1`,assi@
CXD\α↓α%;*qβO?n+S#'v9β@& ≡Bπy(⊂∃[5{FE~5{P 4o do, a`≥Hαβ ≡v|¬`⊂≥40p∀↓iQJAβ∪↔OWdεG4≠yH∞⎇8ε6⊂_2P:`3e`
kX↓H ?$λ
.U
It is Lisp 1( l←U∞%αd¬↔>λ_p↔[9z9:Xz2r withLisp machine techno@1←G`$hQ#@&tλ
(→0≤≥2s:≥p¬ c@¬\AI↑↓ShA←αqβS#*↓IADλ Mt⊂q∀E\{y~-lkλ⊂→Zw1rP≥40p∀
λrequires micro code chang` f\α↓α W β←¬β&yβGOL¬f 4_(⊂⊃[x8 iNe GC and
everything is done With Typed↓a←S]QKef\αI↓α%∧∧WGε\8
∧∞~→(∞ <YP↔\αh C]
JAi↑↓EJ~∃β≠'7πd AβSzβS#π ∧ε}∩λ¬0i∀⊂ε4i\⊗⊂0yH:42P_0yt`# structurepεAoS1XAEJ↓iQJAMC[J\4⊂
'Q∧εvNfDλ
≤YY0→λ4p∂c@QYrAE∃GCkgα)β >dλλm⎇<≠⊂∩]2p y diff@∃` ↔; β∪πSλh#K↔∧ε&/≡]nF∂&≥yg4_;Y∧λβaP&Yz47`$q( @A¬]HAE∃GCkgα)β >dλ /∞α2w2→p⊂0r→92y`3ing,
λ¬`∨#L∧6Bε⎇`π&FTε#απ>M⊗f@λ~_.P82`2d¬P∨Kn ;∂∃∧επε@x[⊂∩[yP∞ L@ /→%' Ae∃IKeF↓iP≥β&C↔O∀hSCK∨⊗c↔7M∧εvO&
x
.D→>≤
L8∧w4[3P:4→vW⊂⊂∃42P&Xtp∞ @AaP∨ d∧Vjε≡4εNr∞Mε*εLX m≤{H⊂↔Yαλ
+&C∃β#∂∪∪@>≤,Rπε≤|WαrλMεO~
_ d∞~→(∞M~;Yd∞~_=∧
88⊂→H90p∩tua`_Aβ#=βCGK@≡N<≥@hV≤LG⊗/>8W5β⊂⊂$]⊂9t7]v2⊂ "e a`'β≠?∂'∂#'[∃∧k↔7}/∩bε.X
∧
<h∩-↑≠→3,]]→1∧ ↑(⊂⊂CE:0q≠2W⊂*~2P72]⊂2s &ect @=H βSF)β@&≤-F*ε≤4π&F≤@λ∞M→(∀l≥9(⊂∩[894P~yP:iYp⊂3 /p∧⊂∀,∧⊂⊂Yp¬s 1000, 300 , 50 @X@n`@`XAKβ#
2∧ ⊗rεl≤7"b∞⎇εN≡∧λ
≥Y(⊂∀[⊂:42H8∧able i`&4⊃`↔O,∧BεO4λ ↑→<[-≥Y9⊂_<P14]9P∪@74 of the @AC@∨∃∧¬g.n,X D¬~+Y%@⊂80sYyFE_L__⊗_L__V_L_→⊗⊂_w2⊂_L_→P !pe all stoped @%\AiQ∀AgC[∀AQS]∀RP→↓¬##↔K*β'Mβλh ⊗↑L¬1 \αP:7H892`6ent @=IHA]U[EKe∃HAgKα≠S'⎇n2ε7-x $
8π:2\αfering with e@YK\4T¬g.n,X L\α⊂7`.es (The s@∃GiS←αqβ 7]\&/∩
_ d X∧p∀s 777⊂00 ∩X↓oQSGαAβ'M∧εvGJ ∀εfO>LV @ ¬0⊂@¬H∂/4ε∪ββ¬Dβ≠β∧∧ ↑_k@⊗λ0p∞d↓]P∨Qβ↓1↓Iβ↓A1↓p¬b`$λ∩0∪λ<p∂`*↓QCaaα+9βSzβ ∀Q(
-mα:q`+y(λAC9HAQCYJAG←α#∃β'p∧πε∞|Tβ β∧∧ ∧ (≤p~_quP )n page 3 @`XAC9H⊂∀,L↔&
_ D∞_9y$ε,λλ_ ⊂8 o@U` β∂|∧F*ε<≥bε.≤∧p∀[<P9:[⊂0P &acto@HAP∨→β⊃AβSL¬V/~↓Q'=≠x r\α than i`(βo←kYα!β ?M W.z8 `%,∧@A¬dAGC@⊗+⊂↔8ε6 9 po`'αKS'⎇m⊗v:∞hλ.4p∂`+β_4+ d¬v≡←4λ l@⊂20z_P6w`3t of the @A` >-H -↑h_p⊂[⊂12P≤92{ %np KHαp4(Q*εf.≤∧p∩H4ε`∨@ ∧π&F≤¬⊂⊃d∧ISP is @%]`∪↔v#↔"∞Mrε⊗Tλλ$∞=:0⊃Zβ and saf@∀AS@7∧¬F.n]nF∂&≥x E@∧¬∃)!ChA[∃C]fAβ##πQ∧IβπTλ M}λ≥≤O≥8π3@ th∞AO∃hAiQ∀AP∪πα8
∧ Y=`⊂≤2y1`%npλA←α1β↔≠4¬⊗≡N]l7J@@εE$H0p
@⊃←S@;8πS#'v;@~ε≥`λ∞|>8h∞M_8
I be@1S@↔[*β←'MDεv@⎇λ⊂→→xzt`2e mu@
PAIKα∪W>⎇_ L@F@
`)%[@∃1∧∧W6.βH⊂⊂]⊂:42H894`#e of pπaKKα!0∩αλ¬~
≡h~0→H12q`!use I a`~Aα β .≥l⊗ <αy⊗⊂_w2εE→4πn't ha`-α)β /\8
∧∞α4vrH8∧o @]` 'S*β∂?∪*β?Iβ&yβOW∧εε␈↔Dλ
.D_9P~→y⊂4`4 is @→S]@'α8
\α⊂∞
-(
ZZαi5 (β"C! h∂LAα3?3/~βπK∃∧εG/8∧w3H87P -ake @∃`∂S'n S↔M∧¬v $≤→0→≤βonal p
KeMkfAi%[@∃β≤CπK↔ ∧ε∞vAQ'∂.=λ =≠z0⊃YyP1`!n only be made i` Asα{Uβ/v{]β#|εrεN≥o∩πε]x
L(_p⊂[⊂12P≤β` e@4¬⊗≡∞DλλO∀_#"J@ hλ (KH% "β↓1↓Iβ1A1β,εF~R∀λλL\Xπp∩e perfor`≠C9G@∃β'∪?CM∧¬v ,KHλ
={9( M<xp~\βsio@8AP∨→∧εFFO1Q&O∨>X $∞{⎇0⊗→⊂12P≥yrs 5l to pπkGPαβ⊂⊗@{~|e@∧¬∀~)QP∨←L∧R¬≡∞-v⊗(β"C!β)zq5→qz≥⊂∪4yx⊂∃4p
i@9H∂Mα?∪?W@hRS-i∧ε'ε: ≡B¬≥UX∀HhαXp⊃Nα co@I` ↔≤∧X$ =λ∃*H4∧ iKXXFEβE$4Wλ⊂ 've be@∃\AS]Y←YmK⊂AgSi AaQJ↓[CC]QK]C]
JP∨↔G#↔;OL¬vw~
x D∞≥{h
M<|∀eD∃0
&∩ihεE
4πn CDC e@EkSa[∃]h@%∧∧⊗v"λX4L@⊂∧ihλ∀)2`4e` eF↓→Sg`0AKiF$X@A∨9JA←L↓iQJAQQS@;?→βS#∂!α$Q(
≤λ~0↔λ5zy≥2y1`)on o@_A+π∪1∪' AQQChAβ;πMβnK@∨≡\@λ /(∪⊃,@0p fRe ⊃C9HXAQ∃]GJX↓≠CKQ¬\R4Tεv∂~∞Mrπ∨ X ,D≥<λ∞M→(⊂∀[8∧erpreteR,∧@@Q1KECSYeJAO=hABAα≠?C@∀λ l@⊂6|P≤wzy1YP9t7\αpli
λbefOpe I made the Speed↓kaf\αI↓απ ∧ε∞∨NXλ-M≤∧P 7ound↓k`AE∃S]NAα β≠↔8βC↔K≤+;Qβ4∧↔∨&↑!PG& ≥b∧l_9DM≥∧¬ε⊗␈Mε}r∞Mε*π<≥V*¬Iz¬~K⊗∧εn∞=
⊗v*∃`ααD∀λλL]~9=LT⊃00iI4tλ∞≥⎇<XlQ"XslL(~0→H1v7yYP2w7]qt⊂:≠P6puYP:42H9pvrH1t0w→pyP⊗H:44`3 wac very old/@U]GQC9OKH~)G←IJ↓S\Ai!JAS]QKeae∃iKd\αH4(Q(⊗wO|∨∩b∧∀|Bεf≥<Rπ&t
f}g]nF.∂$
'.vm_ LT≥~→$∞→<⎇∞P7w⊂∃a`P&~yx⊂'[⊂17j~⊂0P→ ≠_εE
*'h)KY_∀P_w2⊂0H%dV@10 (DOPS% "@RT@A$OZABαβ3'S&c∃β#,ε6O&≥nBε∞-zW"ε=x -]=→~-lc"P⊗↑yrv & to @Q←↑A[UGPAo=aVAEUhASH↓YP∨?←→β#'↑)βg|¬)mMα⊂40]2P9`%veral peo@AYJAeU]P≠'v84*V≤Iα3'≤εαπ≡t V∂N,Tπ&FTλ
m}X¬P 7ill @ JAgaβ∪↔π⊃∧∧↔-⎇;Y¬Dλ
∩$ ⎇90→\β thipεA[Kα ;Mβ&CπP4Tπ⊗␈*∞9ε␈.L@λ ≤α2⊂ -e to your↓→∪'¬"& ,→hrε∞βY⊂∪$i`⊂TRAN@'1β!∂%LAYSgβ#@~@J#"AQQ[p→λ2pq`)ly transpOp¬`∪π⊗c∃β∂|∧F*@λ∩)mMα⊂9:[⊂4r≠w⊂ ∃TLISP bp hAα3?Iβ∞seβ↔G#↔;OLεf(h,9ε∞v|X d ){⊂⊗λ80p∪@LX ↓α&C∃β∂,ε',9]⊂≤2y1`/n who is @%\AGQ¬aOJAα{⊂∩πM ↔"∧M_ n∧≠8>$∞y;Y↓Q↑;p~H0P9`%parate no@QJP→↓∧I∨[∃¬#@⊗N\@λ∞MβP2`.couraea him to dh∞Ag<X ↓α&C∃αVαIDM≥∧λ
l≡c"J ≡λ≠p↔→P:4`-e) j@UIOKHαβ eβ&C∃α,≡ε∞v↑8 $∞⎇<]L←9<\d∞≠h⊂⊃→P:42H30q`4est @%]`∪↔↔βC↔S,∧@hTM_ n¬Hλ
M_9⊂~yP6|H92q`/lh KGβ#'?9∧¬v $≥~→$ X∧q9]⊂9z`2vey @QQChAβ;∃β←,ε&*ε≥nf}glX ∧
8π⊗εBαsometi`≠J↓CE@?αX
∧∞~→(
]9λ
f∧βyWWλ⊂ 'm sure it @]CfAgα{3↔M∀ε'9(⊂~≠P:42H9x2`%d of the
hardware.$@A'α@λ
≡h≠[nD_;@⊂→v2sp[8∧ L@%`∂Aβ∞s⊃β#∂→β¬βd¬w"ε|dε ,=;⊂~≤β b`+β!β'M∧ βCK,εG'Hβ"P∪_yz⊂ )nperpreteR,∧@A !JAG←αkC'∪,ε"εO4λ∩ε∨-xλmP⊂
@]QKLA%hAo←β∪ ∨~βHλ ≡λ≥x.P9w`-eone'q
masters phe@MSfASαqβC#*β↔πKeI↓]A?→04!Q$Jπ>N&}v⎇K∩π∨\|v/∨Dλ
=λ⊂≤[zP9:[⊂2pqZ⊂7s⊂≥42P+_y0 ouq @→SMafA←8AISM→KeK]PAπ! β_4+←F+;↔[,ε"πε|>6N⊗LUbα¬M Wε*∞|↔
ε∀λ M}→(∪n↑λ≠⊂.>λ→P⊂[4∧ that c@=[aCE∃HAβ]QKe@3Lε7α`Q)V∞≡M_ n¬λ_;LD∃0r$ ~<p_ ⊂⊂$`/u may remember↓iQCHαα%βO,¬g"ε|¬5∧ (≠[nL(≥~ ≡β"P⊃[vx6 !ined↓iQC@ ∧π&FTλ
≥8;YnP37`2 UCI Lisp w` eJ↓←EmSα{WO3Jβ?9βλ∧ε&Nlh .2s:⊂βPU
(proBab`→@Jβ¬α9∃S α 8 m↑_8 2Y⊂:7P∩d⊂
"β↓β/Iβ⊃AYAJp4(Q)∩ε∞β_ `/ suggest @QQChAβ;#'∪*β⊂≡9Y0→_v⊂8:\87ybH12w1Z4pq5\P6p|H9t7`7 a general
teNdenc@dXAoJ↓cQ←k1HAgiISmJA→←dAi%[S@;?→β/→¬≠C↔∂L∧fN~
x ↑X9~-⎇\k@⊂λ)zq`( thi@9KfACL~∃π∨9&@@#L¬f≡g\M⊗v:λx2πε≥\RJ@λ≥P⊂\αiable bi@9IS@;8¬Bε7]l7&Nβ{@⊂_pp l@%]NHAα C'SFk↔S'~`4+C⊗{C↔KαO∩εF≤8
∧
αpw4\8p ation, array h C]%a`↔L≡FN}eDπ>_8p∃H4¬anipp @3∂#'?9αB%β∨αX .yFE 4hat's i`≤Aα3W;∂&K?9β≤∧⊗f@~;Ye@{0q4Xq0 e bi`≥I%]N@%bβSK↔*βSKπαh .9tw3H∀!`i βCDR
λh C]%a`↔L≡FN}n5∩b∧h¬3H~Qh⊂∀_qut`.e(λAπ=→⊃β,εf∞g\≡FN}n5B¬¬)xrε∞l@λ
Mβwx )ng hacking, αe@QF\@AAKeg←αsπ33Jβ7eβ¬∪?∂K∞kEβ∪|¬b?"∞↑6*ε↑\6Bε≡-↔&F\X
≤h≤sd (→≠md⎇λ⊂~~4w5@ thad≥f~∃I=↑AS[A←eiC9hAEKPA←EM%←kgYβIβO?n)βC↔|εεf* MrpH!Q$O"∞⎇w.fDλλ-N{h⊂LT≥<y,N;λ∩,@⊂82g\62P![zv2⊂≤zx86≡P:4vZw3yP≠q⊂:4→P6pqZ4w2P≥42P&∩ihεE~yP9:[⊂7wπλ⊂)zqZ⊂:44[3yP0\P4w9]9:q`4ion Fetch↓iS[Kβ→βπ≠ ∧εn∞β;p→≡P9x"Yp⊂0y→FE7q≥4wz`3ly i@5a←ei¬]h\@↓)QSf↓[SOQPAEJAUgCMk0AS\A
←[aCIS]NAQo↑A→%`∂CMε{9β∪N3∪↔K.sP4-\⊗≡F≥lW~@Hλ
λ←_8⎇
O(~≠nt→≠q.P0P!Va"iεL[X↔[MX⊂1w[x0y2H;tz4λ0P""PTY_≠ ∨P
I Don't↓iQS],AiQCPAiQJ↓ae←OIC[fA9KKHAQ↑AEJ↓mKer↓ESNA=`AY←9NSek9]S]Nαq↓αSF+d4+W+OQβv+↔⊃β&yβKWpβ3?;:β↔;?,;!↓! ↓βO↔≤{;∪MzIβS=∧k';'nKk∃βnK;?I¬#'7'v9βCK}∪3↔7~p4*SF)β'7ε{CCπw!βS#Ls∃β'~βS#π ∧π&FT∞f∂⊗α;u.∀≤≤[l↑X;<d {{Xl]]≤X.L(≠p↔λ7w2P≤x2qdY4qFE_y2p@_yP6zXt⊂0yH87yyZq62Wλ⊂'s⊂_wzy9YV⊂0v≠⊂:44\P72`%ds to be balanced by some
proerams that hav@∀ABAO∃]KeC0A[CP↓←DA←ββ↔Kπ&K?;Mph(4
∞s?S#-⊃βC?∨≠' ∪*βS↔O"aβ←#L≠!β'~β;/Q∧ε&.∞MO∩ε
∞M⊗nNlpπ&/>EBπ>}YF"ε,Tπ&@h→z.l(_;
A ]4d
_8zl↑\h≤m⎇9(≤ ≡]~8n]_<@∞∞[y|L≥;:0↔→P897Z2qz⊂≥t4qtλ;wzv→⊂:0uYP7w⊂≥42P7\22yεB7s⊂0[⊂47z\⊂:7P→5W⊂⊂∃pP;w]v2⊂"Xqt⊂2≠P4z⊂~w⊂7`5r own Lisp andrepo@IhAQ←\AY←]≤ASh~)iP∨?XβWMβ&yβ∪=∧KQ↓#≤¬F}≡4
FNnU∀ε∞vD ε␈:
↑V≡B∞,W≡␈↑,6/~∞|Rπ∂<X ∧¬⊂t∃$∞~;9%∃β⊂⊂$]∧@
midπQhA JACYM↑AeK¬g←]C YJAi<AeKa=a`AQ=nAoJ↓ISHA%h@QKα91βW≤+⊃α⊗l
∞Mβ⎇⊃βO?n)β?SF+@$+.#'S?∩βS :∞}&O&Ux M∨λ≥~ T_{q T≥Y0→≤zyP"Y4z⊂ )n LiSp itself, how Many Functions
(h CGI←f}R0AQ←n↓[kGP↓G←[[∃]iS]≤XAQ←\AaeC9caCe∃]`OQ¬GWSg AiQJ↓G←IJ↓Sf@1∧∧W&~βJ(∧ εE $on't↓[@↔πpβS#π ∧π&F≡4π=≠y; D_Y( ∀≤≤[l@y0vvZw3P![w:2i]⊂12`4 it @5SGQh↓H∂'[*β@≡}\QPFNLX∩π> ≡BεO4λ
-nY{⊂≠→p⊂4`. sri@QS]NAα βCK|;@⊗∞β(⊂∀[⊂2pqZ⊂"4`3p. This @%]eOYYKf~∃α≠?7C|ε6NvuDε/F\8
.M8π3@, debudπ@∨'v91βπv!β∂?oβ'3'v90∩α ∀ε ,9;λ∞M~8h∞⎇⎇;⊂∩λ12P H8∧r`+α+@⊂@ ¬0∀epπhA←α1β¬αdJNAβL¬bε
∞O↔εN<≥Bπ⊗↑8 ,≡Xz⊂≤βit`+α S'⎇`λ
≤β⊂;rH1wr`,d ⊃Q¬PBRAα#'O∂|εVwα∞Mε(hαX !p¬S@?αX d∞≤[p∪\αa`≠[∃` Mβ≤¬6NfN5w,<{p~\αces. ⊃&C'Mβ≤εV.y<p~~ww⊂ 3hh∂kYα!βK↔∞c3eβ≤εFO⊂β"P~\⊂9w`-e fl@¬[@↔Mλ∧∩Hh!Q L@88\O∀∃_ `3on~∀$Q`∪@≤∧p↔[ :z2↑0yV@11)~∀4ZP∃5h¬RhhαC"@↓AβXX⊗Spy⊗@81 \dn∪Gα{@↔⊗]_ L∀_8
UP D
M%Eλ∧αNβ~0→\⊂:4`-ingc
Date: 10 Mar "βIaEβ∂!↓Ae 16∞NαAP@(β97`-8∧AG←β∪@⊗.α8 0H0z⊂*U ¬P⊃βLZbb@4⊂
OW⊗S↔∂QRβ3'OαβS']_ L@yFE*≠]⊂98→β a`(αβ@∨*\≥⊂hV<7"ε∂L∧ NO<{p↔λ0z⊂ 5texas-20
If anyo@9JAS@~β';S,ε&/∨LX ¬D⊂∧P 7ou`→Hαβ ∃β>K3 &≥lrπ≠h⊂∩≠P:42H9wy5H87P 2un the
∃i%[S@;8∧ππ⊗|}&∞o4λ M}H⊂
j∪$i`⊂∃αerc@%←\@@*qA9↓¬##'M∧¬↔4≥~→$
α0p∀epπhAmα+@↔≡≥x D
βsεE∃h ISP, c@=]aCS9S]NAα≠?&T
FzεL∧X,@P:42H24pv→qz⊂$[:7P 4he "AiPAπ∃]akedAWL~)→∪' ↓S]iKβ∪CK↔&+CM→αα'QβF Eβ ,∧Vrε←∀ε/G X M≤8π1`% if @QQJAa¬ghAi!Ch~∃αk?OQ∧εε.␈
H $∞z≤],T∃0
&∩ih⊂ /d¬LAo%iPABα↓⊗@z λ∞M_9∪\β the one with↓iQJAα+c@',⊃P@.≠z3NL<H⊂∪~ λ∞`@~j7πIhπβ
α∧ &π ∧a0\93s@ at CRI( ↔_Q⊃CEIrA¬CIaP∨]αI&3M≠AαSLk';∨~↓↓↓hR∪πS+Q↓↓M∧kπI↓α⊂∞'ε(λλ@727-@ST ∃
β∪?5I∧∪πKK⎇9βπQ¬~J%6\a↓" ≡'/(⊂X.∞Yx @ )
αS@UEUKGβ!`∩∧β~4n∧∃~0⊗Zw3p∪
λTo: p¬aNAα QαNαUT Hβ"C!↓2(⊂≠[zv2 c` e@& ';O∀εfNαy(∞MβP12H5w⊂ 9our @1SghAα{⊂∩π,Xλm≡~90↔≥9P7`&
LISP tiMing @%]MOE5CiS←8X ↓↓¬β3↔π≤∧Rε∞L@∧(4TSj@`)`∩I-AI @Q↑A`'|εW$≠~4nE@εEεB ∧id↓s←jA-]P∨]∧εFF∂Dλf␈↔,X nD⊂P<m≤αz0∀↓QCfAαkπ&T
6}nTλλm⎇<_<L≡~9P∩H:4vt[3yFE≠pε o@9JAaCIiSGkαcπIβ∧ε&}|X;$¬_|⊂~Ktp∞tensifE) on↓`∂/lX L≥λ≠8,=~;Y.∃α⊂4`.
se@YKeCX↓YC@;?+π>↑7rαα _ D∞_8]
≤⎇;⊂⊂\⊗⊂&$Th⊂;p\β us@∃HA←\αα∩,4ε#β3¬D∧\Bβ(λ@0, ∃↔∧Zb`X↓C]HA5∪ ⊃α≤
∩Iβn ∂#'v+@~α∧¬∧81∀@⊂_pp
e out @
←[aCICE@3*β←'S@∧ε
∧αp ⊗LX⊂
bp hAα /W ∧β+αTλ&/'LX D
9H∃.tp∞g↓G←[a%YKHAαk'∂K|∧6}→*+AQ@εE+Z0z⊂ -achi@9KfAI<As@?αTπε@_;@⊂≥4π uSe? I woUld be rery i`≥i∃` ↔O&+⊃βSxh#O↔*β# ?tλF}g
⊗w~βλ⊃
}X9≠nT∧ and @→Sβ≠Aβ7∞≠#'lX d {{< ≡Y+@↔ αλ
(hP4(⊃⊃⊂LF≤∧\O∃β
λ∧⊂∀!Q"jJUP %Uα@
λ¬3Kf0A∩AW9←nA←α1α πα8
l↑≥ |d∞⎇_
`$y( A&C↔K∃∧K@~ε≤¬⊂≠2pp∪@PAW]J↓←iQKβ⊃α3'≥4+O'+∪e1∧∧'J¬L≥6/.=
∩εNβH∩L≡_;@↔βE
So far p∂JAαCπ[∃∧εFF* h mMα7{t[3P&$\βp sYstems sith rglUnpee@I`
βSxh+∪=∧εFF*∞M⊗nNβY|d =_nAQ@εE$[8∧erlisp On MAX, Do@1aQS\αaα∪?⊗ ∪<4Tkπ∞3M≠Aβ?pαNε&`h"'nLW)~8|∧
{H∀jY10 εB*adf∩ih⊂ /n Re@QH∂/,∧c!
|~0⊃Yf4yhλ7w⊂(⊃i(FE∪4yx⊂∪pqt4[2P∀)↑vq7`,ics, @πβ $αH4*7∞≠3'Oαβ?9α I1α⊗~aα:&bβ?9ααh∃Bb i∀bε⎇`λ
6(
~,@⊂0s !ilable)~∃%]`∪↔∀c'OA∧¬vr∧d!P@*⎇_;LL<Y⊂∪4yx⊂≠w⊂ ∀OPS ~@λεαb∧%R∪ 6 λ I4p fVβ"U Hhεv )pπ`AC9HA[k1Sg`Aα{9βIhπβ@ ¬&zY262P≠w⊂"&TFE):]3ry9H&4yhβE&4`3p Eachife
UCILISP And MLISP On TOPS(
b`0A)∂!LZd`~)∃KeS
QVA∪9iKe→αK@∨Q( m⎇9(⊗Gελ∪∩*:β"S.]≥~0nP
aclisp
λCroMemco Lisp on Z80λ
*4ε&∞w$ FO∨∧
vr¬h≠α¬,i≠hP`@lλ@⊗Spy⊗@81 0004 CHardes Braniston <CBF at MIT ≠≠ |@∪i%[SMOL@@@~) CiJh@dA≠¬eGP@Drpb@@`tjj5 '(~)
e←ZhAπQCIYKfA→aC@;←≠S/9βbε
→ε Qα6M!66
βaPE∨\-&.∨G$π&N]_ L}c"U
wH⊂tjh4 YL≡→;8-d_=⊂⊂ i%bS"h
cc: LISP-FLπ%+~↓ChA≠%([≠ε0ASCG%]aKd↓ChA↓¬%ε[≠¬1εHAI+&ACPA≠∪(510X~(@@@A≥kiiC≤AChA5∪(@6E@4(Q)↔"ε≡4π,=~→.∧≠x]M≥⎇<h∞M_=⊂≥42P*~vtw3\P8 ou disTpibuted are wall times fOp αdhe Lisp Machine, wheReas the V@¬pAC]⊂A≠εAQS[Kf↓G←k]PA←]YdAiS[∀AgaK9h~+&KK↔∂&ceβ↔F+∂WSNs≥β∂|#∃βSF Qβ'~β∂?;≡K∪↔K.!βCπ↔!β?→∧kπ∂ONk¬)↓∧K∃)β&C∀4*6 aβπv!α6
¬#'7↔~β↔c∂dεV&*
mw"ε⎇mGJε|≡&⊗∞|Tε≡}MLV∨&≥ybbε.X
∧
|→4L≡~;Yd∞}<u ]!"Snl<Z_., λ⊂∩~yuP$KwP0w→↔wy⊂≤0stw→T⊂:4[p¬ to output cHaracters to termifals( eTc.
I submid comparingwall time@LAoSi @QoQ¬hAiQ∀A≠kYβ#'∂Mπβ↔?Cd)β∂πfa%↓ 4KK@'\≥@hT8
R∩πM≥V*b
~2εv}Dε
πl↑'Jε≥lf␈⊗\≡FO6T WF≡↑,6O≡U`α∧J⎇Tεv␈D
7/⊗T
⊗ $≥~→$ ~<|↓QS88m
;Y(
<h≥
(→P⊂Xtv4z~ryP:≠P6puYP0w0[0swz\P6rp\zy2vYw:9Vλ1:z→{2y<[w2FE_pw⊂6Ypyzy→P;pv≠⊂:4vYV⊂0w→⊂4w⊂≤wvrP≥p|yP≥40z9H:42P≠wyz⊂≥yrs*[⊂1w`-parison.
Is anyone willing to try the same benchmar`↔f↓←\Ai!JA-C`ACMHαα6
β>KS!βW+OP4T{;∃β/≠↔Iβ|¬bε∞l@εn∞≡:W⊗.≥lrπ≡≥IBπ&≥\W xQ!PT∞N8 eD_<Y$∞~→0→→P8rjλ0s<P∪4yx⊂≠pqt4[2yP+Zz4⊂#\2pz2\α than 256K woRds? Lh∞~∃=]JAo=kYHAα#K↔πhβ?→β↔+;+'v9α7π∨≠g7¬∧{9β¬β⊃UZ-π;?K⊃¬α∩AEαβπ;⊃∧IβCK-≠W7∃¬##πPhS∨?↔~βS#∃π≠π7∃∧3?Iβλ↓Eα↔,;π g&)α[πBq↓αSF)α3'≥↓α7π≡C';∃εkπeβv{Qβ#∂3∃⬬#'7∀hSG#π⊗K;≥β∨KOS↔hβC↔OL∧F.wDλ
-d_{tLUλ_].D~;H∞L<[<d
yH_-]⎇;]∧
yH≠,];|↑$
Y91 \β"YM}H≠t ↑X=~-lh≤}.>→;
}Y<Z ≡Y λ∞M→(→L≥Xz;L↑|h≠l@⊂4z9H:yriλ4w:2\30qrCE897X0q6<H6wy2H:40wλ6pur\P:x⊂→4πr That. I'll bet another !∩8K words od∧~¬[∃[←er↓o←kY⊂A]←H↓EJAE∃s←]H↓iQJAA←S]h↓←LAI%[SMSβ≠#';8∧πε/NX Mnkλ⊂∀[9ws0\∧A0yH9:w7~w3P&Xqy|vXU
Lac@QYrXAQQJAGαC?'∂*β?→β-Cπ7Cd∧W
R∧λG.*∞MrεNnLW⊗@X;λ \8|}-\(≠p_≥4rt`:ations(
These examples have A properti I don't lii`
ASαqβ¬β⊗+;∂#n K-9ααS#∃¬#'7'v;L4+6{@∩π>\'≡<90∩[:⊂9:[9P4gλ:42P≤prrP→w;4`2onme@9hAIS→IKdA]SIKYdAMe←4AaeKYS←kf4∃ek]L\@A∪PASfA=IiK\↓kgKMUXAi↑↓EJAC YJAi<AMCGQ←dA←UhAgKQk`Ai%[CfA→a←ZA∧~∃EK9GQ[CIV\@AQQKgJ↓EK]G![CeWLAo←k1HAgK∃ZAi↑↓ek\AQQJAI¬]OKd↓←LAE∃S]NA⊃←[S]¬iKH~)ErAg∃ic`A
←gif8@@Q ≤\AgkAa←gJ↓ISgV↓∩W∞A%bA[k
PA[←IJAKqAK]gSβ3∃β?pβ?;∃π≠gOS.il4+&CπQβM→βCK}∪π 3Jβ;?Q∧;↔;↔⊗ 33@∀ ⊗w&↑,W∨&≥lrπ&tλλ$ 88|o≥8(≥.<<Kλ .=λ∩.D_{u-Lβ"Y
⎇:;X.L(_Y-lz≠8.-|h≤n\zλ_.4≥~→.<+J#!!"R(∞⎇⎇;⊃∧ Y(_.∀~;] ↑Y<u \λ_<d ;↑;ml(→0⊗≤pP4`. see@%]NAi!JAmCIS←kf↓YSg`↓csgi∃[f~∃ K]GQ5Ce@/,!9↓αJβ#?C*βS#↔⊗)β'Mε βK↔∂≠?;π⊗c∃βWv#↔KO& ;∪'v9β'9π##∃β6 K'?-_4*3O≠Aβ∂|k7W;M#'↔Mε{⊂∩ε
zrπ&tλFzεl≥↔∩ε≥lBε∞<>W⊗∂LUBε.N8Rπ& Tπ⊗/>]G'~∞⎇⊗f@λ_Y!Q]{|N≤(≥~ ≥H≥<l]→<|eD≥~→/∀≥z;
D_Y( L989m≥YkC!! C"@↓AβX[VSpy⊗@81 1Djj&n G'nLWαε≡@λ
λ4Pk)X6⊂h↓~Y.Hλxhβ"HL=→.Dε-h∪,≡Hλ ≤N_P⊂@1854 PST
Fpkm: Masi@9iKdAα QαB
∩~LX≠∧1"T⎇,-Y8uπ∧∀Y.Dλpc"I≥K<Y.
≤∧Vz≠]⊂ ∩PG's Message of 10 A≠¬d@br`b@bdLh[!'P~∃)↑hA SG,AπCEISK@1βbJB≥∧∧↔"¬8UT KaQ&≡≠$ FO∨
M⊗nNlxπ∂*\≥∩b∧M≡7¬',≥g≡f≡Mw↔~ ≡B¬≥UX∀Hh!Q$NwL↑&fO>¬T"π↑8W4_(∀L\Y<Y-ly+8m};]λ \<XX,|(_p↔[4∧ecTion scheme, Thus( "garbage
αcolh KGβ#'?9⊂β?[↔⊗C↔π⊃∧K@~εM~7'⊗≤.W&.D
FzπM
w∞(→P~[1z4`/ns which Can modify pefe@IK]GJ4⊂ ∂?.sSM↓D~0≤@Tkλ
*⊂ε aPT⊂2`4c.) @]SiPAβ##∃β4¬vf@≠⎇z-lh~3.
|]_-nλ→0≤_px:4[w9P~
λ α No reFerence coUnts Are maintained for small numberq or literal atoms
referencEq from the stack are notcounted
ReferencE counts are maintained in a separate table from the data being counted.
The table cAn be thought of as a hasH table. In addition, the "defAult"entry if
the table is reference cOunt = 1, So that in the "normal" c@¬gJXAQQKeJ↓SfA]<AaCE1J~∃K9ierAα3?Iβλ∧πε∂,M⊗∨.L≡"ε&≤NVjpβ"C!∧Qx<L,9y( ={≠⊃,>~;{D$≥~→-d_{sN≥<⎇≤d
yH
∃(≤p≠Yrx4g→P:42H9z0qZT∧ marking data with a
"refeRenced from the stack" bit in the reference count Table if necessary, (b)
sweeping the reference count table, collecting those data whosa reference counts
are 0 and whiCh are not referenced from the stack.
--------------
Because of this scheme, it is vepy difficult to measure performancE of Interlisp-D
andependent Of garbage collection, because the overhea` for garbage collection is
distributed widely (althouch the timing for the sweep prage befoRe any garbage could be c@=YP∪↔≥#↔⊃_hP4*SFKEβ←␈+3⊃βLs∪'∂∂#∃βSF QβπwIβS'nK;∨Mπ≠#/Wd!βCπ↑)β';&yβ∂?w≠'β↔⊗ S'∨p∧πε∞⎇→f8h,λ .37q6Xw1rP_yP;r[4∧ as garbace ColleCtionoverhead, ib they are to accuratel@d~∃G←9cSIKHAiQJ↓←mKe¬YPAa∃` ≠?⊗kπ;∂*βC'∂'+K∃8hP4*3∂∪Cd∀Ph 0 ;⊗eTn∂%P∞ε∀λλ ~ ≤@d"Q)$aeH0z⊂)∃h#bi∀P∧i2Nα So@1SGSI¬iSO\α↓↓↓hR∪πS+Q↓EY∧kπI↓α⊂∞'ε(λλ@725-EST ∃
I←ZtA! %∪
⊗AC@ ∧¬∃-HxU∃_Q*7.⊗,XλnGH⊂Y'∧∀{p⊗~qtz0]4swλ∧A*7N⊂)(#H0z⊂)UT¬AI
λcc 4↓YSgaM←keG∃`
βπα@λ
:+02!QR;K*,<≠⊂≤Kj7]⊂⊗wzy≠pyypYp¬ o@_@bl[5CdZPD@bjDβ16⊗N h(4
,b&NARβ↔cS.s∪↔⊃¬⊃6@,9∀εfO>¬bα¬M
↔4≥z3
D_Y( ∀≤Y2-↑≠→3,]]_=
≥{H≠l@∧@
Rutgers/QCI lisp fh∂dAQ←afZH`Akg%]NAKaiK]I∃H@PF@[ECh$ACIIIKggS9NTA∪PASf~)S[aYα+7πnLV"π↑8
-lh≥≡. 9λ≤
⎇;]→..h_;LD_(⊂⊃[x8tw→P#aVλ1:z≥tr6⊂≠z42i≥tyrP_2FE !li`∨gβ!β↔c∞≠S#@∀λ
(≤x-\αP0yH)↔jaRP64i\⊂⊂:w≠2yyP≡wzP !re accustom` HAβ#<4
≤"I∂'v9β'≠&yβC#*β';l≡&'~
x D∞⎇_Z-l|kλ ↑_k@∀Kαλ
)αβ#πK';πK∃αiα7|LVb∧$ 4bπ∞-v≡<|p↔\α o`$↓∃`↔CLεF/∩d∧∧Jε≥Pλ
m⎇λ⊂⊃[2pp∩↓oQKi!Kd4PK¬↓Iβ⊃Aβ#∂→β↔c&+;∪↔ ∧ε∞→_ 2\βsing,∧@A∪α1βO=∧εFF∂Dλ
m}9→⊂_v9wP_2BE∧]ypq6→Tε~∀A∨&@4A)←@∧ε2k∪¬Dπ,8ε2`!pπ@∃↓αTε␈∩
Hλ.L<H
∞2r2`!q`
@@ ∧π/≡\≤&f*∞⎇↔&B
]⊗vNβ8;↓Q@∧p⊂@¬iGQSαs⊂~Hβ"H∧ X∧w2~w3P 4ype-↓`∂#πd¬F␈: O⊗v∞β:0⊃K⊂;t`4h same stack mechanipπ[fAα @_h!~T9(∪⊂∀\βp
compilerZA+i¬PAgi¬]ICE⊂AQSgβ↓β@',≥g>≠x] \α⊂:7H4πur↓K]mSβ∪?;↔,¬g HαC"H≡λ≥~ T≠;p⊗Yw:⊂ 0erfo@I[C@;≤∧Rε∂∞λ ,≡\h⊂~≠P12P≥42P)XvrP !pεA$←U∞%αd¬↔>λε⊂ %xcep@P~∃iQ¬hAiQ∀A≡
∧εF∞↑↑4ε∞⊗|¬0~λ8∧wi@
JAC@~β3 >lpλ @4πr @∧AOSM∃\A]k5EKdAα{⊂∩∧9ye~ε<X
Nc"P∀[⊂:y`%,∧@A !JAiSαk∃βC,ε"∧≤βsTd
αptP_2P6 %pπfAMα{@∩π>XλN≡_;]
≤8ε⊂ 0p¬P∨∨α,⊗o~βλ⊂→Zw1rFBαp∂JAα≠π9β∞3⊂⊗@|Y⊂≥4π run wi@QPAY←β#@~ε|dε .Y9(∞x0q`%, whep¬KC@~β?WI∧∧&Nh≤⊂→≠pπrampε~+∂∪∃βC,ε6FNβY`⊂_p∧d`%∃`∂Mβ≤εε∞≡UDε∞vDλ ,∨(≠[nD_Y( ≤Xε2P≥4π have much f@IK@∃β≤εε∞≡UAP@-→;XlT⊃ph ∀≠≠p~ αλ
(hRπQβ&C∃β7|¬V.wD ∩εF≤¬P∩H0p∞ @%]`∪↔↔β@⊗/LX D∞α40zλ27r`3 a s@UEgiC9iSCX↓aCe@ ∧ε}H∪⊂∀\βp
1,∧l\@↓∩AQ←ββ∃βSzβ⊂⊗NβZ0→Z⊂"4`3p 1.XAErAβ##∃β⊗+⊂≡Nβ[Z-lh≠p∪λ842P≤βuemep. I a`→@≤¬phVα≠p_→P:7P~0{2P_P1w`-pi`→Kβ⊃β e∧εFF.βK@⊂λ$P0vH27t`.dεAiQ∀ASMi∃` CK,εF/∩∞λ .9ww0[4∧p∩X4⊂ πl@λ
⎇Y(⊂↔Yα my qtaf@_ASfAα#?'lpλ∞M→(⊂⊃[vx4`,er. I am↓S[aYα+7.β]~-lh⊂ /UC@∩~)YSg`↓` ?\⎇εgJ
_ D
~8 j≠y0 c@¬XA←@⊗#↔I1∧¬∩`,+H∪
≡|λ %@≠⊂3 )p¬ghX↓iQK\ααV∞∀λ
≡| β!8∧he@8A%ki≥KefAα≠#πl|W5α⊂:4≠zst a fe@\AP∪παLW$→Y0⊂]8¬re@LACeJ↓`∂3'∧εεNvt ⊗rαα_;LA ¬$P_vP77]⊂27d[3P0w≡z44g→P @]SYXA!CmJAβ#=βWv#=%8hP4*;|εF*πM ↔"∧∀λ
≡Y(∪
≡≥≠⊂∩H4s⊂ [<P4`.tereSt inperfOph C]
JT@A$AgC]PAi↑A5CiGP4⊃$←+
∩AYSM`XAg%]GJAUgCeF↓[CrA
←[aYα '9βL∧bπ&
_ L↑h≤u,L→;[∂∀≤{⊂↔]P27`7n, but αthat iS about it. I @¬ZA[←IJAG←αs∂↔Kv+⊃βπ⊗{WQβ⊗+3'π⊗K3'SJ↓#O'v≠∃α∀λ
m≥≠β"M =Y(
M=≥≠ T≥~;,T≥≠h
\8;] ≥8π⊂$]∀P0w→⊂47kH67w3H4z⊂ 4akes th∞AoISiJA%h∩)G≠';∂*α%β#∂3∃β3O#S#∃¬#'7∃¬#=β←⊗KS∃βM!%)↓∧{WIβ/≠↔KMε K∃β&{';≥ε≠?7Cd∧W&.O⊃PWπ,≤FO&≥⎇f∞b M↔>λ≥{n-kλ⊂-lλ~_.l(≠∩.N≠→(
}H≠[d
;]→.,<⎇λ
≥H≠;n,(→[ ←~8[ Q"XZ-l~;Yd
|H_m⎇]≤[mD≤y;,≥]~8n4
≥y$∞⎇<≤
M99λ ∀≥Y<N=;{H
|H∀KjXr(≠
≡|λ≥m≡~β"J<z→;,T≤y;,≥]~8n5λ_;LD≠[h
⎇Y(≥l≡h~;NL<Y<nL9
+∧
[|H
≥H≤| \9λ~-a"X<M≡~≠9.M8kH∧
~→(∞?<⎇→-T~<h L<z1ml9λ≥
t_Y(
]y≥; ≡H→;M}9zλ∞M_=β!-;<≤M}Y;9-n≤h_l≥H_Y$ ≠{Y$ <h≠L\9→9¬dλ∩( ≥(→z.m;Yh∞={9(∞M≠⎇9m∞λ≥≠aQ]≤X-n|≠|NL8Z;
≡≡+λ∞M≠⎇9m∧≠[⎇∧ <h≠.\zλ_.4≥~→$
=_:∧ [{~n5H∩(∞M~;Zd∞y#"N=≠⎇; D_Y( ≤[→(∞Mh≥≤L≥\|≠n.λ~=∧∞≠h⊂$∞}<⎇ ](≥z.Mλ_=∧
→8<nD -Hλ_i|h ≥Yλ_!Q\Y8.={X8ML(~;N>≤]8nM;{H∞<=λ
UYkH
h6
(∞⎇=~λε$≠8;E];{]
∞h≠|D
→<|ea"C"H≡h→X.$_<h∞M→(~ ≡Y≥x.,(≥y$
_=Y$ =X:-L8[→$ [|H∞L<⎇~-lkλ≥lT≥z;
D≤z≠n.≠≡#!-_=Y$ε3(≠ld∪3td
9;;n/+λ
∧
T
D}h≠{DεH_z ≥[Y;¬D_;Y∧ (≠;lL;λ⊂D sλ≤∞-xy<n=|C"E∞~→(
]y→;∧
8=≥ ↑\h≤m≥Xy(∞M→(≠-|→;λλ$~<h l<⎇→.$≥~_-d≥~→$
;y→-D⊂+H∧ [⎇→!Q]~_.D≥~→$∞≤[xl↑|{|D
;y→-D≠];,,<H~.∀_;≠-}⎇λ≥
(≠sMO(≥X.-88[ T≡;⎇$ x8Y!QX8[n↑λ~;D ( L¬D_]0~λ4z⊂$\P77zλ22y4]0q62H397vH:42P⊃ aP6Xy5rz~w3FE→2ytc[0z4w[⊗⊂9t[1rP0H→_~Xλ7y⊂→ ~_⊂6X|P12H2tz4→y⊂6wY2v↔⊂λ$7{r]2y⊂0H→_≠_βE4yP_v;p|\P6wr→v⊂!∀KεE⊗VKVVVVCEεEβπX[⊗Spy⊗\ P⊂_Z YDd"Q)$aeH0z⊂)∃j#bi∀P∧i2N⊂#aPλ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ_[⊂&Xy⊂_\N_P_[L≤⊗biUεE#9≠v]⊂$⊃b)$aRP0z⊂∀*j#bT)FE)]q52q]≥⊂)2N⊂#aPλεE*7N⊂)(#H0z⊂)UV`dFB1q]⊂≠4yx:≤0w9v_z7y9H0z⊂)UV`dFB$s⊗i→x6<VU7]⊂,[zy⊂ -essage of 12-Mar-81 1534-EST
; the garbage collector,∧@ASQfAS]%hAe←UiS]J↓SfAG¬YYKH↓KGS]%hAC]⊂~∀fAQCWKf↓iQKg∀ACeOLt~∀v@@ZAQQJAE∃OS]]%]NA←_AG←]MiC]h↓ICiB↓caCG∀XAoQ%GPASLAeKC1YrACPAiQJ4∀v∪gQCehA=HAiQ∀AMSeMhA←L↓iQJAQo↑AI¬iBAgACGKf4∀v@@ZAiQ∀AMSeMhAo←IHAEKe←]HAQQJAG=]giC9hAICQBAga¬GJXA]QSGP↓SfAi!J~∀v%EKOS9]S]N↓←LAi!JAkg¬EYJAACehA=LAiQ∀AMSeMhAICQBAga¬GJ~∀l@@@Z↓iQJAMiCeh↓←LAi!JAgK
←]HA⊃CiBAMaCGJ4∀v@@ZAiQ∀AMSeMhAo←IHAEKe←]HAQQJAg∃G←]H↓ICiB↓gaCG∀~∀∩v↓OCeE¬OJAG=YYKGQ←dAm¬eSCE1Kft~(∩wMe∃J@ZA1CghAUgKHA1←GCi%←\AS8AICi∧AgaC
J~∀∩mYCgi0@ZAY¬ghAY∃KCXAαc?∂π&K?9βLqβS#M→β∪π& βOC∞≠∃↓∃β 9↓α'∪'∨∨/⊃β¬α<→β'_hP%m↓αβO?7.{;∃β'∪'↔Mπ#=β∨zβ ↔g}s⊃βSFKM9↓h(%o∨#S#'~↓5βO& KQβ}1βS#M→β∪π& βOC∞≠∀4(K[↔;SFKM↓∃ε+;⊃β}1βS#O→β∪π& βOC∞≠∀4(K[OSSF Q↓5π≠SπK β?→β␈##↔I∧#πS¬¬≠Cπ∂(h(%o.sS#π"↓5β↔v!β?→ε{S#↔∩β∪πS
βGCπ≡(4(%←≠S∂;∨!↓5β∨#πKQε{→β∂}sOSπw!βOC∞≠∀4(K[↔;∂w≠Q↓5ε+;⊃β}1β∂?w≠Sπ;"βOCπ≡(4(4PI;O∂∞cπIβf OS1g≠SS#O→3↔;&C'M3∨#S#π c↔;SF Q3O&≠;OQf+;∂;∨ 4(4T3K↔↔∨QuuIβ↓AA@K[π7?.sQβ?2β≠K↔*βOCπ≡)βπQ∧+;⊃β}1α≡ hP4)↓α↓qasNs'S'∞c'kπ&K?9β≤{∪∃β|k'SS.!yyxhP4(∀SZS#'~β'Mβλβ∂?CLK;≥α<→1β7}#↔33.!βπ≠&+IβSF)α3'∨↓α7π≡C';∃∧:
1β∂_4)o&+O∂KN∪↔⊃βLqα#↔w∪eα ∞[↔I∨~βS#↔≡KM)↓¬##↔K*βπK∃π#←=β& S¬β∨βπ∂↔~aβ?3"βπ;⊃εs↔]8hQn¬α<→β∂?εK↔Mβ/3↔Kg&C';≥π##πQεKMβ'rβWO∃ε3K?5ε{3⊃β&yβ;↔:aβπ;"β7π//→β;↔:βS#∀hQo∂W↔∪↔;Q∧{;∃9ααS#∃εkπ'9ε{C↔K∂#'?9εKMβS⊗ ;O3∂#';≥ε{ +↔∨#M9↓∧K→βSF)β? V+∂P4S['Mβ∞∪O?3/#∃1β*s≥9β∞qα&:,i1βSFKMβ'~β¬β;zk?A9αα?;3JβC?'w#↔KMεK;S=¬##∃β|¬F h'>7ε∞<Tε∂⊗T∞G,9\{ ≡→9βD∧∃~→/∀_<Y$∞≤X;N=_=→,D_↑( m;Y~-lh≥~ T→<=-≡X;→-nλ≠xM,8⎇β!'z;H∞M→(≠L↑h≤| ≤y+λ ≥Yλ≥.=9Y`⊂~z9P8≠tw:2\↔⊂⊂*~2y2P_y2P:≥wP1p\ry]εB≥P⊂⊗H;rP4_{2P0[92pr≡P6wk→r⊂:4→P7q5→qz↔⊂λ$s⊂*~4yP1XyrP*~2P3 )p¬ghA∃]ier↓←L~∀l∪iQJ↓←YHAβ≠Cπ∂*β∂?CJβ'MβλβC?'w#↔Iβ&yβS#*β∂?CJβ'9βv+]βOε ∂∃9ααS#↔≤(4)LLεε}NnLW↔~
↔6*∞Mε*π=_vrε-≡Bε}eDε6@|H⊃,≡|(⊂∩→z2q`4ion.
; - we have not moved the oBject. In this case, we Copy It to the end of
3 New space, and use the poInter th∞Ai!JAEK≥S]MSαs∃β?2βS#'~β∂?CJp4)@te.
`≠CIRzzh@```@0X`∩∩mEShAβ##πQ¬≠πgMπ##'MεCπMβ∞cC↔π'Iβ ↔,¬bπ',≥g≡f≤LV hαC"G8Y8p.↑y(∃
<Y( ≡Y(⊃M}<H⊂∩~q32`2ent @¬eKCf↓iP≥β'∪π;Od∧↔&*D
v*ε ≡f*ε∀
6/ε≤∧X.L!"Nn
βzz4[2P:7H27P*~2P:9_w9v !tion∞
0⊗@↓KGie¬\t
∀l∪nf@4AMCeMhACI⊃eKgf↓iP≥β⊗)βCK∞sO3π&+⊃9↓¬9Iβ'~βWC∪∂#↔⊃Dλλ-lλ~0→H:42FB≥DD`0oi`≥i∃` β7,sS'?v+⊃βπ⊗{[∃9αα% 6U`λ ↑Y<↑.M~;Yd Y9P↔\αe GHAQCF4⊂v∩∪ KC@9¬#@⊗∞β\{ ≡→9β!πb9e∧¬(≠⊂⊂\z⊂0r→92y`3 to @ JAiE¬]gYCQKH@8hP4)@8¬~ T_{p∩→P;tj~4s⊂#Xz90wλ0{7`)ds the us@∀AWLAβ##∃β∨#π∂/~aβ'9∧{@⊗&↑ λ∞MβP0{≠trεE∞x2y3≠y0
anca pRobdemq because of addresSing ConflIcts Betwe@∃\AiQ∀AgiC
R~∀w¬]HAi!JAC@⊗+πMβ⊗+';≥∧:
∨↔ ¬`hPβ"P∪Xz90w∞∧rw`6e o1,(p∞fR$∩w↑bZAiQ%]NAi<AEJAQ` π≠≡cπS↔ h('∨/#SgAεyD$↔>6.
∞⎇ε∂"∞|RεF≤h !Q@∧p_ct trntab(w2)∩∩mieC]MYCiJ↓IKaKαs∪'≠8∧π/ε⎇`λ∞O<→#!↓8x;,\αP;IK8π4 8πgKJ↓SDAI=]J~∀%C←UB↓nfIO
ieC\$∩w]↑ZA]KβCP (αB0→→zεEεB≥caj∀ h⊂⊗H9x2aZpr⊂ 6ersiOn of the Abkve dh∂dAα#?'≠8∧εv/tλ n 8y+D∧⊃;Y∞P;t2[ε@
;we reach the free poInper
gctrax: Move O1(λ@#;→$$↔=s
αβ(∃
9Y`⊂≥4π be transladed
α gettyp k1 8πgKJ↓oQCHαβ←∃βF [∀4PKc∂Q¬#C+S∞⊃#MIHH%oS⊗ ;O3∂#∃β∪/β↔;∪Ns∃βW∧{9βSOβ∀4(N≠π7∨*β]M35∪↔∀$K[O.T
⊗"εM⎇f(h!≤⊗}V∀λ
f5→x⎇∞0|∧DNw7P⊗H72|:βEq2]∧@
9;TYPES
Tpjtab: jsP w2,Cpyatm ; Atom
jfcL ↓; constaft atom
jsp w2,Cpycon ; cons
jfcl ↓; constaft cons
jsP w2,Cpystr 3 string
↓jfcl 8ε@AG=]giC9hAgiIS]N~(∪Ug`↓ndYGAsGQ\$∩vAG!C]]K0~∀βU→GX∩∩$p
↓β≤{;OS∞sQβ∂F ;;↔`h('+6≠0$$KYβ';&+∨πHhP'+Oαβ]I3∨βgK↔λH%mβ⊗+π04PK+KO"↓Q18HImβ#.s,4(NS∪∂0HH%mβ∞#∪K↔∨_4('W≠Aβ]∩c∂Cg∨β $%ZβGC↔≤Kπ04Ph)o#/∪∃βSzβSKπw≠3πS*β¬α∞|rMβ∂.c1↓5εs?K7∞c3eβ>)β∂?πIβ'Q∧ ;⊃β/≠∃βπ&#Iβ?2β;↔]∧≠?CdhS∂Cg≡{9h'≤['C∨*β=I1FyE$$K[∪=β>)βπ3⊗+π∪eεCπ[∃ε βSK∞sO3π&K?9βNqβ?3"β∂?CKx4(πW∪OQβF [∂?pH%og/→↓5β/≠∃β' h('∪n{[∃β{⊃1#=
H$%o≤{CeβO 4(≤MV␈6]Tε{∩F∃ε7⊗\U⊂hP≥
V␈6]∀ε{∩F∃ε7⊗\U⊂K↑\≥6*ε≤LG⊗/>4εNwMt∧≤\j4πε}≥nF/⊂Q!↔&Ft s∩b
xλM,8⎇
∞O)8sme
*!Q@;;nl;(∪f%
≥le⊃ ∧]x≥z⊂4jλ4w⊂8≠0qrP≥5P12H:90w≤v0z2Yε@
tlc o2,(mark\object(ty%con,0)) 9make a pOinter to put into old coPy
movem o2,(o1) ;and put it theRe
addi free,2 3advance free list
↓jrqt (w2)¬
havCon: tlc o2,(mari\object(ty%con,0)) ;turn into a real cons pointer
↓movem o2,(w3) ↓;put in place to be translAted
jrsT (w2)
¬
<<<the reqt of the type@LACeJ↓YSGJ↓k]i↑↓iQSfx||~∀4ZZZZ4Z~∧~(_⊂≥E2j7πIhπβ
αε∪β ~<6␈'Ehf∞FM\⊗rε≡@λλ→αjVHL P∧i→]⊂#aH⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ_[⊂&Xy1t \X⊂⊃2109-EST (Monday)¬
Fph∂Zt↓'G←iPX
6≥
Fn∞d ↔"∧9ZRk λ⊃PU&w$∧&N=0∧>∞.-⊗.bπJ%∧~ ≡B¬≥UX∀Kr↓Q%∨.-(V∨#$∧¬⊗+$λt_h)_ EZY<∪∂∃5≠nD∧⊃~8mP#pq≤4rv∪\P6ry\psrP≠s⊂⊂Kλ&py⊂∞_P⊂@5:34-EST
Message-Id: <16Mar0! 210911 SF50@CMU-10A>
~∀4⊃↓SG,X~*Jβ ↔3L+[∃β>)β∨π4∧RπN|¬( ∀_{p_≡P7s⊂≥42P)T4qrP∪4yx⊂~w:2i≠0r0∪ dkcuMent? If So,
@=kdA∂ ACIO=aSiQ4ASfA⊃KgGe%EKHAQQKeJ8@A/J↓GC\AIk\Ao%iPA∂ Aike9K@A←α3⊂∩b∞Mε␈.⎇↓PW≡T
ε∂J∞8 m\αP7`6er`e@¬HAC]eoCr\A∪LA%]GeK5K]iC0AπεA%`
βS,ε&v.Dλ meλ≥~ T_{p→]⊂4p∪
λso @MaeKC⊂AWkh↓iQCHαβ'Qβ>{W3⊃∧∧&*ε≥↑ε␈∨=_λML(≥≠d∞y<⊂⊂\0z2Wλ⊂(2`2haps the @=]QbAα3π'HhSS#'v9βS=∧∧Fzb
_ D∞~→(∞M~;Ym|H~3NL<Y4nD≥;∃
≥8=→-O(~0→H60p∩ge AI jkbs, is to ru@8~∃ES≤AiQS9OfA←αs3eβ⎇⊃βO7∞c3@&
→f/~ X M}9zλ∞M;90→H:40zλ0P3"]P#aP≥tr6⊂~0{2P~0x8"[2r↔εB*42gλ<wp∃ can just Measure total runtime.λ
∀ZαiαO∂⎇#P$λhP0 ;⊗eTn∂%P∞ε∀λ &&6α4∪λ~∃∀h ≡λ⊃rλ~U∪sEV,λ
∧
⎇→=LT∀≠⊂⊂]:⊂ lisp -) my CC And machine speCpε@@~) CiJh@blA5Cd@BβIaE↓Dk?;∪∂I%↓I⊃→I6⊗% 4*≠⊗{5iαα D
∃∀h ≡λ⊂ d⊂i*'g XX⊂∀λ)z2k→P(6 !tp ∩~)'kEUα+∂Qi∧c'OAαi5β7Jα≡
β∞s⊃β7∞≠#'lTπ∂ε\8 aQU≠nD∧λ≤\ T_9⊂∀jV`dCE
DicK, jest a @IK[S]⊃KdAC ←khAβ##'Mε 3!eabαε≡DεO~ ≥FbεL↑6∨⊗≤-⊗v: ⊃PVF≤>αε6} λ ≤_⊂$Ir⊂6$Zp¬ to benchmark kutob c@UaSOG%irO@~βGπ∂*p4)↓β %απdaβS'n+Eβ←Nc1β#∂3∃βSzβ ∃β&{;∃β6K¬βO&{COπ&≠!9↓∧Iβ'≤⎇π"π}-↔&* ⊃PW∂]_λmP⊂λDO <n><expR>) to repEat eValuation Oh, say( 1⊂0 times o@HAg↑~)IP∨I∧∧&/'LZ"π≡≤¬_m∧≤Y4m⎇≥=~-⎇KHλλxh≥~-\αP;t[4∧ *Have* th∞AE∀ASMGαcW&\APF∂4 ∩ε&⎇`w"π<Zε/⊗≡LRεODλ n↑ C"D∧ J( ∀≤≠⊂⊂[⊂:7P_2P9h→pqt`.e to John↓βYYK8ACE←UhAQSLA)2~β3'Oα↓5%β∂→βC#,ε&+←1Q'π⊗|,⊗⊗G∀λ .\zλ∀m≥8;⊂.
=~+∧ )y
M8¬rP≥4π benchmapk hipεACHαβS#∃¬≠π7∃¬#'7∃ph"%∨daβ ∃π≠↔;∪Ls∃β#Liβ¬β≤{Ceβ|∧bπ&
~2εF↑NF/∩aQ"h$∧β~Jλx2εO4 ∩π≡≥↑εf*
\↔⊗Z⎇dw∨>\X ¬dλ⊂=∧∞{{9$ ]=≥.,(≥~-\αV⊂$H6pst≥⊂92x≠0qrFB844iH;tz4λ0P1g[x92y\tp∞g↓CYO←ISiQZ0ASCW∃bAG←IJ[C[¬OJAg¬mS]Nαβ@≡Nβ<≠ ↑KC"I∀⊃ph ={\h <;≠∀d 9Y⊂_z7vP≤βpacE, bu@PAUOhαβ;W7⊗+Aβ?∩βGSKNs∃βO∧ ∂¬↓FsW7 -⊂4+O∧ ∂¬β6{@∩ε-_vw.↑4αC@L, ε∧~→0≤λ7y⊂ 3o, use poInpers fgr↓`∂7πdaβ';&+↔πK~I04 ≤εG-9Y`⊂≤βpace for↓a]C[∃bP→%ααCK?∧+@∩π>N&Nv}4εnN⎇∞Bε⊗T ⊗oεLYV.wL\BεNd
FF(Q( N↑≥<Y$∞{{9.M;9+AQHλ
¬∀⊃~<n∧~<h ≥H≥;N,;→0.<9λ⊂hIλ≠∩.x⊂ @MiSYX↓k]IKHAIKm∃YP∨Cn+;Q→αα'Qβ>{K/LhSW;∪-⊃α∞Bh↓E 3D wαε≥o↔&F≥lrε≡⎇↑ε∂&≤-F*π⎇~FBπM ↔"b
ybε
'βαr∧λ4$b M↔∂α
↔_h-≡G
π-⎇w'~
→b∧n≤=FO∨¬D∧Jε}X .≡h≡;nTyλ⊂→X|W⊂⊂⊂4w24[3P4yH22rh ⊂⊂!w[x4v2\α?
Hah -- may@ JACMQKdA[dAISgMKeiCQS←\A%bAMS9SgQK⊂\\\@↓≠CGe=f@JZ↓iQJAMC[J\4⊃∩AI=\OhAIKCYYdAmCK\ASCGI←fACLAKgg∃]iSC0XAg↑↓iQKr↓QCmJ↓BAeK1CiSm∃YrAYα{\4 ∧ε&N␈-_
∂∃KK@ -⎇~
=Y( ,9;@∞M≠⎇9m∞λ_8M}= λ .=λ⊂≠[w∪z be benchmapkable.~∀@jRAQQJAQ¬eIoCIJAK]YSeO]5K]hAαK@~π,]F∂&≡hVgJ 8 mn⎇≤X-≥Y9 D∧
∞∩d∞~≡<m≤x;≠∂⊃"\Z,]≥λ⊂↔≠{V⊂ -ay be qp To 6 !,AErAα∪↔;∂FkπK4
FNnUebrα∞MεO~ i⊗//,↑2εNnMphW-}V.FO∀βDZ h L\(_p∩[4∧s, the Additional 12K Will Add 3K cel@1`
2ea⊂hTmtε≡∞= Rbε⎇mGJβ$πα$→[⊂↔\84riK⊂⊂ @≥<x4`#al "good"↓Q←[J↓`∂gO&+5 0β"H↓QHλ⊂,Nα2y≤αeading this all, i@POfAaβ∪? π⊗ceβK,cπS'6+3eβ&+CK↔≤ε6Nvtλ
m 8πεE_wvx \2r⊂ 4o so@5JA←L↓iQJA5CU@?α λ
\8z~-l<h⊂L]8π3@ befc@![CeW∃H\@A khASβ!β'LhS@⊗/∞,W<αp∞tative o` Ai!JAQ←αk∃β∂|¬Wπ=~0↔→β envir`∨]5K]h\αq0⊂@ ¬εEλ⊂ f you @!CmJAα ;eβn{@⊗*∞:ε.≡≤h
,4≤90∩\βtio@9bP⊃β4∧V.b h L\αP:7H0yu@.
~∀@@K≤εF/6T
εf∂L@λ¬
≠_=∞Nh⊂λ
]_8 :≠w∀FEβEβ∧π17
Mar-`b@@@\hj&?∪'OM∧∧↔"¬X¬⊂)¬,Lλ¬ 88 :~w↔#y~yyTPαi2P~ GC
Date: 17 Mar "βIaE↓απβ≠
YZ5 @ ¬# 2om2 Gp¬Sgf↓ChA Qβ⊂J@⊂εααDβ8<NM9KQn
<|j!QT⎇0M,8⎇εD
d AA analysis???
M
-------
∂17-Mar-81 0837 Robert S. Boyer <BOYER at SRI-CSL> Solicitation
Date: 17 March 1981 08:34-PST (Tues`ay)
From: RobertS. Boy` d@q¬∨3 HAChAM%∩[πM_|~∃Q↑t@@↓ SGV↓∂CEe%KX@yI!∞ACPA'*[¬∩|~∃
Ft@@↓¬←sKHAChAM%∩[πM_~∃'UEUKGPtA'←1SGSi¬iS←\@~∀~))QJA5CGQS9JA←\↓oQSG A∩AG¬\Aek8A→∪'@AiS[%]OfA%fABA→←←]YdA dX4∃oQS
PAK[UYCiKLABA ∃εA↔α↓ae←G∃gg←d↓C]HA∧A¬¬≤↓aCOKHXAC]⊂Aek]L~∃BAYCeCC9hA←L↓)K]K`AGCY1KHA
=←]Kp8@A∪h↓QCf@D↑dA[%YYS←8Ao←e⊃f~∃←_@j``↓]C]←MKG←]⊂A[K[=erXA9↑AGC
QJXA9↑AIeUZXAC9HABA
ε~∃]S]GQ∃giKd↓ISgV8~∀~∃$AQCm∀AkgK⊂A∪]i∃eYSg@AKqi∃]gSm∃YrXA khA∩↓QCmK8OhAgQkISK⊂AiQJ4∃G←[ASYKd↓←kiaUhA←d↓≠βπ%<Ag←kIGKfA∃]←kO Ai↑A
YCCZ↓KqaKIiKgJ4∃ChA=aiS[¬XAG←⊃S]N\4∀∩¬∩↓CZA[¬eOS]¬YY`%∧3π7'fKπIβ>KS!αn ∂3'∨↓β;?8βπ;⊃∧IβC3∞qβS<hS ↔∂|k∃β7|ε&*εl≥VNf≤≡"π≡⎇⎇bph!Q$6␈$
FF*∞∞W↔ε}<Rε}d v/'M≥f:ε∀λ6}o
H .L(≤y.D≠yHλfH≥\ed L
F↓ ]~-]9Y|eD∩)y∧ Y(≥m≥≠~;Lt≥≠h∞.;H≥ ↑⎇≤h
|H≠u
<H∀λJ ,,∧ ∩4t∞1"]~ ≡λ_<LT∃→;L←λ_{m↑_=~,-→+λ∞∞[⎇Z,L9λ≥
(≥→.>≤h_l≥H_Y!Q\→4Lm|[9,D≥z=
⎇=λ∞M{h≠.\zλ≥-l→<\nL9Y~-lh≠yD∞~→( I4tβ!.X<Z,≥]≤kAQ@εE$H40{ % a benchmark that J Moore andI construCted A few
mgnths ago to compare InterlIpπ`AC9HA C
YSg`8@A)Q∀AMSY∃`
β?ph*εJ∧
:εQ∧C?OQ∧~N!βv 7π⊃βb
>f-⊃z&J-:J&R*βπ;⊃βb
>f-⊃z6J-:J&R(h#∂?w#π'eDπ⊗/>λ ,>~=Y-O+λ∩-nα2y6~yx⊂ [2⊂&pXv4yxλ1wr2H33y a far
from optimal rewrite style Theorem prover.@Q)↑↓
) A1←NAS8~∃Cf↓β]←]e[←kf0AaCgβ≠←?K"β⊂⊗}ue∩α∧X(U :R5⊃$
<h_m|→9∞≥h≥~ ≡ β"L←_y4∞D→[tD∞~→(∞>_=~.>~8|d x=~ ↑X;YeD~=λ
≡h_;∞=h~3Dλ\X;O!"S∩*: Hλ
Mh≤⎇ ≡] λ∂≥⎇(~-n[zy$¬∀q5
Z
+@⊂λ*42gλ9:w (TEST)( as
`≠C9rAiS5KfACLAs←@*β←π;"q↓αR-~QβK-#WKn4π≡}\Tπ>_=~.≡~8td¬+(⊂N↑β"R$ <|p~[p¬ that BPG wiLl want to qtandardize he@IJT@@!)β'(αH4+SαX Mnh≠uL↑H≤p~≠y0srH92y<H90p )dhp∩X↓aKGkβ∪@≡<h⊂$
≠⎇⊗λ27riH92y<CE0 iTth JA¬aSiQ5KiSF0AC@; ∧ε.v|≤v/~
_ D
Yh⊂∪_w1|P≤z9:a]8¬rine ⊃J9J\4U∩B2ε≥→%)↓∧{WIβL¬g&.nM⊗}r
_ D {y~-lh⊃⊃*:λ≥x.∀≥≠h∞∞Yy≥,<#"T.]8z{∂∀_(⊂→[pv6⊂→0qyt[tr2P≠q⊂:4→P42`!rp of our p¬CiQ∃`AYCIO@∀4TεFF.},Vj@<≤[nm;Y`⊂≤βystem inorder to Compare @→∪M AiS5KfL~(~∃¬R↓S]iK9iSO]¬YY`%∧∧6}&≥lrε
∞λ M|βy0vH840zλ;wz`,d be easy th∞~∃β#@⊗∞β\s ≡→(⊂∪≤αkm Inp Ke1Sg`Aβ#=α\≤6fO>¬Bπy(⊃
≤λ~0↔~8¬stic`
Ai<~∃E←QPA2M~CM→αα≠/I∧∧WF∞β<∪ Uα⊂;rH8¬se@⊂AeKGU` O'|qβO#,ε&*π|TεnN⎇∞@hVα_=LT≥<p∩Y⊂:42H$W!W∪βPR @
←]giIkGhA%\Aβ]QKe@3M≠Aβ?∩βS#∃∧"44+≤¬vw∨N.V∨"
→b∧n≤9FO∨∧¬Rjε| ε
∧β04∧ {{\nN]8p~λ4s⊂"Zz42i α α
λ∞bn5≠CdZβAE↓↓βAQ\&⊗{ ↔K ∧¬~@H⊂[o≤αy⊂≡⊂'lbiλ0z⊂)T$VaiS≤ε LISP Timangpε@@~) CiJh@bnA5CeGPα↓Ee@∧∧ ∧ε∞
Mε54⊂ jλ∀*0∃@∃c@∪πβ∃⊂hTn-vkRλ∧[l,<Y⊂∀Tε Boy` d@q↓∨3 HAChAM%∩[πM_|4U#=i↓ααJB≥∧∧↔"¬8UT HQ*7.⊗,X7#R∧ DM≥∧
FNn≥lw_h,83@$λλ⊂M␈9<H ≡λ⊂tI∃αa`∪L
~∃
←kYH↓oBASαs∂3W&)β¬β≤¬w∂" 9vg∞β;@⊂~w⊂:4→P34g_v⊂3y_w2⊂*_v6<←H⊂ p∀
hac been↓` ↔↔∂∪'.D
FF∂Dλ ,≥↑(∀ ]|≠⊂∩H0y2P≥9<tw→P:7P→2qt`$e
αwhich LISP systeM to @UcJXA9←nAC9HAS\↓iQJA→kike∀X ↓α≤¬w>λ≥z-MαεE "e animpo@IiCMh↓GeC@&+C'∨pq↓α↔∞K;@&]l⊗v≡Tλ6F∂,|W
π=
w.fDλλLQ Z3L=≥9→,D≤z3L<(≠p≠→y⊂:4→P64c→P7s⊂_P6pqZ4s2Vλ:42`9 may approach
the Purchase price. It @MQ←kYα!β ∃¬∪↔3π&K[↔3Jβ↔πOJβ∪ ?$λV∞≡↓Q'ε/,8 md≥z≠d∞Xπv:]2ry9H0P6pXt4w2H:7P$[24q`]2P:4→P8:i_t0p∪@∀~∃ae%GBAC9HA[C%]iK]¬]GJA
QCeO∃fT
∀4⊂_⊂≥E8j7πIhπβ
αε⊂ &V ∧fp\tp∞tep∧AChααBεJ~j6ε@λ4M⊗U$∧<~↓Q$&∂LW"β t V∂∩∧∧ ≤N_P⊂⊃Dp UQ¬αN@4T3@⊗@{.H \<z0↔≥2y⊂ !t PAR@εP⊗6
B_h*>V⊗V\:C@$∀Y.Dλpc"I≥K<Y.
≤∧Vz≠]⊂ ∩PG's message of 10 A≠¬`@br`b@bdLh[!'P~∃)↑hA SG,AπCEISK@1βbJB≥∧ QαN*jε%XhS∂
i∧c'OB&K7'≠<βOU7∞I1α3O≠BSK∞sO3π&{CMβ∂!αNUl
$4(hR';S/∪3'Oαj⊃βW≡+E⬬∪↔≠↔⊗+;∂∃n≠?W;"β↔πK⊗ ∨∃β≡{33↔≥#'?9π≠∂#↔n)9αSG+M1↓⊗;πK ∞;∀4+≡{3#↔∨#'?9∩β?[↔⊗C↔π⊃εKMβ∪O≠SK'↔+S↔⊃π#=βSF{O¬β7+;∂SN{;Mβ>C'∂!ε≠π9βn{∪'≠JβK↔≠/∪↔;∂(h+∂?.sSM↓D~> 55D¬∃∧H_4
b ZF~r∀∞vO&∧∞FF* ivff}⎇⊗v:
≥Wε␈.L⊗w" [ε≡/∞M⊗}w7!PPh!≥fzπ,\f/⊗]l6*ε=}Vw'4 ↔⊗*
\⊗NwL≥⊗v.D f␈∩∞=V∞fD
g.n,↑'
ε}$εfOL↑&∞b ≡F}o1Q O⊗\lW⊗.l8W
εn-vjπM Rπ∨L≤6Zε≡,Rεv}@ε≡␈]nF. Q!PU⊗\lW⊗.l8Rε≡}]g'~ ≡&*ε\≥⊗w&≥≥f."
≥bε
∞<Wε∂,≡F*πL≤&f* n&}j∞Mε*εL≡F
ε,]⊗v: =w.wL\Bph*Mε*πL≤&f* <⊗rε,Tπ&F}\vG"
|bε∂4 ∩εF≡9απ&≤-F*r ≥bε∞LM↔&N⎇eBπ& Tα⊗&\l↔.gD$ε.wN/∩εNaQ'&FT∞F∞⊗LTεO~∞,V6/,]f≡* =w.wDπRβ
D∞6zπM ↔"ε≥dπ&FT∧&v␈-\⊗b∩ <↔≡*D∞FF/,TεO~
mrπ&≤-F(h,]g'↔∀ f␈∩ ∀πε∂.M⊗∨.L≡"ε&≡NVjpQ!PR∀|≡&⊗∞|Tε≡}MLV∨&≥⎇b∩πM Vrε=⎇g≡O>N2ε}d¬ε
J∞>v./
≥f:πM Rπ∨L≤6ZB
\↔⊗↑≥lrε&≡L∩π>≡MαελQ$'⊗.l↑&.v<\Bε7-⎇Rπ& Tπ∨&≤=2∩ε-≡BεNd∞FF*∞,V6/,]f≡* =w.wD
F∞⊗LTεN2
lV≡/><↔↔JD¬ε∩HQ.7>.↑
⊗v:∞Mε*π,\f/⊗]l6*ε=}Vw"∞L⊗⊗fUDε≡}MLV∨&≥lrπ&
}6*εL≡F
π⎇
w≡*∞,V6/,]f≡* =w.wN1PV∂,Tβαε≥lBπ>
≤6Bε≡,Rεv}Dπ⊗.l↑&.v<\Bε7-⎇Rπ& Tπ∨&≤=2ph!Q"jjUURjjUURjjUQPPh(,V≡∂↑<Rε}d∞FFO4∞6≡F]\Rbε≡DεO~∞lW↔J M⊗66≤>Vg"∞Mrεn\≡7/⊗T∞ε/⊗m}&n∞l8Rε}d ⊗w&↑-FO∨¬X@hV≥lF/ε]lF.wD v"ε|≡&⊗∞|Tε≡}MLV∨&≥⎇bbε,\6∂/<Tπ&FT
w6/- V∞α mw∩ε|≡&⊗∞|Tε≡}MLV∨&≥⎇bεO1Q&&O>N&N↔↑LV"π⎇≤F.g∀¬ε∞gM
w.zλ≥
(≥~-];Y`⊂→5y⊂*~2P9{Yrx⊂8~0yrP_pw⊂1→P9rh_y0z2YεE7z]∀WεEβE)ra[w26<K⊂:42H1t7dXrP7`& a reference cOunt @MGQK[∀AWmKHAiQJ↓ieCI%iSO]¬X∩+≡CπO∃n ;⊃7n C-β≡≠#↔\Tπ/≡\@λ /(≠;n≡λ∪~.x9P+XyP1g[24z4[w2r_<P:4→P12f~rs⊂:~0zεE≥tz4≥2y<P≠0y3rH;0y:≥pv⊂ !ddresq spAces, it was unreaso@9CEYJ↓iP≥β⊗+GW'⊗)βS?,≠#';8h#πMDε∞∨M≡f*π>Mw⊗∞|Tε⊗.mz&*ε≥o∩ε>≡,&∞>Tλ6␈.LDε⊗* 8 mMα2qj→r∪εEβE*44\P;wz[2⊂4`.dicate that any timings shoulD pake into consi`eration↓aCOS9N~∃aα+C≠?⊗kπ;∂*βπMβ>+3 " ≡2ε>≡,&∞≡Tλ6}fLX7&N⎇`ε␈6↑-ε.∞EDεN∩∞Mε/J ≡&*πMtε∞≡>↑&∂&]H∞!QX{sN≥9→4D∞~→(
}Y<X-Mλ≤→.37y6Xw1rP≤4qz:\2WεEβE&0y≤<BEεB8εE λ∞bn5≠CdZβAE↓↓ ⊃E`&∃α≥↓L∪WK↔∂+∂Kπ∨I↓↓hRS=iα↓β3'≥βS'↔L¬f*ε≤@λ
:+02$∧λβ"I≥H≤q-l~;Yd
9<x,|<h_.-⎇;Y¬D≥~→$ [{∪
}z;Yd X8p~≤β are qse@→kXt~(∪%!∞αβ'Mβ|¬b∧d~:¬≤]X∧PhZh≥z
≤zλ⊂∀\β equal to
LISPTRANSH β)=%&@1∧εvFN=λ
≡h_ ⊂≤βubcEt of LIS@!Q∪⊂⊗&t90 (αC"J=h≥~ ↑Y(⊂∀\β no need↓iP≥β≤+;⊃βn)β¬β≤¬wπJ
x D =Y0→≡z44`.e( nop∧⊂∀ Lε2εODλ L\y<tl≡↑(⊂~≠P40{→P ISPT@∪≠%_
: ≥f"∧β∩4j
pπji⊂βES @=\AiQ∀AgC[∀~∃@#,∧⊗&/%Dε -βy⊂ %xa`≠a1JP→ααMε∞vα|kAQ@∧DDKy83@-
~∀_⊂≥E:j7πIhπβ
α∧∧ ≤L_@ Bep¬P≠π⊗!αMdλwε.]l&/⊗t∧ααα∧∧βd|Y0∩[12y3H0z⊂&Rh∧ ≠≠UYaSGβ→y&⊗)`∩¬=x
≤z9_.M9{@⊂λ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ⊂⊂⊂⊂ Xπ Map¬GP@Drpb@Hb`⊃In+@∨ Q(g-βvU⊂λ⊂⊂⊂!→y0∞ard S.↓∂eKKαs ↔K8∧ααα∧∧αβ@⊃xY,]XY0→→β a`(αα6&QlkW3SL∧77A"Tn\XY0⊃]≥⊂⊂)→]⊂ ∪@=YSGSβ#πS'|¬`hUMw"αα∧∧ααεM_ n∞{x
i_p¬s @¬hA'
5β∩4T≠
i↓α↓↓↓↓∧kW3SL∧75αf4i\⊗x2`/ph JAα QαY~Bl@0c"AQUy0⊗≠⊗⊂&z[84q`3 MacLisp, let`'α+∃hQ!PDo]H
≤|h∪,≤{~0→\⊗⊂1`/nsicTing @=H βπp∧εNwLX N∞Y=→.%λ_p↔[x4v"\α, LAP not us@∃H⊂∀,/∩π& Tε≡}↑ ⊗f/%Dπ&Fu∃Bπ↔]nFNnUDε∞vD
W&NM_
≤<kλ∞|<h⊃ ↑Y;∪n 9λ⊂O⊃ S2*D⊃_8D Y|@⊂⊂βomputer Science ⊃→
&RASαq↓EE9→β←'&AβC#*βπ'Tλ l@⊂2|8≠y:4w→FA24→P"pq\βyea↓[CiP↓`∂gO&+5βSzα7W∪&K∂M↓F{⊂∩π⎇
⊗≡B Y∃"l↑YG&N>4π>∂4λ
(≠p↔≠<@
@=]JACPAiQJ↓iSKJ$X ↓α& [∃α⊗+↔↓↓Fs?]β∂!α2∞~Iβπl@λλL=Y( ]{{@¬
β0∂g↓ChA≠%([β∩4⊃C@; ∧¬∨Nβ8[mM8|k∧ 8π1W
P;r`2e the priNcipal impLementors Thef, and
AlexSungurkff (donπt know whepe he is Now! @Q↑ABAαc↔OO,ε"ε&\}&.*aQ%⊗.\@λ ≥Yλ∪-⎇{H∪,≥8π:0Zw2r~z⊂:7H_X[[ ⊂$P -ai`≥i¬S]KH↓ShAk9iSXAαs?]8hR'SMεkπ'nLVv∞βXq%@yzx8≠y:⊂)]0z:`3 since my fh kg!C]GJ↓←LA⊃=]Kso∃YP~∀! KGK5EKd@Drp`R↓SfA]=nAk`↓S\Ai!JACSHXACYQQ←kO A!Ki∃dA↔eUa`~∃¬hA⊃←αs↔g←.c1β'~β;?]∧s?7'v 33@∀λ ,≥8π:0Zw2y↔βE
The i@9iKeAβ∪↔S↔∩βπ;⊃∧∧v.v↑,⊗bπ<8
]9(⊂↔Yα things Were DevelOped @ACeiYd~∃@?pβS#∃∧+cC↔⊗K↔;∂*β? ααλEαk⊗∧∧n∞=M↔> λ⊂≠~yps )pεAeKαs;'≠8∧ε␈/Dλ l@⊂9x0XrVεE_w2⊂ [⊂2py≠4ry∪zr:4XyP&4\βp by ReeD, visavis better ways to do this
On Multics. Multics MacLisp featuRes vippually iNfiniTe address
space (lImited by The size oF a Multics Process directory, which
as virtually unlimited$XABAβ∪↔3?≡ S';8{∂?CLK;≥β> C π>)β∂?fc↔∂S⎇⊃04+≥#C';?→1β N;;W7~βπ;⊃∧{S#↔⊂α7π∞dK@∨α hV∂'↑,W~@λ→y-l<X;∧ {{< ≡~8Z-M=~#!.z=~∧¬∩5∀e∀⊃88iM<| ∧ 9Y⊂≥2y<P≤tsw4Y4qpw≥48 , the facilIty to intepfacE
to procEdqres in Otherla`≥OUCGKfQS]GαcWβ'v9α7WdεFN∨4
7O∨L]Rπ⊗}ZFNv↑5⊂hV⎇`∧o.NM⊗∨~aQ hU⎇≡FBπM Rεv}L⊗⊗fT WF≡↑∞FN}d
v $≥~→$ {{<
≥→<K∧∞z~8m∧~<h ∀≠_<L|(
_-lβ"]-l→<\nL9Y_,-→+λ ≡h≥y-Mλ_<d 9YY,>~=Y%∀∪~<n∧≤≤[l}X;(
|H≥≥mt≠_<L|#"\m}<Xy$ Z;→.5λ≥~ T≤}<nL;(~.∀~;H
r( ≥Yλ∪.]≥~8n∀_<tl]8[→.πH≥~ Q"X<n<98[ ↑H≤≠n∞~;{N5λ~;L=≥9~-lh≠[nL8[≡$∞~→( ↑X;≥,≡≠|K∧ <Y(∞M_=β!.x>( m|H≤n 99 D∧∃~→$
_;Yn\9y(∞|<h→ ↑z9{L\λ≥≠d Y(_.4_{≠n<(≥≠aQR5∀d 88{
≡|λ_.4≤≠|n=8[→$ =λ≥
(≥~-\(
'⊗lj+∧ ]=λ
<h→
≡Y<Yl\λ≤{m\+C"JM→(_m⎇<~0⊗→y⊂;p\P22{→v7x2Y⊂0yP≥;wP6[r:v2\V⊂0P≤rvpw≥4qyP≤0yyFB92{w\5rr→97vP≥42P:~2w⊗q]y92w≥⊂;2y≤tww⊂≠s⊂:4→P32p\9wvrH$j)FB!gfh∪)↔g!Sdh&)λ∀_\[LTV⊂0[2⊂:4→P1wr→P3rw→y0z7\⊂;pyH;y4z≥2w⊂0[2{FE_<P)2Yr⊂∀_N[YTVλ0v24≠zst⊂~z⊂:yYyP'!Sdh&) v4urH9z90]2str\FE∀$H40{ % a paper on this subject).
Althouch used in the support Of Macsyma, the largest and most important
αuse of Multics Maclisp is as the implementation andextension lafguage
of the Multics Emacs "text processing and video process managemeNt"
@MsgiK4\@A∨QQKdA1CeOJ↓gkEgegiK[LAS\A5kYiS
`
α↔∞≠3'Oαβ?[↔∩βS#∃πK↔πK_h+#π4)β';≤¬G.ε\@ε
∧↑]G&N>4ε∨⊗≡9αε∞l@ππ⊗|-F.j ≥f∞g≡9↔
π>\'∨O>LVjε≥l@hV∀
V∞v≤|Vn∞nEV&∂L⊂εn}LYFNvt∞7O∨L]RαD9yU~b ≤&␈/Dλ
m
8zλ ∀~{[nt≠~=∞M→*+AQ@εE(≠tw:2\9P4gλ&zv 4ics Maclisp are 72-bit$ @]QSGP↓S]GYUIKfA∧@r[E%h∩+'KC∃β4¬⊗.fE`λ∧ Y{K,-9{]-T≠];,,<\h¬ X>≠L∀_;Y∧ Y≠{L∃(_<LT→~4L\⎇≠≡!QY;Xm|→9
≥H≥~ T≤≠r-n→<K∧ 9Y⊂→7P77]⊂92x]ty2P_v67qXz4ww ⊂7y⊂≥42FE~4y9`5te "PDLNMK" scheme od∧A∪)LA≠CG1Sg`\↓'s[E=YfAC9HAgiIS]Of↓CeJ~)CYY←
CiKH↓G←]i%Ok←kβ≠3e1ε ;⊃β⊗+3 ><≡F." ≡Bε>≡,&∞>U\6}fL\7"πM≥V*pQ(&NvM≥f:ε≡4π&FT∞7&∞lL↔⊗" \⊗≤f≡>απ≡ ≥Ff␈u\&NvM≥f:α
⎇F"πl≥G.∂1Q'≡∂lXBε}d
∧$bD
7Nn-⎇Bε≡⎇nF∞Nn4α⊗∨↑.&.wD π6∞L\RJR∧ w&F↑$∧n∞=M↔∂Q)F∞v}\⊗>* ≤6≡␈↑N&.n]nG
α∞∞&␈ε↑.GJεM≡7'~Dλ N]X⎇~-⎇X;λ∞∞[|→.∞~9<eA S8,9~<|∧
88|M}kλ⊃.LiJ( ←~<⎇¬a"C"D((→→.≤|Z<∞M;{H
|H≠>$ tnHAQ@εE+Yv6⊗⊂≥42P&]v:4q\β GpEp¬CiS9NA'sMiKZA∃]U←sL←gkM→KefA∧AaCO∃HX~∃MKO[K9iKHAYSeiK¬XA[K5←erX↓S[aYα+7π;&K;≥β4KCCW∞aβOS␈∪π∂∃ε ;⊃β6KCCW∞`4+≠Nc∃βπ≡≠↔OMεK9⬬+;'≠N+⊃β≠∂≠#'?rqαS#*βCπK∞#'∨5εK@~π=tπ>.MEV↑v}⎇`hWM ↔"∧∀λ6∞vmx
∧ Y8<D∞≠h_L]_8[n$~=λ ≥↑(≠-}Y+H∧
~→(
l=λ⊃,LY8⎇↓QY{H M<|λ
≡h_(
∞9y( ≤→≤Y.>h≤| ≤y+λ ≥Yλ~ \=↑(
≥]→<L≤⎇~;ma"XY.Ny93D∞~→(λxh_; ⎇|Z=
(_;LD≤→<Lm|[8-ly+H∧ =;⊂~~qyP+Zv6⊂9≥wεE$[⊂0w<H9t⎇2H6rvw\<P12]9rrgλ→~[%H;wy2≤P0w2λ_[⊂6Zv64w[⊂∀→[λ14p∀
words) The Multics at MIT (there are about @QQeKJ↓IWuK8A[kYQSGKf4⊃C@3bβ?[↔⊂βS#∃¬;?K3 β;?]Jβ#πMβ→β'πdc'?9¬;?K∪~β? βn+7?KJ`4+←FK∂!αJβ ↔3L+[∃βLε2β
]⊗∨⊗|8V≡}l@∧l]5`¬&FT TM" 9vv6≤}W⊗∂M→vrπ.Yg_h&4ε∨π↑4αjε}Mε/∩∞9↔&/4∞f∂↔∀λ&/'|\Vrβ∀λλ-lλ
+D∧∃~→$ x8z T≤→<AQPp∃$
<h M∀≥{|LNkλ⊂⊂[2⊂4yH⊃;2i≡P30y]⊃⊗⊂1≥z⊂:4→P9|y]2vP3Yz9P!T*P6$[tz2r εE0w→⊂1pwλ90y2[<P2|_rrr⊂ P"dhλ82y⊂_x:P∀~4st6≡P0y|[1t97]w7ziH897qYyywy
VεE0[:47zYt⊂87]ry3:[⊂1t0\0qz2\⊂0w2λ14z⊂≤z94w→P40w→64w3H4w9z≤:qz4[w9FE_pw⊂2≠P0P&≠z⊂30\z2y⊂≥wy5P≥40w⊂_P_P -ip lOa`/store chain. You
wanted To know a Bout @⊃SgWfh~∀4R↓↓↓↓∧#πS∃R↓↓EY∧kπK∂B↓EeAλ↓IIi+!β↔O h)↓↓α↓α≠K}ii↓α≤K ↔K ↓"]9∧{3'9¬≠' ↔↔!$4(hQ↓↓↓ααπ9αm~UAQ+ β#π~↓aEQ∧≠g3'v#↔KMbβ?→↓!9βK↔≡{K∪Mε+π∂!rα'SMε [↔K∞;∃βO,+%βSNk∀4)α↓↓↓βO→↓IUεkM9↓DIβ∪?r;Qβ/v{]β←F+S#↔∩βS#π ∧w~πN,⊗≡Z↑Mro',≤6Z@λ ,∧∞→<Xl]] λ
}A"H∧∧λλ~ ≥→H≤
L=→→.$ +( ∀{≠λ ,=λ∩.D|h≥∞0quV]7P
track, thoegh). Its average
roTatioNal lAtefc@dASf@`X MM∧kM)αM#@~πN,⊗w≡lX D∞X=→$
<h⊂,-⎇=⊂
α90KqE@'αAPBα∧∧αε↔≤LW4λ∧⊂⊗14K 3α∪'Qβ↔KS↔MJβC↔I∧ε6.≡⎇lBbε|∧@ε@↔≠P -pεP→β∧∧W$⊂εzf≥4qyP≤2qw`2d.~∀@@@Alb`dhβo←eIM:~(hR%β∂∞s; ?Dλ L\8ε6 9 p QSαs ~ε|dε⊗.βXp∀≠py5@ ph∂ggαK 'M_
≤αyP 4hat @]←kIH4⊂ O#|εrπ~→(∞ <YP↔\αh C]
JA←L↓≠k@3αM⊗∨~ \⊗≤@~8p_λ8∧o @≥` ↔π ∧ε∞≥X;NL9y+AQQ[p→λ0p l its @YSei@,∧⊗bε\X -}↑+λ∞M→(⊂-n~<=,≡→9⊂_0yt`# arc@!SiKGβ#WK∀hS?2∞Mε*∧α≠p↔→|{rf≠⊂≠⊂_ ⊂9r`2i` f@!MeOZαβS#∃∧:∃IAαIβCK⎇3'&↑4ελh-
w∂&≥H $ 9]R.4πnmenp to the Lisp impl@∃[@↔nMw∩r∧ vv@≤(⊂↔[2P92Yβistepλ
∧Q¬"RAGα Cπ d∧Rε@yH⊂∀≠v24g→β a @→kYXA1Sg`Aββ?'nLW$→>~.z9V⊂_w2⊂ 4his
pπC@7*βC↔∨Lε7&/$λ
.P:42H5w6 9 kne you @
C\AGα 3∂Wd∧↔&*
_ ED→:0~~2y↔εB*4:yK⊂:42Haightforward way by the compiler to improve generated code,
but in no way could it be claimed that what it generates is
competitive.
Multics MacLisp is "owned by EIT. It is distributed by MIT to anyone
who wants. It is part of some Honeywell products [Emacs], and is
supported by Honeywell to the extent and only to the extent necessary
to keep these products operative. Honeywell can distribute it,
but may not charge for it, but may charge for products written it it".
Although its support is a current hot potato, interest in using
Multics Maclisp is continually growing, and interesting subsysTems
in iT are being develkpeD as od∧AiQ%fAoe%iS]Nαp4(∀T ;gSFK;≥β.c@≡+qQ hP`[6∃Tn∂%Wβ
αε⊗C+λ~*∧:α↓~FNn≥lr∧⊗]l6Fn≡-7~α↓Q%&{$∧αεf≡>π&N]≥f:ε≡@¬≥*X→∩αα↓Q%≡Nl8R∧J
↔6.d}Bε>}NF.r
↑V≡B
≥bπ& Tπ>∂∀
v"πm⎇G.wL\Wε.D &.v=
V∂⊗>1PWN↑EB∧J∞
&␈ε}8Rπ&tλ&.>≥dπ&@h≥|M≡→(∀m⎇9(≠/≡y;⊃D 9Y∞⎇=~∞M→(~ ]≤λ≠l@εA9w[pP7`& yo`*8A⊃Ke∀OfAi!JAS]%iSCX↓YSgh↓←DAi!S]Of↓∩AoC9hAi↑↓iKgh↓iQJ~)caKKα!β/→β!P@H!_↔π⊗∨∀πε.lZ&.v<Tε∞vD
7&←,≤v*α∞,⊗v&⎇Pε∞≡<Z7
HQ!∀∂↔,∨∩π⊗\lWε.l8 $ 9Y⊂≤βtorag`
@Q5CieS`ACGGα+@∨~α#"A_<X 0↑P92s→y2w1YP0w2λ9z7i_qrP∀≠pz14↑⊂4w;→y9tw[∀BE∧Tt7y:λ64yzλ9z9:Xz:y2H∀92q[y29Vλ4:w5\W↔↔∀CE L@=]NAY%ghAgQacGiUeJ@Q
IdAC
GKgf$~∀βπ¬$AQK¬mrAgQacGiUeKf~(∪π $↓QKCmdAgieUGike∃f~∀∪%]aKeAeKiK⊂AMk]
iS←\↓GCYYL~∀&≤¬voε≥H ,D→]3L>~;sD x;∪∞FE∧i[pyt2Y⊂3:g_z4wgλ1pv6≤β
Tabde dp MGβ#'?9∧≠π33~↓"5Yh4 dβ λ
:0TPh→⊃
#!!5_:-D≤Y0n↑\z0↔[⊂⊂∨TCEa6≠quP![vx4`,ing
Reader sPead
ProPerti listqtructp eKL~∀ββQ←ZAgQa`↔∂'+K↔MαCOπS,ε&∂&\@λ
|X<\L∨<j#!!2;] ↑YX;∧
≠{|∞1"B5∞
9{{M⎇9=≤M≤h→]-l⎇~;mnc"B(≡Z9~
\=~8d¬→[∪l≡~;Yd ;Y @4|2b
FE∧i\2qtp[⊂;0y~pq62H67wu]xεE∧S5qpvλ;0y4Xq62P≠5wuz\εE∧aSdεS time
GC time
Compiled↓G←IJ↓YWCH↓iSKJ4∀∪ α↓iKgh↓iS[J4⊂∪βe%iQ[KQSFAaIKISG¬iKf~(∪)ca∀AIKi∃aSS]¬iS←\4∀~¬'UOGKgQS←]f↓g←YS
SiKHαp4(⊃⊃∩o↔ qPhPβ"@↓Al +(≡≤K&ε∀λ -&Vα38.=9]→.$_=
λ4Pk)X6⊂h∧∧λβ"HL=→.Dε(⊂<∞$ ..ε∀ -.FG(∀∀jA"Q\M⎇.H∪,≡z;] ↑H_=∧
⊂4PeY06⊂aQU≠nD ~<|
M;:0↔→P0z∀jV`dCEαE*~2yrP_y2P7≥vq2y≤β that I @≥K]Ke¬iKHAαK9β3∂#∃↓EK9] "
\V∂∨↑-⊗v:
≥g∨'.X7&N⎇dhV=}Vw'4 f␈∩∞l↔⊗N}Z2∧NnLWε@~<|¬V,λ∪n <X=
≥{\kD {Y(∞M~;Yd∞≠h⊂LT_x<L\];λ
|H~0↔βE0
e@¬gkeS9NA'w#↔K∪O≠A5Eαβ'Mβ&yβ←π&≠!β←F+S#↔∩βS#∃ε3W;∂&K?;Mε K∃β≥;πCC, 4+| εv␈E` EeH~0~λ6pur\P0P!~sP24Y32y2[1rW∩P9zsYp¬stInterlisp-10 timi`≥OLAgQ←UYH~∃ JA[C⊃J@ACPAYKCMhA←]
JRAo%iPA≥=''β!→→∞Ag∃hAi↑↓(AEK→←eJAQQJAi%[@↔⊂hSCK??∪π5βLε2εf|≤F.α
→bph!Q"jjUURjε,XvNr h n9pq2→r⊂6r\ypsrH⊗VVVKVVFEβE$P$_{2P5≥yz⊂&Xp2P9[vrP6Ypyzy≠pp∞ts of how many iNstruCtions it @QCWKf~∃i↑↓I↑Am¬eS←kLAiQS9OfASαqα2&≥↓1βπv!α%β&C?W∨G!βS#-Iβ7π>CQβ *β?→β>+;↔K∞a4 NsS↔K/≠Q84Ph*π3bβ7.≡>W⊗.\X NNh_<LT~;@
n;8Y.⊂7s⊂∀ ∧P-⊃0 instruc@QS←]f0AiCW%]N~∃9↑ACG
←k]h↓←DAi!JAeK1CiSm∀AgaKα+⊃β?2βS#?≡)β';∨#@↔∞>M⊗}w5aPTn\≡7/⊗]\Vwπ4λf␈∩ \↔F~¬∞vFN=λ
<h∀m⎇9(∀n 8z0-D∀⊃∀¬V,λ∪-|→#"M≥\⎇≤N\⎇~3mnh≥≠d
;<≤M}Y(⊃N]X⎇~-⎇H_p⊂[4∧ pEp¬M←E5C]GJ$ACeJ↓H∂'[,¬bεNaQ'ε∂,]g&F↑8W5A"C!
≠h⊂l≥≠λ⊂⊂H73wε\{px 0ed c@=[aSY∃HAMk9GiS←8@Q]←PAS\A∧AEI←
P
%β>C'∂!∧CπL4T 31β|1β'S~βπK∨~α2>∞ bP∀
*4π&∞<X dε,λ∩-n⎇≤],>~;{N5H
∧G∧≠{@ \>_j!Q↑{[nL(≥~ ≡λ~0↔λ:44`3 afdqubsEquent fagures, the Time "tk c@¬YP⊃ ∧ε6}n↑MεNvqQ&∞g=tεNv=JV&/4
FF*∞M⊗n(≥≠d∞Y=≥.
H→P→≠vP4`4|∧∩(hRS-β≤∧⊗f@λ_ ⊂∀h¬BR↓←@→↓α⊂λ ≡Yy0⊗Yw:⊂ 4akes 50 ASαsOSK,∧7&Nβ{\e@⊂⊂λ &@AP∨9∧¬V∂F5⊃P@*≠h⊂⊃Xv6⊂ ! functi`∨\αβ'9β&C∃βO∞k∃β d¬v≡Z∞⎇ε/⊗Tλ
(_p⊂[4∧ed↓H @.βXp~~wwεE~0yP !lhλA←α1β'S~βπK∨~α2>∞ bP∀
*4π&∞αy0→H~⊂4`.qtre@
iSO]L@V@Bαβ⊂⊗@|H⊂∩XqtεE→αh∂e[¬XAC@⊗;W7↔w!0⊂@ ¬εE∩pε the called @→k]Gi%←\AQ¬`
βπwIβ >dλ
.Nh_<L@zp
e@9ifAπA π-βI&AiQ∃\∩+LεBπ_:y.P~P↔↓S]giIkGiSα{;Mβ∧¬G/~ε⊂ D Xπy each↓'! πYβ$ACIH
βπv!↓Iβ4¬w!α@
eAch non-sp@∃GmCDαβπK≥p∧¬&@h_Z-lλ≥P⊂\αiables with a↓!%∨∞αβ'Mβ⊗{W>
H∞!Q]~→$∞x;9%@⊂⊂λthis i@L@djVβI0∨∨ Xλnl<H⊂↔[⊂
axc)~∀4⊂
MxλmP2w:≤αy tahπ@↔Mβ1eβ'w≠SKW≤εFN}n5BεJlUbαD)It9h
⊃I@dπ FOLεRRAβ##↔aQ'&@h_p⊂[4∧ FOLεAoSαc1βS∞[∃↓EJβ7?K*β';O'∪W∂SL¬vw~∞Mε∞r¬λ$d|9:2αDβR3∧λSsc!∀ OCAH -βI&@@9¬!%%$hQ#@&
_ d
<h
εT≠{@⊂∪p|1Vλ4W2Wλ0q7j]⊂_[@ more d¬P∨I∧∧&f@xz`⊂→w:1<JTε~∃β[g?U¬;π;Q∧εFzεMtπ&FTλf␈⊗β90→λ4s⊂#∪dπ c@¬YP∪M∧¬↔'≡]H D∞Y8u.9ts"[<V⊂ 4hkugh}.
λTo @⊃↑ABA →↔β!A→2TAQCWKfp`ASαsOSK,≠S'∨w→↓-↓~βC↔I∧∧Vwπ/∀ε}r -FN∂∞
GNXπ9FB9t4`#h must be pπWSaAK@@Q$]J\A%H βg⎇)α
2\
BBK∀α<4ytε∞vDλd`9βP4iH:42FB8∧hi@IHAK]Q` eβ|¬b∧∀I8∃∧e_ie~πM VrπM
↔
ε≤4β"ε←∞G,(~0↔≤z92`#tigns)*~∀!cCKJ↓←\A≠¬qF@$hP4*Szβ∂π∪bβ¬αNαx∃¬∧X@λ @8¬`≥Gβ#'?9¬#π/↔~βπQβd+πOQβAP∩ε≤LFO&≥yf∞b
→g∂'.XλnM9{\aQ\→0→λ1pv ,,∧A)Q%`
β'~β';∪-β↔;∪,sQβ?2β←#↔&C↔Iβ&C∃β∂∞c3↔⊃∧∧g.v>M⊗}r
_ aQX(⊂MMβqu@ or a↓`∂'↑ F*εnX L>~;sED→=_eAαEεE⊂P INKED @→k]Gi%←\AGα 3 "∞L⊗↑∂4ε∪αε]z&*ε≥n7'↔\8
≥{\h∞M_;H ∀≠[p↔ v4w5YrεE &unction c@¬YX@9¬K?Uβ≡C?W3"βS#↔⊗+≠ ?,Tε∞g|∨↔
π∞↑BαDiyDL@RqSJ4 H∃¬∀β"Z-d≡;⎇.$_[≠l=|h→ \{_<L≡~;{D∞9[⊃.≡h≡;nT~_=LT_(∀n 8z9M≤c"\L\<{p↔λ37y≥pw:4[3P:4→P1pv≠9P64[5rr.
¬
0%-Apr-81 2141↓JHL via LON@ON
To: lisptimiNg atSU-AI
how about inclUdingh~∃K]YSeO]5KhAg]SiGQ%]N@QMiCGV5OeOkAfXAKYCXAo%iPAC1Sgh@!aidR0~∀βG1←gke∀XAKi R~∃m¬eSCE1JAY←=Sk`@↓oSiQ%\Ago%iGQKα!β↔;6KC/;n+;P4WβK'↔LεFO6↑4ε}r∞>G-9Y|eD_Z=∞∃λ_↑.L<h≤l\9(∃
t_Y(
]<|z-lc"C! ↓Al +(≡≤K.ε∀λ DF⊗b0p.-λ∩→.⎇=≥⊂∂!`i&λ0z⊂&Rj⊂
AI> Liqp Timifg↓≠CSY%]NA→%ch@~) CiJh@lAβAaSH@Drpb@@bt`p5 '(~)
eOZhAπCe0A⊃Ko%i`⊃↓d~εJ1nks,
C@¬eX~∀4∀_⊗`L5βadZ`b@@bL`d∪%A∞@@∪QS[S]≤AEK]
Q[Ce,@@@~))↑t@@E↓→M!)%≤9 ∪'↔@Y ∨πtDACh↓'*[β$@@@~))QJA→←YY←]S]NA%bAiQ∀AMSeMhA←L↓iQJAQS[S]≤AEK]
Q[Ce-fAi↑↓EJAiISKH\AβfAMkGP~)ShASLAMCSIYrAg%[aYJ8A∪hA%bAgS5aYrA∧AG←[ S]Ci=aSCX↓aCSe%]NAMU]GiS=\AiQ¬h~+& /↔Mβ⊃βO↔'→↓#K/βK↔O,sS↔⊃ε Mβ3O≠SM%bβ¬β7∂#∂#'v9β≠Wv≠S'?raβπ; βO?7*β?S#/⊂4+∂}sOSK∞K;SMbβπ;⊃πβK?∪,≠↔MβλβG↔Q∧{⊂∩π
z7∞N-HRπε≥≡&Nv}4ε}2
~F.o4 gε}T V∞≡↓Q'≡= @
M→(→/ ;<≠ T_Y;
}h≤≤M|≥8q.P→~\L⊂87y\tq62H80ty~w3yWλ$Ss"H4s1`,u`ed↓iQJ~)K]iSIJAiKMiS]NαβCK??∪π51¬;#'∂Bβ'Mβ∂!βS#*β ?S&{5 " ≥F}vt
vO&∧
FF*∞LW∨" L↔&
AQ'>F≤9αε∂,Tπ∂&},V"ε≥`λ @v7q0[⊂;0y~pq62\β* Belh∂nA%`
βK-βK >L¬0⊃Yp⊂:4→P:4fZw3yP→αrgm
λthe SAIL KL runjing with a lOa`λACYKeCO∀AWL@8jj\AQQJA←Uiakh↓←@→β&C∃βS/≠P$ ∧ε&}?,≥RεO4∞FF*
nVn⊗↑ ε}∩∞ ⊗O⊗≥lw~B∞Mε*π.Yg&N\TαD0Sv∧∞~;9$
{H≥
(∩s¬∃λ_;LA"Y~ T→xu
≥9(
λXSvλ∞M;9*%dλ∃~ T→Z4Nz⊂9:[⊂4w;≠v;2yH!gi"Zw3P*\⊂4w≤2yx'[9rP*≠FE64\z⊂9x_qrP"↑40z`3tion whi@
PAeKMkYif↓S\Ai!JAYCIK@∃β>≠S'↔*β∪ ?$λ
(→P∀\αst
rp \@RβS#∃∧{S#↔⊂∧ππ9\h ≡Y(∩-d≥~→$∞Y<⎇-N~;Yd {|Y$
989l↑iH∩$∞⎇9yl↑⎇λ⊂≤[zP0v≤wFE)≥w⊂4`4 a f@∃nAiS5KfAi<AOKhαβ¬βO& &T
6/"
x D∞Y89
≥YxkAQ@εE$]⊂;w`5ld be j`∪Gα)βC=∧∧v/"∞8 m\αP92\zv29H397fH<sp∃ dh∂dAβ##∃αdJNAβn+↔S'v9βπQ¬~J$Q( md≥y1
l<y_/∃λ_].D≥~_.D≠8>$
Xπr be p@=`∂O'⊗c∃8Q!⊂HJ↑.ε*hβ"LFW,Hβ!¬∀U3JI31(ε∃β_ 4_) ;in se@
←]IF4⊂ "≡≥"& ,Tε#Jsv∩∩JQ!PC∪W⊗"hαJ∀JYU∩3(T +@≤∞≠TPεB∀#aj∩d¬E 2.599)
α
2592
(BUNTIME 1.884∧R@~(Q≡∞$J6∃↓⊂¬c+3U∀hPQ&#+K$↓PRE*Ye$LXTβ
S¬⊗"JQ%∧<≥I→T*β∃c∪∪∩∀↓PPh&&SK∩↓Q"E∃YjDLLTε∩cC⊗U∩h%λt≥$→XRβ
g⊗s~J↓Q hS4εng]]]]Nβ;;+≠8εvvVlp
mm[Y`≠[533@7nnfg]]UMNβ;;;≠9;;+;8εvvvlp
mmYY`≠[733@7njfg]]U]Nβ;
λ(DEFUJ @!¬∪%&@!0A2A5+'([¬!! βHA¬+≤ααεBBeI6∞≡u~RJεLrRMα≤z2NR∀
& 5J1P@J∧∧ααα i∀bmλ→∃∃~α(β!∧λλλ∧∧λ
α H30Qλ∀λ⊂ ,⊗∀PεEαP⊂λMAPCAN~∀%α↓"5Yh5$Ly`
H30Qλ∀λ∩*$↓ ¬∧Pλ⊂⊂⊂⊂
()'cS∧A∧Pλ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ∀!gg⊃ε@
(MUCT-APPEAR¬
*CATCH
↓ 'OU@(4∀∩∩@Q!%∨≥≤∩∀∩$@@@Q5β!ε@4∀∩α@@@Q
U≥π)∪=_Q β5¬↓α@!∩R@Q
≠⊂~⊃αA"6⊗l∩⊗I↓D~∩IαJIα6V≥!6εB∧*εI$hP$$∧HI↓!*$BJ>]α:>VQ¬!%%%JH4(⊃∀ααα ∃⊂hP⊃∀αα∧i→BJJ⊃Q HJ
E∩JHQ!∩αα∧∧ααDβ∩4jD⊂**%⊃ B(∧ ⊗∩
%∀β"B% 04⊂h~H
⊃JYPp
$SβH Q→¬≠¬ αα↓"%%αB∞∩I∧I%%$hP$%"≤z:"¬¬βbα HTtu∩⊂⊗∀@
(+ CON@λ@Q9∪⊂⊃⊗∧
&JMβ %↓λ¬λε¬*(
H3Qu ∧⊗**%⊃ B"$∧λλλ∧∧λ⊂λ Ri)X@ (MAKE-POSSIBILITY-1 X
α ↓ Y
∩∩$∩@@A→+≤
∀$∩∩α∩$@@AβA!→2[
≠⊂~N%∩ε&:%_4(⊃⊃⊂HH∀∧α∧≤yj5%∀→→e%_Q!⊂HH⊃⊃∩αα i∀bmλ→∃∃~∃∃⊂hP⊃∀ααα∧∧αE"¬
∧ M*6"αDX→4*M z5≤L)→DM¬∃V"¬HQ!⊂HH⊃⊃∩αα∧∧¬@h!⊃⊂HH⊃∀ααα∧λe,pQ!⊂HH⊃⊃∩αα∧∧∧
¬ K∩l≤yj5%∀→→e%_Q!⊂HH⊃⊃∩αα∧∧∧≤\j:E∀ →jE_h!⊃⊂HH⊃∀ααα∧ dLbZλ∀M∃5∃∩JJ∃∃⊂hPQ!PRDHXe,r X∀\*Z u≥≤_)∀dMK∃S
α ∧¬J∧jYb∧
EJl9ye≥%(→∀u%4λ4|U:J$ LjJ0hP⊃⊃∩αα i∀bmλ→∃∃~∀↓PRα∧∧ααᬬ∧d X(D
α e∩h!∀αBDH→T∀$∀¬¬
J↓Q Jα∧¬∧≤|βQβ!!(λλ∧¬∪R3¬Z⊂24J4λ∪0*λh
⊃JYPp
$Sdε(LAMBDA (I) (RPLACD I
(LIST
'(NIL)
(CDR I)))))
Q))
(Q)))
(MAPCAN
(FUNCDIMN(LAMBDA (I)
(PROGN
(SETQ L 0)
((LAMBDA (A) (AND A
(OR (NULL CONSTRAINTS)
(NULL APPDY-CONSTRAINTS)
(FUNCALL APPLY-CONSTRAINTS
CONSTRAINTS))
(LIST (LIST* I A))))
(MAPCAN
(FUNCTIKN(LAMBDA (J) ((LAMBDA (Q) (COJD (Q ⊃≥
∨∃&ADRRRR4∀∩∩∩$Q!%∨≥≤@Q'∃)"A≤PbVA8RR~∀$∩∩∩@@@@@Qπ∨≥⊂@PQ∨H@Q≥ 1_A
+8R~∀∩$∩∩∩∩@Q
+9πβ→_↓
+≤A$A∀RR4∀∩∩∩$∩@@@@@Q→%'(TA8A∀RR$RRRR4∀∩∩AdRRRR$~∀α@A0RR$~∀α`$R~∀~(~∀Q ∃
+≤A5β↔
[A∨''∪ ∪→β)dZd@Q`A2A
U≤Aβ!A→2[π=≥')%¬∪≥)&↓π↔≥'Q%β∪≥Q&~∀∩$∩@@A9∪_[!¬∪%&R~∀@@@@@@ Q→β≠ α@Q8R@~∀$@PQ→¬≠¬ αQ"R@4∀∩@@Qπ∨≥⊂~∀∩@@@Q≥%_[!β%%&@Q5β!ε@!
+≥πQ∪∨ Q1β≠¬ ∧@Q∩RQ%!→¬πλA∩4∀∩∩∩$∩∩@@Q→∪'PT@NQ9∪_@$hP$$$HH$%↓αB∞∩I∧I%%%JH4(∧HI↓↓↓ααE%$hP%↓↓α↓"E%JH4(¬α↓"6ε∧~ε9hP%↓↓αB~V:≥"& <e D l(H∩αD∃∀hP∀∧ααα∧¬¬¬∀xy`hPα(λ∧∧λλλ¬
q1∀$ H
!Q@(λ∧∧λλ묬⊃⊂3((⊂(
λ∃(
⊂)hα⊂ FB∧DDDH∀'i⊂
'*f&λ!gg)U) dg∃)PFEαD@DPλ⊂⊂⊂∀∪*f&⊂⊂h(&,Kagg)U) dg∃)TFEαD@DPλ⊂⊂⊂∀⊃*g!`S&⊂ h∀&,VaSdεSTRAINDS
∩∩$∩∩@@@@Aπ=≥')%¬∪⊂~R~I$4(HH$%↓Db&NQαB2&N ¬"∧Jλ∃∩JJ⊃Q HJ X∃∧≤→dhPα"(¬λβ*g!U$gg(LAMBDA J) ( ⊃→¬≠¬ αQ"R@!π∨
λQ"@Q9π↔≥&↓"RRR$~∀α∩$∩Q!%=∂≤@QM !"A8@PbV↓_RR~(∩∩α∩@@@@@Qπ∨9λ@PQ=$@Q≥U→_A
U_R4PH$$$HI↓↓"5*:∞εdaα~Vrα)α¬JH4(∧HH$%↓α↓↓↓↓Db&NQRα1α JI%%%JH4(∧Jαe%%JI$4(J↓↓αaJI$4λK↓%$4Ph($ D"⊗~VpαBε&∃→E↓ E∩hαHλ∧∧λλλ¬λqsQ↓Q@∧T(NULL L) '((NIL)))¬
(T
( ⊃→¬≠¬ αQπβ≥⊂A!∨'LR@~∀$@@@Q5β!πβ8@∩(J↓↓↓↓D2V:∞αI∀`9β∀& Sa" @
( di∀TPεEαP⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂∀(∀'cgεB∧DT(LAMBDA AVMID ANS ∩@4∀∩∩@Q≠β!
β≤@~(∩∩@@Q~Vt~R&>p¬∧d X(D
α ∃∩h!⊃⊂Jα∧∧ααBα∪⊂)XQ⊂ ¬
*(
λ9pπ"⊂
(P∀'⊂gg)P∀TTTTCE (P@%=∂∀@Q
≠∃λ@ Qπβ$Q≠ ≠ $@Q
β$A∩$~∀α∩$∩∩α∩↓β-∨∪⊂RR~∀$∩∩α∩@@@Q1∪'(T↓β-∨∪⊂Aβ≥&$R~∧∩$∩∩α@@Q(@!→∪'(αQ↓"I~5"R¬λ4
∩ ∃⊂hPα""!⊃ "(∧∧λ⊂5IY1
#!↓ ""!⊃(λλ∧∧λ∪∩*:λH⊂h→Qβ"A⊃ ∧DDBDP⊂⊂λ∀!b)λ$TTFB∧@ ANS)))))))~∀$∩@@AA_∞NMJH4(⊃∀αD≤~ λ
λ24Te⊃ ¬∧DH∀!b)λ( di∀TTTTJF@
(PAIRS1 (CDR L ∩R$R~∧∩@Qπβ¬$A1Hh ⊂J∧¬∧ $~ λ E***%⊃ ¬εEβE∀""Q*g⊂(⊂di)Yλ∀ )
(@π↔: h %!DrV"D BJαu
@$f∀TJFA∧T∃∧A∧P
∀ AM@@ α@!ββ≥λ↓!∨'ε$@∩(J↓↓↓αl
B∞εp∧hP∀∧αααλjTt≥I→tbDβ⊂3((α P∀∀ di)JPεE∧H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂ )∪cgεEαDT∀&⊂da" H∀ k'Rb⊂ g∀TPεEαDP⊂∀∪`h!`S⊂εE∧BP⊂⊂∀⊃*g!j∩dπF(LAMBDA (A)
∩∩$@@@@PQ β5¬↓α@!"R@Q
≠⊂~⊃αBE↓ h4`9β)P(JTTTFB∧DDPλ⊂⊂⊂⊂
()'cS⊂⊂!gS ∧ ((AAR (MEMBER CAR A)
↓ AVOID$R~∀∩$∩∩α@@@A→%'(DA¬-∨∪λααε*MJH4(⊃⊃⊂HJ∧∧αE"¬ DM≥E$αDd~:BRαλ8∃∩∧∃⊃P@H⊃⊃⊂HHα(λ∧∧⊂5Si_λ∧FEαD@ (@→∪M(T@Q
$A∩$~∀$HH$$⊃∀αααλ8∀`(λ∧FEαD@ ANC)))))))
α @OSS!)
λ ∩@!∞εI¬αε&J~H4(⊃∀αD≤J λ
λ24Te∃***$↓ ¬∧Pλ⊂⊂∀(⊂di)Yλ∀!b)λ&⊂ )))
(CAAR D)
λ (CDARL)))))
α
(dec@1CeJ@!caKGαKπ1βλβ %$hQ#O↔' β¬↓:@4(∀∧αC
∧
!Q@(λ¬εh∞α!Q@∧P⊂
≤P_∀CEP⊂
0P1_TBE∧H⊂∀0@ b c)
(d e f)
(d E f)
(g h i)
↓ (g hi)
(j k l)
(m n o)
α (p Q r)
))
(setq bNP~∀$@@QBαβ β
Hh(%↓αC)β-∧a$4λJ↓↓#⊃∧∧Rε2⊃Q Jα¬∞απ
∞!⊂hPα(λ¬ h~
∃!"B$∧
(ε¬!"B$∧λ_ ⊂_⊂1TFB∧P⊂∀≤⊂8P9
FA∧Pλ∀≠P≤
FA∧Pλ∀5⊂ + l!
(∩ 1)
(3 2)
(_ 7)
(9 8)
(0 9)
(m j o)
∩@QHAJ↓HR
∀$@@AT↓RAXR4∀∩@@!ZA\A<R~∀∩@QHA∀ALR~(∩@@Q@AbAd$~∀%α↓#≥β@β%$∀PI↓↓%Hh( (% F.↔]`λ∞L<⎇묬 εE⊂
∀60vX20P∀≥_P<→βt)
(setq X (paip¬fABαβ ↓↓J↓∨πG,∧⊗bα¬∀αBJ¬↓∩JHQ!∩αα∞<W'
∞B∩αBβ(
∞∞8π:4[p¬) @PbRR~(∩@@QMKibA≥h@@ZQgiCQkfAO
iS@7*Iβ∨QJH4(∀∧αGπ-_ NDλ≠⊂∩[3z4 x))
(pp¬SMhQP∪'≤εBα|X
`.ti`≠J4⊂∩%α↓↓↓↓α↓"FV⎇"&⊗: ∧αDS∪p*Dλ
β$∞ (⊂∪]∀TFEαD@ 100 @``@9JI$4!∀ααG∞-⊗wλ
≠
≡⎇λ l\⎇~0⊗YFA∧DH⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂8z[z4r`.t ⊃Mαc?πQ∧∧w"J∧∧ _ __⊂⊂0,∧RRR$~∀@@!a`↔nM⊗n*(
¬∃≤⎇_.NαyP 'ctime)))
λ∞`@2jπCIhπβ
α∧ εεb4Tλtλβ"JMnHλ∧
~<p_≥90w9[0z7i≤β a`(ααNU6 I↓↓hR#↔K*;@~πM Rπ⊗\≥Bπε≥]⊗v:∞8
∞\β3↔ As I pkinte` o@UhXAi!JA←Y⊂A%+≥Q∪⊂⊗∀hQ#@>
_λm∧otal p¬`↔nM⊗n(~→.2P0zλ)`dfλ4yP 'iven
λ¬ErAα ∪∪'v9βC#*α≡∞RLj∃βπv!α↑RLj∃β↔w#@⊗N↑4ε⊗.Mx
e@⊂εEεB*44`3 proGp¬C@5∧¬↔4~→0↔_p¬fo@IiPAGα 3 &\@∞D _⊂ `Rd⊂1`/nstraint @
←[ES9Ci←e%CXAa¬Se@'v84+C⊗{⊂∨⊗≥Pr:ε} ¬≤≤:
α`HαB"!∃<Xλ#KFE)*S*$fbH≤P"a∪l⊂:4[pBE+U$fbP∂P"a'V⊂⊂∃@≠pp
o@IrAiS5J@ACAae←pαq$4(hQIUe∩$$%↑sW7 -⊃β/→πβπ'KNs∨L4RBJV:$J6∃↓λqeYEJ%n⊗∀zaβSNk∃β'pβGπ∂}s∪L4RB≡∞RLj∃↓IJqeEQJ%n≡≥"& ,T ⊗rπ<\6}vL1PBEzI∀l*ε
%g
J,f6lj(↓↔q0Sk∧λh∪(Y3tV$∞~;9$
9H∀l\{{Y∞1"C"F&.,H↓QJ⊂ *S*$fbH_W∀X TPεE
πC@)%≠
@DαqP∪ e∀hRλzDL@1(
%Fli∀H∧@
2592
(@%U→)∪≠∀@d\`@pR@~(Q≡∞αI∀l*∧ F@_TPεBα(WTIME %.59000003)
~∀Hjrd@4⊂Q%+9)∪≠
bP→@⊗W∩JQ%∧<≥I→T*β%` εF*(β!¬∃u∩)X( +GεL∧→YLYZ∀PβEαE→
\Y⊂εB∀)*g∃$fbP Tε0∩`PR@~∀!∂π)∪5
@b\βIIE%h)"↑$J6∃↓*qEII≠→MM%h($(0=A*jπCIkAE↓↓β⊃A`&BβπQαlJQ6εJ↓"+π≡Yα#?fc?←πJI'3O≠AβSNk';∨~↓↓↓hR∪πS+Q↓↓U∧
BI↓λπ∪C
∧εSβBXZ5 h(j&}k$ αε∂D TM"β02$¬⊂X8m4⊂≠s
Mβ{p|JFE)zX52qj∞⊂64y\⊂:4vZw3yFB*7]⊂≤83P ]⊂)bVPdFEεB'zz≠s⊂1j\4wyt]<V⊂<[zP6tYt:⊂*≤<P:7H3rz⊂⊂y0tsH)2|w≠v29P_z⊂$dRFE:7H9:w≤wvrP≥4vtg→yP7cλ&pqv~yx⊂7[⊂:42H#3ww≠<P#⊗LU⊂⊂*~2P6pXt4w2CE4yP≤5zst≠<P→≥5P→↔
P:4vYyP0@∩f⊗XHλ37y qome things.¬
I'm not suRe he has A net a`dbeqs _Aα∪WQβN{Uβ∂|εVf" |W @ Z;D {{] ≤⎇λ∃m≡~λ∩
≥(≥~∞.(⊃_.l(⊃≡,↑H_=∧ 4r+AQ@εEβ∧π0&-Apr-`b@@bPb`∪⊃∃ %∪π,AChAI+)∂ I&@∪%∀tA)S5S]NA K]GQ5CeF@@@@~) CiJh@@lA¬ad@bβIaE↓ 9AE6-~P4*7∪?5i∧B⊗∩JL~-βπ"αJVR<*JL4U≠W +.≠Qiα⊗)iαSNk';≥ε∪↔;∂FkπK-α↓4*&yiαJ∧9βπQ¬~U6εHh*'→m∪↔C3JjS=i¬K?WI∧k↔OO∞;∃β?2↓Y6π¬⊃5aEβ QAIl*NP4Ph*π;Jβ∂#πv≠∃α%∧≠?W3"β∨πQ∧π⊗␈*∞Mrπ∨M≤6@4≥≠h n9Xu
≥{\h L9Z3L\λ~0↔λ&qap\84<←CE$P!Xw⊂3zYyyP+Z0z⊂&[yz⊂ /d∧AiQ∃ZACE∀XAEkβ!β'Q∧εv␈.L@λ ,(_Y.Nα2y≠7P:7H40{ %
to euesS. If yg`*↓o←kY⊂AYSW∀Ai↑Aβ≠↔;⊃εk∃β¬∧∧6␈π∀λ l@⊂:42H&pqf~yx⊂6Xw:pvβE∀4`& theRe is a Eaclisp manual), @QQChAβ;?W3 β ∃α|Y1βS|y0⊂hαC"H≥≤{k∧∞z→0↔λ<sp∃ pπCrA∀[E←@@βS'↔*aβ←#∂!β∪=¬K?Uβn+π9]αα'2∂→w*ε\Xλ-d⊃+8M␈β"U
≤z|k∧ {{]L↑]~3L@P:47\p¬ to time is non-sTp¬C@'>CS≠∨↔;πK⊃p∧α¬> ≡Bε≡⎇nf/↔=_ ma Y≠d∂8πp∃ use >A∪LAβ##πQ∧¬↔4≥z_.D≤;p~H8πant, idwi`→X↓H π[|ε"∧∞β~0→\⊗⊂9`)nce
using A-box ti@
P∂Mβ>K3 " X
≥8∧w0]2P:4→P7p⊗@∃` #↔∞!β∪W*βS :∞λλ,\αy⊂ 2e`
@'d¬G5αεE 7hich↓SfAo!ChAgαc?←M∧εW4→≠p≠[⊂1w`-pare@⊂A`∪=∧¬f}r\X∞∞L8π22Y⊂ i@M`\4Ph ∀J∞⎇⊗f@λ≥≤O∀≥≠h @4sp∃@IJA←@,εBπNβx
`2 functi`∨]LAC@; ∧π.αp∞ @QQK@5∧εF}v≤⎇π"r∧ ε␈>↑h .∧¬∃∩↓IP≥βv{Qβ/,∧Wαπ<X ≡X9→$λph⊂~~vp ng yet0Ag↑AβK?Uβ∧ε&}⊗≤-GJπ⎇yb?" |W"πM ↔"pβ"K%U++#%Q C"F∃β⊂$P≥44w5H4z⊂ )pεAgaα+∂'≠L∧6∞fO∀ε
ε,≤BεNLX∩π&tλ nM8z`⊂≥4π Mc@πCe@&Ceβ≠,¬f∨&≥x N⊃ XY,<=<p∩H8πe @¬eJAI=S]NAαββK↔∞aβCK|∧w,8εySITε FOp∧AKC
PA]←αq7OS∞s∪πK ∧ε .αp∞c@QS←\~)o@∃β≤∧⊗rπ∞-w6NLTε
εLX M≥X∧r2H9rvp[84q`38εASL↓s←kdα↓#∨↔v+@⊗N5∀∧dM8∧λ <8π77]⊂22`!l wi@QP⊂∀-_
¬D≥~→-d≥~_.D~8 P→βood↓`∂C↔≤¬⊗ -8h⊂∃[4πwl@∃IOJ\4⊂λ (αL@↔λ$z⊂ )pεAKq¬GiYR↓iQJA∃
>a∧εFN≡>5BεN⎇mw-8π3@ m` @7|ε'JπM_ ,Uβ⊂!:]⊂;rP→5w∪zβE80sYP⊂λo@HAgoC@RAg↑↓iQS@~β'O9?!βC?zβ?WSα,⊗ <αp∂`+β→0∩∧>X N2s:6≡P:42\2P4`3
`∨]1rA←]∀A`≠↔↔Iβ'lh n4¬al way @Q↑A[Kα GWK*β7.β;p→≡P:4fYT⊂;t~qt⊂$H9tv ,
`∪]
Y`↔∪*β3πS,ε"ε↑dλ
-d≥~→$∞Y8;∧∞~;:-lh≤Y.zr29N⊂;t0]⊂ P 3ent @]Cf~∃β≠'7Cdπ∩ε∞βH⊂∀[24q`!tignd¬P∨I∧π⊗␈*∞MrεW\Lv*π⎇ W&F↑ πN␈↑$∧dM:∧εO_Q( N]YZ0↔→β the proBlee CorreCth `%ph (αLkD
y(⊂≠Zv6⊂'→pr⊂ 4o deVise @∧AgKa¬aCiJ↓∂εAi%[@∃β&+GQ→∧IβCK|εfNε\@λ
≡λ_Y,<=<p∩H4zεE≥pyP H9zx %p¬gKhαβ?2∞Mε*ε≥lf␈⊗β8=
≥{H∩$|λ≠⊂∀Zβ`
Ai<AOKhαβ⊂↔⊗⎇Pλ ≥≠λ∪l@⊂8 oU,λ
(HH% /,∧⊃eQ ¬β∧π0 ,5βadZβAE↓↓λπ∪≠λα0Y.
β0y2λ)P∞ Greenberg <@∂eK∃]EKe≤AChA5∪ @6o+3S'≥→y&⊗)aαSLk';≥∧∪↔;∂FkπK1Q$&∂LW"αα∧∧β2∧≡
&Nbε∪∪C
∧ &Fi90→]∧@
F@I←Zt@@@A¬∃eP≠π⊗!αM9∧;K↔↔v∪↔K≥α↓↓↓↓α↓r?,XVv⊗↑,rε∂D TMαβ3=-N~8|ga"T⎇,-Y8⎇π∧λ∀Y'∧∃~;-≥Yh⊂L]Xz≠,≡X¬FE∃7]⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂∀(#P ]⊂)jVPdBE!X]⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊃⊂&)h*∀'↔"$Tmh⊗"∪anQ⊂_z⊂)jK`dFEβE$P)_w⊂:4~yP8)≠qy0vH:492YP:4vYyP7`. MIT-Mudtics ≤A!KeKf↓oQC@ ∧εO"∞<⊗N"aQ hU.X NM99(∧¬≤y0n∃(λλπεKM∧π
KM∧∧∞
KG↓ YxnM99(∧∧
≤y,>h(λ∧∧ KE∧∧ kF∧∧λλ Ef(λλ∧∧
∧$∞<y0→≤β out kf Max
set at 120)
¬
Befgre se AccepT that thi@LAS[a1K[K]QCiS←8ASfAIKCIYd@l`AQS[Kf4∃gY←β;↔Iβ&Cπ9αl
∞ $~:αε}d
4 LED∧Jπ⎇zVf"
H
-p¬ to poi@9hA←KPAiQCP~∃iQ∀Ac@;n{∪'≠L∧V"π∞-v/⊗≥P ∧∞y;]∧
9H⊂~~2P6pZv⊂ @¬Yg↑Aβ∪π9β|¬b∧ ∃Y∃%_Q)T ≤β∩4j¬λ_;∞wP1`/mpil@∃HXAMα{@∩∧i~d*¬9yDL"λ¬p)Iλεaf∪βC@⊗A5∪∃+$*M↓ ≡0hVα8
did @=\A7,cS'∂~IβO'&C?WQ∧¬wε.βZ0↔→β ids h @?αX
¬λ_].D⊂∧P 1uit @%h⊂∀,,V -βy2P~z⊂3 )nished on↓β∩@QMKmKe¬XAiSαk↔M∃`λ
M→(∩h∃αXX⊂~yP92\5y22Y∧@
do be 2 h∂d@LAaS[∃`
βOd¬w>∂$¬εNw>N'.∨M_ md≤X= U(≥~ ≥H∪=-N~8teaα@
The CL-10 at saiL, giVen all beneba`(αβ?2∞Mε*εMx
,.λε⊂ )pεA:⎇ 4*R<yα>J$*JMα|1α6ε<r&@%XHRε6≤8
↑H≥~ ≥H≥~ T⊂2( 8+($¬@∧¬∀~)⊃CfAα ;g⎇lRε.β_p∩H2p∞c@=k]iKβ∪↔" M⊗ ,X8u-Nα8 @%\A[C-S]NAβ##'M¬β@⊗@yx 0[P92`.
`∪\αβ@≡n≥H ∧
β:vq→y⊂7`& sec@=]IfAα{⊂∩∧8
Rπ~;9'tλ⊂λ %p¬QC@∧ε2πε X LT~8h∞wvrFB9zq:≠2P1`/np
KeMS←\AAaP∨ d∧Vj∧α(⊂⊗Zyyr`$ i`≤A5rAaKβ∪WOπbβ?2∞MεO~∞λ M|βy0vOFA∀$H4¬ade j`≡Aαk?β'4¬⊗≡∂M_ mnh≠p~~2y⊂ 4ha`≤Aα≠?;[,ε'&Nlpλ∞M→(⊂⊃Z0y0q]2y1P≥4π
@1←oKd5GCgJ0AC@; ∧ε}r ↑Vgε≤:2bε\≤7ε@z;Yd¬Xx= =λπU 4hrg`.↓iP≥β≤∧↔&≡¬x
∞Yy`∀Kα ∀~(_⊂≥AαeT∂π%P∞ε∀λλ@_ ≤∧d"Q)$aeH0z⊂)∃h#bi∀P∧i2N⊂*4fZw3P!→w1t6Xy0
Date: 6 Apr !dpb@Dβ→A]⊗-~P$(h M⎇,H∩λX∀R0i4_8
RUTGERS
Subbe@
htA⊗)`∩¬M→VNvtλλL]Xz≠,≡X¬P⊂λ∧¬∃)<pA%!≤AChAM*Sβ∩4⊃∪@9m∪↔C3JjS-i¬K?WI∧¬V/∨<≤v*ε|dβ"l≤λ EW ( &@_→⊗bThεEεBαI transl@¬iKHAe←kdAα∪↔;∂FkπK4λ
t∀Ku(9(∪∩.x⊂∞ The @=]YbAαs?97|∧'6N|X aQ]_ 0[9v0z~ww⊂ 7as due to the Fact @QQChAαK9αI⎇*ε%αdK@∨α¬ ↔4~;@⊂_v6⊂&~yx⊂_K≠αE $era`-¬iSmKβ→%βSF+K∃β≤∧⊗rε⎇mGJε,Tβ*ε≤,w.n]nG4≥≠h ={<∩-L9λ⊂∪≥w1z4[w9WεB!3p∩tunately the a`%≥k[K]Q`
β -K?;⊃¬##∃↓'#!β←-∪∃βπe;πgM∧r&!βLqβg∨αZ"ε≡≤8 %A ¬1gH$P5 5qt e@1S[C]¬iKHAβ##↔∃p↓↓"I⎇*ε%αd¬↔>λ~_.∀In ELisp We will usE a p@I←i←G=XAiQ¬hAI←∃`
β;|ε@hVα_=LT≥~~.P897X42v@.) Note that tota`_Aβ∪W;SL¬V/~ ≡&*π=H
,@t:6,H12z:→y⊂:4_w
RP@∞OF↓≠βπ→αK@∨α∞M⊗nNβY|e@⊂⊂$7]p{2`2 i`∨@⊗)β >dλ
.D~8 P≤αp @;&K7* ≥f"εLX nP4yP⊃aP∞
I co@9P ↔∂'+C∃β&CπQβ&C'Mβ>K3 " ,Rπ≤∧p⊂@%GC@1∧¬v $⊃~0→\⊂897Yβrams sho@MJA←]1r~+∂∪'S#n+S'
∧¬⊗wXπv 6es s@5CYXAαK;@&\|W.hπ⊂⊂∪`af )pπ`Ao%YP⊃β∧ε&}≥8p∩H12z:→y
@
←@∪∃∧∧f␈∩∞8 ,≥≠λ⊂∀[8∧egep¬f@1∧∧'/"∞⎇⊗f@λ~_.l(≥≠d Xπp_↓C]HAβ+; |ε⊂≥42v@ when↓` ↔SαX Mm8π3FB397`- functigns h∂dAββWSSL¬f 4≥~→-T~;]
t→_= ∀≤⎇≤N\⎇→0→→yP @
CkgSαs⊂~εl≡7&/!Q'.αs:4[p¬ but mo@IJA∂ε↓iS@7*qαS#*β⊂⊗O,8
∧ x;⊂⊗λ4yP'≠P24`&d¬KeK9hAiQ¬\A←I!Kef~)EKGCUc@∃βL¬b¬∩zX4J∧β~0→\⊂:42\2P4`3 j`≡Aα WS?n S↔⊃∧∧WGε≥n6N}e`λ∧
y(∩ ≤α⊂:7CE2|8≠4qt`4ly e@aaC@; ∧ε .Y9(∞z7q0Yp¬ by 50K↓EKM←β∪∃βKαX Mm8π3@.
~∃∃YSg`QKqi∃]IKHαβπ&L∧Y.ytw3H&4yh
P27`%pεA]←β!βg↔ ∧εF∂lTε
ε=x .
9→0→ αλ
*&C↔K↔4¬w,(≤sm\αP7`& the pπsgi∃ZAMkαs∂S'|sE↓ Uf*R XTl∀X∧@⊗λ!`b)
P0p∩e running
inteRpreted. This slh∂of↓iQS]≥bAI←]\A]←β#'∂π⊗ce 2∧
Fzε|X
∧ 8π⊂ )dea Od∧AQ←\~∃ Y%`∂AβLε2ε>⎇→f 4≥≠h∞⎇|Z`⊂≠zz⊗⊂∩P1w`-pareD it @]SiPA∧AG←AdAP∨→¬⊃>@,9∀∧fO>∧εNpβ"P≠Z4qt≥42P)XvrP &unctions Are being @%]aKeAeKiK⊂X@A↔QQJAi∃[aiCQS←\A%` 4+?∪↔πQ∧εFzπ=_ .
≤(⊂⊃[p2P*~2yrP≥44w3\β in↓CggKαk #E∧cπ;∨, ↔¬1¬≠';∂*βS#↔⊗)βπK(h#K↔∞c3eβ|¬fgJ ⊂λ @2{P !t thipεAa←αK;Ad∧∧F@⎇y=L↑H∩(∞⎇8ε6⊂_z:2f\8⊂:7H92y`)pπhAi!Sf~∃β#↔7C& S'∨pβπ;⊃∧∧6}wM→g.(≥≠d {{< ≡Y(⊃-M<|λ∞⎇=~∞M~8h∞prtVZw:2i≤92z2Yε@
R∂UCA Lisp.] ElIqp uSes dynaei@ AKqa¬]gS←8ACMHαβ∂?;'∪π∂SL{9β?2β7.β;p→≡U
Howevep∧AiQ∃eJASβ→β+≥∧∧↔πε≡,Vw" M⊗&6↑,Vv≡Tλ&/'|XVrπM Rε6≡.7"πM≥V*ε≥l@hVβy~ ↑H≥~-\αyP∀≤7yytX68P "ecau@MJA[K5←erAαCπMβ≤{;SK∞≠S↔⊃¬#=β''→β';LεFN∞AQ'∨&≡LRε↔∀
FF* X LE+C"AQQ;⊂∀\βp:
interpreted: 20.∃ E-bkx Time, as uSe` by RPG 20.⊃ sec.)
R/UCI Lis@@@QoSQPAiQ∀AgC[∀AMk]
iSO]LAS]i∃` CK-#↔↓¬Ph!↓βLsS↔Kαλ L↑→9≥λ⊂→Q.4λ
∧~)'↑A αc'OA∧K@~αα_<d∞αyz`[∀P0@ pπ[CYαaβπ↔|εVwα hλ.>→<@∞M_;@
%u0r$ ~<p_ ⊂⊂*4~yFE 3u`∂OKMifAi!ChABαβ⊂≡}|@λ∞∞Y9~,>~;p↔λ33q the @→S]CX↓mKe@≤¬⊗}r
x Dλ8ε4i\⊂4qP X∧
@MKFLAαK;@&↑.π⊗/LX ¬Dλ∩( ≥(≠[nD≤Y0,O(≥≠d
8:y$∞≤Y0∩~qz4g[9P3'\α ElIpπ`AGα{7C'd∧V H,8 lL+λ⊂.∀≥y( M{I⎇∧
{[p≠H47{P≥42P8_qry⊂≤αefi@1XAae=EQKZαβ'Mβ>{';≥¬#=βπ4∧f.∨AQ&O"d∧∧oJ }V/∨4
↔4≥~_.D~=∞⎇8ε6⊂_2P9v~st:6≡P9v']ry⊂ 4ha`≤AH← ⊗∞Jα3'Oαaβ←'&@4+Od¬w>&}⎇bε'\Tπ&@h≤⊂,|αy⊂ 2ebalLpε@@#4ε&}j X∞∞L9Y→,D_9→∞,<|r-lj(⊂→[vr{t_z⊂7`&d¬gKh4⊃ErAβ##∃β⊗+S@&↑ ε≡}LTε.8π2`2ated↓ErA β#π!∨~β∂?7∧K3↔Iph (αS[nL(≥~ ≡λ∩(
m|[8-M≤∧P 2epobt "fo@I[CHDαα≥¬Tλ
≥9+λ
m⎇λ⊃%\Yx tiee@LACfAUcCH~)ErA∃α≥)ααMε*∧U\&␈B∞M⊗n<h⊂≠Zv6⊂!→P77`4icably smalh Kd↓S\Ai!JAGCMJA←L↓ YSg@X⊂∀)∀πε.|≡&"πM Rπ∂<Tε}H⊃+,-|λ⊂~~vrP 7ith Elisp as p@I←EIK5CiSG¬XXAgαK;∂∃∧¬↔ @ ¬4`3 signibacAnpli pπ[CYαc↔Iβ&Cπ9β≤¬vw⊗]nFN}l≥B∧≥
Tπ&N\UBε/lX D∞z=~∧ελ≠⊂↔XpεE'[⊂:42H9|qj→vW⊂⊂∩P:44[5P:4~yP9d≠{yP*~0z⊂"Kq3t≥4rrP≠vtz9H9wvrH9wy:λ4πf
overhead That Elisp e` MKβ∪πS↔~aβCK|∪π ∪JβCπ∨,ε"π⊗\i⊗f@≤h
∞M≠x
cZ⊂:42CE27a]vrw:_z4wgλ9pt`3 that ref@%YP∪M∧ K∃βv{Qβ∂|εVwε\@
%@⊂⊂*`.tid @M←[K←9JAG←αs['≠≤∧W1"[9$
⎇~→.∞βtybK⊂ P 7ill Reca`%⊂AG←]YK]iS=]C@1∧~BUβ&K7* ≡2ε
,W'→<@
≥Y→0≤λ5sεE⊃v4y`0's l@=C@⊃β|¬bπ& Tπ∂O>LVj@Hλ∩$∞Y<∪n∞α⊂!h∃P:4vYyP;t]4⊂3 Zy60→ light (1 @Q↑@dR4⊃P∪?∞!βπ[-∪π>↑5`hPβ"K%U++#%Q"C"@↓AβX⊂⊗-Apr-`b@@dβ↓A\&∃α≥↓hRS=iα↓β3'≥βSKπw≠3πS|ε'4_8
SU-AI
Here'pεAiQ∀AeKC0AaS[%]NAgβ#W6e`∧∂~ ∀πε↑≥nF.α
x
.Eλ≥~ T≠{⊃∧
U3U →αbFE
8πhi@
PASF↓oQC@ ∧¬∃,hI∀l*
_ D 88s
≡|λ∩ ↑Y(⊃m≡Y<j$
<h⊃('l⊂ 4ime (excl@UIS@;8h#πMDεn8εw`2y tiMe). Also, AH∂ ∧J2*∞Mε*εnX L>~;sN5β⊂"4→P4w4]4pv⊂≤8sεE≠w⊂!`Rf⊂27YyP6p[<P!gT P ∃UMs _Aβ;#'∂BβπK∃π≠?7∃πβπ>Tλ7,8=~-⎇H≤⎇∞\β3⊂'[⊂$j)K∧A1gH4z⊂ -ay run veRy slOwly.↓)QJAQ←iCX↓acMi%[@∃βF+K∃β∂!αNεLaβ'M∧;'[↔ph+ e∧ ∪∪'v9βS#*α≡∞RLj∃βπv!α↑RLj∃β↔w#C'↔~β ↔3⎇90∩Q!PE&
~2ππ-xwε∞β(∩.P42g_ps7i≥4⊂1`[42r: ``@'¬∪⊂AGα{;OS⊗ ';Q∧∧6}n-→f∂&}-⊗∞b∞λ⊗O⊗≥lphW∞-v >X;!dt≠|@
8pp∀¬A ¬∧DBTy0 '-
αRULTIME 9 EBLπ0Ai%[B4U:R&6*↓uα⊗∀za↓↓Xβ7.β;p→≡P:4fYP⊂λapprgh8R~∧~(djrd∩∩αw9k[EKβ⊃β >d
ε∞O-→f/_Q%¬∃,jI∀l*∧⊂ G⊗L*(↓↔q0Sk∧≥~;,T~;@∞pqwg→9FE∀⊃aj$fQP→≤W∞XZ∀Pα]caj∩dbP$[⊂9rq[w21FB∀+j$SbP→5.86)3333) ;EBOX + MEMORY time in seconds
2592
(RUNTIME 1.903)
(@∂π)%≠
@dαqQEYJ4)"="&&∃β)9MM ¬∩h!Q#∪+⊗$hRλ*Tu$→XRβ∩fεβBJ↓Q"D≤8I∀l*ε FF*(β!¬∃u∩)X(
+FW, εε j(↓Q@εE→
\Y⊂εB∀)*g∃$fbP Tε159)
(GCTIME 2.@hjR@4⊂Q/)%≠
@J8pl`!≠→MMQJ4(Q&#+K$↓PBE*Ye$LXTβ
@L∧X~
PεE∀⊃aj$fQP_W921)
λ(WTIME %.10 dfLff@%h ( `@lλ @-Apr-`b@@`ddh∪%A∞@@∪IkYKf@@@~))Vt@AP∪'≥βS']_ L@P0p∀↓' ∃6 I↓↓hR%β#∂3∃βO,¬g"ε|¬0~λ842P→αir`'β!β ↔v≠# .≤-2bε≥lBε∞β_ 2Xp∧p∩Aβ##↔K*βπK∃∧∧∩ε@];8L↑@εE /d∧ASGβ≠W/4λ
=λ⊂↔→p¬d @Q↑AEJ↓H π∂,∧B`$⊃Z0→≤βt i@LA`∪#∂!βO?n)βO@≤∧p~→vyP∀∀`df⊗βE37`2 i`≥gQC]GJ$AP∨;dπ∩π⊗]H
,≤Xε0→ p¬Ka←β∪Qα⊗∀zaβSL¬V*αα→0≤_v:r4[3P6r[wy0→
λ¬`∪'n)% 2λh n8∧unate`→@JαNε&bβ∪ >↑4εn∞αy( ≡X:0⊗_q0 e pπ←[J↓H ?-Pλ
|β⊂"a∪βX +↓≠¬∨04⊂ @&≥\RbπM
w.zλ⊂∀]⊂4qP≥w92`0ph∂I@,∧6N⊗β→+D
z→0↔λ87p∪Sib`→J↓∩AoC9hAi↑↓`∂.Tλ
(≠;nzεE )nf`∨@⊗kπS'|¬bπNβx
P_pp∞ @≥SmJAαk∃β←LεFBε≤4εn∞o∀ε&O>M⊗v∨M_ mnh_<d∞≠xtm≤Y→+D 9H⊂≤[zyεE≤βystem can gif@∀ABAEIKC@/&{←9β|∧bε@9;;n<P92Y2y2g_pyV⊂_pqt2H8πri@QJP↔SG∪?W∨@∧π&Nβ9+↓Q\_9lT→X=-Nα⊂:4[p¬, E@¬∨0Aβ#'7∃bq19β∧¬F.∂<Tε ==Y(
\αP:4_z⊂∞ Whe`≤A$AgK]⊂AWkh↓iQJ~)EKMGαC7πK←→α%βL¬f≡g\LRπε T¬≤ →Dπ&Nβ90→H9wP 4hat @e←jAGα 9β∨,εBπ≡⎇\RεNLXλ$
βs⊂ (ow
@1←]NAαKQβπd¬Bπ_:y.∃β⊂# 2om now on↓∩AoSαc1βC⊗{['∪*α⊗
>@βS'\UB∧0Sv∧¬h∪0I@l⊂:4[p¬,
and GAP &l)0∩∧,X6∂/<T∧Jε⎇mGJπ∞-w6NLTπ&F≤@λ MβryP≠4πt @5KCLAβ##πQ∧¬↔4_;⊂⊗λ$P;p[8∧ to
se@∀Xλ$!Q%≡f≤⎇π&gα(⊂⊗[y2P )mportantlY is The i@MgkJA=H ββ≤¬ε.∂M→f*:d ⊗ $≥~→$∞{y4L<<h⊂↔Yα
@ K]GQ5Ce@/~β←'O@∧π&@h_;
Mβ{P 3peci@¬YSuCQS←]f↓←@→β&C↔'I∧επε@yx 0[yP:7H:42P≥2yz→0z0FβE:42↑P9t7]v2⊂ -ake @IK[Ce-`
βSzβS#π ∧ε.⊗lXλnEH∩0∪λ9wvr[w2P #ares th∞A[¬S@∃β≥+∂!hS@∨ε\8
,≥~:P.M8πw9H:42`9 h kgβ!β ∃∧∧6f.≡,V"ε-∀π&FTλ↔/&
x D 8π2 m`
\AQQSfAαK@≡r|¬⊂_2qpz\β`
4TIβ &≥<RπεtλλLT~;@⊂_ww:9≠v⊂9`/ h kGαAβπM∧Iβ@>≥nBπεtλ
-l→<\nL8π2 wha`(αβ'Mβ⊗+';≥∧∧v∞NβY0∩βE14P≥42P)\2qt`!lization @¬]HAo!ChAMα+πSW⊗+@~ε|dπ&FTλ
≡Yy0~λ& ihλ4purH9zq`( α`'ββ↔∂'∞c'kπ&K?;M∧s↔∂↔≥≠πKe∧∧⊗v"⎇z"ε&↑9↔,8[⊂∩Kα ∀~)
WdAα+cπ↑
F*B
_ D∞~→( @4y9`4 benchiark sevEp¬C@1∧¬v $≥~→$ ];XnM9{\d <Y(
≥<≠⊂∀Xtz⊂εB&"d(∀9R⊂ 7hichin MacHic@@ASKC9`
βSF QβSF+C∃β∂∪∃β7|ε&*πM ⊗rβTλ↔⊗?]\Vwπ5`λ
M~8 FB4¬eanpεAiQ¬hAiQ∀ACeOU[C@;'→βπK*βCπO≤∧V"ε⎇`λ∞M→(∀nL8z`⊂≤αathep∧AiQ¬\AiQI←kOPαβ@⊗.⎇_ nL<X WβE)t`.ca this tak` fAαc?;∨,ε"πε ≥bπε Tπε.⎇~7&/$λλm⎇]Y0↔≥4p∂nQS@9∧εFFO4λλl≡y*( ∀≥x;ND≥~_.A 0'-Apr-_1 1∪23 JONL at MIT-MC (Jon L TπQSi∀R@∪!I←a←g∃H@NO5S]RNα9β ↔v≠#7π⊗Y1β←M#!β'w#↔KC⊗+SπSL{99hR∪πS+Q↓↓]∧
BI↓λπ∪C
∧⊂
F⊗+14jA QTM⎇.H∩Iyβ&⊂ ]⊂&dj daP∀∩7w⊂&λ+t4z→T@
Subject: P@I←a←g∃H@E[%]RDAα∪↔;∂FkπK5Dπ>OMεNwLZ'π⊗↑L↔&N⎇a`hUMw"εf≡:π&N]_ Lt_9⊂∀jV`dCE
It hardlq Seems appropriate to rqf timing testpεAoSQQWkh↓S]GYUIS]Nαβ¬β←␈∪⊂4+⎇⊃βS←zβπ ?/!βS#*β∪'O≥+OO'}qβ3π∨!β≠πfaβ←#L≠!β∨.s↔Kπ&+⊃↓#L¬b∧n≡=⊗w&↑$w~π⎇}&'~∀↓PW≡t
W.≡∧
V␈⊗T∧&F.≡D"π⊗≡Mε/∩∞Mε∞r∧-FN>∞D"bεl≥V.g∀λ
(⊃⊂)4→];L>~;sD∞y;]∧
>(∃l∨(β"M≥H∀q.∞→;8L↑Hλ ≤N_⊂1<H&y↔ Shigeii Goth∞A←α1βS#*α↔3↔≤εFN≡≥D∧≡}]↑VvN<≡FN}d↓PTf≤-wε∂M}&N∂5D∧vO∞ vr¬L]F.?,≡εBε≥lB¬&]H .
≠{Y$λ{kC∧
;H∃
⎇|∧wWβE
(DEFUN @)¬⊗@Q0↓2A4R4∀∩Qπ=≥⊃↓BB≡J⊗
"⊗JA¬Aαe$hP%↓↓α↓↓↓↓E"ε-↓E"ε-↓E~V E¬A%αe¬Q%4PH%↓↓α↓"RεZ↓"NV∪ αe%¬Qαa$hP$%↓α↓↓"R Y↓"NαX#
¬%∀¬B¬∃∀αJHQ!∩αα∧∧ααED ∩Jα∃⊃PRα
Mε*πL↑7"ε<≡6*b
l⊗n.D
D
∀→∃S"b
≡2π&t V.∂>↑&*πM Rπ&≥]⊗v:
|bαEH→2β"ε$βαHQ!PU& Tπ6∞N\Rε}d∞FFO4∞GεOm_⊗bεn]f∨&≥⎇bε≡≥`ε⊗*∞<V.rD f␈"
≥bε
9voε↑M↔&N⎇aPF⊗↑Nv..d
FO∨∞4ε6←$∧'∨ε\X ∧%λ≠[n⊂4w⊂_P⊂1g[22vw_z4wwλ5s⊂'[2P24Xv2q`4 for
the "kl@UIOKfλAoQS
PA[kMhAEJ↓aKeM=aSKH↓S\A←β∪∪↔I∧εFzε|ZBπ∨\9αε
∞N&O6≤≥@hWM
⊗v:∞Mrπ↔]`πε.≡=vv∞-O∩ε6≡>Bbε.X
∧∞X=~ ↑H~0↔λ:42P_w0v<\tyP7Yα the basIc
issues which trying to time it Brkught out, After @IKGKSβ3';≥εkπ;eπ∪↔OC}sO↔Mh+≠K}iβπK␈+;⊃β&C∃β∂|k7W;M#e!↓∧Iβ7πNc↔⊃β⎇+Qβ¬∧s?S∃εK9β←FK∂!β> Mβ∪O≠∂WO≡+⊂4 >CπQαJβS#?.;#Qβ>+K∃β≡{7¬β4εVv&≥\Vw&≥DεO∨>XW5λ_;LD⊂)y∧
~:y$∞≠h⊂→Yw2⊂*~0zεE≠7z2P≥4π this group For c@=]gSI∃aCiS=\\@AQQJA←β∪'∨'v 1β;⎇#∃β≠⊗{5α↔∩qα∨?&yβπ≠ 4+¬∧c↔;∨&CeβO-∪'πM∧{⊂∩ε=yVo.m_λl≡~;{N4_8[n↑λ≥~ T≥~;-≥Y|h Mβy⊂$~yP:2\z⊂1`\rV⊂εB2yx"Xtpv6≡P397[P82g\4∧e in the Ifterh Sg@AG←[5k]SidXASf↓S\Ai!JAMS1J@~∀A∃∨≥0w∂∨)<A≥∨)∀~∃O\↓iQJA5∪(@6l→β7π≡C';∃ph(4 αα∪πS+Q↓II∧{∂S?⊗+I↓EKAA↓E QAa6,"P4)αα≠K?kQα+?pα1α←FKS∃↓dR>*1∧ Qα6M!66
βaPRαλ:V⊗V\>C@$∀Y4n
{\q$∞≠h⊃m}≠i|d
~<t∧∞~;:-l|c"D∧∃≠nD¬Hλ D∧ Hβ!∧λλλ∧∧⊂<h L<X <H&pqd[82y≠pp∞tionedin hipεAG←αk7πnDε}r∞Mε*∧⎇x
q Hλ∞M9:0↔→yP @
←[aCISg←]LAEKi]KC@9∧b&NC~βπK∃∧¬FN↑]H∞$∞≠h⊂∪Yw2y0]2PεEλ⊂6wi→P42`!t than liGht; bqt @QQJAe∃aYSKLAISH↓iQe←β9β¬βd¬↔'≠→#!$λ≠;n (≠⊂∀Yβht @=\Ag←5JAiQ%]OfX↓KgaK
SCYYdAiQJ↓a`↔;&K7*∞l↔⊗N≤-⊗fOM≤W1"Hλ
|H_;D ;]→.-α4qxλ897s\0p
, and I thoueht I'` sUmmarize them
and pas@LAiQK4ACI←9JAi↑↓iQJA=` '∨Lsπ1β⊗+∂'CL∧Vwπ4
v $≥~→$
Xπr2K∧¬∀@↓⊃P∨←-3↔I1∧I∨↓βd¬⊗N(≥≠d∞x:(∞M_9⊂≥42P#Yw2y0[⊂1w`.carn↓oSiPαβ@∨ε\X ∧↓ ¬⊂⊂≥t4q`( I'`-α)↓β↔v≠?W≠&+C⊃βL¬bπε Tπε∂>@λ
<h⊂L\αs⊂ "etwe@∃\A7∞~2&Nαβπ;⊃h ∩αλiu∃%(→bbπ,≡FF/$λ
8π⊂ 7ith Some @=iQKdαβ3'OβY↓βπv!βO↔4∧W,8ε⊂%_x0w2\p¬
re@MKCeG AP∪π↔→β#π4∧Rε&⎇lR∧ ∀λ L↑y8<L=λ≤p~~v6⊂ )n FORTRAN8@@~∀@@@@↓∃cghαβ'9β≤∧↔∞(≡3nT|Y(∞∞αz⊂ /d¬LAEdAQ←←α[';≥∧∧↔"ε↑h -d≠;p→→P6r`!ni`≥O1Kgf~(@Agi¬iSgi%Gf@1∧I∨" ≥G=h≠∩-p¬ to apriq`
As=jAiQ¬hAM←αc3 ?⎇→f*πM RεF≡NFf*↓Q"απ>YVn∂-∀εO~ ⊂λ .X91D∞→8p∀≠4qpvλ24ya]yyt`/n of thre@∀AeKY∃mC@; βC/'w#@~Q$αε&≡86f@|y0∩λ1<P 4he @)¬⊗AMk9GiS←8@Q←KPAP∨→∧εFF*
\⊗wJ∞λ nytq6→P87`)nts At
shi@
PAi↑↓YP∨?X¬∩`$λ⊃~ ↑y(⊂~→qt74Xpp @A←S@;'→β .≥∀ε⊗*
lW:πMtπ={9(
|β⊂<`/u(λ@~(@AC]⊂AKmKαqβ ↔L¬vv"∞Mε*∧β∩4j∧≤90∩\βtio@8As@?αTεn∂∀λ M≥Yλ⊂~~2p
UpπCMkαa`~πM Rε↑←∀hR∧λ
m}Y≤h ≡Y(
ε∃(⊂
jSd NKS(λ@Pβ⊃%αWvK⊂⊗@|[ ⊂⊃$hλNUM rePpese@9iCiS=\XAC9H@~∀@PfR↓βki←5CiSF↓S]IK
iSO\αβ?→βF+3C≠,¬Bε@];9.4qP"→qv0y_z4wg≤P14P_P1w`-pideR,∧∩(hQ↓↓↓α↓απ3n{OQβ-3↔Kg|s∃β≠∞k'3'∂⊃β←'&Aα'≠&+C &≤8 ∧∞Y8sl@w0⎇ %d that
∀@↓iQJA∃β⊂⊃β∧+?C3*β#π⊃∧¬f␈"∞,W∂.↑:F.α∧,&f↑=0λD {{<
≥_=~-⎇H~0↔λ:42P∃ i dKZεE⊂λ2|0v\42V⊂_w2⊂)Y{2y0[⊂82`2pπ←]f↓gkaa1SKHAβ∪↔OWe#@~εn-vjπl≡&N␈↑1PBαε"α{L |d <[u-l∞C"A⊃ ∧DPλ⊂22s_zr: compIlatiOn rewr`∪@'#↔9β≤¬v&*D
vO&↓Q Jε=x N2yx /ndent ↓ tiei@9H∂MHK #?≤Y7∂?oβ'3↔ ∧π&Nβ:0↔→FE⊂⊂λ⊂⊂"0]2Y⊂_NP ∂CT 10∩p@@dbdβ96B∩ H%↓↓Jqc /1⊃∩αα∧ε∩cF↑1PRα∧∧∧7⊗⎇S"∧l~9∀e$Z ε∂"λλ∃∀~β30+λlC"D∧λλλλL=→.DεLλ∪l>λ ≤N_⊂⊂@039-PDT ↓ 10 ][L∩∩@@@d][L~∀@@A¬e←4tAπ'⊂]↓ α↓ChAπT['π∨I
@A =k@≥α∂βC↔3 ¬⊂hR∧∧αα∧L≡F+R∧ ∧ x⎇λε↔,∧⊂⊂_z⊂→→
[Rab∃∧P⊂⊂ ↔≤→f\P⊂⊂⊂
37y∃a`f$Th⊂7w≠<TFEλ⊂⊂⊂#≤4πm: tyso@8AChAU) 1βLZbb@4∀@@@yπ←i<OfA←ISOS]¬XAiS5S]Of↓←\A∪
∪⊃&≥↓y↓↓α↓↓I9NkL4)α↓↓↓r>{S :}4ε␈⊗≤⎇⊗v∞D
FNn≥lw
ε⎇d∧NwL↑&fO>πbαβ⊗Ucεo1Q"αα∧πFoO<X Eλ→[n⊂"pqS$ih⊂≠w⊂→0/0
`R$@@@`8jjm[L~∀4R↓αS#-∪∃βO,∧Vo~∞Mrε⊗T
6}nT
Vv/∞
F∞NβY0∩λ24ya\2x0w_|P12]8πee@8A)cgα{9∂M∧εFNn≥lrHαHλ ≥Yλ⊂~~0z⊂ /d∧A∂←β#=!β∂→β@>]H ∧ <h⊂L↑≥y1-d⊂εpyZw:2i yP0w→⊂ p(→v:∪yH22s !ult-
λ c@=[aSYα S'∨pβS'↔L¬f/≠4λ'/"∞Mε*α,,W∂"↑ w>z8[ TH∩3NL<[⊂∀\βp timi`≥OLAMOd4⊂@ABαβ@⊗*↑}&O'LYbε7]l7&N⎇`αG⊗↑ F∞≡≥lr∧≥(X∃$-*∧ε↔J _u∀ ~HU∃α∀λλ-lλ≥4m≥Yc"D∧≥~→$∧\Z9m∞λH⊂⊃≠5qu@ declApati@=]fAgα+↔5β≤¬vw≡≤:F.wDλλ.D_<[n]Yλ M↑hπ⊂⊂∩w22`%d,
as Shh∂gi¬GVAgβ+↔>↑8
∧
9H∩
≡h≠[nL(≠p∪λ⊃→_⊂∪βct 1980 1036-PDT" @QQKeJ↓Sf~∀AckSβ#∃β¬∧∧&O"
x D∞β0q4Xq0 i@QrAS\αβS']_ L@P nter`→Sβ≠Aβ≠,¬f∨&≥yg4→→0_→w24`.dεA←\4⊂ ↓βTεW∂"∞Mε*π-_ m∞α⊂9b]⊂7s⊂→2qv !p¬CiSα{;Mβ-#
↓ X
L]H→P↔\α su@
PABAβ≠'7Cd∧Rε7]l7&N⎇`
%@∧¬∀@@@@A∧Aa←SαsQβ←FK∂!Dλ
}y=P∩\α, s@∃K[fAβ#=β *β7'O≤∧V"ε≤4π&F≤@λ∞M→(∪M}~;p↔λ4πf
"block"↓G←[a%YCiSα{9βK- W'K,ε2ε
LV≡O=_ md_9⊂_wvx4[2Vz4[p¬ as po @]QCh@4⊂@AW%]HA←α1β≠Wv≠S'∨pk3'≠↑ ↔*∞⎇w.fDλλLT→→0→Zy0q6→P⊂λI pres@U[@∃β&CπQβ≥βπ> X
∞M+#"D∧≤⎇_,=h≠8-≥]_:-l8π1`% is @QQJAo=` OQ∧¬v ,Y;Y ↑H~0↔λ9:w:~vrP 3lh∂oI=o\AQ∃` ∃%Xh ∩α /∩ε≡⎇↑ε∂⊗α8 `/n, the de@
SgS←αqβ ↔';↔πdλ L≡⎇λ⊂⊂[2⊂9`,ow f@U]GiSα{9β3L¬f@<9y#!⊂⊂4`. MacLISP @%`
β7∞#∃β∪β_ L≥8∧q`!lh `%∧∧↔"π,¬0↔≥4p
e, so @QQChAα{; 'α(⊂↔[2P5t[2⊂7`&
@
←[aSαcπS'|¬bε⊗Tλ L\αr2`$,∧@A∪αs∪↔↔ ¬Bε↔∀λ M}λ_]. →;Z-lh≥~ T≠[p≠~qrP 7ith @QQJ4R↓β@.βY→.9z0w→4p∞g↓←@→βL∧W"ε⎇lRεNβx 2H4s9q\αp iC YJAGα{7C'd S'∨p∧π∂.↑8
≥{C"D∧λ∧⊃1≠4πckλA`≠↔↔≠WMβ>CπQ⎇JaβC#*β;/[L∧6*εlX ,Mβ∪p∀↓EJAk9Ic@3β∀πε.βX;
∨Y9⊂→αh∂d~(@A]←β!β ↔≤¬vnNβY`⊂_P⊃40Xury"8εAiQ∀ACE←YJAiS5S]OF↓`∂#?8∧ε
π X L≥≥~(
|β⊂0@ d¬CGi=` 4R↓β ↔';↔.βH
$ 8π2 10 f@=` β'>s?K≥lrbε|∧@∞]Y→0→ zz4`,iz`∪]≤XAiQ∀@EEYα{∂- ∧ε↔.<⎇~-⎇KHλ↓Q@εEεBα (DRA+,z2&:]→` (αHλ∧∧λλ∃
(→P↔[4∧owing s@Q` πS,∧wJ@λ≥z
≤zλ⊂≠YP1pv≠⊂:42H*jgf∩dεKS hack0AP↔πJβ#π[*4)↓∧∧fO↔>@λ ,9;@⊂~w:0∩odqce@⊂AS@;&yβC#*β?3⊃∧b&NAβ 0∪3αHλ↓QHλλ∧∧λ⊂<L@zp
e@9ifACIJAgKβ!β@/∧λ M}H≤⊂⊂\βsing po @∧AMk]
iSO\αβπ;⊃∧∧⊗rε≥n7'↔\8
≥{Hβ!↓(λ⊂∀[⊂0P 3peci@¬YQ`%nkπ;π>+⊃β#∂≠!βS∞∪3∃βLε2¬D8@ lE@εE⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂∩w⊂1`!q`
ABαβ⊂⊗∂>@λ
M9Z`⊂~yP0qXpx:0X4∧e, the @→SeghαβWOπ>)β/→∧εFFO4 FNv=_ Lq B(∧∞z;∪∧ {{]L↑]λ⊂~~2P40\t⊂2g≥9<P*≠P0P(∃i`%⊂∀⊗∪↔πλ⊂⊗V@λ4s⊂'≠zεE∧H⊂0qaYx:0q≠2V⊂ )t wiLl remai`≤A∧AgY←\AS]i∃aaeKQSmJAI←kiJ8~∀@@@@A)]↑AG←ββ'↔Mε{⊂∩πM RεF≤8
¬↑_8[ T_8Y$
y<∃∧¬+(∪ml(~0→H⊂72k→y⊂0v≥2y2bλ1<FEαP⊂:4→P64w~p¬r, qo that at a`≥r↓KSmKαqβC?LsQβ'pβS'7er" -- do@∃`
β;|εBε@→8=LT≠=8m∧→→0N\βst`.dεAQKαcAβ3LK;≥β∂∪?WlAPBα
x D∞~→(∞z0qeNβ a`(αβ3↔π≥!β←'&AβS#Lε2¬-YyDL@Rth ≡≤≤[l≤z λ
⎇Y(⊂⊃Xw⊂6pZpP:4→FA⊂⊂→2qt`3ion Whide in the mi@⊃IP∪∃∧{⊂∩ε∀λ \]9ym≥Yh∀l↑|z0↔[⊗⊂;t]47zzλ82w0[:8 .
λ The tiMe coSt of using the qlow lifkaga sEems To be a facth∂dAα{⊂∩ε,X
∞|9;C!∧λλ@⊂_w2⊂~K∧@
(" Ufi@→←e@5∧2&b~αYRπ⊗↑λ L↑y;] ≡~;sAQHλλ∧∧λ∪8-o(≡0∩Xy9P YwP;rH1t0w→p¬d Mac@→∪M @∨M∧ε&/π,Z6.wL≡FN}d v $⊃R6 J3(∀mq Hλ∞M_9⊂~z⊂;w]v2⊂ "e unid¬P∨Khπ2απ]mFN↑Tλ
(≠p~~2y⊂(⊃(_X⊂≠4yx 3 sith shi@
PAα~(@ACZ↓H π]_
≤<Kλ∞|(→≠d
Xπr code pπ←[J↓H 'cw+7M↓G≠7π∪bβ?;↔~IβπMα∪'7↔,∧FN∂LT"HαHλ∞
z;] ↑\h⊂-lλ≠p~~2y0∪ (h C@⊗;↔Iβ|¬f/~α(⊂⊂\β addpess@∃`
2∧λ⊗g≡uDπ&F↑,RεO4λλ!QHλ⊂→→pr⊗w[48 @AC@∨∃∧¬w$≥→{d∞z~0⊃Z⊂⊃1`!ches" f`∪Q9kZAmα 3@.↑4ε}H_8M}=λ &6 @⊂≥4π
+6 @X 1β≤¬rπ~_=∧
β:vq→y⊂1`/nsing h∂LAβ≠7πMDεw8εq2\αs won ∂hAα ∂SW∞c3eβ⊗) (αHλ ≥≠≠p⊃Xz4w3H4εew↓G@↔MH gP2W3Kα interpreti`≥Nαβ¬β≠|ε&jεM_
lTβ"B$∧λ∧"'H$P⊂⊂ (ADDDA∩R@!∂% βQ % A$@b`@αq%↓e` E⊃ ¬⊂⊂⊂v:47]pπh I p ←←αYβ¬βd¬w"ε|dε -α0u@ d¬P∨I∧∧fg<z~-lh≥~ T⊂∧g*SP9q`(eme @%\AMCY←d4R↓β >dλ
(≥0↔~pε`∨e4AgGQ∃[@∃1∧∧6}w=_ ↑H≥~ T_9≥L≥]_9lT→[p→λ1wvx~v0p∀ion s@Q` πS,∧wJ@β"H∧ <h⊂→Yp¬`≤AαK9βSF+@≡(≤Y.∞Y<p∩[8∧a`)%mJAGα{∪∃β≤∧W∂.]l6/~ h n⊂⊂λIGR@ β)∃% A@∧¬JKαC"D∧λλ∩)@*fP 3cheme8∧∩&lzP∀(⊂ ⊗ YPλ@ $~∀$HI↓α*:α¬"β∃3H'lεEαD@ SAVE TT →@≤¬vn=z→.2@
MLπ ~∃∧ 15QE↓$4!⊃⊂Jα *5α¬EJT`(Svβ!∧@ CAME TT,@M←[Ko!KeJ~(∩∩%α↓0∩raQ"αα∧
VvNmx MT≤xp∀→vrP~ MH∂-
↓)(@2αiM"AHh ⊂Hα"(∧λp31$
∃ ⊂¬Vα⊂λ@ $~∀$HI↓↓e` AQ@εE⊂λ∀→TP⊂zz7`-atic ind`+α≠S'⎇`λ
|β⊂42[83:`, h
k[∃` '
∧∧F.≡L≡&∂&≥x NP10→ a co@5aS@3,ε"`!α@
ApεA7∂≠';S,ε"ε∞βY⊂⊂αh∂`',ε"πε⎇_ NL9λ⊂↔]z⊂ @5←ghA%]`∪↔⊗c'OA∧επ-βsp∩ammers ∀@↓o←kYα!βCK|∧&∞⊗β_ P_2P:`3ing "IGREAT@ % λAeCI!KdAi!C\@E≥%⊗ε$*JA αCS#∃∧kπ∞I~5αQ$αε≡|∧\L↑|≠p↔→2s: is "p@ ↓∃`λ∧λ]=⊂_P1w`-pi`→Kβ⊃β∂πp∧ε∞≡>X .]_8
2H9z0z~qP4`.d¬P∨Kn S'⎇aP@$λ_;LD→≠h∞M~8 P_t0w3YP0p∃@Q←[C@&K∂πMH∞'P⊂0zλ842P≥2y4P≠2pp∪@PXASH↓G←kYα!β∨'4(4)↓∧¬w/"∞|↔-X∧w3H1t2`#hπfAgβ+∂!β∂→↓
≠d¬v∂&≥lroε⎇_ ND_8 3]vrw:λ8¬se@⊂AgSi A¬∪19+⊂∃7|¬fgHβ"H∧
|→0→_z4w`. . Pp¬P∨[L∧FNvtλ
(_p⊂\0q4`,itp∩Aα3?Iβ≤¬voε≥H %↑~;9$∞≤∧p⊂@%]NA←α1β@6≤-⊗∞⊗β→0→CE⊂⊂ )pεAae=ECEYβIβ@& Tε}vβ_ P≥p|P 4o me@∃hAiQ∀A~>∃"Jε9∧∧6F∞β≠⊂∩[3rP⊗KP;t4Xt⊂6z\z⊂12CE⊂⊂ -et s@%]GJAαkW∂!∧εW<αs:`, AI @IKgKCIGPA]∃K@∪M∧∧&␈&∧λ o≥8[p⊗~qP0w→⊂7:fYy0 c
λ∧@AGα Cπ L¬FO&≤X e@⊂⊂& !p¬erOLA≠β'Q %'π=!∃βLε2ε
∞h .<P9d[tp ar sobt h∂LAα WS?n S↔⊂hQ↓β'v#W∂SL¬vrπ<8
]9+C!⊂εEεBβ∧π10-Apr-`b@@@λεβ+λα2⊃(JR0rd =λ∀JZ⊃q4J4α4Y'∧∀Y0⊗→yP⊂⊂λ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ_X⊂ \9⊂⊂@981 "β→AE6-~P$
4ε&}k$ ∧,%)_4Zε≤¬⊂∀*j#bT)FE)]q12`#t: Be8∧A%Kαc↔M↓α↓ (αU≠g⊂)(#H0z⊂)UT¬AI
λ¬GF@Rβ3'O∧εFNnα;Yd =λ∀jU02#! 8π⊗i→x64VU5]⊂,[zy⊂ -essage of 5( β@∧ε"kC∀ε∪∪∪EXU≥Q!PD|5Dε↔∂Dλ∞-}(≥z-Mα⊂77]4qrP≥40r I was ad`'<AiQJ↓←]Ir↓aKeGα{9β←Fyβ∨?"βS#∀hSS#'v9β∪?v)β e∧εFF* LV∞≠~;LT≤∧wjH9x2aZq0rb ⊂⊂$`& p∂JA¬eJAO=S]NAβ#=β↔v!βG@hS∪?'v9β'πT¬w$_{p↔≥2y9`)ons For eAch teqt, @¬]HAMUaaQKI[←eJ↓SDAGα{;K↔↔≠'?;_h#πK*β⊂≡}≥lrπ&tλ
≡Y(⊂~≠P12P_x897]2r⊂ "y p∪←β)1βG|εRεN≥∀ε -8π2 d¬KoKβ⊃β@6β{∃-n→90→≤β
αdhan o@ISGS]¬YQ`%∧εεf∞β[Y,EH⊂
4→P92`\ww⊂ &or e@1S[C]¬iSMNαβS#∃∧+c@',⊂λ ≡Yxh∞|<c"M|H_p↔]y9rP≥40r tp e]%]NAi!JAiQ%]OfA%]i↑A1 1!⊂∧w
π⎇zVf" ,Rε
∞λλ-≥H~0↔λ:42FB4εec@,X@A)!SfASβ→β ↔≤∧↔/≡T ⊗r¬X9∩∧f≡:α∧dXε∀
$|h→
t≠[p~λ92s"\α to argu@5K]iF↓Er4T¬f∞nUDε↔∂Dλλ.∀λ∧ i⊃P8λ). A @
C\A←α∪['∨,ε6gJ∞}&O&T ∩ππ-xwε∞β(∃
t→≠h∞M~<k∧ ]=β!∞~_=∧∞x8h
m⎇λ⊂∪→pyt`"le i@8AiQJ↓C[←k9hA←L↓iSKJ↓∩AQC⊂AEKMα{C∃β&C∃β7,∧W&Nlp AQQ]4NM→<[-}Y+λ
≡λ≠⊂↔[urr th∞A[∀AYSW∀AiQJ↓H @.βXp~~ww9P≥40r had @5←eJAQQC@9β(4+π⊗;W7↔w#@~π|X LT≥<p∩Y⊂37`2 pre@ACe@'v9β@& Tε&∂L⊂ ∧ ]=⊂≥40r ondi PAIRS1
∃C9HA!β%%&dAβ;↔K∃∧∧⊗∨'\≥FgJ 8λ-Mα2r large h
k[ KefAα{⊂∩πM_ ,↑hπ⊂⊂∪4πw @QQChAβ##∀∀T¬↔>⎇9(
<h⊂⊃→pp∞ Bph∂kO!hAk`0A∩Ao%YP⊃β|∧bε≡|Z'<αP:2\z⊂&"V()∪yK⊂1:`4 wou@1H~+⊗)βOW↔βC'O,∧BεNd
FF/,TεO~ ≥gJε= ⊗v>T ⊗rπ ↑&&@|[8-ly+C!! Q0≠→w⊂4`& LEXPR#s Chafge the perfopiance, I am not suRe that is the right
say tk do the convep¬gS←8Ai↑AUπ∩A→%`∂Ad ↔"π⎇}Vf" ,Rπ6↑/∩π.n↑7.∞Dλ M}H_
Xp#"IM<|λ∞∞[y|L≥990→λ:7P*\pP0wλ&"d(∀⊂4w≠y22yλ:7P$_w262H6sy2H:40wλ~BE !rguments. They are noreally used fOp∧AS]⊃KMC]%iJACIOk[KαsSM⊃∧εvF.d
↔ @ ¬6pZpyP9Yw9rP≥4π numberthem8@AβL↓]C@7,∧Bπ⊗≡-⊗∞⊗LZ2ε∂,Tπ⊗/
Hλ,<9λ∃m≡~λ
λ~Qh %∃β"Jλ~Qh E∃α⊂↔↔ ⊗⊂:4~yP7a≥4wzi[<P6pZryP:~2P89≠sy0vH9wvr]t0r≠x0pzYW⊂⊂ [7z42\∧E87\ytq6→P6rj~7r⊂4\P:7P≠0vq2_Vq4w→⊂;0y~pq62\β to the required valqes and
refer to them globally. While this is less than Ideal, I claie that it
is better than (ARG n), Makifga list of the extra arguments is also
possible, but (CADR ARGS) is little better than (ARG 2).
¬
At this point we start having to asK what the pur`Osa oF this project
is& Ib iT is to seE how the dialects vary, Then I claim that noThing↓Sf~∃α ∂∂?oβ3'OF+⊃β Jβ≠ ?,9⊗v:∞↑2π&tλ6}wlX ND~;]
t_{p∩→P:40]⊂;rP≥wzv"λ77r~wαE &act wpite that↓oCrA%\AiQ∀AISC1KGh\↓∪hAg∃K[fAQ↑A[J↓iQChαβ'QβO→βC↔⊗3↔∂SgH4+∪.;'S'n S∃β4¬w$≠9(∞MβP9p↑P:40]⊂*adH&4yhλ9tvx≠<P27YyP77]⊂9zx≤7y:⊂⊃l(!β\FE3t]4⊂6w\2P:4_w⊂~P_y3z`-ents, andthat↓∩Ao←UYHAM%]HAg=[BA←β##↔I¬;πeβ&yβ∪<hS7eβ& O-aQ"jjUURjhQ!PT?-}Vv'.]F/~¬∞&/π-≡6*HQ)∩ε⊗]M⊗/6T∞FF∂D ↔"πM Rε␈↑N6/"
|bπ&
~2ππ-⎇&.∨D ∩π∨L≡F."∞⎇ε∂"
←∩ε>|≥G_h.|W⊗*D ⊗v"∞Mε*ε},F/∩
|bεN↑
w↔ε≥l6*rλ.W"∧∀
vNfD∞&.OL↑&∂&T∞FF.T ⊗wO|∨∪PhαC"F∃H∩(∞|;]λ∞MβP89≠{4r2H37y→pqt⊂≠pu7yλ:<x2H7x2y_z4wwλ∀;0y~pq62H67wu]x∩εE→8w1j~ww⊂1Xv6⊗↔ ↔∀P H92v0]4{2Vλ47x2Y:v6<H:7z0[⊗⊂7y→2y⊂'[⊂:42H;0y4[zyP&∩ih9FB0s2∪$ih⊂≤|yz2[yP0y≠zw2. I also hope that there is enouch standardized
timifgdacilities around to at Least gat @M←[JA%IKBA=HAiQ∀ACaaI←qS[¬iJ~∃α O?g+S∃β∨β↔↔∪~βπMβ>+3!aQ hS%`∧Jπ|≥g"πMtε&/LZ&nNβY+∧
><q-LKλ∃m =λ⊂~~2P8zXv4z0]4{2P→4s3"\2w1`%pεAEKQoKK\4∃`∪#*β[πKL{WMαdJNAβ≥KOS↔o→βπK␈+;⊃β∂∪∃)αJβ#?C*βS : Mrπ&
~2ε↔∀λ
l≡_z~-lh~≠nt≥X<M≥⎇<c!.≤[yn,8εyP_w2⊂![w9z9≥qz9P_y2P4_w262Y⊂1<P≥42P:≤αafslators. Addirs@PA∩AQ=aKH~)iQChαβS#∃εββ@',≥g∞f≤Mw$≥[s∞]]→9.9SS@≥wzv"λ12P5≥yz⊂*~0z⊗⊂_:z⊂ .ow it see@5bA$hS←'∪bβ;↔↔ βS-β&yβ7∨≤εBε↑d
FF*∞N&∞w=Hλ.M9{\d
><p∩[3⊗⊂+Z4qt⊂~yP7`+ as Long As
I caf merel@dAae←YSAJAQQJAMβ∪π7↔>{C-β∞s⊃β;⎇!β↔c∞≠Qβ←⎇∪ ≡NβY`⊂_wr2Wλ$s⊂,[zBE 7ant @∧A≥∪_=≠CG→%`∂Aβ∧+@↔≡⎇`λ∞MβP8)≠x7y`% the exac@PAae←≥` πTλ
m
|y(∞M9:0↔→β ic
λp @;Lεf/↔<≥FgJ∞,Wε←.LV"ε≡4π&FT
ε/⊗mx M\9Xp∩H5s⊂,[zy⊂ &avgrite LISP system0AiQKαp4*%∧k'∨#"β ∃βn{K∃β>K3 &≥lrπ&tλ
t→=Q.<z44[3P6|\rr3↔βEαE→K⊂ 0{~w3P _9:v %q'' Iq absolutely fair. First one certainly cannot looi
at specializations of a program tk the data( A≠=eK←m∃dXAS9]CiJ↓YCuS9Kgf@!]↑~∃↓[CU←HAG←]YKegS=]fNAQ↑Ackα{S∃αdereNt sySte`≠f8A)QSLASfAQ←iCY1rAMC%` 8∀Ph"πM¬β?'≠&+⊃β?-!1βSF)βOS∞s∪πK ∧βrβTλ↔ε?]\Vwα HUE¬$λλm⎇]Y0→≤βi`∨\αβ'L4Ph ⊂J LV .αp∞ @→←↑@Q∧b@@9p¬bε∞βJ(¬@↔↔∀P∂←
(def@U\AM←αyβ 2¬
L8εq2_P⊂λaD@\\\αβπ9%αq19%αCπK≥β↓%↓e` D¬_8 3H5∀TTCE
I p∂C@~β⊂⊗@~8λ∞⎇=~⊂⊂βhuc@,AEKGα WO∃¬;∃βO∧∧Vwλλ@⊂→2p iGhp Mkαaβg↔∂∪@~ε≤¬⊂∩v64`.ois
th∂OKβ##↔I∧∧∩ε6↑pλ∂≤αpq9H10q`+,λ
(hQQ9ααλ .40p 3 I sHould↓QCmJ↓`∂.β]
}=λ⊂⊗[y2P$→v8⊂ 7ith @QQSfAAaP∨∨α,⊗jB ≥f hαZ3D∞~→( @8¬t`+β∪∃α∀λ
m≥≠ λ .=λ⊂⊂[5z42\⊂87`)nt o@_AiQSβ→β ↔v≠#'π⊗Yβ@>≤∧h∞MβP:2\zεE 4he tepπiS]≤Ag`'≤εF.jd↓P@@ QP→≠vP77]P7w∩P;t`,l provide with↓KCGPαβ ↔≠≤¬εn∂-0λ ∀→→4l>X∧p⊂Tion @=H β↔∞≠ $,λ ∞
8εt`4ive'↓S\Ai!JAae=H∂KπhCE%β&CπQβLε2ε@Xπp∀↓S\A≠
∂πKαMπJε≥H mlh≥z.Mλ≥≤L≥\{⊂⊂]4p∂n
λ¬`∪'αλ d Xπy tho`'∀AMCGαK3'SL∧W4≥~_.D_8 2H4ε`∨@ ∧π.vα9P∩\αsal. As @QS[JAα;?/4λ md_;Y∧ εE "ecome p eKαceβ≠∞k'3'∂⊃βO'&AβπMDπ&FT
7O∨LX .T∧ I wi`→X↓ae@?αh
,L(≤t \z9P∀XP42`,p ∃Mα{@∩ε\≤6B∧β∩4j¬@εE∧BDVy8→VBEβ∧π10-Apr-`b@@bβ⊃AT_|V␈⊗|T∧Rrλ8↔π⊗↑NF*βHy$4_8
MIT-MC> Rules
Date: 10 Apral 190⊂@λ↓E@#&∪∩l-8APD\[s'⊂#r`/p¬OJA(X α∂∂∪@⊗/LLRβDy(2ε∂D TMαβ30gaαE)jX52q`48∧@A¬UYKf~))↑tA! %∪
⊗AC@ ∧¬∃-HxU∃_Q(λl7H≠⊂∀\βptiming at SE-AI, RP@∞ACPA'*[¬∩~∧~(~∃∩Aβ#?=β> EβO-βK'O,∧Bε∂D
FF* 8
≡⎇~<m≥Yh⊂,-⎇= .Y8:m≥Yh≤N]→<h∞M_9β!.y;]∧
{H~ ↑Y(_m⎇\z0∩→y0w3H4z9P≤2v2{_w1rP≥40z clas@MSFAY¬nA←L↓ae←OIC[KSαs≥04R∪' βλβ∪G;≥#'?9εCπMβn{K∃β&Cπ9β&CK↔∃ε K∨Wn+;SMπ##↔9¬##↔eε K∀4RβCK?⊗ 3e∧K9βSF)β←K}s∃β?⊗#↔I9⊂h(4
L¬bπε⎇≥g"ε|dε&∞>EBε∞MDπ&FT 6}n]x D∞{k8l≥≠→9∧∧[→>∞∞\kλD
∀Sqieβ"U →αbaVλ("*iK⊂"$iU⊗⊂0y→P9x"Xtpv6≡P40w→42r_<P:4→P1wf\4v2y≤FE7sλ:42P≠4yx⊂≤|yz2[SyP$IvP3 !mi`→S¬dAoSQP\~∃→keiQ∃eP↔?⊗)1βSF)β7π≡c'OAε ;⊃βfKGC5πβK?∨⊗ 7Mβ&CπQβF [∀4TεW≡.D∞W≡/%\F.6≥lV"ε↑]G&J\≡&?.\Yg"ε=⎇g∨'.\7&N⎇n2εF≡hRεNnl↔⊗N≤-GHh,LW6.M}ε."
≥bπ& Tε&O,\7&N⎇dε}2∞ ↔∨≡≥lrε∂,}Vn.nN2ε↔∀∧&↑/≡⎇w⊗'4!PW> ↑&*πM W≡*
<WO>},Bε∂,Tππ⊗U↑π⊗}<Z7≡.D
⊗rπ=⎇V*εm}&jε}$ε∞v}Mε/⊂Q,↔"ε=yWεNLUW&N\U`hPQ(⊗Bb∞Mε/⊗T ↔⊗*∞=vn
→g&/,↑7&Nlpλ∞
||z,-→(≥l∨<h≠l@⊂7x:~vt⎇ )ng
Keyword argument calLing in VAX NIL. Maybe we can talk about
thiNes lIia this at some time. α
-gjc
λ
∀_⊗bb5βadZ`b@@b@`bβπM-β0])WDACPA¬Ke-KYKr∪eKgUY`A←_AaCSI`
β .s∂#7∂∪%β?rβ⊂↔⊗≥o"rα↓Q$&∂LW"β ∀λ↔π∩ε⊂∞'ε(λ∞'&-NLFe4∀u↓QQ\[mWH⊂tjh6 ZM<β⊂0zλ!2y5Yv2|FB*7]⊂≤83` 3u)ai
λSubject: resuLt of pa`∪ELAEK]
QSCe,A←\A→` πo%`hPβ"B!⊃ ""!≡_:4D Y;Xm
8<Zd∞Y<p~[8∧s
∩∩$∩∪gk [SiI∃HAEr↓PAM←α#↔Kπ⊗x4(⊃⊃⊂HHα"* >⎇X>¬@50 f@berkeley)
λ ↓ 10 april 8!
λ
*F+@⊗* ≡&*πM Rπ⊗↑8
-Nα9P'\α re@9]S@;8∧π&FT
ε∞O,∧h ,;Xp∀≠py5@≠w⊂# 2anz Lisp @=\@~∃α αZε@↓EE=;AAβK,¬fNvtλ&/⊗αy0⊗→|P⊂∀BSD E@9SpL@↓)QJA1←CHAα [↔K∞;∃β←∂→β &↑:0hWM ⊗rε⎇lRπ> Ybπε Tπ&N]_ L@P;pyH27w2K⊂⊂*4[tp∞g↓←\A+αs'aβLε2ε&⎇lRεNdεcπε∞4ε}0Q(λ$∞y8p↔[2⊂0w→⊂:42H:4vrH1t0y→p¬d @Q↑ABAββC/∂,ε74~;XmNαr2iH9wvrH4πf The system
h∂mKβ∪#↔π β⊂⊗@|H⊂⊗Yvsy<H4pw0Ypp
e@9h\@A$AeC\↓iQJA K]GQ5Ce@/~β?9β∞qβG≠d¬v∞→9β!.}8p~→vP:7H92r:XrP:4→P4w:→y32`2ence ob the me@5←erA5C]CO∃`\
∀4∃)QJ↓aeOOICZAo¬`
βK,¬bπ>≡Mαεnβy~,@4qpz~ww⊂ /nhy @Q↑AiQ∀AaKgPAMk]
iSO\4⊃gQ←β;9β ,c?]→ααC↔KF CMβL¬w*π=
w.fDλ
-d≥~→$ ]=≥. (≥0→YP6pq\αh∂fAαc'/∃αC∂CUo#'7∃J4+πv!↓#∨~kS'\U∩ε∞βY⊂→pqt pπSiJ↓GCLA⊃KE@'v)βS#,ε6*ε\≤7ε@|kC!↓ ¬∀2→q:w test()~∀PQYC5EIB@!hbAp↓H∂Q$hP%↓↓G≠↔SE∧πααG ≥↔.h_ ⊂_⊂⊂∀P pxp∃@¬X@@RPR@PαI%$Q!∩αα∞<W'
∞@ $¬λεP⊃Kc90w≡⊂⊂λrunp S[∀R@~∀$∩@@@@@FW→` πo$αF≡≤∧@⊂
8:4fYTTPεBα ∩@@@@Aβ!E%$hP%↓↓G≠↔SE∧∧w"αα ⊂λβ(
e¬]t@QMiCi@,ε2ε>>M⊗n*#"A⊃(λλ∧∧λλjhnX;↑D¬_x9∞⊂⊂λp@QS[JR$@∩(HI↓↓↓α↓β∨QJH4(∀∧αGπ-_ NDλ∧6 %ngth↓pRR~(∩@@QA` 'n@λ¬
α4q`4 ∂e@,¬g&Nβ9#!∧@ (QUOTIENDQ~2|
Q↓↓@¬Rπ (⊂∪]∀TFEαD@ εP⊗≠⊗ ;i↓α⊂ εε λλ_ αλ
(HH$%↓~Z≠KπwQ↓YAp¬∩JHβ"B$∧λ∧8)~w:⊂∀≠4yz '`∂Gi%[@∀Q!⊂Jα∧∧ααα¬∞↔.␈M_ -nα⊂∀3≠4πa`(αβ⊂∨"∀↓P@! ∧DDH⊃P
F@IC]t@D```@β↓A8Q!⊂HHα(λe8\X;O$
H E∃*#"A∀λλjhnX;↑D¬≥→0→≤90 ))
#-Franz runp S[∀R@FW→` πo$αF≡≤∧@⊂
8:4fYTTPεBα ($~∀@@ [
eC9t@@#≥#πSW~β⊂≡∨M_ ,U εE⊂λ⊃Qc 2anz (cadbQaiS5JRRR$~∀4Ph!55hh ∃& Tπ=>Y(
|β⊂:4→P1w`-pi`→Kα!β≠≥H $
<h F@Xε0⊂Aα∪gS↔~p4(Q)ε/⊗Tλλ. (≥~ T≤Y0→]v:1]∞αλ
(hRO∂KLεπ"π>L↔π→9⊂≠w⊂# 2i A`@H@b`@Hdtblhjp@BβIaDQ*&/6≥G"εF≡8 ↓QQ\X-oH∪⊂∀\βp _A=a`↔Mβ→P (%P∂D¬≠≠p⊂Y⊂∪p !irs)
λ[fasl paip¬f@;⎇h4+PhQ5y↓G#↔OQHh!IUK⊃#KWw#'7∃β91AMα63≠≠463≠≠463~J |7&N\Tβ∪~βH
YLYYQYLYYYYLYPFE≠4rεE ←⊂∀:→yz∀FB→~\Y
9:w:~vrP≠K→\→YLYYYYLYYYYLTT3q]4rrP
↔__@6666666666667)
nil
-> (test)
λ2592(runtime 7,20 &LffffLffffLfRQO
iSKJh\flXllllXllllXlnR~)]SH~(Z|@QQKghR4⊂djrHQek]QS[J@\Xff@≠→MMM≠→MMM≠→M%#>≠S'↔*↓Q9Y31YYY31YYY31Q]$hS;'⊂hQ5y↓F+c'QHh $ h¬RjjUQPDJ
H m⎇y9 ≡λ≥z
≤zλ⊃N]X⎇~-⎇\h∃l↑Y(_L]8π3@ callEd and it @MKKKf↓U`↔O βπ ?/!βπ∪bβS#'_h# ↔v≠#7π⊗Yβ∪?/→β'Mε≠π31α;7↔\,Wαh _ __⊂⊂≥4rr`3, I notiCe` that i@8AWkd↓`∂gO&+44$⎇V.o∀pλ∞⎇⎇;⊂∩λ27P0\P3wgY⊂0P *ob as 'me@5EKdNαβ@≡z ∀π⊗/
Hλ,<9λ⊂⊗Yvq2iλ1<P -emq
and @IC\ASβ!β←'&AβS#,ε6*π,↑7.gN7 hPβ"TL↑X;∞D
~<p_βE#90[=⊂&$\βp _A=acf@Lh~∧Zβq↓#3} ⊃↓∨n+7GC∞K@↔~⊃Q%NX<p⊗λ4rvx\0p `%LY←:~)h⊂∀%P∂D¬≥→4nE εE→
\Y∀9≥w:4fYP_W6833 &LfffFLfffF$QOGi%[@∃↓α ef-*#!
β0vεB⊗[⊂∀≥2yz)
2592(re@9iSKJbP→]≠→MMM≠→MMM≠→MM∃ v∨&≥\Rβ"e f6lhlf6lhlf6lj#!
β0 l
λ-> (test
2592(ru@9iS@7*↓E 3vfc33dfc33ffc#:∃ v∨&≥\Rβ"d6RHh-m⊗`@ ¬⊗@> (test)~∀HjrdQIk]iS5J@b\β9aMMα63≠≠463≠≠45∩F>>M⊗n(λ
.5)¬
@9SX~∀4|@@#,πεO"⊃Q'<|Z0_≥⊂27g→P7w Fr`∩A¬ad@bβ↓↓IIS⊃EiUα↓Ee@∧∧#!↓αAβ∧π13-Apr-`b@@Bβ→I@&∃α≥↓hRS=iα↓β3'≥βSKπw≠3πS⎇∪@~ε≤¬⊂∀jV`dH⊂⊂εE⊃4y1`4, inSCC@P phe@IJAC@⊗)β≠Wv≠S'∨w→β←'&A↓]β∂∪⊂∨.\X NNiH⊃M}H→0≤_vx6 %, α`)!JAMSβ∪@∨" h
-l⎇~3md≤⎇_.∞≤h⊂↔]z≥εEβE∀""Q*g⊂(⊂di)PβE⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂∀⊗⊂,P&Uij⊗`T("`iλ εUN↓β!!→d[π>u~RJεLrRMα≤z0∃≥J(∀L@U∀c!∧P⊂'∩d⊂
@AIRS) ,∧\\R4⊂⊂∀)∀π>9yy.≡λ≥~ T→[p⊗≠4πwi@9H
βS⊗ ;O3∂#'?9Ph ⊂@ ¬∀"⊃c*g PAIRS n~∀@@@@@P@"d
6
∩λ∧αEB ∀∧m
8@ (~∀⊃0*$⊃P
gλ h &⊗T¬CONSP %β%→)&A
≠⊂~NαJ$ Lh¬∀aQ@∧DPλ'$f⊗T di)JP⊂∞.∞)
∀∩!β%∞@DRQβ%≤@dRQ¬%ε@f$Qβ%∞hRQβI∞@jR!β%∞@XRQβ%≤@n@%JH4(Q%αVF≡:Bε ∀¬bbr ≥bJβU`αF≡⎇n2ε ∀¬ε≡}tc are FIXNUM versions of ADD⊃, PLUS, LESSP etc.
(FUNCALL fun x1 ... xn) evaluates all of its arguments and
applies the value of fUn to the arguments x1 &.. xn. So
(FOO @∧ADAF↓HR@zQ¬+≥
β→_@≥
∨≡Aα β β~β⊃$∀Ph($$JkKC≥hh(4(0-E~jπCIiAE↓↓ ⊃Md&∃α≥↓L;K/Wv#KW∪/→↓#K/βK'O*I↓↓hRS=iα↓β3'∨βS'7Ls≥βπ αNU6 I↓↓hR%β .c'↔[*βS#π βπQβ&C∃β?/#O↔Qε{⊃βSFKMβC⊗{+↔∂"α%βO& S↔⊃π;#πQεkeβ∨} 3L4W;↔K∃bβπ;⊃π##∃β␈∪∪↔I∧{⊃β'oβ?KS∞s∂∃9∧∪WQαJβ←'∪bβK↔'&+KπS*βS#↔hβπ;g> eh∀Ph)E9∧Iβ←πw!βS=πβK?[N#∃β≠␈⊃β↔π≡Aβ7πV{AβSOβ∃β?ε+CπSN{9↓#6 K'π⊗c∃β3}{/WA`h+≠Wv≠S'?rβ∂π3ba999Jβ¬βK.cπS'6)1β#␈β↔≠WfceβS␈#π11∧{K∪↔∩β?9β&C∃β[∂∪'?W~α2&N¬_4+πv!α2&≥↓βOg≥#↔7Mε K/Wv!9α%∧∧⊗g≡t ε␈εT
FF∂Dλ
<Y(
≡h→0↔≠zst≤βtandardized
@QS[S]≤AMCG%YSiS∃`
βπ⊗{W;⊃¬#=βπ ∧εf.≡:Bε>↑Dπ={9(
≤→8 ⊂≠q⊂:4→P0p⊂Prkpi@5CiJ~)CEg←αcWS∃¬≠C↔↔'→βπM¬;↔31ph( (&%b∧J∞|⊗wα∞Mrε&↑LWεNα;Y%D≠>4l]→Kλ∞⎇_=⊂≥42P8]pv4j_z4{"H24s#→y2w1YyP12]8πee@8~∃iQ∀AmCe%←kfA1∪' AMsgiK5bAC@⊗{W;⊃ε K∃9∧Iβ#?ε)βS=∧#=βSFKEβ β∀π>∂L9εNvtλ
}h≥X.-;y4aQ\≤[l@y0vyH0s2 constp¬`↔∂'→βπK*β#πlMF.α /∩π& Tπ'⊗≥n6f∂Mz'
@H⊂=∧ X8\nD⊂(⊂∀≠x2rεB840zλ:42P_0:90[9v0z≠y⊂; /lp @;&+↔KM89β←?,¬F"ε,TεG<⎇∞M_9⊗λ1:z nh∂nAαKQβO,∧Vo~ ⊃PGz;⊂⊗λ52r`$ po @⊃↑A[←β≠Qβ?2βS#∃¬#@⊗∞β\{ ≡~;p↔≤β mySelf, whicH is @=P
βπα4εf@{Y` ≡c"R$ x;@⊂≠p¬re@1rAae=mSIJ↓iQJAα3@⊗∞β90≠[y1P [2⊂77]⊂2|0Xz⊂;w\αking code, @∪L↓s←j~)oCMh↓BA:La6 .≤9FO∨∧
ε/↔=x D∞≠h⊂_≤αkpo@MJAiQ∀AKqC
hAae=H∂Kπh∧π>F|8Rπε≥]⊗v:
_ aQ];Z.l<Xp⊂[4∧p∩Aβ∪↔C?↔#↔↓β∂→βC#*βC↔K4¬w-αpw1YP7s⊂≡wzy d¬Cm←β∪'S∃∧b&NA¬≠gOS,¬RbπM VphαR(
]9z≥∧ Y(≠-}Y(⊂≠Zv64g→β to dk e@YKesI!S]NA5sgKYα10⊂@ ¬εE Tε Havi`≥NαβββK,¬F/~tpλ
≡h_8N≥{≥5 ]≤∧P &air.↓
SeGβ!1β?v)β∂↔↔#π'mH∞$ x;[M}λ≠⊂↔[uFE !t sp@∃GSCYαKkπSL¬vw~
x D (≤⊂→≠qy0vH87P 4he data. Moreo@YKdXAαK;+π&)β#πTK;↔O~↓#+qQ&ε@8:Sn⊂1w`.vers@%←]fN↓iP≥β∂+?S∃∧C↔βKL≠ ~J M⊗∨&≤LW4≥~_.D≥~→$∞≤[qn 8εyP≤βhouLd be
examined↓CfAYαKS@<ε∂~∞λ nytq6→Tε Areuang sti@1JASF↓iP∨S∞c3eβLε',9→5L≥] C!)zx 0ose I p∂C]QK@Ai<A`∪↔≤εBε7]l7&N⎇`ε≡∞MDπ&Nβ9( ≥Yλ∀∞5x7iYp⊂3 !ctorial iN itc
λrec@UagSm∀AM@?⊗i1β'"β'Mβ&{Sπ∪eIβ?C∧{@≡∞D
FzπM Rπ∨
~&O"
xbπ> ≡Bπ& ≡Bπε↑:G4≥≠c!.α90w≤v0z2H4z⊂ )nto @¬\ASi∃aCiSYJAae=KeCZ↓]↑A[¬i`∪↔⊂β←#πα@ε∞↔=x ∞↑→(∀nO8ε2FB1ww9Zp2y0]4ww9H<wp∃ brang to @ KCd\αα0≡vT v $≥~→$∞~~0↔→yP$P≥pw:2Y⊂:7P≥2yzβE;tj~⊂:44\β prodπeCZ↓SfAQ=nAMk9GiS←9bAoSQPA[←IJAiQ¬\@jA¬aOk[∃]ifA KQC@4∧PhV≥lBε∂,TεF∞βY≠ \λ≥z.Mλ→~,@32y2[:⊂9|\z2vyK⊂*44\P4yP≥4πtally f@¬Sd\~(~∃βF↓a←S]QKHA←UhXAi!JAgi¬]ICe⊂@|@@*βπK∨,¬V.wD D-Eλ λ ={]Y.9twwλ4yFEβET2→q:w→5wP∀_XP↔↔ ⊂0w∀H↔↔↔∧H≡[εEαT22s≥w⊂3 /o n ((hambda (a1 ≤\8ACLRX\\RQCeN`R@\8\@QCIJA\R$R~∀~)∩AoCLAMYS@AoSi AπQk
P
β .≠πWO*β←∃β∨β↔;Qβ⊃β∪↔d¬⊗ =≥→U-D≡98..h_=∧ 9≠~-mz<c!.≠yy.M→<@ ∀→Y0≠H<rpy≤β baci(
∀4∀h\AAKeACAbA%∧ε6F←]H ∧
_=P∩H9rw:λ5zz≠wy2P~2r8⊂≥tz4≥44yP≤93sy_vV⊂ !nd
In the future I wi`→X0AEkhαβπ;}Mε/∩∞λ m≥]λ⊂↔Yα thiq be@9GQ[CIP
β←∂→βS=∧εF/∨AQ'&FTλ
↑⎇~3LT≤}0→]2p
.~∀4T3@⊗@{(∪M}h≠p↔λ$P;t[4∧ pRovade with eac@ AEK]
QSCE,ABAI∃`∂∂KMβS'∨p∧ε}∩ Xλ,=β"P⊂≤94vt]4{2SH4s⊂*~2P8 2ocram(s! @QQChAαK@~εmx
∧
9H∪,8x8 :~<P0v≠w3P 7ith Tp¬C@;≡cπS'|¬`hWM~π
εmx D∞~≠p→YP30qZv4z4YyP:4_z⊂0y→P77`4 u`≥Sβ3↔KO∞a0∩∧≡4π&N\Tε>}↑4ε}r ≥f"∧⊃Q&⊗.=yV*πN.VgJ hλ-]8ε4`\⊂;tj~⊂0v&λ:42P≤βystems _A$AgSY0Aae←YSAJAMaKGSα3'
βF+3@4T∧f␈∩ Xλ,=λ∪∩*: C"A⊃ ∧Vy≤3RFEβEβ∧π13-Apr-`b@@Bβ→M`&≤bIβπ ∧∧lME[¬B~,SB∧}-w.vN.Vf/4¬π⊗/∞-↔∞*(λ∧∧λβ"HL=→.Dε,h⊂.∞H ≤N_P⊂⊃Xf`[ M(~¬
I←ZtA
→$ACPA≠∪(510~∃MkEUK
htA¬∀pA∂e=k]IeUYKf@!eKae%c@∃%α↓$
&yiαJ∧9βπQ¬~U&εHh#∂
RβC∪1∧ Qα6M!6b`hR'96⊗+C3Em#=iαL{WIβn+GOπ>)β/→β M&π∧ε"kC∀ε∪+≠∃XU≥ Q!PT→8<D∞\→`⊗βE I woulD like to Id∧Aa←McSEY∀AaCeQSGSa¬iJASαqβO?n)β?→π##∃αdJNAβ&K7'≠8h+C↔∨#@~π↑9⊗v: XDbε⎇`π&FTε#αr∧
Vv6}.G.v≡LVgJD T$b
~2π≡≥]⊗f∂$
Fz∧I~5αα X n 8z0-M≤∧FE~w⊂9x~y4p∀) butvastly difd¬KeK9hAS\↓IKiC%X\@A%\A←e⊃KdAi<@QM←β⊃β';∨#π;∂*IβKWph#g}Z"ε6≡.7"π∞-wε␈<XBε⊗]l6Fn≡-2bε∀λ n-||h∞NX;\mL=~3md≥z;
D_Y(∞,<=0∀\2r↔λ yFE≤z0y:~w3P(≠ts:9K⊂&b&λ40yP≠7P& Sa" Vλ()'cS⊗⊂&$Tj∃⊗&Ph!V⊂∪`h!`S↔↔↔⊂λ v6⊂≠s⊂εE≥42yrH:44w→yP1p[⊂12P_qqwf\64yt→r⊂4gλ&b&⊂_:z⊂4[⊂0P+_yz6<H24s3→y2w:λ;p|WβEαE∧S|P8zYyz4w[⊂4yP≥t2z4→y⊂$P≤t7zv→⊂80y≥4qtx_z2P4[⊂:42H:4vt[3yP:[22yεB:42yYP1ty_zvyz_w1ryH7y⊂9Z7zv"λ&b&⊂→97x⊂≠zz⊂"≥rP:7H2|:9→vrP2~s32y→w1ryKεEεE at94\P)2r]2FE⊗KVVVVKFEεE∩P;wz[2⊂6$ZpP:7H9rrP≥t0z∪b&⊂ (as to say about theSe issuas. I don't object
to having languages that are not recognizably LISP as lkng as they are
appropRiate languages fkr AI research. ``Appropriate'', I think, means
at least BeingprogrammiNg environment @ CgKH↓CfA←Aa←gK⊂Ai↑AQQJAg=eh~∃=HAECQGPAE¬gKHA∃]mSe=][K]PAiQCPA!β'
β_KY%WBAY¬]OkC≥KfAKαs∂?W⊗ ∨∃9∧K9βπwIβ↔[,¬g H,≡Bπ& TεnNm_ .](≤q-lλ≠9$∂9x
yλ1ww1Yx:4g[⊂7s⊂≥42P3~y9z_2w1`(mark.
13-Apr-_1 1724 YONKE at BBND Re: Groundrules (reprisa)
Date: 13 Apr 1dpb@d@dd[ M(~∃'∃]IKdhA3∨≥-
AChααα
: h*OW⊗S↔∂QRαK∃i∧;K?Wv#KW3/→↓#K/βK'O*I↓↓hR≠K?kQαf>tZ∃βπ ∧∧(SQβ!*≠nH
*⊃h_.D∀u+(→#"S,↑|x9lU21εDπ⊗pPIh↔,,eX<≤K'ε(λ@_∞→→≥_L↔(gg∩b←εE∩w⊗i2\68Vj≠]⊂$w]y⊂6r\ypsrH5s⊂_LP x)λ_X\_H_Y→\Kh)bεBεA"4XuP I agree wiTh qoup suMmari (h∂dAβ∪↔'S-∪πS'|q%β?2βg?W⊂β3πO h#'↔≥≠π>U`λ∧¬⊂∧P #an always wr`∪I∀ABAaβ∪?∂K∞iβS#∂!β'π↑+@~ε←∀εfO>∧εf@{zc! {{p∩λ0p∞d↓k]IKβ⊃βC#*β@⊗N⎇∞Bε≡⎇lFO&≥yg4≠8:lT≥~→$
⎇~→.9P6 /ok l@%P∂(β"P→Z4z⊗⊂→U3W DRE@-∃%'
A=\Aβ]QKe@3M≠A6+,ε&N≡
tεO~ hλ.≡→<@⊂≥40w_P9x %e`ing
banana, bqt @=iQKd↓iQS]≥`
β7∂Iβ ∃¬≠3 ?u`
!Q@εE)[y90→ wa didj'`(αβ⊂≡=λ⊂⊂H1t0w_pP:7H80v%H0z⊂ 4he l@%`∂Aβn+↔S'v9↓55εkπg (h+ 6←∞Bπ&≥\R`$λ∩)mT→{r-lh≥≠d λThe prgjEct iS currentlY a s@%aQ←]%]NAMβ∪?5β|εFF/$
7&∞βYP↔\αd money,
λ¬Ekh↓≠GπCIiQbAβ;π;S~βS : |W"π=yV*ε\≤6FNlTπ&N\Tε∞vDλ∩ε?,≤Bπ∨LXF.wAQ'&@h→≠d∞{{9$
yH∃
(_p↔\αrelAtion∞
∩∩$∩P↔Kαλrhh `@l,k(≡≤K ≤ P⊂⊂@930 Mabry Tysonyβ) 9)sg←αqβπQ¬*RεB
→5IAp∧M⊗U$∧?⊗βx
`.drul@∃`
↓∞,Wπ⊗≤∧p∩JP⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ_YP \9⊂⊂@981 $β MA⊗≥~P4(h M⎇,H∪,≤\X P∃<ywgλ≤ j( *8q`/n at↓+! D
M +&π`hU>XλM,8⎇≥λ)2U⊂⊃y0∂`+αs∪KWd∧W4λ∧92\90p∪@∀R@@@4⊃)↑t↓%!∞Aα QαNαUT HQ)⊗rm,X
O+1≠g⊂,w`5p me@M`∂π∨*β? ↓α⊂ eX<≤@⊗N_P⊂⊃Pfr[πM(∩(hRg?W⊂↓↔∨L≥f&∂,@λπd
(⊂. ⎇;9-nλ∪⊃+
∀H⊂⊃[w;2`2pπS@?p⊃β'M∧s?Qβ≤{@↔⊗\:BεNd
T≤JYI∃≥Q(λ-l λ⊂_≤2yzfXq24Vλ50∂`(αβ'9αF+∪Kπ≡Y∨MαdK@∨αβHλ
M→(⊂⊃[vx4`,er does not handh JAβ##∀∀T¬F∞n,L∩π>≡Mαβ@Hλ
P_y3yP≥t2z4→y⊂4jλ4yP H22s )ned @→k]Gi%←\A←β⊃βπd ⊗wε↑-f∞`Q( ≥8Y_%@ε@
Nh∂nA$ACgVαaβ←#,ε&*εMxW4≤∧wj\⊂;w`2d "sTandard" c@=[@∃β4ε&}kqQ hT≤|⊗NrD ∩>α
H
-p¬ to poi@9hA←KPAaQCPA⊃KIISGVOLAWeSα;';πbβCK∨?∪π5β≡C?W3 ∧ε⊗(β"P↔Zβ( @A!JAa←αK;C↔ ∧ε␈/Dλ
=λ⊂∀→P1w`5ld not handhe > 5 ardπfAC9HAQC9IP∪↔ ∧εO"
_ AQX(∃l∨(≥~ ≡λ≥{n]→λ⊂↔≠z⊂0s→2qz the @QS[C]≤ASLA¬]rAgαK⊂≡v≤h
,<9]∞|>(
∀yλ⊂→X|@
@1KgfAβ##πd¬c
*∃aP@@ ¬!<H842P≥p|V⊂∩P1t2Xurr the LISP OARCHI fal@∀AC@; ∧ε -βzw2λ840zλ:42P∂~P0y→βs waq
αhandleD beginj`∪]≤AS@9∧s?[↔n∪↔I↓α⊂∞&VKC"AQ@εE∀∃βhil@∀A∩Ao¬`
β∂F+∂/'v9β/9∧εFF∂ED∧Jε⎇x
∧∂8πp∃@HAP≠↔G!β'↔≥≠π>U`λ∧ 8πp∃ pπiSYαaβπK*βS#'v[';≤hSS#π ∧ε
ε=x .
8ε2`2 wou@1HAQCYJA]↑↓ieO@,∧&f*∞⎇↔&BεTε∂⊗}4π&@h_ ⊂∪0p
bda ev@∃\ASL↓Sh~∃α≠π9∨α@λ
8π26→P~P !pgs @Q↑AiQ∀A→C[ IBA←α1βC#*β⊂↔8π1`4ion @⊃K@≠≥m↔&Nβ{@↔λ⊂*42H0p∞s@]KdXAα{⊂⊂@ ¬1`/urse, is @Q↑Akgα)β 6↑:F.λ∪⊂)XQ⊂<d
βy⊂ ! PROG a`≥HααN⊗R∂→0∩αλh M⎇(≥~ T≠xZ,@tp∞al
entp¬rA←α1↓EE{9Iβ'w#=αI~5α∧βp4Hd @%hAY←α{ ∨~
H
-≤αP&`Pd∧@∪'@AI←Kβ→βC#*β@≡∞β9(∞M~;Yd∞z→0↔βE0 `(αβ⊂⊗NβY≤d 9H⊂∀[8∧ernal LAMBDA↓oSiPα↓yUβ∂∪⊂∨~ ≡2εODλ
|<h⊂≠Zz4⊂ H3:w1]4sw≠pε <β)βπK?→0∩Hβ"K%U++#%Q ¬εE∀2st`3ter/Stack↓βYY←
CiS←8AP∨→∧bε&
$ β@6≤.0hT≤@ε∞fDλ ↑→;Y∞P7w≡wzy compIler @=` βπ ∧εf.≤:Bε↑dλ
(≠⊂∩]2r⊂ /d∧AiKα≠#+⎇H l@|@
@∃[EeC
K@⊃β&C↔K↔↔I0∩¬M R∧n≤9FO∨∧λ6}o
_ ↑H
_-l λ∩$∞~~3MT⊂:4→P w:→y&4`3p co@5aSIKβ⊃$4 ⊗{S!β& /*
_ NL<[X-D⊃⊂3( qP≥4π mean a↓]C@7L¬f 4λ∧7`2 b`∪]⊃S]NR↓←DAi∃[a←E¬ar4T¬F}≡≤M⊗}w5Dεv←-\⊗fGα(⊂↔[⊂:42H9z0qZβ b`+β!βC?∨≠' 3Jβ'9β&C∃βK.;'OS-∪@~R ]v&/-aPVF≤∧Y∞|<Y(¬ x8r T≠90⊗[y0riJP16*\αs the ne@
KggSβ#eβ?2βK↔∨M≠S↔I∧∧F/≡≤,⊗⊗Nβ~5∂⊃ ¬3'\α sp@∃K@A←α1βπ∂≤∧W>hπ⊂εB∧¬∃β1c↑HAβ∪↔∂'≤εF/∩∞λλ.ytw3H4¬eant one didn't nee` to pa`'β→βC#*β;G\,W!α@
o@_ACeOU[C@;'→βπM∧¬⊗rπM R∧dXε∀
$_x<lUλ≥z ↑Y(⊂$∞⎇_8mP80y\βi`≥NαβCK|Mv≡}Dλ
.FA0∃@MK@@1∧∧⊗v"∞⎇ε/⊗T
FF* ≤FG<⎇≠,]]λ⊂↔Yα the stachεASf↓KqaYαK∂'SgIβK↔∂+'K↔ ¬`hPβ"U
∞<kλ∞M→<Y$
<h_$ ~<⎇
≥X⎇~-⎇H_Y.Ny90↔λ3:w1]4ww~w:2y→0qrP∪ fa"⊂yP0w→εE4w≥2y70[⊂& fP yP~w⊂9w[pP1`/mpileps. Since there canbe n↓CGiSYJA β5¬↓α~)mCeS¬EYKf↓ChAC9rA←]∀AiS[∀XAiQ∀A]KK⊂AM←dαβGSπ≡Yβπ∪d{∂πSN{9↓β⊗K;∪'v9$4+O→β+↔≤+GOπ↔Iβ'→ε ;eβ≤{7C'd+A9α&C∃βO& ∂-β∞c3 ><≡FN}eDπ&F|\vBb <⊗rε,QPV&⎇lRε∂4 ∩π⊗\⎇↔∂&↑$π<=Y(
}→<X.M;{H∞0z42\α than as a pre-planned alhocAtion
so I g`+α+@∨~∂→w*ε=x
-Lλ~_.l(_ ⊂≤αeas@=]CEY∀AG←[ASYKd↓oQSG AeKO%`∂S↔⊂βπ33}≠πS↔_h#C#|εV.B ∀π>␈]HFr?Dλ
≡Y(⊂~~5zst≥⊂4r≥pyP9]4r6⊂→5w2P≥40z way.
So, translate the > 5 c@¬gBACLAEKgPAsO@*β∂π9ε ;⊃β&+3 "
\RεF}tπN␈T F.≡≤LV"ε⎇`εO"aQ HH∃↑'ε:QQ `@l,k(≡≤K&ε∀λ @→ X∧d"Q)$aeH0z⊂)∃j#bi∀P∧i2N⊂#y7]w29:[2yP∀≤2x94\p¬)
Date: 14 Apr 1dpb@@β EE6-~P4
5∪?5i∧B⊗∩JL~-βπ ∧¬∃-HxU∃_Q*7.⊗,X7#Rλ,SB∧}-w.vN.Vf/4¬π⊗/∞-↔≡*(λ∧↓ ¬*7N⊂)(#H0z⊂)UV`dFB$p∞-Reply-To: Your @5KggC≥JA←Lbf[βAdZpBb`∃MJj⊗NPhP4*SF)βCK}∪3↔5¬;'S!πK?WI∧επ⊗←
z6."∞ ↔ε∂
∞&∂≡T v $→>≤∞$|h⊂≠Zz4⊂∨λ~P0y→yP4iCE:40]⊂4z⊂≥yryP≥42P![w9z9≥qz⊂*~0z⊂ 7e abe tryIng to avo@%HXA]¬[C@3Jβ∧4 f 7 ∪λβ←'S@↓y↓Uε K∨Mp↓α%β∞iβOW⊗)α%β≤∧⊗rε=x ,T≥<λ∞⎇=~∞wvrj~4s3@...
λIt @MKCKf↓iQChαβ⊂⊗@|H⊗-}<H⊂_≤αkjeCt to work p∂JAα K∃β>{';≥∧εFzε ≡f*πMtπ<αs2εB10qeH842P≥90w9[0z4`/n. Else How c@¬\Ac←β)β+W&;∃βπd¬Bε@yH⊂≠Z0z⊂ 9ou wanpλAi<~∃@+αXF.,πP⊂∃βha`(αα%β←L¬Fbπ∞-v⊗∞-H∞$ ≠h⊂∀\β b`+αK3⊃β-↓β¬αl
≤@~8p_λ1ww;→y9t`/n pachπCOJ4⊂ #πα8 n]8∧w3H840zλ4¬any h∂LAβ##∃β&+@∨'4λ↔ε*
_ D 00s
≡|λ $
9H⊂≤[zP1`/npemplate
λdoiNdεAKC
PA←]∀ASLA∧AISMα3↔K↔w!β∪'∞c↔∂Q∧εFFNβY|d {⎇3 D→y5∧∞→;\lU+Hλλ≥↑#"N∞Y9P∩\αefc@∃`
βπ~βS :∞Mε*εmz&jε≥dπ>F≤=α∧J∞8Vv"∞Mε*πN,⊗w≡L≡FN}gt∧∂"∞MεO_Q(
⎇;]λ ∀_x;D
]<u∧∞y;Y∧∂;x
P≥42P&Pab4y\⊂80qZβage. BuT as Time goes On that
∃o%YP⊃β>+Qβ3|s∨/$λ⊗v"
Ivv>↑ ε∞vD ε∂6T F/∨4 ⊗v"
HW>h≤t \z9R,4≤Y3 ↑X;XlT≥≠c!,8π<P≠w2P*→yz↔ I do jgd↓G←]i∃[aYCQJAeK]` 'SLs∃βSF)β≠Wv≠S'∨pβ'9α,~%αM~7α`Q,'/"
]w>≠≡( L9Z0↔~w3P*~2P3 5nctiOns and then usIng the teSt inclose to
its Op¬SOS9CXAM=aP∃9ααC ?>9⊗⊗G∀λ∞-}(≥z-Mα⊂9p↑P:40]⊂0qP≠4πngas I can implement
the constructs in the orieifal, you don't realhp∩Aα≠πK∃¬#=βO,∧RεF}t∧JεMqPVOE`λ∧ <h∃
=λ∃
(_p⊂\r[FEβEαEεB⊗VVVKVVFEβE&ti]w22y≤z0w2~w3FE∩P3r`%qs what I said tk Tyson (encloq` HR↓SfAe∃YKmC9h\A∩↓oCfAU]IKd↓iQJA%[aeKMcS@?ph+S#∂!β';&+C 6≥D∧d X(D∂~ 9w.fDλλm⎇<~0⊗→P7w:≠P:42H9z0qZP24`2ectlY, rather @QQCL~)iQe←UKPAB↓` ↔∨M≠S↔Io≠π[∃∧¬wε/,≡FN}e`¬≡z
←∩ε≡⎇]V.wN4ε∞⊗|ZBπε T∧d-α⊂∀D {{]L↑\z0↔[εA0∪Imply did Not applp∩Aβ#=β@≥}Wαπ?~7&.U`∧π= λ ∀⎇Y(
L8<[L\λ≤sm\αz44[3P4f\5y:0[:εE !boutyour LISP, whi@
PASf↓oQC@ α%β←∞sS↔⊃∧εFzεMu`hPβ"QN
{(≠M}h≠sD (~≠n (≥≠d∞|→0m≤↑(⊂≠Z0z⊂$]⊂4yP≥40r is tested↓oSiPαβ↔π∂@β ↔;≤¬εn∂-1PF∞βY⊂_2P0q≠2P:7H89:i]⊂:40]⊂<wjIy2P2≠tp∞g↓iQJAISOQh↓iQS]≤XAiQ=k@∨!∧Iβ←?,c⊃β3L[∀4 &yβO↔*βS#∃¬∪↔OWdεFNvtλ6}εTλ M}H≥~ T_Y3L=≠8<M∀_;Y¬]|H⊂~~2P:9_w9v !tignprggram.
What A @5CrAKαs⊃βWαβ∪?'v9β'M¬#=βO,¬f"ε|↑Bε⊗βx
4λ:42P≠y0 gina`_Aα∪↔;∂FkπK1Q&∞vDλ /∀⊂εpq[4yx⊂≥90w9[0z4`/n to you @%\A←e⊃KdAi<ASCW∀AaQS9H∂Mβ,∧↔=9<CAQ@εE X4πutLIST(@QoQ%GPA∩↓[Sgi¬WK@;dπ∩ε≡≥H \λ
S ~uλ⊂~~97r`'h a @]KSeH↓`∂C?}s↔Kπα9RHhαR(∞M~;Zd∞y(⊂-Mα⊂7`5eht @Q↑AOKPAgie¬SGQh↓oQSG A→∪'AbAI↑↓[CGe=fP⊃β∞s⊃β←F+9βSF+d4 ∂∪∃βSzβ ∃β/≠↔↓→∧3?Iβ,πε∞o
H %D⊂(⊂~~4s5@ thad↓→∪'(αQβ'M¬#WKlX ∧
8π:7H:42FB!cg)H30∂rm afd↓iQK\αβ∂?7∧K3↔⊃bβ@≡z ∀πε.=yVn∞βY⊂_P6pq\αh∞Am∃` O'|qβ/→∧KQ8∀Ph"πSαL⊗≡F\@λ
\αyy`Yp¬ to Tp∪g pas@MS]NA5KC]h↓←]JA⊃SI\OPA]KK⊂Ai↑AββπOMπ##∃βw+7 ↔⊂h+/→ε K∨Wn+;SMε Eβ'rβS#∃∧b⊗bB⊂∧ε≡∂<UBπ> Z&*ε∀
7&∞=0πε∂>9⊗v:∞
&␈&|9vbε≤1PW<y0∩ ⊂0w2λ;t2`2e the adjustmeNt of the Stackis e@aaQSGαKS 'α(⊂→→xzt`2ed ≤~(~∃)QUbPAi!KeJA%`
β¬∧∧FO∨M→f∨&≥x D Y=≥l\8π⊂#≥w1z4[w⊂4`.terfAca LAMBDAs afd
λinteph
CX↓→β≠¬⊃βfASαqβO?n)β∂?oβ'3↔↔→1αOL¬f≡*∞Mε/⊗Tλ6∞r ,RεR ≤7&OlT∧d X(Dλh.hλ.-88[ ↑h_=∧ 8π<P≠w2P*~vrV⊂≥42P7→rr⊂ &or sTack AlhocAtion(b`∪]⊃S]NR4⊃SfA9KGKgMCerAαK9βπwIβ∂?oβ'3↔∩qαS#*β@∨&≤8
d 8ε6 /catiOn, though can↓EJ
∃α#?;∃ε Eβ¬∧ε&.≡≡8
↑H≤p⊂]2P7`0eradion rather↓iQC\↓CfABαβCK∃oβ3πmlV"ε≥H
|x9~-⎇Kβ"N≥h∩( ↑9<p→H<p∂`*↓G←kYα!β#π4∧Rε
∞,V∂≡⎇l⊗⊗@→(⊂⊃[vx4`,er which @IKGSgβ#↔Iβ∞c3 ><≡F/_Q(
⎇9z∧ (≥{n]→≠AnD~_=LT≥~≠n\βt: it waq stilhλAI=]JAi!ChAo¬r\4U≠=!β'∪π;Od∧↔&*∞Mε*βdεRε≡≤8 $ <h⊂L↑⎇λ⊗-}(_p⊂[⊂0w2λ82v , ie how yOu deCi`ed↓←\ASβ!0⊂H!⊃⊂J@<Xλ3KFAβ∧π21
Apr-`b@@@λε3 @∧i(⊃P⊂∧iPβCP@ @@@~))P≥iα↓β &≤8 ∞NX;\mL=≠p→≤β a`(ααN@*X→∩αα↓Q$Jε ≡f*ε⎇mGJε Xλ.2⊂3 2om @'¬∪⊂⊃D W.gM_λnT∧ F@IC]tX↓C]HAIkiOKβ∪@~ε⎇`λ∞M→#"L@4y0∪@PA`∪'nK;≥β⊗+;∂#n @⊗Z∞8 d X8 πλ(62`!q`
Agα+;⊃βL¬w/∩∞,W>9_
9Kα To pπ@↔∀hS←#πα@λ∞ 8πp ,e have doNe so d¬CdAβK?Uβ≤∧⊗rεMx mP0p∀h@∩(M~ε&1U∩⊗NVe"M 5I→U@:α M1→'!hh ∀vtλ ≡|⎇{n2⊂:7H εTP awa`2↓←dAi<A)3!∀AShAα{WQaQ HHα+<N hεFEβEβ∧π13-Mar-`b@@@λπ∪+Hα31(Y⊂3@⊂_z⊂&dU⊗`dP
%0vr\β R.↓≠@↔↔F 9%hR∪πS+Q↓EM∧jεI↓α⊂∞'ε(λ 132-ESTλ
*4ε&}kαH∪(X2⊂3D =λ∪)~α⊂
AI (@∃C5KfA⊂¬b∧n\X
≥J#"JMβ]⊂)∀ π at SU-AI
∀~)∩AoCL@Em←αcW;S,∧W,9λ@≥≥]≠h∞M→(∪ ~tλ∃
≥8∧w3H&pt`,ing List, bp hA$O@⊃βd¬⊗@<α@
@Q↑AOKβ!β >ldεO"
_ D
=λ⊂→→xzt`2es rea` S]≤A`∪#*β[ >L¬0⊗YyP7`& h CSαaα%∨αh $∞y9 ↔λ4p∞
the @1CghAα3↔]β& gMd↓P@$λ∩)mT~;@⊂_t0p∩ge of UC@∩A1∪' Aα ;⊃ααX4J∧β3∩*:λ
∃-m=Y0→≤βit`2↓←@→α≤∧⊗fNmx Mm8(⊂⊂]∧¬∃∪β∪['lU∩ε∞βY⊂∩P40{→P6w`2e than a @ACggSαs⊂~ε≥nF/⊗↑8
∧
8π⊂&∩ih⊗y→v0p∀ed proh¬KGiLX⊂∀,.W"ε←∀ε∞≡|¬3ND_8
MIT-AI i`&↓kgKHαβC↔KF CMβ|¬f≡(_ ⊂≥pru@ d¬P∨I∧∧6F.==⊗v:
\⊗N`Q(λ-lλ≠9.ypsr\β(λAC9HA7SαkC ?,L⊗w↔(∩$ ≠h⊂~~4yP !t 3 @AECKα!0∩∧α9H∂≥⎇(⊂⊃Xw⊂9`%nd
@M←[JAα{⊂∩πM Rε≡|∧\L↑|≠p↔→2p∞c@∀AErAU&A[C%X@@#∂→β ?∞λ np¬d @Q↑ACYαaβC#*β∪πeo#= .L∨⊂hW>NV&2∃D∧J>DλλLT~;] ↑Y<p~→p⊂∞
λ∧@A∩↓`∂#?αX D_;⊂→[P8:`4 i`≤Aα βC'αL6Bεmx D
αrw:~ww4`.dεA`'⎇+@∩π∞-v@,8⎇⊂~w⊂:4→F@
SIGART↓_ ↔←α8 ↑≥→0→ ⊂;t4Xt⊂4`3 read by @¬EP∨W ∧ε∂~
Hλ. y(⊂⊂H& ihλ0zr4Yw1rFBαas @¬]siQ%]NL@4⊂ α∂|ε&&N≥H ∂∀λεP⊂∩4p
Mea`⊃C8~∀4P0 ;4∧#)\<K ≤ P⊂_K X@ DeutscH at PARC-MAXC Re: Timang Benchiarkq
Date: 31 Mar !dpb@@λεcC D
¬≥ Q(gε@{.HλL==≤l=λ_=∧
⊂4PeY06⊂aQT⎇8M,8⎇εD
Y.H
M;:0↔→P!2w_t6py~yFE$[⊗y2x≠<Vz7N⊂)(#IyP6r\ypsrH5s⊂→LP
ar 1981 1451-PSD
To: DickGabriel ,RPC at SU-AI>¬
It @%bAmSQCYYr↓S[a←β∪Sπ≠"βS#π ∧π&N]_ Lt≥→<nNh∪SjD_Y(
M;:0~→r⊂:7H6pr2Kzx⊂1[r2FE→90svYw:9Vλ1:z inclUde systems whi@
PACe∀AS\A!KCmr↓kgJA9∨ ≥→ααW* ⎇w"ε,X Ml9β"Nl<Z( ,9≠⊗$
{H∩-nα2y6~yx⊗bλ12q`]yrP /d∧AG←αkC &↑LVgJ X N4πne@=kfASα#↔πMε ?W β←#παAPGε
_ L@yP0q]8¬alLy go@PAcgKα!β¬βd¬w"pQ!PE⊗α9z∞Eλ_].D⊂∧SvH40{ )ng troublE getting @AK←aY∀Ai↑A
←]ie%E`↔S*β ↔≠≤¬εn∂->2λh!⊃⊂Jo,∧⊂∪KFAβ∧π21-Apr-_1 1⊗04 Greefberg.S@e[E←Y%GfACPA≠∪(5≠kIi%Gf@~) CiJh@@db↓βaeS0@bbpD@bbt@hAKgP~∃
e=Zt@A≥eKK] KeN]Ms[E←1SGfA¬hA≠∪P[≠kYβ#'∂LhRS=iαα∪'∂Xα∨π ⊗K↔1↓e∩B: ≡B¬≥UX∀KpQ)⊗rm,ZεgJXMs@$λ∪9.≡x9y$
yH F∀⊂<⊂→~v⊂_LN_P⊂⊃TtjpA∃`∂Qβ4ε&}jλM⊗≡Zλ|⊗↔⊗≤Y@hPβ"Ul]≠ λ∞tp∞c@∀A∩Agα+;AβL¬w*πM W∞(≤Y.≡9→≤eD⊂(⊂∀_{2P"≠w2P)[vrP&[y2P %xperim` @;& S'?pp4*SF)α6&"jε%β⊗+GW3'→β∂πp∧ε⊗*∞}&O'LYbε↑ldε∂~∞Z6/∩
H l≤λπ⊂,YyVεE~w22bY⊗⊂7cλ1wzy≤βa those @→SYKf↓oCeJ↓G←[a%YKH\@AαAα 5βπ5∪π'⊃¬##πPhR%β←Lc1β#∂3∃βSzβOSπv!β e∧εFF␈<Tεw.\,W.h_;LD_{p↔_v:r2H:40zλ1ww9Zw3FE~yP" Se⊂ ∪LMP∞L@↓)QJ@4b`AGα 9βπd¬F}≡≤LRε
8 mnh~3Dε(⊂ !U≥P0@ p¬P∨W&K;∃β|∧`hW=x ,T≠→3L}~λ⊂∀\β involve@⊂AW\A5kYiSα≠@~@H∪r∧∞βrv ,,∧A)Q¬h@∨M∧εvGJ ⊃PG{xZd∞z=~∧ ~8t∧ 88r
≥Y<h
m⎇kC!↓ @↓AβX⊂↔5βadZβAE↓↓α⊂ ε6βDfpX9<P*≡yww <ATP.Tyso@8AChAU)β "
→5IAp∧M⊗U$¬↔9→0→H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ⊂≠P \9⊂⊂⊃dpb@@λε#≠αβ0tjAα@
F@I←Z`)∧kπ KJαSgO|¬bβ@⊂5∀¬J≡8 `/n ad↓+! D
M%Iβp4*O,∧&V.>@∞D
Y.H
.αr2`3
λTo: RPG @¬hA'*jε$Q(λl7H~→,NX8rd =λ∀JZ⊃q4J1"C"IMβz⊂ "eifg↓iP∨S∞c3eβ4∧⊗nNβ~0.∧≥z5
∧⊃00iI4t ∧ (→~,Mβ∪p∀p¬KCY%uJAi!ChA≠¬π⊂∩&≥4+π,εF}n≡M⊗≡∞MK∩εN≤LR∧dY
¬↔~
}W"ε|d∧-Eλ.2π>≡Mαβ2
x D
9x 2H0y3z[rp∞ts, ECI-Lisp
∀Q]QSGP↓SfAaβ∪↔OWn 3E∧∧6f@|y(∞MβP;t_z⊂$2Y90qeH4yP9≥w34`.dεRAI=KfAQ¬mJA→∃1!%@_h# W β∪/↔~β;/Q∧επε␈m_F*εmx D ==≠m\=~0d {{]L↑\z0↔[↔αEεB+t0zλ$P24Y⊗⊂0w→⊂ P 4hifk↓ShASLAmCY%HXAo¬bAi↑↓[CGJ↓iQJA1CghAQQeKJ↓CeOf↓S]i↑4⊃BAYαKGQ9ααπ;eε K∨Wn+;Qβ>KS!β&CπQβ&+∂#;M W+βhλ ∀→≠{D}λ≤q. <X= T≥~→$
~<u↓QY>_l↑≥λ⊂≠Z2y2P∩P72bY⊂4r↔βE
It ap@AKCef↓iP≥βn)βS#∂!βS#*β7π ⎇⊃βC?↔#'?9∧{⊂∩πM Rπ&≥\RεO4∞7ε.nDεNrλλ∀M∃6⊃PW⊗≡Mε/∩∞Mε∞r
_ D∞~→(∞≤αqz4[w9P'Yα co@⊃JAiQ¬hAS]Y←YmJ↓iQJ@xj[Ce≥k[K]PAMk]
iS←]L\∩*&C∃β∪L3∪↔K,s∂¬βL¬bε∂,}Vn.β]∞ <|r-lh→Sn⊂:42[P9t7]v2⊂ "e swamped↓ErAi!J~¬e∃GkeGαK?9βL¬b¬∧→~%≠
d∧ααDα(⊂∃≥yz⊂ 2an a↓iKgh↓C]H@djJA←α1βS#*βS'↔*β'Mβ≤εε.wDλ
-a"T⊂)~Tl ⊂
4w:2\αpreTe`!.
-------
free space. The ratio of runtime versus GC time was
approximately the same as what you had supplied. However I later ran it
with twice that space. I was now getting exactly one GC per test (each
recovering approximately the same amount of space). My total GC time
had dropped a factor of 3 1/2.
UCI-Lisp uses the standard mark and sweep routine. Obviously there is
an overhead associated with each GC. Furthermore, a GC during which
most of the core is tied up is more costly than one in which free space
is almost empty. Thus GC time required for a problem is a hard point
to pin down.
If I were to set my free space up so that I totally filled memory, I
would have less than one GC per run on the average. If I used more free
space than physical core would allow (not possible on our 20 but a problem
on our 10), I would swap GC time for paging time. This would seem to be
unfair as paging time could be considered either the jobs cost or system
overhead (like swapping). On our 10, increasing core size to beyond
the physical space dramatically increases run time because of paging costs.
It might be a reasonable idea to specify a maximum amount of free space
(or should it be total core used?) in which a program can be run. This
may not be possible for the Lisp machines. An alternative idea would be
to adjust core size so that you get exactly one GC per test. Suppose that
you start off with a fresh free space and run the problem, GCing only when
it was done. This would count the cost to collect the words used once
without counting what it would cost to track through the temporary data
during the running of the program (which is dependent on when the GC
happens). I feel this would be a reasonable comparison to the costs
associAted with having a parallel GC or a machine with such a large
address space so as to never have a GC.
-------
07-Apr-81 2213 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> SCCPP on UCI-Lisp
Date: 8 Apr 1dpb@`@`b[πM(~∃
I←ZtA5CEer↓)sg←8@yβ)@])sg=\ACh↓+) 1¬&Zd`x~∃'k UKGhhA'ππA A←\↓+π∩[1Sg`~))↑tAIaNACPA'*[¬∩~∀~(∩∪%KMkYif↓←LA→%' Ai%[S]N↓iKgiLAM←d↓+π∩[1Sg`~(~∀Q)%[KfA¬eJAS8AiQJ↓MWeZ↓$W∞A]QKeJ↓$ASf↓iQJAIk]iS5J@Q]=hAS]
YcIS9NA∂ε↓iS[J$~∃C]⊂A∞ASLAiQJ↓∂εAi%[B\@↓βYXAQS[Kf↓CeJA%\AgK
←]If8@@E∪9iKe`λA[KC9fAS]QKeae∃iKHX4∀E'Y=nDA[∃C]fA
←[aSαc↔⊃β↔+QβW≡K;≥α-*=73Ns/M⊃α∩≠πO"⊃β7↔∞sMβ∂|¬WεNL\Bπ>≡Mαπ& T¬-,qQ&fNm>2π⊗↑
F∞≡\@ε↔J M↔⊗.>DεG.↑∞2rHQ!PPH⊃⊃∩αα
∞&}≡↑>6␈⊂Q*π⊗}},⊗hHα"2iE,L
F↓""2i∃,,
F↓ ¬∧Pλ⊂$w:→y8∧i[7{DPλ#0yzαP⊂⊂⊂λ$w:2\8∧P⊂∀v7{DBc0yzβEαE)Pah(≥βE⊂#9→r]εEλ⊂→X_ _∧P_M↔__∃L↔≠\⊂λ~W→Y
Y↔→\αYW→\
Y↔≠\λ⊂⊂~YK~→U\ ~\⊂⊂ _W_Z
XXW≠ ⊂_Y↔
[UXHK~[εEαP_Z↔ ~∃Yπ∞→P⊂~K→[UI ≠X∧YK→ZUY ≠XDDL_↔∩λ
XXW~
P_Y↔
→QPHKα36
↓ 3.34+HXn`∩$d`\NHVbb\T`@bd8nbVbD\hh~(~∀@@X````$@bh\X`V`\Tp@@j8h`V@αqU@%~qMU-αqUM↓α↓UI9C↓-E9#⊂%IEs a-Eq!U↓↓ ⊃0∪C∃0 %Fn#"A∀ - F&
h Ffλλ
%f
`_ ~Y∧YK→[∃X ~YDDL_W→≠JXW→\λ⊂_Y↔ Z∃P⊃.43
14.⊂9+0.63 5.37+ 8jd∩f8fjV`8jd∩∩HbP→EJYE)Qα↓↓EIqIM-EpεChαB(ε⊗α∪→
X↔≠_H⊂~W→MUX↔~L∧YW~ ∃X↔~LFEεEλ⊂'7`4es: The f@U]GiS=]fAo%iPA[=aJAi!C\@J↓CeOk5K]if↓oKeJ↓GQC]≥KHAi<@jACIOk[KαsP4 7+;∂SN{;Mβ↔Iβ7π↑K;≥β&C∃β3∂≠Q↓M∧K;S=∧∧∩εf≡:B`$λ∃~ ↑y(≥l↑Y(∩-n[{≥L\λ~3D
→<|d∞~_;AQLi(
|H≥~ T≤]0↔λ:4vrH9wP*~2P24Y32y2[1rP4\β insigniFicant,∧@A)!JAiS5S]Of↓←\Ai!J~∧d@h`Ao∃eJAo%iPAB↓YP∨π βπ[↔⊗ ∨¬βd∧W>h≥~ ≡λ #D∧∃~→$∞~;:-l|h⊂↔[⊂:42H%` -D`AoKIJAoSQP∩¬B↓[←IKICiJA1←CH\A)QJ↓ISMM∃aK]Gα+@~ε≥`π&FT∞f∂⊗α;⎇.∀≥~;-≥Yh≤N]\h_.,(≤≤M|X8[∂∀→_
bCE:7P≤|yz2[P7s2\42prλ2:rP≥5P9{Xx84g→U⊂⊂*~2P⊃X∩P392YP9x XrP2l_vx6 %pεAQC⊂ACE←Uh@j~)←d@L↓∂εOf↓oQSY∀AiQJhaεA→` ↔∃π≠Cπ∂*β↔cπoβ3↔MεCπ↓β}s∃α≡~β↔π∂Bp4)5ji555hh(4(0-I
jπCIiAE↓↓⊃↓E`&n Ke¬#gO?r↓rεRαrSgO|qβπQ¬*R⊗b
→5IAp&3?≥!β7πL`Y⎇hR∪πS+Q↓IE∧ CI↓λπ∪C
∧ F⊗hεaiUεA#)≠vY⊂&Xq9<P∃<yw`. 8ATP.Tys@=\ACHααVR⊗βλ∃~K&π`hU>XλM,8⎇εD ≠|u∧
8:3αgc"U
wH≤\ @P0p∀↓'"[β$~∀4T+;∂3⎇≠↔↓βLε2ε
∞8 .D≠yH ≥≠λ∪/∀≠90→\βageS to @e←j\@↓βaaCIK]iYdAg←[∀AP∨→∧εFF.T¬εNpβ"P__y:4a]v0q the Resul@Q`
α∀λ l]]λ⊂≤[zP5 5st bed¬P∨K*βS#∃∧c'OA∧k↔/M→f*J ⎇w"εMz7"pβ"R$ z→0⊃Zp¬d TIIING,MSG[TIM,LSP] And oNly f@=k]HAQo↑A[MKfAMβ∪?5βn)β'→¬##↔K*p4*%∧ 3O=¬≠π]β&CπQβ}s∃β?2βS#↔h∧ε∂π ≡&.wMK∩εF≤Dε⊗.]`π⊗/
H
,\λ≥≠d¬(_].D∩(⊂↔→{2y⊂→βot
a reply. I don't know what i@LAO←S9JA←\0AEkh↓aYKCMJACG-]←oY∃IOJAIKGKSββQβ?0h+C#M→84 β16πC∩iaE↓ 1iAUS⊃E ,8:Bc+ε#3ββ∧εβββεεββλβ"Q ≡→.H∧εH⊂<∞∧ ..ε∀ -LεU0p jβE#97[]⊂&pX9<P*≡yww∂ j(↔∃<ywgλ0z⊂*U"h iKY_∨εB)zq5→qz≥⊂∀2Y⊂*~vpw3H12w1Z6py5H⊂⊂εE∃7]⊂)∀ π at SU-AI
αI@8[%Kaαce -Mw"¬N|X D
9<tl≤βrP'Yα 6-Apr-81 1502-CSD
λ ∃∩↓ckOO∃ghAi!ChAKα ∂!β¬∪?∂K∞iβOW⊗k'SS,!β≠?⊂∧ε/6↑/⊗}vT
Fzπ.X D y=λ ∀≥;Z.≡9#"Ml99(∞=h≥y$ x;H L<xp→~q2P4]⊂9tv\68Wλ⊂ v9[V⊂86→pyrP≠0rrP≥42P6_w3zpYrFE$[⊂;t4Xt⊂4jλ;pyP≥y0z:→w↔εEβE v9[V⊂4jλ;pqw z⊂1v→py⊂#≤7vP<[zy⊂ -essage whether the code got compilEd or
ran interpreted fo@HAiQJ↓iS[Kβ→βg?*β∨?Qr↓↓"?vceβ≠⊗{5β3}{ ≡Nlpε∂"∞Mε*ε=|F*`Q)∩>" }V/∨4
↔"π,≥bεNnLWππ,↑F."∞=⊗v≡T∞FF/,Tπ>∂4
f␈&
≥f:πM ↔"π<XVn∞D
Fzε=yWεNLQPVOEa⊂hRUURjjUQPRβuX↔π∩Wε∩β '&3βS&uT≥≥EG∪ 4εβββεεβββεε⊂hTL≡F+R∧εr∧∂∞ β K∧⊂β ∪6¬T≥≥AQ$7⊗⎇S"∧n≤.'J¬Lε0→[w⊂⊗ U(↔ ∀yson at UDEXAS-20>~∃MkEUK
htA¬∀pA%Kαc↔M↓α↓4
&yiαJ∧9βπQ¬~U&εHh#∂
Rβ#↔∪⊗K∂-β∂!αJV$:⊗JLhP4*;|εBε⊗]→f*πMzF∞fO∀ε&∞β:0⊗~py⊂ 7ith MACDISP, I didnπt realize thad↓≠βπ→%' ~∃¬ki←[¬iSGC1YrA[¬IJA→∃1!%@~β?WQ∧¬v $⊃2∀
.h≥z.Mλ
H
}H≠;n (_<L↑990↔≥9S⊂⊂∃a` -Lisp
(p∂QSα≠!β'~βCK↔≥+7π dπ∩ε≡Mx lT≥≠h∞⎇_8
Hedrick i@LAek]9S]NR↓IP∨↔~β#π[*α2εBα
'1 X].D→≠q.P77`4 proVi` JA→←dACUiP∨7∂#'
β≤{;[↔↔≠'?9ph ⊂HαUz ≡λ∩( M9 λ ≥Yλ∩$∞~~0↔~β idis vAlid, was @Q↑A[C-JAiQ∀AP∪πα8
∧∞~≤Y,T_8 3\β into
αa↓YSghαq↓απwIβπK?+7πn@λ∞⎇=~⊂≥40p∀↓iKGQ9SckJ|@A%∧∧F}r|@λ∞p¬parate @QQJAYαK@∨ Q( / y<⊂~λ;t2`2e @∩Aαs↔π⊃∧¬↔"pβ"C!$z⊂ !ppearpεAi↑↓[@∃β&CπQβ&C∃β7∞S?Iβ∧¬w.~;sD
yH⊂~~2P:4[p¬ i@LAgaK9hAS\ααBε&∃→D4 ⊗ S#↔⊂∧π&F≥`λ
≥H≥~ T≤y0⊃]4sw9H4πf Co` JAβ##πQ∧¬⊗w⊗β{∃LT≥~→$πβ~Vp\3zvr[:⊂3 5nctiOns ≤~))QJA⊃SMMKβ∪↔;∂*β'9β∂∪↔W↔,¬g"π ≡7=8π3@ d¬P∨I∧εFF.T
6F←]H ∧ Y(∀n|9<→,D_Z(∞M→#"Npr 1dpb@Bβ⊃Ue6≥~P4
4ε&}k$ V∞↔/∀¬'O=ybβd~Jαu'≡8 md_=⊂∃h"l TTY_∨βE)zq~2qz≥λ):v %pε@@5∧:
βSNk∀4*&yaβKε9βπQ¬~U&εHh($*Mε*εm~'∂"∞M⊗n<h≥
=λ∩$∞X;H
8pt∀¬D∩(⊂.,X=≤L≡Z;≡$ z≠tlT≥≠h∞↑y(_.∞≤[}
≥8=→-O#"Lfε λ¬ →8z-\;
( nY9(∞>_8y%dλ∃~ T≤X=
≥h≠yD∞];]
≥9(≥L↑\⎇<dλph≥
≥9(≥l≡c"X.∞≤[}
≥8=→-O(≥~ T≤x;,T_8h∞⎇_=λ∂≥⎇(~ ≤λ≤⎇.∞≠~9,EHλ∩
}y=Y.$∩(∪ ≡→<H∞,;H~.A"]z.Mλ≥≥m≤y(≥
=λ≤n 8y+D∧∩(∃l≡h≠[nt→y=∞M;Yh ←_8⎇
O(≠{LT⊃ph∞ <H≥ ↑⎇λ
\8zβ!.Y8{nl<Z;Lt_<≤∞-}~;,≡→;≡$∞~→(∞<;9( ≥;⎇;ND≠yH∞>_8y%∃Hλ∪/∀≥≠⎇ ≥λ⊃pd∞~;9!QZ_9∧ ≤[|∞ 9λ_$ X8⎇
}H≠yDεh +f%C"C!*0r+)M<|λ∞↑y<h∞M→(≤nL;Y_.,λ≠8.-h_;LD≤⎇y,↑λ≤[n↑~;Y%dλ∪xNm;⎇<mO(≥~ ↑Y(~.1"X;D
⎇Y<M 89λ ≡|{xm≤=→9∧∞z=~∧ 88z∧λpkH∧λ]<]
<[;n,+λ_$λph→∞↑Z;Yd∞z~8m↓"[;n>λ≠yD∞~→( =|Y(
≡h≥~,\λ≥<∧
<h≠-}Y(_m}⎇≠≡$∞~_;D
{Y(
≥H≥z
≤zλ→N,9(≤n 8y#!-<h_-M;|⎇∧ ;<≥∂∃Hλ∃
∞<h⊃h4≥~;,T≤Y<.]<Y9∧ [|H ∀≤≤[l-→;(
≡h_(
<Yλ∞
z;]↓Q]≠h∞
;H→
}{KC!!"R9D (≥y.,(≥≠d∞y=λ
←(→\L\(≤| ≤y(≥.∧≤{h∞M_= ∀≥≠⎇ ≥≠≡( m;≠→,D≠9;-}↑+λ ⊃"]{n]→λ∩ ≡Y(≠ ↑|h≥
;H≠ml(⊃pd∞→<H∞.;H≠md≥~→$ =Y4L≤y+H∧ 9H∩$∞<y1∧
;|Y$ \Y9!Q\|_,<(≥~ ≥H≤~∂≡z8x-D_{tLT≥{⎇-Lλ_;
M⎇h
m⎇λ∀
}|z0ML(≠sD
⎇<Hε&λ_].D_(∀∞-x[→-Q"[{D
⎇<Hε⊗
+λ ∀≥{⎇-Lλ≤⎇l≡λ⊃pd∞~;9$ [|H∞ 9z;Lt≥~;,UHλ∃
<h≥m};→λ∞<9;(∞Mh_Y!Q];YL≥<H_.4≤_9m≥Yh≥
≥9(_m};→λ ,(_smnz9→.,9λ→-≡~→<D∞~→(
-x\h =|⎇λ
}H≤}.>→;#!-⎇Y<M 89λ¬
~:y$∞⎇x<∞
;Yb%Dλ∪{D
⎇<Hε⊗ λ∩-l|Y8.=9Y` =|Y(∞=>Y(∞Mh_Y/≥{Yβ!.~→(∞
≡<r,<;λ∀n 8y( NX;8.M8x;
O(~3L>Y8<l↑h≤]-d≥~;,T_Y8l≡<y(
|H≤_,⎇9Y` =|⎇≤ea C"I≡λ≠:,]≥λ⊂LT_(≤L\<{p↔_q62P~r2p@ tk specify a maximum aeoUnt oF freE space
α(op should @%hAEJ↓iP∨S∞aβ∂?⊗)βGO,∧CzJ
_ D∞z~0⊃Z⊂0P 0rkgbam can be Run. Thic
λiay nh∂hAα∪∃βC⎇≠G' d)β≠∨⊂∧π&FT FO∨∧
V∞≡
_ L↑iHλλ≥H_;∞L<[X.M=Y(
≤→8 ⊂≥wzv"λ12FE≥4π adjp ghαβ∂?K*βG'k*βG=β&CπQβL{Uβ∨-!β↔c∞≠S#@∀λ ml(⊃pd∞→<@∞L<⎇ D∧∀⎇4∞
|y(∞M_9β!∂8πzP≤z0q:λ5s3⊂≥tz4_P392\t⊂3 2ea space and run the problem, GCing onlY whe@8~∃@' β←πMε#?;∃p∧α¬&
~2π>}YF"ε=x
-nλ≥~ T_{tnD≥≠h ={≠⊃,>λ≥~ T≥{tLNh≥4l\λ≠p↔_rFE+Zz47z]⊂1w`5nting what it @]←kYH↓G←gh↓iP≥β'∪π∂-¬##K?,∧vBπM Rπε]↑ε␈⊗≡/∩ε&≡L⊂hVLX M≥Yh∃
(≤]-mX;Yd
yH∃
(≤∀M||X;$¬≥z~,=λ~4d →<⊃-l→;]∧
{H⊂≠Z2w⊂*~2P#aCE0λappefs),∧@@A$AMKKαaβS#M→β←?,¬F"ε,Tε
π,\↔≡}l≤&f* 8 m↑_8 4\βon To the cocTq
associ@¬iKHAβ;'S!∧Cπ['v9β¬β∧ KπMHVb∧x4ε␈∩ ⊂εn∞=
⊗v*∞⎇↔&B∞:V≡B ⊂εf∂,|PhV≤LG⊗/>4π∂ε≤8Rπ≡tλ↔
πMtεv/lX D
_=P∩H0P#aK∧A⊗@------
(5βadZ`b@``h`b`)+16∞N ¬C εg3ββεεβββεεββλβ"Q ≡→.H∧πλ⊂<∞∧ ..ε∀ λ ε∃0p jβE#97[]⊂&pX9<P*≡yww∂ j(↔∃<yw`. at UTEPAS-20.
λSubject: SCCPP on UAI-LIpπ`~∃Q↑tAeAH
βπ ∧¬≥
X→⊂hPβ"B!~Y<p~[8∧s Od∧A2M~AβSLk';≥¬#↔OS~β∪ ?$
T≤JYI↔>β"C!¬∃~3,↑h_<LT~;@∞M→(⊃M}Y(∀E8h≥z ↑Y(∀D
<h⊂~~2P9:[84vrH∀77`4 ifc@1kAS]≤AπεAQS[JR4⊃C@; ∧∧:ε≡4π&FTλt
πM→V*R∧λ⊗fB∞M⊗n<h⊂.,(~0↔λ9rq`/nds.@E∪]QKe`D↓[@↔πw→β'≠&+@↔π,X
\ β"D)v7`7 ∧A[Kα ;Mβ≤{7C'd∧V"ε,X
∧∞<z0↔→P*`∃O-linkq(λ@E→CghD↓[@↔πw→β∂?oβ'3↔ ∧π>OMλ∞M→(∃*Yc"P⊗~w1yP≤2x6 !cad @ rAISβ∪↔∂Q∧¬'.o∞5bHh!Q HHα"(∧∧∀≤[l<αyy`/p∧⊂∀
¬∪?∂K∞h$$→9Bk∪εfHHα2r%V, L↓Q@∧P⊂λ$p∞tep¬`∪'αc?\%αα≠πO I↓↓↓αα';S,ε'J∧
6f←q⊃∀6∂>AP@!α@
SC@π! @Ph ∩∧n,V+Pβ"H∧εlλλ_ ∧P⊂⊃PX AAXε"`&nλλεUβ→P∩,d\f@@IM)Mβ
f%Mn⊂λ⊂~P∪.43# 0αqUa↓β⊃E 3⊗A3
d¬LDε,K@≠Mβ+118jd4PI↓EQpεβ"[%`∞ε4λ +F6jh .4ε`∩f8fbVDαqP≠λ⊃⊗#αsF¬3
dBrβ %`
F5l,#F6A"B!⊃ ∧YW X∧+"8j`∩∩H`\nd,bb\J@@bd\β9E-EλqQP4Ph!↓↓3↓AA@J↓E@"d¬L¬6 M.∧∧
+Eε¬l M&↓,kDfUl E&4λλ
&%N
f∃M B&&+L&¬6+M
$∧ ,CGε*h+F7!"B$ε- @→ ∃X↔
⊂⊂~W
~⊃X↔
YYW [∃X↔
YDDY Tε27+1*38 12.∪4+1.∀3
10λL`dV`LlL@@j\LnV`\Td∩f\LjV`\Td∩∩dDXbbVD\h`@bd\rLVb\h@~∀α@Dh\dd,`\lb@j\fTV`\jH∩f\H@V`\jL~∀4R↓α;∨&+Eiα&C∃β≠,s∂S'}sEβ←M#!β7⎇∪∃βSF 9↓Uε K∨Wn+;SMπ;↔K∃∧≠#π≠>+⊃βSz↓Uβπ⊗;W7↔w 4+≠,s∂S'|sEβ Jβ7π∂L¬f*πM Rεf≤8
∧εh~3NMβP0@ list∞ Theq`
Ao∃eJASαs[?34∧V"ε≥`εf/>4π&F≥aPC~T
v $≥~→$∞];@⊂≥4rrP≤wP:4→P24c→αerence i@LAS]g%K]SM%GC]h8@A)Q∀AiS[%]OfA=\AiQ∀~∀d`X`AoKIJAoSQPABAαc?π⊃ε [↔K∞;∃β3/≠EβSF Q↓Ep∧α¬& Tπ&N]_ L↑h≠sD∞~→( 9+,,∧∞y<Y$∞z=~↓QX(∪-|→<X.L(≠∪l≤λπ⊂⊂∃42P2~s32`2enceS in The variouS timing runs are probably due
po system oveRheaddqe to swapping, The 3 !,AMeK∀AgaC
JAKq¬[aYKLAQCH↓CE←KP@j
∃α{@∩βdλt~?4
vFNLTπ&FTεc∧Z j&.
∞>ε∞≡TλWF∞↑ F/~
⊗"ε⎇lR∧<4λV∞≡¬aPBjUQRjjQQ# ~X≡παk∧∧ ⊂ _X
348∧fj[
' ⊃⊃ ⊃eamβ↓AAAαεβββ∧∧ !QQ_= WHλλ@3 Apr190⊂@λ∧β∪ 4@ (ijεE⊃93vMλ&pq9≡P*0→@M←\@@d
RAh¬≡.≥{H⊂.D∃0
"V iV@208 4U≠W ,∧7#Rλ∧Y'⊂#q7]w21:[2yP∀≤2x94\β`
R@@∩*&y`∩¬*λrε∂D
5*@02#!$p∞-Repl`25)↑tAe←kdAαk↔OO∞;∃β?2↓EMX≡παk∧∧ ⊂ X∧3 25β'(~(~∃ '|εWαα,8
≥Y_<LD∂H
$ <Y⎇-\8π:∪ hλ@R conversi@=\DASβ→β+∨α@ε≡␈.,V∨"
_ D
0r+)I4pβ! 8π2, preSumably(λA]=hAS\αα#↔∪⊗K∂-∨~α3'Oαq↓αSF)β∂?oβ'3↔⊂∧ε&@y<h
m⎇λ⊂∀_w26"H842FB4∧ambda with .jAC@⊗;@~π⎇ W&F↑ λ
≡λ~0→H0P22Yαi`≥Kα!β≠Wv≠S'∨p∧ε␈∩ ≥bεNnLW-β0vεB4∧ambda.
No@\A∩ACMP
"∞⎇ε/⊗TλF}<h⊂≤[zy⊂ 7ord "qtandard"↓G←[J↓H K⎇P∂aQ@εE Yppw, I'dli`↔J↓iP≥β∧{';Q∧¬w/"∞Mε∂" V'⊗α8p∃IyP7`2icinal prodπeCZαβ@≡F|X D_Y#!4πk.A⊃JAA←S@;&+⊃β?αZBπε ≡BεFTλλm}9→⊂≠5z⊂ (andlE 8 @@*βπK∨~βπ;⊃∧¬ε∞vMH ,D~9λ
≥A"P⊂H9pp→ thad↓o←kY⊂A]O@ βπ6lXλnD≥~→$∞~;:-lh~0↔λ0w<P≤βignidicant way (A'd sai
hess than .1%),∧∩(hRβeβ&C∃β←∂I1α¬∧∧6F.=<V"πM R∧d~:α∧|~(4DJ h
-L(_;LD→[p~[2⊂:4_z⊂:4→P∨~P_y3yP≥pyFE~0p∞dle` bedπS@;vK;≥βL¬b∧v}h -\Y<@ε↔-lCAQ@εEεB∀+t4[2P$P≥pyP!Z2qut[3P7wλ840z ⊂ P 'ot your nexpλA[∃`∂Oπ>)1↓αL{UβO&K3 " ≡&*πM
⊗v↑≥lphWM ↔"ε∀λλm⎇<~0⊗→y⊂;w]v2⊂ (ave No trouble with5 a`%≥bAi↑↓BA3∞k ∪¬∧∧W6.d ⊗ $~=β!,x;AnD~_;LM→(
$ <Y|d∞≠h⊂~~2P&0[q20@≠s⊂:4→P3:g_z4wwλ22s )nition. The answer, of
course, i@LAi↑AUgJA]∃giKHαα2ε6∀"πMβ␈⊃β¬αα
$|: ≥f"¬8ZE∂~d∧∧7⊗⎇Tπ&FT
wεN⎇≥f∞`Q,Vw'/∀ε}2ε∩∩{≠$ ⊗w&t DM≥∧ t
∀9 ∩εOD F}}>4εfN<T∧l 9I∃≥α Mv/~∞Mε*π<≥V*πM
⊗v:∞⎇ε.pQ)↔"εm→f'~ ≥bεNnLW⊗V≥D∧d X(D
π⎇≡FBβfTε∂⊗}4ε∂~
≡Bε&|↑2π>≡Mαε
nVv∨M≥vrε|dβs* ≡&?~e⊃PRjUURjjQQ# ~X≡π∩kε∀β∪ &FcS+5X5≥"FF3+[εεβββεεβββε⊃PT&≡LSRβ⊗4∧∂π$ε∪KC∀ε# βeX5≥ Q(g⊗↑W$∧n∞./∩¬'≡9vrβH~EαuO≡6}r ≡B¬-H[∧
~V&βph*>V⊗V\>CR¬M≥VNvt
W≡:
⎇bεf≤:Bεo<tε7⊗⎇Tεn(Q*F{R∞.ε:ε≡@¬≥*X→⊂hPQ*vF.d ∩π≡]nBεo∀
F∂∨D
W≡:∞MrπN}TαF
lW:ε]≥g/&↑4ε∞>u∃B∧J M⊗&r}Dπ⊗.≥M↔V*∞Mε∂ Q)∩π>≡4ε>/NM⊗v:
\W∨≡≤|W~πM VrπM ↔"π≥}RεF≤Dπ≡.nDπ≡}\Tβ:ε
}W↔~ \↔⊗f≤↑"ph)}W∩π?≡7&.T∞v∂~ Mw>r∞=rπ>T∞v/⊗T
'/∨D v/'M≥f:πM Rεn≥≥Brα
MεO~∞=ε␈.LDε/G
L⊗NpQ)WJε=⎇Vn.nDε∞⊗}↑Bε>↑NFNvt ∩εo<tε7⊗⎇TπN␈T∞vFNLT∧Jπ|≡2π'≡
⊗v:∞Mε∂"
⎇f*ε≥e`hRUURjjUQPRjUURjjQQ hP`{εeT∂π%Wβ
αε⊗#β ~*∧:α↓Q"{ε5T∂π%Wβ
αε⊗S≠λ→YBαα↓Q"{ε%T∂π%Wβ
αε&3#0→8∃≤EH→bε∂D
5∀JX→∩M,W"ε7,≥gVf≡>ααα↓Q$&∂LW"αβ$λ↔π∩ε⊂∞'ε( DfG 4∀jA"Q\M⎇.H∩h~r∃⊂)d_=
:R+0)⊃"T⎇,-Y8⎇π$∀Y.D \X;O-~<|∧↓"U≠g$∪3λ ≡λ∀u%X2#"I≥K4Y.
≡+5
wH⊗;n↑H≠9.>x9y$
yH EX<≤K'ε( Lfε+4∀jA"C"F∃(⊃≠l↑h→\L≥↑[~.≡λ≤≠n<(_;O∀≤Y<nNZ8⎇
≥{\h
|H~5∞4≠⎇{D
{H≥
(_9 NY<|d∞|_8lQ"B8.l:;_,-→(≥
t_(≥.<<Oc!!"69.4_;Y∧
[kH∧
z;XlT→\X-oH≠~.>λ≥<l↑h_(∞<9{9-nλ_X.<9λ_-M≠xx.M;{C!!"<xm ;9( ≥Yλ_$ Z9≠,≡λ→[n∧≠8<M≥9Y` L=_(∞≡≤]8nN<Y<d ≥<Z-lh→x. X9y!Q@"0m⎇≠→8nM;{H∞M→<Y$ <Y(∞>_=~,4_<\L∨<h
m|H∃
(_Z.Mαpx⊂_w2⊂ &or¬
segment @⊃KgGe%ai←eLRAiQ¬hAaYα ∂∃β∞qβGC∧+@∩ε-}Vv"
ybπ& Tπ∞O,QPPH≥xbπ& Tε .X;↑D
~<p_λ0r29→yyP)\0qrWλ address
sp@¬G@∃β>C'∂!¬+;'a∧;'[↔~βg?Up∧α¬& Z&*π|≡2ε
LW=9{@ @4∧ag↓S\Ai!J~∧∩%mCpAαk↔7}/∩ε∂,9εO&\8
∞↑Y(
NX9P∩[⊂14P≥42P &act @QQChAYβ1K\αβ#π⊂hP$'Szβ?K≤⎇⊗v∞β≠⊗$∞];@⊂≥tz4 ondy 120Kb iemop¬rRAβ;#'∂@∧εn∞LTπ&FT
ε∞y#"A⊃<z0≥→P;2`2y smalhλ@Pβ)EIβ↔KS↔MJq↓αSzβ↔/Dλλ.
⎇;Y∧∞~→(
βy92[27riH9tu2CE Od∧AaC≥JAiC YKfAIKckSβ∪↔↓β4¬w$≥~~.∀⊃⊃0d∞y;]∧∞≠h⊂⊂H→⊂6 %vel @AC@∨'v84(⊃~6≡F]\Rε∞l@λ∞ 9y1∧∞~→(∞↑y<An∀≤_9lT≥_8ML<k@
]Y[|NNαp∞atelq, UNIX
does not page the use@HAaCO∀AaCE1Kf@9ααS#∃∧#'≠≠,ε&.v<TεF/,TεO_Q!⊂O& ≡Bπ>
→F*π≥}Rπ>}X D≠[|M\;≠⊗$¬~9H∞ 9z3LT≥~→$∞_9y$∞_8[ ↑h(⊂↔[6<FEαDy2x]ty2P
⊂1<`4es oF resIdentphycIcad @5K[OedAMOdαβ↔[↔↔I↓YR↑⊃β/_hP$'[Lε''8;λ
\αp
o@Ir@@5hβ?9ααYdMB∂_ nT≤Y4.]<Y(εV-H_O≡→<h
|H≤Y.≥9→3NA ¬∧D\4<q`)cal @5K[OedAMOdαβ↔[↔↔I↓YR↑⊃β/→π3'KSαX⊗bε\YV␈↔∃`λ∧
~~<d 9→≤aQ@"5.∧≥Y<O∀≤=2,={≡+D∧∀{h∂≥⎇(_l≥H≤≤L↑≥≡(
↑8zλ∞∞;→(
}=λ∩∞]=;Ym}<c"A⊃*→1dε,N∪,/=→*$ 9→≤L↑|h∀n 8y<d
{H≡-}<H∃H≠λ→Sn⊂:42H:4vrH12tg→W
2) DoepεASh↓acLAIKg←]¬EYrA→Cgh@!KSiQ∃dAk]⊃KdAk9SfA←HAkMS`RP⊃βε KS'∨+3πKLcd4(O##∃β≤{7C'f+⊃β∂|∧F+xQ!⊂LNd∂⊗␈* ≡&*ε=x . <Z;Lt_{p⊗\4v2rλ1wr2H:7P+Z0z⊂,[zP0y→P:ybY⊂:7P~wεE∧Bf`af∩ih⊗⊂≠7P∀8_y:4q]v0q6≡P37`2 heavy arithmeTic cOmputation ,∧∩∧∩%+@∃β'∪'↔⊃¬#=βW≤)α K∞siα3O≠Aβ≠|ε"π≡⎇\R∧N\≤v*∧≥l⊗gO=_ d∞⎇≥1LD_;Y↓Q@∧Dd]⊂5:y]⊂;pyH:7wP≤v7{P≥4π be usable. There hav@∀AEKK8Ag←[∀~∀∩∪IKGK]PAMSq∃bAi↑↓iQJA
←[aS1KdAi<AS[aI←mJAAKeM←I[C]Gα)β'9ε KKπHh $π∞≠∂πO≤K;≥β∞s⊃βπ⊗KS#7-#'
β≡{7CW& S'?pβ GQ∧εFF/<TεF∂lTπε.≥IGHh!⊃⊗v←DλλL\9H∀n\YZ0⊃Zrs:→αh∂dAα{WIβ¬+KC?≡+E 2∧ ∩π&
_ MP;rP_y2P'≠{FE∧Bq2z:~w3P /n @≥∪0@QoQ%GPAgαC?W3 ∧πε←,@π&@h⊃0↔~|⊂8zZz2P*≤αivi@¬YQ`%Jp4)MJα# ?tλ
≤YZ0⊃]v:⊂ )pεASh↓iP≥β?∪'S∃∧ β∪KM3↔Iβ4¬w$_(⊂∩→{0q`% hanging Odf the
∀∪U]SEkLA←\A∧AIdbβ 7 #&C'MβLε2ε
MV
εLX
M≤y+λ∞|αP;w]v2⊂ "e interfacing
a grinel@0RAM←β⊃βC#*β?C↔⊗ S'lpλ∞|yz2[←FE∧Bcy4`.ell's kn Dr-11b's are absolutely triv`∪C0X ↓α&C↔K∃∧ C∀Q!⊂Oπ-xλL≤Y_ P Tπ2 @⊃←uK\ααW;π@∧ε'⊗≤¬P∩\αs (alhλAo=aWS]≤RACMα '3π⊗c∃βSxh $≤∧]-d≤;u.⊂#y4[52v⊂≥497jYt⊂0@ dr-!⊃b. Your @ KghAα∪↔Qβ>{W3⊃∧∧&(hαB")]8¬rP⊂qqr`4ta (accetta@cmua).
4) @/!ChACIJA`'⎇+Aβ∨,s↔Kπbβ'7C⊗+@∨≡≥x NP7s⊂→αranzlisp as a↓o←eW¬EP∪∃∧ε7O∨LX !Q@∧wgλ0P; !x8∞~∀$∪∪LAβK?Uβ∂∪∃βK,∧⊗f@≤∧P )np Ke∃ciKHαβ'9β4¬⊗v&≥lrε@⎇=⊂_q3p∃@PA≠K∞siαM~7@ ¬∧DXyP0@ pπsgi∃ZAE@,¬⊗f&≥lrπε⎇x ∧
{H⊂~~2P ⊗AX, I woul@⊂AgkO≥KghAβ#π3/L¬f(h!⊃↔&@h⊂;LO(⊂ t]5tw (p∂Si-S]↓gIRP↔πJI0∩α RεO4λ
(≤Y.tr2`.t EACLIS@ 4⊂λ$≤∧⊂∩\αson(ex-MIPλAmαK@≡Nβ{@⊂≤2y0∪@=\RACI←kMHαβ#↔K*βπ;⊃∧¬ε∂~∞N&N∞Dλ
q"B".↑y(⊃N0p∞z Lisp as a↓≠βπ→%' AgUEgiSβ#WS∃∧¬vrπM R¬4≠¬`hPβ"C!
{|\O∀≥≠h ,(≤∀L↑y;]
≥Yh∀n\zλ⊂⊂H3rw2\0p lY dimview↓←DAi!JAo←IYH\@↓)QJAYβ0ASβ_4+,Z7"π>L↔↔ε≥lrπ&t V∂'↑,Rε∂4 ∩π⊗↑8V∂⊗=π&@{{λ¬UαP:4~w3qP_y2P)]4r6⊂~tp∞d↓←DAE¬eJ\~)≠\Ai!JAE@⊗K↔#Q¬≠'&UDαπN|¬(∞⎇8ε6⊂→2s4g~z2v 9 p∂C]PAa↑Aα∪∃βW≤¬⊗v:λ⎇w∞f≥lr?~λYT ≥4λf␈⊂β"P~~2P ⊗AX. A rery winning EditoR!!¬
@ CMαK⊂$%P %U+++!Q@εEβ¬XZ⊗Px9⊗L P⊂→031 RPG
To: RPG at SU-AI, jknl at SU-AI
∂14-Apr-81 2022 HEDRICK at RUTGERS reviseD (final⊗?) version od report on Lisp conference
Date: 14 Apr 1→81 1237-EST
From: HEDRICK at RUTGERS
Subject: reviseD (final⊗?) version od∧AeKA←ehA=\A→SM`AG←9MKeK9GJ~∃Q↑tAK%fACh↓≠∪([¬∩XAO∃←MLA¬hA'%$[↔_X↓E←sKHAChAM%∩[↔0XAK]≥KY[←IJACh↓+'ε[%'∩X~))↑tA⊃eKSMUfACh↓(∞"ε∃"695 4*K.#'OS⊗K WS.!6S=Rα ∨∂∪⊃βπ ∧¬≥∀∃X5≤bDλλL-x8Y∧ =λ∀h9βi"Vλ117p\2⊂0zλ)`dfβE)2r~yz94X8z2r a<]⊂⊃bgc#λ0z⊂)T$VaiSεA)2Y4yz9~q:z2Y⊗b0z→]⊂⊂@4 Apr198 "4∀∩¬∩↓QCmJ↓aKGK%mKHA∧A]k[ KdA←_AG←[5K]if↓←\A[dAKCe1SKdAIKa←ePX@A⊃∃eJASLAB
∃IKmSg%←\Ai!ChAS9G←ea=eCiKLA[←gPA←LAQQKZ\A∪hA%bAgi%YP⊃β∂+'S∃εK;≠?⊗kπ04VK9βS}s∃1β∞s⊃βOF{W3⊃¬βK? ∞∪3eβv{Qβ *β∂'K∨+3πS.!β?W'≠'∪∃π##∃α
∩Bπ;,ε@hV=yVo.m_
∂∃@εEεB⊗VVVKVVVVKVVVVKVVVVKVVVVKVVVVKVVVVKVVVVKVVVVKVVVVKVVVVKVVVVKVVVFKVVVVCE*44\P4yP_P9v$Yβhtly revIpπ@↔⊃π∪↔C?↔!β?9π##∃αdK@∨α 9vv6↑,Vv≡T ↔"¬8)∩`$λ∩=↓QX∧0yH12rgλ6sr4Y4rr⊂≥4π refh KGβ!βO?n)β?→¬##∃β≤¬vnn]nBε}d∞ε.␈
LRπ>
tπ⊗.≤APW& Tε&O.8
∧ ≤X9NEH∃~ T_{sLl<Y;L<(≥x.4_x;
L9λ_O∀⊂4Tλ∀≥≠h M<xp~\yP:4→P3:j≥y2FE≠s⊂&4\βp in the AI c@=[[k]%irXA¬fAoK1XACf↓iQJAAe←a←MCXAM=`Aβ%AαAi↑↓Ekr~) WYa!S\AG=[aki∃efAM=`Akg∀AoSi!S\Ai!SfAG=[[k]%ir\@↓∪hAY¬giKH↓Ie←Zptf`↓CZ
∃β#=βπ⊗{WQ↓ βC5β|¬bβBλ≡π⊗NEaPPh)x LT≠yH∞M→(≠,≥YxH ={Xy.-\h∃
=λ∪-}~=X.L9λ∃
(≠9,↑~;Yd∞x8h ∀→Y1-M9Y`∞M_9β!.~→4LT_<Y$∞⎇9→ ][≡(
\;↑(∞∞[zY,>≤h≥
t≤Y:-↑≠→;,]]λ∪
≡| λ ≥Yλ∃
=λ∃lT≠8>!QY;Y∧∞<λ∃m≡~λ≠,≥↑(~ ≥→K8L≥y9⊗λ4w1`/mpatible implementations. There had
been soma hope fOp gettingqome coheRence among them. As far as I can
s` JX↓iQKg∀AMKCIbACe∀Ag←[∃oQChαβ+@/>M⊗&N\ABε∞l@λ
M=≥≠ T≥x<d 8xp↔[x64yZ2rεE≥4πwards creatine coHerence. There were in f@¬Gh@bLA→Sg@AS[a1K[K]QCiS←8~∃ae=UKGiLAYSgQKH\@Q'←[∀A←LAQQKgJ↓QCmJ↓EKK\↓MS]Sβ≠#↔⊃bβ#?←/3↔I1π≠=βSF P4-nVn⊗↑$εO~ ∀ε⊗OD
F}z -⊗:r∀∧∧6␈.NVv∂L]GJb
mvv*
x D∞~→3$ <Y( >Y8=
≥Yh≠L↑c"[ ≥Y⎇8,|<kH∧
X=~ ↑H≥~ ←(_<LT≤Y:-↑≠→;,]]_=
≥{\h
|H→6
≡⎇~;Lt→~8-L8⎇≤d Y|C!-Y=h
<Y≥l≡Y+H∧
~≥<d∞~→4LT~<h∞≥{95m =λ∪ ↑|h⊂m 9x P≥40w⊂≥42P'≥vq2`2 13
woulD ieply( @A!KeJAQQKrA¬eJ\@↓βYXAIKgkYQ`
βπ⊗)βCW⊗c'∂πdceβπ4∧⊗Nf≤-F(h.Yff/>4π∨&≡LV"ε}Mε/↔⎇≡6*pQ!PTNβ]→.-α4yx∞∧A⊂⊂λ)i$P≤7y:0X42P$[82y6~yx⊂-Ti$nWλ⊂77jλ<rz→αqnded. projected To take 18
moNths once it is fqnded. They are thinci@9JA←L↓iQJAYβ0XA_ZjXAα{@$λN ;e↓≠⊃7 '"β7π∂FK;∃β&CπQβ&C↔eβ≤∧⊗rε|↑Bε7]lFNvt f␈∩aQ"αα →g&/-I↔∂αβ1λ ≠→<[o αW⊂⊂⊃7y⊂"≠x44`., a Lisp machiNe wiTh biT-mapPed
dispLay. Fifi@MQKH\4⊂@@A%]`∪↔⊗c'OAlS↔Kπ≤C=αn∀∩2`*d∧∧6␈$λ$∀r}4∧V/-_6Fzβλ⊂⊂H44st x2y3≠y0
ance
perc@=]C@1∧≠?7C/#↔I9αβ'9βπ∪?∨K/≠E!βπ∪?+↔≥#↔↓β&yβ ∃¬∪↔π∪Jα7πe`h(%EKAI9↓∧Iβ ↔d¬⊗/6T
&/∨]JG4≥z;
D_Y(∞∞[|∀M≤=_<O∃A"H∧∧∃P6∧ ;]→.-~<|∧ u4peY4r7%dλ∃~ ←(~≠n (≥≠d
_=P∩H:42Pλ94y:≥pv⊂&Xqt4g→QεE∧J4W2Wλ:42P≠4πwest level of the inteRpreter) running by June, but
it Will be up th∞AB↓sCCd↓EKM←IJAiQ∀AoQ←1JAK]YSe←]5K]hAαK@~π⎇}&@=8π3GβEj4~yP4iH:42P≠wyz⊂_y4r4Xpr⊂'Y⊂0v6λ:42P≤97u"Xz9P0\P30yλ0yP6[yzεEαzyr`2pεACe∀AG←]
KeMKα!94Tjε∞3O≠Ah∀R↓↓α3O≠Aβ7∞≠#';*αn&&%i0∩αλ∀π6/.8
-⎇H≠p∪λ&4yxλ2|:2[22r≥4π make heavy use o@_~∀βE%h[[CAaKHA⊃SgaY¬rXAC9HAQCYS]NA∧A]k[ KdA←_A]Kn↓YCMOUCOJ~(∪MKCQkeKf8A
S]%gQKH↓g←[J↓iS[J↓CG↑X↓EkhA⊃KmKY=a[K]PAG←]QS]kKL\~∀∪IKgkYQbACe∀Aae←AeSKi¬erXA]SiPA5∪(AY%GK]g%]NAi]↑AG←5[KeS
CX~∀%G←[a¬]SKf↓iP≥β&KOSKN∪WS∃π##↔5ph)↓↓∧r&1α\j&Rur↓α';&+;∪↔ ∧π&Z
↔6* X
L↑↑=~
≥Yh≥
=λ∃
(∪~.x⊂6pXt4w2H40qFB∧z40]⊂;tv≠⊂12P≥yrs 5l ona co@9mK]i%←]CX↓[CGQ%]J\@y the malitary (Navy?). Projectedtk be ready in about 2.5
years.
Spice Lisp [CIU]. Dialect of MACLisp for personal computers. Will
use microcode assist. First implementation will be on VAX and
↓extended addressing DEA)20 by simulating the proposed miCpkcoDe.
It is uncLear @]QKiQ∃`AiQ∀A-β0↓C]HA⊃ εJD@AmKeMS←]f↓oS@3bβ ∃β/≠π 3(h(&3M≠CMβ⎇⊃β;∨ qα?≠4¬⊗≡N≥MGJ@λ≥~ ←(_<LT~;] ]Y→9∧
8:;MO(→Sn⊂22q≥qstw→FE∧j[:4v⊂≥42P8→y9wg_v⊂6pXt4w2H⊂40y→;pq2H4yP0]0tv0X62Wλ$7{r]2y⊂ 4hey
obfIousl@dAQCmα)β#?ε+EβSF QβSF+O*∞⎇⊗f@λ_Y$∞<x8ML(~3D∞~→2.⊂7{wβEy4Yt:↔⊗yrrP_2v7{H37y_wvvr[:9P7[⊂:44\nP()≠u2qj→r⊂:7H12P9→pr<P~wεE∧Ypy6<H_\\→ εA⊂⊂λ#90w≡⊂&4y\⊂-a2\5v2|WU⊂⊂&Paf4y\⊂24p[2qz⊂→7y⊂+⊂l↔⊂⊂→4w4`3hed. Many
∪a∃←aYJ↓gCKZ↓iVAE∀AkMK9iQkg%CgiS ACE←UhAiQ%fXAEUhASh↓gCK[LAi↑Aα∪∀4(N βO?fK⊃β'oβ3↔7,sSπSN{99↓∧kπg *β¬βS⊗K≠#∃π≠3/←/⊃βS#∞qβ'Q∧k'∨#"β ∀4PKπ;⊃π≠?7↔F{]β;⎇!βπMα∪O↔cJ⊃βπMε βSgεK∂π1∧j&Qβπ∪?∪W∨!04*␈##↔I∧∧FN∞L\7'≠!Q"α¬>L⊗v&≡,B∧f≡>ααE↑L⊗BJ¬T¬&F≡4εO~∞,V∞fO∀ε
π,↑6.∂,=αππ-⎇&.∨D
⊗ph!≡ε␈↔L≤&Nf≡O∩r¬M WJε≡,Rπ'/≥⊗v:∞Mrπ?-≡F*ε≡4εo.=∧ε}2 M↔∨α ≡0hP≡
w∨≡≤-F*ε≥d∧fO>¬b¬& Tε≡}↑
⊗f/$
ε∂~ ←π&.n=⊗}w4∞Fzε≥MF␈:
≡Bπ&t &(h!≡W≡.D f␈∩∞?↔∨&]Tππ⊗|}&∞n]≥f:r∧λ7/↔,]g&g∀ ∩π6↑/∩π≡\≥Fbπ ≡'"ε≡1PPO>M⊗fB∞}&O'L]bεNd ↔∨≡]\&gJ
H⊗v?\≤v*r∧
FF/∀∞6F␈]LBεF≡hRε∞aQ NN↑
F.n]nF∂&≥⎇bε6} ε/GL]f&.E\⊗&',↑7~∧HX2k∪∧∞vO&
≥bβ2
]vw&∞5`hR∧λVfO>∧αE↔↑Lv/↔5∀αj¬M
↔~ε≡4ε
π,\6}&≥lrε}d
"⎇ 9∀∧fO>∧ε6␈$ WG&]lF. Q!⊗∞&N,W∨≡≥lr∧$X5S∪αd∧¬&F≡4π≡F}]F"ε,Tε6Nm~6F.D 'JπM Rε.lDε}2∞Mε(h!≡7.n\↑"ph$∧∧l$D 4lMKTαj¬M
↔~ε≡4εv␈D∞&.∞MO∩ε
M↔∨α M⊗∞f\>Brα ≡BεO4
⊗w&]lF." ≡2ελQ!↔∨.<<W∨≡}$π&z M↔∨αd∧∧O"
↔~ε]}&*εL≡F
πO~ε/~ ≥f"ε ≡2ε⊗\]`hP≤|Vv/,≥FgJ =F.∞lXBπ/¬dαπ& ←∩ε∂,Tπ>␈-=⊗v:
⎇bε
∞ w↔&≤-F(h!≥⊗oεL]V.wL≡FN}edα¬& ↑&*ε ≡2ε⊗\Ybε
λHT~@,Lλ
≥<≠⊂∩[rs:0]4ww⊂→5yεEα|rpy≤W⊂⊂*~2|P7≠{P40]2P0wλ4vx6→vrw:_z4wwλ:40zλ6pur\P9wfYP:yrH7sεEαr|:2[22r_p292\ytw3K⊂⊂;t→w⊂:4→P87i≥0q62H4vx6→vrw:_z4wwλ4yFEαs0w4\t2r⊗λ4z⊂+Zv6⊂1→P:yrY⊂:7P_94w3H:x⊂0H3:v&≡P2|:→w22rλ;2y9ZwwεEαs7y⊂≥42P"⊃aVY_ ⊂⊂*4~yP4yH897u→qz2rλ:7P1→P4w⊂
⊂6ww≥49WεBεE'cλ0v6⊂≥42yrK⊂:42H897u→qz⊂:~0z⊂3Yw2y0]2r⊂:~2P6w\z⊂4w≥2y2y]⊂;pyH1v2p\6<FE≥42P+⊂l⊂$w≥2y64\x↔⊂⊂∪pw<P≤2wx6→P0y2H1wvvZz:2rλ:7P1≠z4⊂:~2P+ V⊂0w2βE$w:→y24y\⊗⊂0w→⊂0y2H4w⊂1_p⊂9t_x2P:[:4v⊂≥44yP~0x8"[9WεEβE'7`7 some comments as to why there are 13 pRojec@Qb\@A$AoSY0A]←H↓G←[[∃]h~∃5kGPA=\AiQ∀@E←I!KdAI%CYKGβ#@~∩d∧∧l$Dλ
.P4z9H7{w⊂≥44w3K⊂0w2λ0P87\80q6→FE4v\62vr[:0z4[w⊂3'\α it make@LAaKe→KGhAMK]gJ8@A'Sαk'3π⊗ce "
↑F∞B}4πε/<Xλ.,zβ"M≡h_ ∞l<↑(
≥]→<L↑⎇~;LT≤≤[m,8⎇ D∧∩;@
←(≠p_~w4wwλ4z⊂ )pεABAαk?K∃πβC/7Lε6NvqQ&∂π∞-v∞≡∧
FF∞d
FF␈<Tε⊗.≥lrπ∂<X ∧ ↑(⊂~~2P$g≥2y6$\βp oR MACLisp people, and
theq`
AMα{3/M¬;?W3 β#π[*β ↔↔pβ←π∪bβπ'm_ l\α⊂:7H12P![wx2`2ating h O@⊗)β∂3|ε6.gα#"N⎇=~⊂∃z0t than↓iQKr↓CeJ\α↓α?W⊂∧ππ⊗βzP∩Xz⊂4`3 stbictli a shop¬`⊃↑LW-αP3 )x to a
∃Gβ∪'S'≤∧⊗bπ∞-v⊗@→; ⊗λ0p∞d↓` ↔G,¬↔,<h⊂⊗Zw0vp[⊂2s &ort.A)QCPASfA%ifA←αs3dQ(
}|z0⊃≠2P5 5pπiSM%GCiS=\\@A%\AiQ∀AQ←]≤Aek\αβ←¬β>K3 "∞
&}⊗≤-GJπ|≥g"πMtε≡F⎇z6(h,⊂ε&N≥H ,>λ≥~ ≡λ~0→H3wtg→P:7P_2P0{_tp able o@8AaKeM←]CX↓[CGQ%]Kf\4⊂⊂∀
v{]β≠|ε"π& T∧NwLZ&fO>∧ε∞vD T ≤M~7απ∞-vF.>N2bα
Mε/J ≡&*ε≥IBε∂LLVoπN4π&@c"R-↑≠→3,]]λ⊂∩↑4yz4[3P6 [3zpsYyP3 /p∧A]Kβ9β#π⊗#←πK*q↓απpβS#∃ε≠πO∃∧{⊂∩∧X_4fO>↓PW& [∩ε∞L∧{d <Y(∞N↑:;Lt≥≠h =→8;D∞<λ⊂-lλ→→.l;≠t∧∞~→(
L9Y⎇,≤y(⊃N↑]~→.%Hλβ!!αA*4→P w:→y24i\⊂897Z2qz9H0y2P_wwy2~w0z2Y⊂;tj~⊂2pqZ⊂7z4→y⊗⊂ ]⊂62p\z⊂4gλ:42FB9rw9YP:40]⊂:42↑P0p∩e adl impl@∃[C@;&K;≥β&C∃βO∞k∃β3∞s∨Wπ>)1↓α∞cO=1∧¬W.≡∧
v ! Y~ T∪~4n∧_{p∩→P4yP≤βhabed. HowevEp∧ACAββπK↔w#3eβ&C∃απw#↔KM≡7αα,i↔π≥8;↓QXεpqZ4s2Qλ∀4W2Kα the part done in assembly l@¬]OkC≥JRASβ→βK↔d S'[,ceβ3∂∪∨*AQ&∞vD
FF*∞↑6/∩
→g&/,l⊗≡*¬ Rv:d F.↔\|v/∩∀λF/ε]lG
π↑ vrεL↑F∞NL4ε}2∞Mε*π>L⊗≡XQ(
=λ⊂⊂\2P24Y32y2[:⊂3'\α diFderent machife@LX@A)!kfAiIC]ga=` @&≥lr∧NnLWε@~<p_βE0 c a faiphq @5CU@?⊂∧ππ⊗⎇( ,> Hλλ≡h→P⊂\⊂0qP∩P1pwλ9rrVλ842P≤93u %cts @=iQKdαβS#πph ∃≥)∀w4≥y0→→P92`)mple@5K]iCQS←]f↓←@→β&C∃β[Lε''8;λ
\8z~-l(→P↔\α particuLar~∃αCπK∪> C∃1∧εvO&∧ fzπ ≡'&N>X ≡H≥~
}9z≥∧ z=Q-d≥≠h∞
|Y_,-9~5∂∃β⊂⊂$H:44g~β S@%$~∃@#|εε/~∞MrεN↑λ M}Y(⊂~~4yWλ*42P≥yrs 5ljesS kf @QQSfAAaWUK
hAoS1XAEJ↓C@≠≠,≠S↔⊂hS eβ>C=βO∧{;O?↔→βS#,¬Rbπ=→f≡* 8 .∞α0tgλ3:w2~w3P0\90w3Yvrw:≤P1w`5ld result↓S\~∃α βCK⎇βK'↔& Ceβ¬∪?∪W≥!0∩α
Mε/⊗T
↔4_(⊂→Zw3v"H4pw:Xv⊂:4_z⊂0x≤64riH:7P [6εE$[82y6~yx⊂+→y9t`/ns& YP QSβ→β'M∧k?K∃∧K7C?↔#π;Q∧εFF∞d
↔"π=x
-l≤kW!Q@εE*~2P&`Pd∧i`'@Aae←αS↔∂S~βπK∃∧s?Qβ∧ CC'≥+3πKdπ∩ε≡⎇x LM8π0z→r⊂∞ Eachob them i@L~∃@'oβ3↔↔,sS'lpλ M9YQ. ;] M8;⊃,>≤kλ∞⎇=~λ∞p¬parate (or non-existent)
manuals, In dπCMKβ∪π1β&C∃α3O≠Aα↔∞≠#';*βO.]↑2π&t ε∂6T
FF*
]w∨" hV∂'↑,W~@β"P⊂[2⊂:4→P7z4→y⊂24Xv2q`4q are probably more or lEpπfAgUEgKiLAWLA%h\@A=HAiQ∀~∃GkIaK]h↓ae←U∃GifX↓iQKe∀ACeJ↓G←]g%IKeC YJAI%IMKe∃]GKf↓S\AgQsYJT4∀@A
IC]tA1Sg`A%`
βSF)β7∨≥!β∂?w≠↔K[∂#'[∃p↓αS#/Iβ←πw#↔⊃β≡{7πSFK;≥β/4(≤∧=-≤z{⊗%D≥<p∀[3P2l~yz4w→P:2aZ70∂lOdπr\@↓∪hAo¬bAI←9JAS\↓
"∞⎇εN≡↓Q O≡
x
-Lλ~→-Nλ~0~≤β transpo@IiCES1Si`%ph!↓αdK@∨α \⊗≡F≥lRεO4λ
(≠;nz⊂90Y4qpv α FIp¬ghX↓ShASβ→βOS∞s∪π∪|s∃1β>KS 4PK7'∂⊗{∂?∪*βGWC∧{@↔ Hλ
<8{p↔→⊗⊂4`4 has every hanguage deature o@9J~∧∪
C\ASαkπ∂'v)β↔c≤+CQβ4{@∩π>λ⊗.F↑NFJπ>L⊗≡←5dα∧⊗α;X-M≤∧V⊂~z⊂9z\87y:≤FE∧j~2P14]⊗rpx≤2r⊂"~yx6 !y( @AQQKrA KYSKYJAiQ¬hA[C9rA←L↓SifA→KCiKβ∪↔L4PK∂?Wd!β/;dπ∩ε⊗TλF}vT vrπ>λV≡N≥EWπ<Xλ /pπ@∃βF C∪←∂∪∃ 2∧
FFO4 VN≡∞AP@!<≠p→\βiblY be @Q` πn>ε␈↔L≤&f*∞Mrε∞β[p~~2y⊂ -icro@
←@∪π⊗c∃β7∞≠#'lTπ>OM↓P@!<z0⊗Zv0q capabilities _Aβ## ?\⎇αεVβh⊂__y:4a]v0q tho`+≥Q`⊃β> Eβ∨M3↔9β&x4(≤∧⊂↔\αp CE%YSiR8~∀@AMaSGJ↓→Sg`↓C]HA9∪⊂ACIJAS\↓`∂?7*β@≡9\y$ {{<∞
{:0→YyP∞ They are Atp K[Aif~∀%ChAGαc↔π≠L¬f 4≥<λ∞M→(∪mLλ≠⊂⊂[3zpsYP22`3icn, and @QCWS]≤ASC]dAP∨→∧εFF(β"B,@wwr~p2pyH4πf Lisp Machi@9JA SM`XAEUhAM←β⊃βO?n+←#πα@λ
]|Y#!↓8{p↔≥2s:4[w0v⊂≠pqt4[2yW At @QQJA[=[@↔n@π&F↑8 $∞≤[p∃→qz1P≥0p k↓iP≤4PK↔π∂@∧ε␈& X ED_Y0~λ0y2P≤4∧anning @Q↑AS[AYK@7,¬g"π=x ,↑z_=∧ ~9P∪→y2w:βE dialec@Q`
2∧
FF/∀λ
l↑Y(⊂→]90∂ngly e@9G←ke¬H∂.Dλ
t≥_;
P:7P→pqt;z42`2,∧⊂∀!~FF/∀λλ. (_[nMλ→z.m8π3@ tho`+≥Q`⊃β&yβC?α.F∞⊗α;⊂∀]<V⊂ 4hh∂kO A'!∪
AS@_h ⊂Nβ{[∂∀~;] ]Y→0∩λ8∧o @ JAa←β∪Sπ d∧Rε∞β;p↔→β pe@I`∂?;∞aβ'π≤¬εNv↑4π>OM↓P@!8y0→≥0p n↓GCaC SYSi%Kf@8hP4*SF)β ≤pλ∞≡9<p~~ww⊂ )pεP⊃β>CeβOzβ7πo∀ππ⊗⎇( ,>≤kh∧λ<h⊂∪_y⊂0yH$P1`!n se@∀X⊂∀- W,(_<LT≥~→$
]<p~~pε`∪Gα S'⎇n3@!α@
MD@_@4AaQSβ→β'M∧∧∩εV↑pλ
L8π3zXpπe @⊃KgSO8XAoSβ#!β∨,s↔Kπdceβ∨|¬v"ε≤LV∂~βH∩.D~_<aQ@∧q2Yw⊂;"\αy i@9H #W,¬g&N≥Dε}r
lW><H⊂∩→{2v'\4¬entpεAS\αα3'Oαp4)↓¬+Sπ∧¬Rπε
_ d
<h⊂⊂H92y`%arch↓ae@?T∧V∨"
_ D∞≠x] ≤X∧v )ty, @¬]HAgα+↔7M∧εFzε,QP@NMx
-lh≥Q.<P3w[p⊂;w\5P∞ In retr`∨@≤εε.∨EDπ&FTλ∀Jε=x -↑8π4`4y wo@UYHAE∀~∀'o+∂!β⊗+S@&↑ λ
|YH⊂∀Yα Utah had dec@%IKHAβ#=β∪zβS#↔Lε"π⊗↑8 ,≡Xz⊂≥ytw3CE eIther↓∪]iKIYSg`↓←dA≠¬β⊂∪'≥↓1↓α∂→β'Q∧¬↔5α⊂:4→|P40]2P0z≥2rx*→p⊂:7CEqi→pz2P_P72kH24pv→qz⊗⊂_w2⊂'≠P7w2H4yP$[82y2\z2r. Probably theip α Worc Will Be ignored p % These projEcts Are simply transporting INterlIpπ`Ai<A←iQ∃d⊂∀(Nkπ∂#Ls↔M⊃∧εvFN=εO~ ≥G>∂≡4πε.≡9vv∞-HR`$λ∃~ T≠{[∂∀≤Y8-D_|Z.M8z<mQ"B: ↑Y(∃m};→λ ,(≥~ ≡λ~5∧
<h_$∞z_;,T≥~_.D≥~→/∀_x;D}λ→→.l;≠|↓Q@∧r2Xt77`,ocq @Q↑Aae=IkGJ↓BA]Kβ9β'7∧c↔7↔w#πS'}qβ7∨⊗)βGWL∧6@=≤+@⊂λ!:zεB∧z44\β ic wha`(ααNJ%∧επε@|≠p→YyP:7H27W I`≤A5rA←A%]SO\αβ'QβLε2ε∨-_
≤x;β!↓9[p→λ840zλ897`*ect @Q↑AEJ↓IW]J↓S\Agβ+∂!βλ∧π>∂∀λ
=λ⊂~~2P92\βu`→ILACeJ4⊂λ'C,∧&fN5aP@$λ∪0(d∧i`'β↓↓5βLεBεO4
Vv6βx]∞]X9→$∞~_=∧∞{h⊂⊗]qt⊂ 7or`⊗AαK@~ε,X
-lh→≠ml(≠p↔λ&`af~yxεEαtp∞ @¬\Ak]
←←eI%]CiKα!β@>≤ε+D∧∃~→.2P4`3 some evi@⊃K]GJ↓iQC@ ∧ε.∞=↓P@!<≤[m2qz is made u@@AP∨→α∪SKW*β ↔∪L∧W6/,4"π≡
tε⊗.M_ .l(≥~ ≡λ≥~ ↑Y(⊂∀\β
α @1SiiYα)β .↑-↔"πMtπ&FTλ nM→<\eDλ∃y$
→8<LD_(⊂→[vr{t_z⊂0v]ytw3H1wvvYw:εEαq<P /ne. He s@¬S@ASβ!β@>≤∧p↔ z⊂:9≥p¬ that there @]CfAGαCπ?M∧ 7?;8∧π&FQQ LL_9FO∨∧
ε.␈
H %@⊂⊂$`4 p∂C@~β#@/>@λ∞M_8
there p∂Ke∀@hAI%H ≠↔⊗+;@4PKCK∨T∧V∨'4λv}NβY`⊂~w⊂∩ diff@∃` ↔; β∪'K,≠S'⎇n2breaP@@ ¬"`6eryo@9JAgKα+7Mβ&yβ ↔d¬⊗/6Tλ
=λ⊂∀]⊂4qP_P3w`/d idea fo@HAaQKβ∪∃βSzβ ∃β|¬f.}≥lphW⎇x MP7w bh∂iPαα';S,ε&fO>∧ε∞vD T ≤β~0→\↔⊂⊂$[8∧erlisp Tendc th∞AE∀AP↔|∧Y!QX{p↔≤βar`-α S'[*β'9βLεG4→→5L]≠x∪,]] @⊂λ$z⊂ (as goo` u@MKdAMα ∂'M_
≤αyP [2εE 7ell-coordinate@⊂Agkaββ?KQp∧α∧↔↑@λ∞M→<Y$∞βpp∪ a su@Iae@'α8
-lh_p↔[1rw9]yP∀:~0zεE~w1v 5ded @5←ghAα{⊂∩πM R∧Nβ]→.4∧ic@@A`↔O,ε'5(≥~ ≡β"H∧¬(∩0↔≥2y6 )pπ`ASβ→βGWLεF*ε←∞ε.w=_
LT_{p⊗\0y2`$ po MAC@→Sβ≠@$$∧αj∧α;] ↑Xε4`3p ac a di@¬YKGhαβ3π∂↑+⊃β¬∧¬g.n,X D
βs⊂ )mpobtant @→KCiKβ∪↔L4PK∂?7∧∧↔ε.Dλ
t⊂ε`aS4yx⊗λ0p∞d↓QCHAαs=β'oβ?KS∞sQβ≠,∧↔'<Y0→H4p `'β≠';≥∧¬⊗p@ ¬∧fPa` i@M`\A≥=iJAi!ChAi!SfAGα{77↔w!βK↔4∧W.h≠p↔≠<P:7H30q`)liti@∃` 4λL∧6}nβ;p↔≠<P:`3e`λASαqβCK|∧w,8εyVλ50∂`(αβS :∞Mε*π↑8 .⊂9z`0ph∂e@ ∧ε.wm_ M⎇Xεr`.t.~∀%≠C@;JβC↔|∧⊂⊗→P12`,i` mJ↓iQC@ ∧εNr∞Z6/∩∞8
.∞≠x]∧ 8π:2\αh S@≤εαεO4λλL↑≥→0→βE `)!C\A≠¬β⊂∪'≤εααF← 6/πDλ md≥~→$ ~8p_λ&pqd~w2V⊂≥t2y2H&`af~yx⊂ 2eadlY
∪@≤¬εNv↑5⊂hUM∞W4≥z_.D≥x<d
y90_~w3P 0eopl@∀AoSi A∪Mi∃aP∪'≤εαεO1Q"ααTλ m⎇yλ⊂~\β` dAα3π∂'d¬↔&N↑1P@$λ ⊂≥42P &act @QQChAα 3 "
_ .
α2vr[8∧a`)%←]fA¬aJAGα{7CπαM⊗⊗@→#"D∧ (⊂∪[wr⊗⊂_wvx ,ete @⊃←Gk[∃]`∪παM⊗}pQ$ααj ⎇v}α∞8
.∞≠x :βE
To the h∂kiMS@∪∃∧¬v↔≡↑.f/∩
_
∧ <≤⊂∩Xy2r tha`(αβ'9β&C∃β3|¬f 4≤X
`. MACLisp @5SGQh4⊂ 'dλ L≤⎇λ⊂~_urP /ver @%H β'α@λ =⎇;⊂∩λ27P 4he f@=YP∪?>K;≥hhQ↓↓Tλ n↑≤≠⊂≤H842P≥yry d¬CGSαc'S'-→β >dλ
(≤p⊂[p¬ pOw` dAα @~∧α;] ↑Xε4`3p#s, or~∀%IP∨∂,¬V.wDλ
(→P⊂Xz⊂:4_z⊂4`4 a`→@⊗+π'α(⊂∀_yP:4→vP∀4Yα itdkes - @∩Aβ#π/∀hP';tλ
}z=~-⎇H≠p↔λ:44`3 que@MiS←\$~∀@@4ACOe∃JA←\↓BAG←αk7?9εcπ;∨, ∨∃β&+∪'≠LεFN}eDπ>OMε/GL]g∞Nβ{\d Y|@⊂≥42P&~yxεEαdpqt~w2P [2⊂7`4hers who Nead @%h⊂∀$∧αjπ∞-v'.<Tε
ε=x .
α2z2H4pw:Xv⊂ @MQP∨←Ls⊂~ε≥H ∧∞~→(∞↑y<@⊂→αaci@1SiSKLAC@; ∧ε⊗.≥lphPα8p↔[vp∂n↓C[@?v9β'↔∧c↔7↔w#πS'|sE 2∧λ∩ε>⎇xBε6β|[$ Y|@⊂≥44qP≠tst:λ12P CE lOose-leaf binde@HXAg↑↓iQChαβS#↔Jβ∂?Wd∧Bππ-}fNεT ⊗&&≡M⊗}v≥Dπε∞|↑0hPα8;LD_z_.∞→<\d [|@⊂≥42P&~yx⊂6Xqt4w→V⊂0w→⊂62jλ<wrP≤pv2q]⊂;t4XtεE∧Y2q:sYry⊂ !nd editor you wanted.
α - somehow assure useps outside MIT thatthere was a central supporp
organization that would @IKga←9HAi↑↓iQKSHAG←]
Ke]f8@@Q)!SfAg∃K[f~(∪i↑A JAieUJXAEUhAiQ∃eJA[¬rAEJ↓BA!∧αβCK?⊗c↔59Hh)↓↓hβC?O≤K 3e∧#=βO|¬V/&
→f 4≥≠h
≡{{_.L(≠[me325∧∞<y0→≤β from the hacK-of-the¬
waek↓GYkD0AgQSαc∃βC⊗+O/,h
-lh≥~ T→X8nD≥~_.D∪88mM<|λ∞⎇8ε6⊂_ww:4[:rFEαz7P2→{2v'\⊂6wi→P0ss\2yyd]2v<P≥40w⊂∩w:2y≠4yx↔λ⊂$z~yP:w_v2pyβEp↔hether theRe is a real problemhere or aPR pRoblem.
α
I am not Convi@9GKHAQQChAQQJA≠¬π→Sg@AM←Y-bAGC8AI↑AQQSfA%H β3.3QβSxh+@& YW≡.LlW
RλMε/⊗T
v∂~ ⊂ππ⊗| w∞∞Dλ
=λ⊂**⊂(⊂⊗Zst:⊂≤βomehow be able to
causE it @Q↑AQCAaKL\4∀∩¬
αK;π∪gIβS#-∪∃β'~βS#∃π W/>M⊗}r
x D∞z_=∧∞z;≠∧
_<⊂_→w⊂72↑8∧ as far as
Hardware acquisItion. We polled represe@9iCiSYKfA←_AmCe%←kfAUgKdAα;K/Wπ→8$*n{OQβ}1βS#,iβ#π4∧R∧$X5S α}4ε∞vD¬S∪α}5bα¬M WJε≥IBπ≡∨∀π&FT
∧%αβ($∧
<h→ \9 β!,]=λ ≡Y(≤nM;≠λ Mz;Yd
;|⎇∧
yH∃
:<@∞⎇|Z`
⎇H~0~ α HoweveR theRe are adso a
significant number oF peoPle who use VAX as their primary system. Some
gf these are using Franz Lisp. It seems fIne. Bp hA5C]rA¬eJAI∃caKe¬iJ~∃α3?Iααh∃B∧≥nF/⊗M~7αr∧λf/:∞ V␈εLTε∂⊗Tλ7/↔,]g&gα(⊂~\ts3@ pers@=]CHA
←[akQKef~)MP∨I∧kW∂!bβ?Iβ-3↔9βF [∃β&+∪';LεF*π
H⊗w~∞Mrπ/<Tπ&F]P D∧∃~→$
8:;D∞≠_8l↑h≥~ ≡β"P.,(~~,]≠≡( ={;:.Nα2r are
MIT, where most Lisp Worc ipεAkg%]NA→%`∂Aαn ∂#'v+L4)α↓α
p¬Bπ>
_λm∧~<h ={;:.Nα2r th∞A∃∃` '∂Fx4)↓αα∞ -UDπ>F≤=αεO4 6}n]_
∞L9λ∃
t∀|∩,<(
~-d_(⊂→[vr{t_z⊂4g→2s4g~z2P3≥z:y2JT∧
PARC, @]QKeJ↓[←gh↓→Sg`↓o←eV↓SfAI=]JAo%iPA =YaQS9fAC]⊂A ←e¬I←f~(@@A⊃A Q'k5KpRX↓oQSG ASfA
←[[SQiKHAQ↑A ←1aQS]L~∃∨i!KefA¬eJAQ∃IOS]≤AiQK%`AEKQbAoSQPA←]∀A←dAQo↑AKaaKeS5K]iC0A[CG!S]Kf0A←d~)CeJA)kghAAYC@'rβ←π'&K;≥8hP4*?pβS#∃ε{S#↔∩β#π; ¬Bπ& Z&*ε≤,Rε
nVn⊗↑ ε}∩ 9voεL≥⊗w'4 v $_(⊂→Yy0wj\FE1`(ortage of cyclEpεP→↓¬##∃βn{GQβ4{∂π⊃∧¬↔4⊂∧ ⊂P-Sumex. Thqs There is sOma~∃ββK↔O∨+K∃β|¬b∧
*λ∩π&tλFzπ=x ,↑~~;LT~;;,\~8= ]≡+@⊂λ$( ⊂~yP8)→yyzi~w3P*~2rP:≠FE1:↑P0P ,arge ergeP kf Dolphins. There may also be pressure from
elsawhere, but iT wac not clear in this meeting. A number of other
peOple have said That Id ARPA doepεAO↑↓iQSf↓oCrX↓iQKr↓oSIX↓M←YY=nT@A kh~∃→KnAa∃←aYJ↓←iQKHAiQC8A⊃!αβ≠↔↔bβGSK}s∨3e∧+;/W>AβS=∧≠?77LεBπ&tλF}g
⊗w_Q*vO&∧
FF.≡ λ
}{H∪-⎇Y>+∧∞9[⊃.≡h⊂4Jλ(→≠l↑hπ⊂⊂∩pε ARPA does$ Then it wiLl ∃E∃G←[J↓BAIJ↓ICGi<AgiC9ICeH↓C]HA9↑A←]∀AgC]QbAi↑↓EJAYα+≠Aβ␈+Q9↓¬β↔?Cd)βπK(h+∂?v≠↔K≠,∧Bπ& ≡Bπ& T∧&@|~~-d~<h ∀_Z=∧∞≠{h∞=≠⎇h¬ <≤_.,;]≠∂∀_8[n↑λ +f$≥~→!Q\≠ul↑H≠qD (∪∩.x⊂&pXt4w2JTε Dhe feeling↓SfAi!ChAB↓sCCd↓CG↑A%hAo←UYHAQ¬mJ~∃α∪↔↔9ε β∨K, Qβ'&+¬ " .W"ε≡N2π&≥\Rεn∨∀εF∂lTπε∂>8V"r∧
FF*∞
&}⊗LYRεO4
FF∂AQ'&F↑,RεO4
fzε|.fN␈↑4ε␈& X D x;Y
≤_8
2Kα @Eople a` mSβ≠↔↓α
∩B¬β&yβ3?|YβπK␈+;⊂4T∧6∂⊗\h
-M≤∧P 4o se@∀ASLAβ##↔K*β←πOp∧w"π=yV/&
→f*ε,↑G&/%`λ∧ {Y(∞∞Yx[ ](~0→H:40zβE;t0]2{2`2 it @%`
β7/≠QβO-βC?K α';S/∪3'Oαq↓αSG+EβSF)α3'∨↓β7π≤C';∃¬;'31ε{;3dhS←?KZβ' β&C↔eβ>K3!βπ+Qα'w#↔K∪O≠A6⊃∧¬vrε≡Ebα¬M
↔
ε]≤vG" ,Rπ&\9εvN<≥FgHQ( L\<z0⊃≠2V⊂1≥z⊂:4→P&4i\⊂&pqZ4w2P≤2wx ,e aben't interested↓S\AI=S]NA%h\
∀!/QKi!KdAi!JAg[∃YP⊃β|1βS#∂!β'W≤¬αεn⎇lWJπ⎇≥Fbε≡-w/≡T
FF.≡ ε∂π X
≡→(∀L]8:3N1"]≠d Y(∀l\9KB$
~→( ,<Z0m
h~4md⎇λ∀.]=→(∞,89≡%D≠[tD <Y( ≥↑(⊂↔]42y perc@=]C@0hS∂?7π+S↔K~aβS#|εV.B
\⊗wJ ≡&*ε⎇`π&FT ε␈⊗α8
/n. The o@9YrA←β##↔I∧εFFNlpλ∞M_8
εBαcoeLd be dkne quacKly would @ JABAβ≠';∨d∧Rπ<y0→λ+ lελ9t4`#h DEC i`∪O!hAEJ4⊂ π d∧RπεtλλN]8ε2 i` Ai!KrAo=kYHX↓←dABαβ@≡n≥IB∧⊗⎇yfgJ¬ ∩¬∧J¬S α Z↔.Ol≥F.wE∃`hTHX2εF≤@ε
π=→f>fT
W≡∂$
∧%αβ(λ@0, which would @ JAC\αβ'β↔∞aβO?e+S'∨p¬Bε↔↑APF&\8
,L9λ⊂↔≠z⊂:7H1:t`,d id. The gueSpεASF↓iQCHαβ↔[↔p∧∧
∃λ⊂λ
≡{I⎇∧ (≠⊂⊂\3rFE→w3r`'h cuSth∂[Kβ⊃βC=∧∧6∂/<T∧$0h⊂~≠P27P≤wvr`4hi`≥Nαβ'Qβ⎇##↔K>KG*∞⎇w.fM` nD→≠kAQR9H∞M→<Y$
<h∪M}~~0↔→β be@QiKdAβ##πdλ
(⊃≠mN~~0↔ ⊂ @⊃←\OHαβ#π[*β7W∂@∧ε}H_#! ⎇90→\β whether↓β%!ααβ←'-(
4Ph ⊂`@lLK(≡≤K ≤ P⊂_@801∪¬∃aP≠π⊗!αM→∧;C↔↔v∪↔K≥α↓↓↓↓α↓r?,XVv⊗↑,rε∂D TMλεfz[84q`3> Mulp SGβ→αS'nK;≥β⊗+@∨.LN2πX∧w2~qpz2Y⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ⊂⊂⊂⊂ →⊂ x≤αi`_@Drpb@H`jn[∃`∂P4T3@⊗@{*H∧∧λλ⊂L↑Xπ0y→⊂)W Gree@9EKeNα↓↓↓↓α↓↓`$|,V.v,X L@P0p∀↓≠∪([5kYiS
`
x4U≠W ,≠Qi↓∧kW3SL∧74∃~3-≥Yh⊂→→yzv 4pεAmSαs∪'∂∂#↔⊂4U#=i↓α↓↓↓↓¬∩B: ≡B¬≥UX∀Hh(8λg⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂!d≠q36p[↔2pvλ0z⊂&Rh⊂
MulpicS, @IC at MIP ≠≠ X∩)α↓↓β3M≠CSK∞sO3π&{CMβ∂!αNUl
$4λhR3πW>Aβ+?αDε∂" ↑Vg&≤:2εv} λ ↑9≥~,>h∪8,=~<|¬D_]0~λ0z⊂ ! pretty~∃α≠C@.LO∩ε␈ X E\{y→$
;<≠ ]9;] ≡~;{D
yH∪(~⊂p3Edλ⊃≥,T≥≠h Mβwz;[y1FE_<P!p\4⊂$7Y36pwλ0w2≠|yr`,d∧XAo∀AM←kαs⊃β?/⊃β∂?oβ'3↔∩β⊂≡∞lZ&∂&≥lphV<≥Fg~∞Mr∧t9yd
ε≥dπ&FTλ6}&Tλf␈∩
\↔ε≡≥d∩∧v\\Ff/>4π&@h≤x/∃≥λ∩
≡c"P⊃Xzyr`$ quadpatic time expansion in list-searching!
This was the cause of The 8X[gKG=]HAeU\\@AIKG←I%]N~∃5CaGC8ACfA∧A[CGI↑AWK∃aS]N↓ieCG,A←LAQQJAKαs⊃β?2βS#∃εc'OQε≠3↔[,ε&gJAQ$Jπ∞-v'.<\Bπ& Tε6}MMw>Nltπ⊗/>]G'~
|bπ>
≤6B∧∀λ⊗jεmtεf}l|W∩ε≡9ε∞n\G hPQ)FO∨↓Q"Ph%∞6/'∀ &∂≡Tε∪αr⊃Q# αaQ"Ff|≤Bα>|≤'BHQ*@hR∞LW∨"⊃Q#∪+⊗%`hR∞.Vw&≥\Rβ~dg∪β∪6%⊂hR |7&N\Tβ∩sFwβ≠;5⊃PW Q%π&/>E⊂hS&W∪∩pQ%π↔.nM⊗n
ε5c3;⊗εβ~HQ%ε>∨M≥V*β5g∪≠βvF2Hh.APRGL↑7"HQ&#+K%aPRG.]g&N\Tβ~sg⊗3≠+5⊃PRF|>FNnTε"s3VεcC∩⊃Q' h%∞↔.OE⊃PPh `{&5T∂π%Wβ
αε⊗#≠⊂~*∧:α↓_e∀ k$∧⊗.l=εn∂-4ααα¬λe∃∧yK∩Hh*MsRα∧
FO∨∞N&∞w=H↔&␈.4ε∂"
:Rl ∀∧αh) W⊗*D &.f}uBεO4∞FF* ,Vv≡
\↔⊗Z n&}jλ,W⊗↑]HWJR ≡BεO4
⊗rπ-}V>FO⊃PTn≤9FO∨∧∞7NwL∨αbε.X
∧
→=λ
\(≤≠m≥]λ⊂↔]z⊂0P→2{P 4hings about it.
~∃→Segh0A
5βπ%≡↓C]HAQQJA@QECG-ckOi∀RAgs9iCp\↓ ⊗~l
∞J=∧KD4+
β7π∂F ;'Oh∧ε&←$λF.6≥m⊗v:
\⊗∨⊗|4εNr \⊗≤f≡>αεNd∞vFN=∧π&FT f␈⊗QQ&O~ .&}↑]`εNwMtεv∞\XBε∂,}Vn.β]≤eD≥;[
≥y(≤nL9Y_.,λ∪8,9~<|∧
88tM}c"]m≡~λ~ ≡Y(→/ 8⎇≠∂∀ (⊂.,⎇;9-nλ≥z
≤zλ~.∀≥~→$
88|Mt→[|MT~=≤l]→H
λZ;~#!.~_=∧ [|[%∃H∃~ T_X8m>=;⎇ T≤};NL>λ≥ ≥y<h ∀→[tMT_;Y∧∞≤[y∞\y<h =y→#!.≠h⊃l]Y<X.L(≥~ ≡λ→Sn-+H⊂$ >_;.
→(~ ]≤→(
<Y.AQA"B,¬_=≠mT →*$∞≥<[N4~;]
tλ≠⊂∀\z⊂∪p]7vP"JFE∧p
9tsw≤⊂2P⊗≡∀P4`3 (liSt 'sIgnp 'e p)
λ ∃)!kf@1αa↓#∂|¬Vn
∀ ↔4≥~→$∞8π8z[z4w3H1t0y_qz2i α ∃
α{@∩ε← ⊗oεLUBπε X ED≠xp⊃]y92g_p¬s @=H ↓β∧≠?π≠αβa%βL¬bπε Tε≡}LQP@,Y;⊂↔]P::`2n into ⊃CQ←ZApαIβ e∧εFF* ≤7&N⎇`λ
|β⊂:4→P6pq\αh∞~∃ββ∂?↔4εαb∧HXdl 8∧Sd∞≤[⎇M≤→<h ∀→[tMT≥z~,=λ~0→H9zq9]4z2`4e` f@=`⊂∀ &C∃β∂∞c3'≠8∧ε -βy6@≥tz4_y3zfYw:9P_7zw2λ4w⊂*~2P7`"viouS ianner.
Here is the equivalent standard EacLisp macro def@%]SiS=\A←L4∃aG←α+⊂↔β!Q hP∃ F.7]`πε≡|Xgαε\≤7ε@h
≡¬⊃"B(∧∧λλλ∧¬≠~<nD x=
⎇(
_l≤α9⊂ 8)))
To pq`≤AQQSfA K]GQ5Ce@-∧K;C↔↔βK↔SO3↔3@∃D∧Jπ>Xv><⎇ ←≤_;LM9Y`⊂≥42FE≠pqy7\P7w1YV⊂2`)therat rea`λAi%[@∃β|ε"ε∂Dλ M≡\⎇∞8¬`≥i%[@∃9∧3?Iβ&C?O∀hS←#=∧¬f.∞Dλ
.D⊂(⊂⊃Xw⊂8)≠{4r2H844`3 fal@∀AgSi ASCGβ∪?Mβ,ππε∞βY→,E@εEεBαA`≥←β##↔I∧¬ε∞≡4λ M}H→→,@4p∞i@9H
βSF+G*
\⊗∨⊗|∧h∞wP:4_z⊂:4→|P0y→P2|8_w22bβE0∂nce only ic:
~∀!IKMk8AaG←α+⊂↔α
\⊗∨⊗t¬πBHβ"H∧¬λ∧6 !mbda(form)
α (rplacax c@¬dAM←β∪5%$hQ↓↓↓αCCC3∞≠⊃βAαC∂βI∧∧f␈⊗β**!QHλλ∧ Yx[%⊃ ∧P⊂λ≥{0v≥p¬ o@_A%!→¬πλACMgkKKα!βS=∧∧&*π]lF.⊗≥lV hαHλ∧¬≠~0→]⊂∪pz≠vP∀1Xp∧r @`RRRR4⊂∩*dzεε22β@≡9;<d∞≠h⊂⊃→P0P $eclaratio@8AP∨→∧b0≤≤→Dε'9Xp~~ww⊂'_vryWλ#3p∩↓≠CG→%`∂@4TI∨[∃∧∧6}n\X NL9λ⊂~~4yP']z↔⊂)T ¬CIAL me@¬]fAi!ChAi!KeJA%`
β¬∧∧vf@xX;↓Q]X;∞\αP1`%lhλAC9HAiQ¬hAES9ISMNαβ'Mβ'K;π]_λd
{H⊂~~0z⊂ #ell.
λλ
*F+K∃βLε2π≡ ≡B¬≤α1sJ∧→≠q.]
λ2) SIG@≥ ↓∪&A≥=(
α¬∧2NF
⊂q↓αRD)α~&∃~Qα&$*5α&p∧¬$DTλ∃∀≤I~5"∧~4∧ pQ)∀d⊂0p*ItH⊃IzH⊂siZ⊂4R*9sH∃ T⊗Q4IUα⊂"W⊃W⊗⊂∀∀dcg(λ&"P'
P S LON-NIL
IF AND OFLY IF TH@
A4
2V∃∧z→α9∧JMα¬∧rV&
-⊃α2⊗≥→αRα qα>I∧*F@,→D¬$z↓Q%T4Sh ~p1sJ∧⊃∪q*4⊃Su∧
Q0λjRi"P'λ*#P!⊃P ∂F L¬+≠¬∃$A)3A :\@↓)⊃
~)∪⊂~∩L~εB≡∃→α~>db6@:λI∧*¬λJαk ∧λ∃∀MI T-∧α0hλ→q0λ T$iggλ$g!j∀*ab$SβH
&X↓β∃λ~)'⊃∨+1λA¬
↓' → ↓ 1!→¬→β)∨I2t@A0AαA→∀Aπ
A8Aε@~)3
A[∃C]fAiKeO@αaα9βn+π;M∧s?QβT+@⊗←¬kPhPβ"J
*3U∩)U(_;LD
⊂uλ~∃0 P⊃aj$fQTP92]8¬rnthe numbeR kf microseconds of
potal runtime and Gctime. No@QJAiQ¬hAOGQS[JA%`
β'v≠3@.L\BεNaQ'↔∞nM⊗n
→b∧n≤9FO∨¬aPPh*Mε/⊗T
↔4_(⊃
≤YY<L]Xy( ,=≥y,]H_
dt_;Y∧ ∀∪∃*4h~;Dλ\X;O%λ≥z
≤zλ~.⊃"]~ ≡λ
h∞L8y4dεH_<L};93NNkλ⊂⊃≠z4⊂3~|7:v\P∀6pXt4w2H4w:2Yry9TH0w2⊂≤2z:`2ns
a fixnum as its result. PLUS takes any number of any type of number and
returfs the most @¬aae←AeSCi∀Aica∀A]k[ Kd\A%\AiQ∀AiKgQ`
β .c?]1∧¬vv*
x D∞~→3!QX∧yP→2yt`'ned to overflow the VAX machine integer pafge afddrifT into
BIGNUMs, which are any integer lArger than the archiTecture supports. In MacLipπ`~∃¬]HA
Iβ≥ )π##↔K*β'Mβ
αα&≡u*5βC∞≠'π/*βS#π ∧ε∞fM}w4≠{Y$∞≠h~ ≡Y(_m⎇]~9n]⎇<c!.{|Y∞4≠yH
\9;|O∀≤Y<∞,<y3ND≠{Y$
];8L↑KH∀muλ_Y.|<Y(
|H≥z ↑Y(≥
<Y( ≡Y(
d}h_;LA"T∪
Zi|kD
~→(∞prrP~yP:9≥p¬ f@=` ↓5ε ;⊃α$J~
⊗∀*0∀≤UDαRε≥lB¬$→XU~b¬tε∞vD
∃,⎇I_Tu"AQ#rε≥lB∧=(X∃$-*¬Bβb ≥f"∧HZ5≥αDλ .LiH⊃l]Y<Z,4_<Z.M≠95
≤h~4d {≠|l\λ_p↔[x4v"YεA3t~v2P9\2qtc~qP:<\2P4`3 ope@8AG←I∃H\
∀4⊂Q>%αAβaJβS↔O'→β'→¬Aβ'M∧¬v&"βC"AQLεP )pεA]k5Ke@'~α⊗FV a0⊂@ C"Jλα FFER1 @%`
β7,¬g&N⎇lV"ε,¬0~λ50∂d↓IKMS9K@vA%`
β;|εBε≡≥H \λ→P↔\α theq`
Ai∃cifX↓QWoKYKd\~(~∃⊃Kβ∪∃∨M∧keβS⊗ ;O∂⊗KCAβ|∧b¬≤→→B∧n≤9FO∨¬!P@HαJ≤l↑≥<
!QJ∩Hε∀ +@_λ_⊂∀,H_P⊂⊃8`@`@!0@b@DX A↓α↓E 3¬∃∩JQ%ε⊗.l8
∧εJ#"E
⊃uq*'αP⊂∩P`@9αε∪ 4 D¬∀λ∧⊂⊂.017 0,∧`@%αAA9AλεbβαβHλ∀JPεE∀_2s1`( 5)
(P@∨/∃$p∃↓αTαCαβHλ@14∧@`\@R@@!α⊂ F6mλ %@_≤∩) (0.Dj@`\β↓%%hQ# ↔v≠!↓EαH4)"α u 84O ⊂ X⊂∀2,∧jf@ ∧β
@L∧∀P
_X .\ff@@λεr`&-(λ@) (8.dpf@@8¬cKβ∃∃∩@ ¬∀1→w1t,X¬)
(P@∨/∃$p∃↓α⊂
$¬ -KFF(λ .832) (1128jbl@`rP→IKA%↓∧¬Le@≤P⊂∃6,749))
λ¬/QSα≠!α∀λ L≥H_p↔[x4v %d. @)%[@↔M∧∧↔ε*
_ D∞y8p↔[29WεB∧¬
The fo@1YP∨←L¬f 4~8h∞M→(⊂⊃→w1t6Xy0 .~∀$HI7KC8¬PhPβ"C!≥]U@; Benchh CE,Aπ←[5K]GKβ→`⊂@ ¬εE∞β;; Fp¬C@;Rα3'Oαβ ↔≠≤¬εn∂-0λ @90∂m↓
CiKαkπ8Q'3@4≥→0→]⊂397[P!2`2hπ@↔LX∞$ X8 `%d on↓aWY@L¬f}n≤≥Bε∂-_
αrz4XTε~∀4⊂ #∪,∧6f∂,TαG∨ Xλm≤8ε⊂ !ns c@=K@→β2β';
∧¬∩εZ∞≡∩π∨4λ
D¬↑
C!∧@ ∃C1aQB@)BT@Uα⊃)↓,8
P⊂
l *p q(A`∃)αS[πIαSe(Q!⊂Jα∧∧π$≤L@⊂≤α3 s@QCehAβ∪↔ME∧ε&/≠$λ L↑lj*!QJ→→,=_8 2H∀67`#alf @AG←KMα ∪⊃β∧∧7ε@≥<h∞ |≠⊂~\β1 p@AY`↔M∧επ&Nβ90→H8:4`-es1
p@QS[KfHAaiSαk↔MM∧επ=8εx⊂≤1z4`-es p@
iS@7,ε3λhαB"$∞≤≠⊂~\β1))
λ∧vvA→` πo$π/≡↑4εn∞=H
.x⊂40Xury<H42y2Nβ p∪←β)β∂πp∧π,=x 4]2P6 /ts o@_A`∨πβ_ e@∧¬∀Q⊃K@≠\≤7-βP8 /inte@IH∂A↓GAβe%∧∧αC@H
→l↑λ ⊂≤λ⊂πorder)(get ,@d@G←e⊃KdRR$~∀4RC∪↔≠n ∂Ktλ =y9P_λ∀2TP_∀0p∀om →J$R~)F#↔6β88n4π pZer`∨@α↓#a∀λλ¬∞z9{N∧→( ∂¬*""!↔⎇_],T→[p→λ_⊂7`2 0 ≤@h ∩FLXfn∞>-rππ,X Mtλ∧∀P dr x ) niL))¬
(pλ@Q
←]f@!GCdAβA%↓ 8 mnh
_l≤α9⊂,
P⊂81\6:yXH1P∀1Y29⊂,
TTTTJTFE∧HεA∀2→q:w pctimes (c p! (cond((pcOebp P) ⊃Gβ#'7↔~β
βAJH4(⊃⊃∩αα¬∞BαG∞9⊗oα¬ 6∂∩∞¬∩αG 8
≥9<l$ h
_lNH≤
%∃***!Q@εE∀→2s:wλ81z4[p¬s "α↓#
β@H4)↓α↓↓↓↓αC∂?;"↓!#;.c1βAJβ;'⊃Hh(%↓α↓↓↓#"↓#C∂|∧V ,9→⊂
1pp∩↓pR4PH$%↓αCCS'n+@~ε4¬ε≡∞N λ∂¬*#"A⊃ ∧P⊂
81z4[p¬s "αβ
↓β≤∧F'∩∂↓∩JJ∃∃⊂hPβ"J L9]3D∞≤≠⊂~\β ⊃p↓rR@Q
←]H@ QaG←α+⊂↔α∂
$¬≤_p_≠8¬s X y))
λ ↓ ((pc@=KE`AdR@@#ε≠C#W~βeβ@¬∃⊂hPα""$¬λ∧2`1 (car x ∩@!GCdAβI%$Q!⊂HJ∧¬ππ≡≥↑ααF<≡"πBα(
∞∞≠_
yLP⊂λc@⊃`AbRQGI@⊂∧πBJ∃∃⊂hPα""$¬λ∧87Zw:2`2dπ`@Q
CdApαI↓#∂∂⊃βe%Hh ⊂H⊃∀ααG∞8
-↑λ
_l≡H≡∀H∀81`0lp f@λ∧πJαα_p∩≤α p⊂R$RR4PH$%↓G!↓#C≤¬⊗oα¬ 6∂∩∂∃∩αG 8
NαyP⊃↓p@@#≤∧G$≤∧TTJTTTFBαλ
)F#↔7]`λ∞∞≠_
`31 ⊃p↓rR4R↓↓↓↓α↓↓#∂|¬f"αα
≠N]≠λ⊂≤
P8 )
λ∧∩@@@@@!FsW31∧π∩Jπα
#!∧P⊂⊂λ⊂⊂λ(t@QGCHAp@%αC∂πI∧π∩JHβ"B$∧λλλ∧¬≤_p↔Ypεadd (car x ∩~(∩∩%GβC '↑4αF≡≤N"πBα(
<9_ y))
∩QAaP∪W≠ ↓#∂&#@∩πα
(¬ y→≤D∂***%⊃ ¬∧Pλ⊂⊂⊂∀
≤ε (car x$@QGCHArRR4⊂λ%↓α↓↓↓↓F≠?;MαC∂πI∧παJαα_p↔[9P∀1Xp∧r @`R@@#∧εεg<hλ@ (cddr x ∩AβI%%%Hh ⊂J∧∧ααα∞@αF≡⎇n2αF<≡"πJ∀¬ε≡}n4αF≡≤N"πJ∀¬ππεL¬4f∀≤∧⊂∀_p∧d`$αβe%%JI%%$hP4)#&+⊂↔8π⊂(≤βi`≠`Q`≠π⊂∧πBHβ"H∧∧λλλ∧¬_{p↔→⊂⊂∀7≥v6⊂ 8) 0)
λ (ath∂ZAβA%β@¬⊃P@!(λλ∧∧λ
≡L↑Xπp⊂ (ca`$αβa%%αC∂π∪⊂∧πBJ⊃Q Jα∧∧ααα∞@αF≡⎇n2πX8@⊂≡∀TTTCE
(defu@8AaiSαk↔M↓GAβe%αC∂?; ∧αBF| αGπαY0→≠x⊂<) (pz@∃` ?∧λ∞%∃(
≤∂,<[j%⊃ ¬∧DBP⊂∀∧≤1wr`&p p⊂RQaGi%[@↔M∧παπJ∃⊃P@! ∧DPλ∀⊂λpCoafp y) (pctimepεA`%∧παJHβ"B!⊃(λ
¬ <(
<<H⊂≤
P⊂λc@¬` β@∃∃⊂hPα""$∧λ
≤∞tp
p (ca`$αβa%↓GβS'\X f∀λ∧1`$p p) (cd`$αβe%%JH4(⊃⊃∩ααα
≤
⎇8π:2\3x⊂∀_py⊂ 8) ⊃Gα @∩πα**!Q@∧DDH⊂⊂∀8≤βi`≠`QGC@⊂∧πBJ¬∞ε∨&≥\W
∂∀αF≡L∧@⊂≡∀TTTCE t (psi@5`@@#≤∧↔απ∃∀αGε>M⊗n<hλ@ x c@⊃`AbR$RRRR4⊂∩)F#↔ Wp∧ππ&≥\W6(
αO¬H≡*$¬≤≤[lTλ∧:Uλ;∀FEαD@ (setq r (setq U* ptimes2 y)))
∩∩$@AB@@@Qg∃ib@UβA)↓β≤∧F'∩¬+αRJ⊃Q HHα(λ∧∧λλλ¬ {{Y∧¬λ∧7:[4∧ *@`TR@QIKike8AjTR$R~∧∩$∩@@@@@@QAiSKKβ→Mβ@∃⊃P@H⊃∀ααα∧∧ααF⎇tε
J∃⊃P@! ¬∀2→pεun↓aiS[∃bd@QdR@@#≤¬vv"¬↓εw.β≠λ∂∃(≠Z-E εE∧BDP∀:λ∀81gYs0r2λ∀86*\P⊂λcAr *x
) ⊃G¬dArR$~∀α∩$∩@@@@@QaQS[KfQGCIH@UpT$@QGC⊃dAbR$~∀α∩$∩@@@@@QaQS[KfH@QGI⊃dAbR$RRRR4∀∩∧Q⊃KMk\↓aiS[∃bf@QdR@~∀@Qae=N@AJ↓jAFR~∀@@@ABbQG←]⊂@PQ]UYXAr$@QeKQkeLA9SXBR$~∀αQMKibA∀@PF@!GCd@)pTR@!GCdAβI%%$hP%#O-#Eβ
αCCS'n+E↓β≤∧⊗'∩∂∃∩αF<≤Gαα-↓"Jα∃⊃PPJ 9vv"¬↓ππV↑-wαε5∀αG≡↑N∩πJ¬ 6&'$ ∩JJ¬ vzε⊗⊂
%⊃ B(∧∧λλ묬≠x@¬
β:v , v) (> e (car @XRRR~(∩@@@@@@QMKibATT@@#≤+SEβ2↓#CCe+EEβ*Q↓#3M≠Qβ∃∧∧2JJ∃⊃P@J∧∧ααα∧¬π≡∂L⊂λ∂∀λ∧1`$dr y)) ⊃O<ABbR$~∀%α↓↓↓↓αA!eβ*↓#∂πα λ∞e*#"A∀λλλ∧∧λ
≤l↑≤(⊂d¬≤≤⊂⊗≥yP1P
1pr9λ;∀TTCE (cond ((pzerg` ↓FR@QMKibATT@Ag∃ibAlQaIS→H ↔I
βU)↓Fc'OQαC∂πI∧εbJαα_p⊂Y9⊂;∀JTTTTCEDPλ⊂⊂⊂∀≥⊂∀98≠0qp@
1r1≥∀P1TJTFE∧H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂∀9r]8P<P
1r29λ<TTFB∧P⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂∀→wP0XJTTFEλ⊂⊂⊂⊂_P⊂∀1[w2⊂∀
0s2
1r29λ;∀P∀∂⊂∀1`!ddr v) e)) (seTq v (cdd`$↓lRR@!O↑AB$RR
∀$QgKiDAb@Q
IdAl$R~∧@@@AD@QG←αs⊃↓↓F{@∩α
nVfB¬ 6'∩∞U∩Jα∧πλ¬ x9≤D∞*(⊂∩JT@
rplacdu ⊃Gα{;Mβ*↓#∂?w→β
↓F≠∪Iβ*I%%%αC∨=β*I%$Q!∩F≡⎇lBαB∞∂&/⊗βxλ⊂
9rz8H1P∀8≤4∧us (caddp u) c))) (rpl@¬GHAjQGII⊃`AjR$@QO↑↓HRR~(∩@@@@@QhQeaYα ∂¬↓F≠∪∪I∧εRJε5∃∩Hh$∧ααα TααG<ZG
πT¬ε≡&L π*J⊃Q"αα∧∧ε"α¬∞6/'∀∂∩αF<LG∩π∃∃⊂hP∃ 6}vD¬αFW]H ∧∂*(
∞,=≥4Md≠Z;¬∃*#"A∃≤y5∞∀→(
¬4
_x.$
ZαE∀λ_p.$≡**%⊃"B*∞<=≤ ⊂_P⊂8*~vryP
1pr9λ<TP∀_pr9
<⊃∀TJFA⊂⊂λ⊂⊂1Pλ∀1wg→⊂∀∀0[2⊂∀1Y9⊂:TH∀∨⊂∀_pr9≥TP2TJP⊂λsetq u (cddr u)) (go C)))
(go b)))
~∀!IKMk8AaKqAigb@!`A\R4⊂∩QI<@P@#p∧αG∂]x
≤9]⊂≠⊂→∀P
8zw`4ia`≥h↓\@dR$~∀%α↓↓↓↓G→↓#∂|¬f"α¬
v&'∧ bJπ¬∀αGλλ"%∃*#"A∀λλ묬≤¬2`2op n$AfB~(∩@@@QgKiDA`@QAiSKKβ→βAβαI$4!∀ααα¬ ⊗v"¬
v&'∧λ E∀λ∧9b]8P9P
8:4fYyP9P≤∀TTP
TBEεBα(deFun s@∃i`↔A∧¬fN`Q$ααG∞X
∞∞Xπp⊂ 'x !O←eI∃` $Q$ααG∞X
∞∞Yxλ∧␈(λ@⊂ wy22\α)~∀@Qakβ#CK∨α∧α?R∧4α>␈,LW% εE⊂λ∀9r`4q r (pples # ⊃pb@b@@@bR@!aaYKL@N@#J↓E↓EJ↓≥#Iβ ↓E%JI%↓m∧ε#jπα
}%?Jh#!∧λ
≤l↑≤(∀F$λ≤∃
≥9<h∞∧ , εε
*$π|L@πT , εε
TAQHλ
∞<=_ ⊂≤α3 (ptiee@LAd@bαqA%%Zβ@∪~¬Pλ∞⊂;t`4h fl@=CiS]≤Aa←SαsQβ∂|∧V ,X8p∀Yw:0∪
λ )
λ; tim`
Amα C'|¬0→H1wvx≥z0p∀ions @=H βC|εv/↔4λ l@⊂87`,yn`∨[%CYfX↓]P∨Q∧∧6␈.nM⊗v8Q'7π⊗≥nFNvtλλN↑λ~0↔_v:r4[3P3qH84vrH≥P8 2ovade acc@=k]hAα{⊂∩εul2`$≥~0⊗YU
λ∧vA !JAM←αc3 ?⎇_ L@P3:`.ctio@8A`↔O,ε2αG∞M⊗n*(⊂∪≠y⊂8 2oces@L[iS[∀AC@; ∧εO~∞Mπ/_Q'2α∧n,⊗wR↑:ε.≡≤h
,5A"C!¬→→1M\8|[d∞≥~3,Tλ∧∀P p⊂λ,(pq`≥i%[@∃%αa#OS∂#WMβ>≠S'\U∩JHQ!P@%→→1N]H_Y-lzλ
e!"H∧¬≤y0~≤P9z0\8∧ (ptiee)) ; Franz picKs( 60 perq` FXe]HAαsW7 -⊃β'M∧: 4)α↓#C↔GβSOE¬⊃β9%h!↓↓G≠↔SE¬∪↔MEαCCS'n)%$∀R↓↓#C-CCSO
β@∪∩
`
!QHλ
∞<=_ ⊂≤2yQ (ptime))
; @QQSfA=]JAe∃ckCe∃`
β L;;G↔~p4)↓αCC↔c¬#@∨
∞"2εr⊃Q"αα∞<W'
∞,W6h
≤∞M8εrTJF@
(h Sgβ!↓∂C|εv/∪T∧εrαα_@_H9z0y≥⊂92`31)(bDAeKfDAeKfHRQDb↓` ↔M⊂∧π,<h TJT@
(defuN b1(x y)(mapcar ' ⊃Yα 7 ∪λCAβMJCGW?&K↔;QαC∪#?∂!↓!T
2π∩∃∀β βεεββαβHλ∀JP8λ Y))¬
λ;instruc@QS←]fh~∀`-αβπ7LZ"εf|≤FNvuDπ'O TαG≡↑NWαHQ'2π& YbαF,]f≡Bε
$πh≥~
≡h≤r
};→λ ,(≤∀L↑≥≡( L<⎇ AQL¬P:~2w⊂∀_2w1`( 5)
; then (bench 10)¬
; then (bench 1∃)
;...
λ∞df5βadZ`b@@bHhj∪%A∞@@∪→aCMt↓EK]GαC7πKX↓↓↓hRS=iα↓β3'∨βSKπw≠3πS␈∪@~ε≤@λ
:+02$∧λβ"JM→(⊃J(3VH ,;Xp∀≠py5@~yP:7H92s2\92r⊂≥4π as: FRPOLY.
-ppg-
λ∞dh5βadZ`b@@bLdh∪¬∃aUCe⊂A&LA≥eKK] KeN@@@@@y∨K.+; ↔⊗9βπQ∧j&QY↑Vg&≤>3r~,SR∧j(∀uRλ,Vv≡
\↔⊗ZD W.gM≤74⊃];,,<\h∧∧λβ"J,9~<nNZ8].L9 1 ≡→.H∧εMλ⊂.∞Z;λε↔.λ(ε⊗L¬→~λ2yzεB)2r4\z94q≥z2rεP<X
GreeNberg.Symbolics at MIT-Multics
Redistributed
To: lispTpafslators at SU-AI, rpg↓ChA'T[β∩~) CiJh@@@@dfAβAeSX@Drpb@H`jr[∃gh~∃→eWZt@@@A Ke]CIHA&\↓∂eKK9EKeN@@@@@y∂e∃K]EKIH
βπ ∧∧lMEYW.gM≤7 pQ*7.⊗,\7#R∧
&+Rλj$ uαH⊂L]Xz≠,≡X¬V⊂∪zr:4XyP':[q2y9CE*7]λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂)(#H0z⊂)UV`dFB!q]⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ64yx≥90w9[0z7y≤β adSU-AI
¬
Here They are, And not bad at all ≤@↓¬KCd↓S\A[%]HAi!ChA≠UYiSGLA→Sg@~∃eKAeKgKαsSMβ∞c1β≠Lπεv
≥f"εmH ml(_<d
9;9,M8=→%D≥~≥.∀~_<d
Yh∀λIβ"SN]8Y4NT⊂82≠70
ks, number @
←]gSαs≥!β-#
9↓∧∪'∨;λ∧ε∂⊗T ⊗f@≠xp.L9β"L={]~,};⎇0→[<W↔π ⊂⊂!gY2P;p\P1w`-pileD, us@%]NAS9ciCYαc↔↓β∨KOS↔hh# π≡[GW∨&)βπl@λ ≥H_9
xh⊃ \Xεpq\4π ded¬SMSβ#'?9pαP≡∂=` nD_{⊂∩Xy⊂4`&
RPG's i@9achAαsW7 ,ε'4≥y4LT→→0m≥8;λ
}H≠p⊃]0p , pπ↑A∩↓ISHA%hAE←β#!β←∂K@≠Pβ"C!
α4qhβE∃εE
4∧oad ∂OCλdR4Tε@hR∞8W'<
#!¬≤¬⊂_H_W⊂⊂ ⊂⊂<P P_W0 0 (x 1 "αqA↓Aβ 0∪αα**!QJ_Y-lzλ E⊃ ¬∀8≠{ry= 2 (⊂,∧`blXrd@`8`R@P@X`bjDb`⊃↓αqA%↓A↓1AE+9IU↓α¬cαJ⊃Q"F⊗]l6BβU⊃PBG
x
l↑LεP~H∀_↔150491 0 ≤@αI↓!Aq⊃EIQ⊂παβαd∧
$¬ @_MX~P⊗8 0 ≤@αI$4d 42∞0/120,0; 42 usEp¬fH@Hh
β'w#↔Kπ≤εFO6UDβ ∩ L⊗.n⎇n2`hαP8N≤8π:2YP:y`%p¬f@BαyM↓¬0 DλQj#!↓ @↓AβY~εPx9⊗@81 !Pb`⊂&∃α≥↓L+@↔⊗≤L∩αα↓Q%&[$∧αεF≤8 ∞NX;\mL=≠p→≤β a`(ααNU6 I↓↓hR'9β&C∃α~α*∧`9α,P "enchmar`↔f0AaQJ↓GC@3dε2π≡
x
-Lλ_Y'∧¬∀∩!' )+@R∩4PI"
⊗t~!↓Ip¬⊂hPα*⊂HYβ!d 5*)
(BENAH !⊂,)~∀$Q¬ ≥
⊂@bj8R~(HH% /,∧⊃eQ C"@↓AlM (≡≤K&ε∀λ %Fπα0tjH6 ZM<β⊂0zλ!2y5Yv2|Pαwqz0[⊂;99H22q`)mal
Date: 24 Apr 1dpb@@λεSS+'&CJmλ:@hTn-vkRλ:5$
¬m&NH_=∧λY<Zl]→>#!*≠nH
M<|⊂~≤αa`≥g1Ci←eM↓gj[¬R~¬'UEUKGPp β?≥#π1β5∪@~εLXλm≥8;β!↓ ¬⊂$H1pw∪]⊂9rbH0p∞y peac@=\AM←β⊃β@/=_ L@P7q`4al f@=` β'wβWQβ|ε"ε←↑Nπ/"
_ D 8π<P_2s1`(mark∞
Why don≥hAoJ↓Q`↔O ∧εn∞αy(
≡λ_ ⊂≤αp @3*βS#π ∧ε∞fDλ N]8Y0→≤β abe dec@%[CHAβ#=βK,#W∂∀hS∂?;4εW∞Nβ{@
≥H≥~ T→]0~≥y2WεB∧Aβ∧π25-Apr-`b@@Bβ⊃QH_}&.∞βXY.3S)`9mbglIcs at MIT
Mu`→i%Gf@∪IJtA←α≠SπDλ
N∞h→→,=8εpvλ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ⊂→~P⊂x94`, 10∩pD@bjtLrAKgP~∃
e=Zt@A≥eKK] KeN]Ms[E←1SGfA¬hA≠∪P[≠kYβ#'∂LhROW T+∂QiααK∃i∧¬v∨&≥Dπ7↔4 F.≡≥\⊗`hαU≠g⊂⊂!iU l↔5~q⊂0zλ!"i%Qf"lFB1q]⊂λ64yx≥90w9[0z7y≤β atSU-AI
In-Repl@d[)↑tA≠KgMCGJA=H@dh↓βaeS0@brpD@bpTTdAKgPAMe←4Aπ'-¬0]EW_~∀
∃]QrAI=]hAo∀Aakh↓ieCS1S]NA⊃←ifA=\A]k5EKef↓g↑A]<[←]J↓QCfA∧AGQC9GJAi<AEI←\ASh}4∀~∧_⊗dj5βadZ`b@@bβ→I@&6 ;7↔d¬F*ε≤@λ
:316¬X23 ⊂αi2]⊂λ)2]⊂≠qz0vλ990∪ decimal
Date: 25 Apr !dpb@@λε3 *Z
5 h(h M⎇.H∃L≥Y90⊗≠2P0zλ)jfbV⊗`dfCE)za~2qz≥λ)2]⊂λ)2]⊂≠qz0vλ990∪ decimal
To: GreeNberg.Sy`≠E=YSGf↓ChA≠%([≠+1)∪πε0Aπ'
¬0]EW_AChA %↔ 1 2
∃α≠
i↓αβ3'O¬#@⊗∞β\{ ≡≠|\d =λ∀jU02#!↓ H∩-d≤Y4n
{\y$∞≠h⊂~~2P6r\βsage sent 25 Apr 1dpb@@λε##~X∧∀jD_↑(↓Q@εE$IvP;t]4⊂5%Y↔⊂⊂&~yx⊂$\β no@PACgg∃[EI@Jβ3πl}V∞y(
@ whp∩Aβ≠#/Wd∧Bε∞o≥vv*
↔6(Q(
t≤=0⊂[4s<P→2qtfXv⊂4g≥2sri≤β? Adding dec@%[CHAββ?'≠'→β∂?.c⊃β3, ⊃βSxh#π∪&KS'?v 1β∂|¬f7/=_ me+:3D =λ∪ \<⎇
⎇Y(→
≤;→8nD
∩;NL<[~.≡λ∧V⊂→2qtvXvεE(≠tw:9H4vx6≡P36 /ating-point.
-------
λ∞dj5βadZ`b@@b\dn∪∂IKKME∃eN]'βK7 ?dK∂Mβ∂!α6&"j7W3&K∂MM∪∃i↓¬∪∃iβ|≠Sπ⊃∧εg↔~ LV≡N\≥Bαα↓Q$&∂LW"αβ&T∧∂π-≥Bβ ↔ε∩β∪π&#*ε↑:@hTn-vkR∧λw⊗.]l&/⊗uj7Nn-x
≤|h_.D∪25¬Y=;⊂~~qyFE∀zq5"Xz≥⊂⊂∀2]⊂⊂∀2]⊂ /ctal vrs decimal
∃)<t@A-¬][KYαc∃βπ ∧¬≥,X[αl →QPF≡5$α∧≥8h∃Bv-<bε∂Dλ$-∀8YD-JD FO∨∞N&∞w=Hλ.M|\h ≡λ∀u%X2#"I≥K4Y.
≤+5
wHλ∪,↑|x9lT≠yHε&(⊂<∞
;λ '↔ ( &@≥_ZP→yz⊂3≤αom Vanee@1YJ~∀4∃)QJ↓Sggk∀AQKe∀ASfA9←hAY¬]OkC≥JAIKMSO\A=` β←F P4)H
.x⊂7jYt::0H12]@≥42P4\βsue is miniei@iS]NA
←]MkMS←\A%\~∃IIC]gYα S'?rβ ↔S>+↔9β&Kπ3↔≤εG4_;Y∧
8:z-lh≥~ T≤]3 ↑h_s \<KC!↓ @↓AβY~VPx9⊗@81 "Hb`∪πM)β ])S@→β∂!α ↔⊗[↔3↔J&K∃R↓αK∃Rβ?∂S∞aβKK~β∪↔∂Lkπ1hR∪πS+Q↓IU∧ CI↓λπ∪C
∧∧@_Nα34:31)PCT
From: CSTAP.ji` ACPA¬Ke-KYKr4∃)↑t↓∂eKKαs ↔K8rOg↔⊗{3'∂≤α6&QlkW3SL∧71"Xpg⊂64`3ppransla`)=` Mβ∂!αNUl
% "λh⊗vN]H T_8
SUMEX-AIM
λSubject: Re: Re2 @=GiCX↓mefA⊃KGS[¬X∩*L¬bo⊗↑ GJOMw"¬N|¬0→λ4ryiXpπe Od∧@dj↓βad@Drpb@Dh
IUmαNA↓E≠πSW⊗#πe%ph (αHλ∧∧⊃_= WHλ 5 Aprbr`!α⊂β lM+*
uλ
<=→0→→0|TFB⊂⊂⊂⊂⊃93vMλ!y2b[12y3K)x mbolicS@MIT
Muddics
C@UEUKGPp ↓α⊗)`∩αλ,S@$≠xp~_v⊂; 2pεAIKα≠'7π`h!↓↓ααS=iααP⊗∞β[9-Mα2P !t S@+5 0@6 J44$∧ααε<7"α∧8∧uH≠λπ5 +d ad↓↓⊗J\*2⊗@∃DεfO>λ
∞0p∞sLators at SU)AI
λ In-Replp∩[Q↑t@A5KggC≥JA←LdjAβAeSH@Drpb@Dh iE*β↔OQ∧3C/5¬3π;↔,¬Ff(Q!PRα∧∧¬&FT
↔>⎇9(
<Y(
≡h≠[nD≠_;L}89y$ →<z,]H≠p→λ;t0zβE⊂⊂⊂λ&4yhλ7zst≥80P!→]P:4→P4yy]pP4`3 minimizine co@9McgSα{9β'ph)↓↓αβSKπw≠3πSN{9β /#←↔↔p∧ε&N≥HV∨'4λ⊗v"
\⊗NNβY`⊂≥42P)≥v2yP_v2py ∧¬α
Right, we shoUld maka the coNvers@%←\AE∃i`∨↔,¬bε&≤≥F.∨N4ε∂~ X↔∂J ≡2πε}>6N⊗LU@hV≥lBπ& ≡BεO4
vGJ ∀π∨.||W∨"∞Mε∂"∞|RεN≥<Rε&\8
-\9λ⊂~~2P22Y0zv* α I don't kno@\~∃@?2βπ;e∧#'π3.≠Qβ←FK∂!β≤ 9∨Q¬+;∪↔↔≠Sπl@λ L8z;,≥ Hλ }<H⊂⊗~yx⊂9↑yz2vH∀#90[=∀FE_z⊂6"Xyz⊂'[68P$_w26"\β ocTal oN input noT on output (siNce we've never dkund
any neeD for↓ShB\4∀~∀_⊂≥I"jπCIhπβ
αε∩C λ_:5$
¬m&↑H_=∧λY<Zl]→>(↓≤\X;O$≥~3-≥Yh∀L↑⎇;∃∞P⊂εE⊃0z2]λ→~⊂ \9⊂_@981 "β→aIIS U -λ:@hTn-vkRλ:5$
¬m&NH_=∧λY<Zl]→>#!
≠nH∞83` 3u( CR4⊃'kE)KGht↓IeC]hAiS[%]NAe∃ckYIL~∃πFhAπ'4
a;≠∂#↔7πtα⊗/-<Vf/∃D∧:uP6¬MX¬s ⊂2y5r[2|FEβE ∩∪α3@↔ε⎇K∩ε⊗]l6FN≡-2h!⊃⊂HH⊃⊃↔>8[:.Nα2r by j d¬P∨∪-∪πKqQ HHα""!⊃*_p→]0|↔5~pε@bep¬WKYα+e$∀PH$$⊃⊃⊂K∪Dλ↔π⊗≥DβCλβ"C! →<Y$ <Y(∞M→(∀L↑⎇;⊂~≤β ob p¬`↔mm⊗v:∞Mε*π ≥↔.h_Y-lz≠8.
h≠p↔λ!90w≡⊂"4i\⊂7wβE0P+⊂l⊂_@1-0∞p`↓` @.βZ0↔→P!2i~βadeY 4BSD U`≥SβA0∩α
Mε*εMxλ,D_9P∩\αage was Less
than↓←]JAβ;#↔→∧εFF*∞M⊗nNβY`⊂≥pyP"≠w2Wλ*42`3e reSults pπkaKβ∪@≡9→(∞M→(∃
≥8;Yn⊃ Z0↔]P40{→P;t4Xt⊂;r\2P6pY2P1<H8yP )n Earch ≤~(~∀4Ph"O∂⊗KCAβ∨#πKS,!β?9∧3C%α∂βA↓I ↓AYIβ!`∪ $ε∪KC⊃Q%⊗/l≥C@$≠~4n↓ ¬#)_w=⊂&~yx⊗⊂∪βpus 34
-> l@=C@⊃↓>3CC?gI$4*↑3πO1∧∧g.≠{≡%mw#"NA ¬⊗@> (setup ∩~(Qt@Bα↓E 3∧εααG∀ε∩β
f∧βαα∂∧β
β∃` ∧ελ #F¬**#!%/H
,;Xp∀λ→∀FE
87{r\≤P⊃
_∪⊂_M≠P_↔ ∀P∀_ _→QYH_↔⊂⊂) (0.⊂ 0& ))
α-x@QEK9GP@j$~∀Qa=oCdzj@@@αqEE↓αqA%↓C↓9]Uβ↓9QM≠→%↓∧∧ F7 h P ↔→_[
∀TFE ←⊂∀1→w1t X⊂FE
87sr\≤¬ "β↓↓!IqAE@3tε∩`&
*(¬π H@→LYP⊃W TP∀→K→⊂⊂⊃8dff@~I$4 hπbαF,Yf≡Bε∩RHhαJ≤
}y<O$ε-(
ε↔λπ⊂∩Lff@j8fjR@ rd\`Lff@hDXlffLR@@! A0∪BεUc ≠45∩Hh%P∂D↓"X a\αipt done on Fri ApR 24 04:0'~48 1→81¬
λt 28Apr 1981 0425-PDT
λSure, I caf Run them both o@8AB@@⊂εβ∪α¬
7.n←α#β∪¬∀ε∞vD ∩β∪εfααE<8 n2TWεB$0qP≤wvr`/ne alpeady done th E pransladion?
∪¬%YP~∀4ZZZZ4Z~∧~)∩AI←8OhAi!S]FAM↑\A&C∃β?vceβS⊗K∂/E∧εε∂↔N4ε∂⊗T
FF*
]wε*↑Mε∞rVUV∂⊗}4ππ⊗|-F.hQ(λ-lλ_p.Lz p~~97{@. I'f@∀AMCW∃HAGCQGPAC9HAiQI←nAS8A∪]i∃a→Sg@AoSi AiQJ↓`∂Cπ>C↔SSHh#OS,3⊃9αd+Qβ7*βSKe∧εFzεMxλl≡→(⊂≠Z0z⊂$H24r_w2⊂ 3hh∂nAβK?U9¬K?Uβn eβ3αX6@4≠y0~λ12q`!use
at o@9JAa←αK;AαJβ#π⊃∧∧∩∧n≤9FO∨¬P∂I≥]→0→∪4yx⊂≥90w9[0z7`2 phat I u@MK@⊃d ∩>fDλλ-N{c"NN↑(⊂~≠P24`' p QCPAP∨;*βWAβ∞s⊃βO,∧Rπz_=∧
=λ⊂∩≠p¬s @Q↑AiQ∀AEK]
QP↔πα-2`!α@
( e@∧∧rhhα@↓AβY≤εPx9⊗@81 $β E@(α38,.↑(∃∂≡{{@⊂∂ j(↔∃<yw`. at UTAP⊃βLZd`\α∪%J@Rα~JεuQα ↔v≠# .≤-2αα∧∧ααα↓Q$&∂LW"β∪αλ⊂.∞Hλλ@981 $β→EAX8E HαQP→≠vX
Mabr`2↓)sg←αq↓`$~Jα`*≤∧p∪@=\ACHααV@$Xε⊂*5αY_∨βE)z`"h¬KGhβQαK∃Rα~JεuQα ↔v≠# .≤-2αα∧↓PE&w$¬∃∧tλλ.D∀p
VPd@
In-Re@AYr[&y`∩¬≥x
.⊂6r`3pπCOJ↓←@→↓α eX<≤@⊗N_P⊂⊃Pfd[πM(⊂∀!Q hR∧∧α∧n≥_ ∧ \[p⊗H)jV`RP91`6d a`(α↓IQX≡π%,∧⊂⊃```@⊂¬T:uβ"D∧λλ⊃ ≡→(
⊂ →P x≤α 1981 12Ld[!≥ 4)↓α↓α7-x '⊂"4`#hεA∂C ` '↔b↓rJB8∧ε∂"λ∧u%X2/C!⊂⊂⊂⊂∀zq5 %ct: FRAN@4↓ ↔l8
\<Z`⊂λ⊂⊂εEλ⊂⊂⊂*≠]⊂⊂⊂≠4yx 4p¬C@;≤¬F∂&|.2ε∂D
5*@02(∧∧β"C!⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂∞.8X 99ph ⊂@ ¬⊂⊂λ⊂ λe@IJOfAαkeβS⊗ ;O∂⊗KCAβ|∧b¬≤→→B∧n≤9FO∨∧εC!∧¬∀@@@@#≤+S@/¬⊃P@$λλλ¬ Hλλ@ 1( `@@@Q2@D@b\@`@A@∧β
β∃` ∧ελλ ↔ ∀TTPβE⊂⊂⊂λ∀12g_t⊂→)
(POWER0~@H@P`\@b`≥↓αqA%↓A↓1AE8↓A9AJ↓!Ad∧ &@⊂_↔λ
TPεEλ⊂⊂⊂∀_2s1`( 5)
(POWER= 5 (0.11⊗ 0& $@Pb\β→MA↓λ¬cβCE∀αCαβHλJH_∪⊂⊂))
(bench10!
(POWER= 10 (2.534 1.`R@@!α∪∩c;44β hπ_@51) (_,∧r`Fh
3⊗ε∩JJ↓Q"αα∧¬ε⊗.βXp∀λ_ZTFB⊂⊂⊂⊂
(#kbT≤¬ "β)↓!E2qYU↓β GεlJ(¬ε,,@↔
X[⊂≤∞Tε298) ⊂@3→1e↓+19]QJI%4Ph!↓↓ααP≡F≤9α∧J∞,⊗rε=x .
;→9¬D∃~3,↑h_<LT~;@∞pqw`.ds&
...∞...
~∃$AQCmα)β¬β∂+↔OSL{9βπ⊗{WQβ&C∃βK/≠W3S~βg?Uπ≠#/]p∧α¬& Tππ⊗|-F.j ∀π≡9(∩.P:40]ε@
the diFd¬KeK9GJAE∃i`∨↔,¬bπ& Tε&O.8
∧∞Y<⎇-Nα⊂7cλ∀!"g⊂d⊂_ZJP0w2λ:42P≥44y2βE92y]v:⊂'Y⊂∀!"S!`⊂_MTW⊂⊂∩pε I am not wrong, @QQJAeU]iS[∃fACMQKdAgUEieC
iSMN4∃Wkh↓iQJ@!eCiQ∃`AYCIOBRA≥αAiS5KfASL@n\pDpAmfnP→E+ 9↓α&C∃β∪N3∪↔K.s∂∃βLp4+SF)βS←zβ↔cπoβ3↔M∧K@~πM ↔"πM Rε6≡.7"ε⎇lRπ∂<X d
;]→,|αy⊂ #oeffIcientq while the
oTher @UgCfAQQJAe∃CXA]U[EKd↓mKegαK?9β|∧bπ& Tπ∞∞\TεNwL\v/∩d∧¬&F≡@λ
≥Y~8l≡→<c!.≠h∪,T≥~_.D≡;⎇.$≠88m
;Y( My<h∞,8; -n;8Y.∧≠=;∞M<≠∩,<=~;md→X<nL<H∃
;H~.A Y≠l↑h~3NL9y4D
=;⊂~~x64aXz4ww∂←←P⊂λ'7z2H:40zλ:42P≤2yzv≥9P37\⊂:42H9vpv≠2yεE_2w1`(marks give the expected resulT that the integer multiplication i@L~∃MCMiKdAβ##π→¬∪↔π1∧¬g.n,Z"εO]H
≡≠~0l≡~;sEA ¬εE∩P0v@_zy4g]yP0q≠zz⊂ 4his. Are you @MkeJA=H β@≥x
.∧≤Y4n]≥_od∧⊃≠h∂≥⎇(⊂∪Yz⊂:4→F@
s@¬[@∃β⊗+@∨.β→≤d
9H⊗-}(~0↔_y2pyYP8 o@U`AMe∃JAgaα ∂*¬
w$≥z_.L=Y0→
P9wP≥40r the
am`∨KαsQβ?2α≡
β&+∂K↔∂≠↔Mβ&yβO?n+S#'v9β'W≤¬αε@→<p→H840wλ≤_∩P≠q⊂<`/ur tota`_~)iS@7*q↓απ2βS#∃∧ε&.∞βλ⊂↔≥vq2iλ8εersion ContiNu` fAQ↑AeKαqβ≠π≥#↔I1∧Iβ←?,c⊃β (h#@6↑/∩εNnLWε/>LV"ε≥`π>G∀λ
.D~<h @0yz2\↔εE⊗KVVVFKFEεE⊃)('f⊗P0p∀↓'β∪_4⊃)QJ↓ieC]MGeC@¬!βOπα4εn∞LTε⊗f≥lFgJ∞Mrε>≡h $∞{{9$∞[x
`'h idea of the RuntiMe*¬
I'll Run the entire @QQSMNαβπ>≥→bπε|L↔Jε≥lBπ≡]lBε←↑@λ∞M→(⊂→→pp @IKgkYβ#@~Pβ"B!⊃+<\ @T@
0 $5≠CrZ`b@@bβ⊃QT→\⊗↔↔∀
GO≡⎇`βd
J¬e'O=x D =λ∃*H4⊂4eVL∂@⊂αi2]⊂⊃) g-λ!2w1Z4py5H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ⊂→⊂&X|P_@981 "β!MM⊗≤"P4
4ε&}k$ V∞↔-∀¬'O=x Dπ⊂5∀¬j≡8smd_=⊂∃j"d TVY_∨βE)zq~2qz≥λ)2]⊂⊃) g-λ!2w1Z6py5H⊂⊂⊂εB*7]⊂∀(#P0]⊂)bVPdFE$[⊗i2x≠<Vj7N⊂,wz\⊂6ry\psrP≠s⊂→ K`x9⊗N_P_@432-CST
Here is the results of the FRPOLY Benchmar`⊗\@A∩Aα#'⊃βv{S'∂*βS#π β∂?7εK3πSN{84+}1βS#M→β ↔v≠#7π⊗YβK↔∨+3C↔ β'9βλ∧εn␈,Tε}2 ⊂π∂ε\X ∞↑λ≥~ ≡λ~=∧ ~9λ
⎇H≥~ Q"Tph~∀λ_L]Xz≠,≡X¬WεBεA&|H1wvvYw:⊂ )n the n`∨i∃bACHαβS#∃∧+;⊃βn+;S'}sEβSF QαV≤I63'≤εαε&|↑6r?D ε∂6T ⊂hT)_tu,T∞ε∞≡<≤v*r∧ ∩ε&⎇dw"ε=mw:πM ↔"εmx D∞⎇<Y%dλ∃~ T_8p→Yvq6<H60w3]psrP≤wzy1YFE40\P0P'≥vq2yλ7s⊂4≠wuyP→4πr A BIGNUM package but I don't know where that package
is.
Results of LISP timing tests forUCI-Lisp
(Timas are iN the fkrm R+G where R is the runtime (not inclqding GC time)
and G is the GC time. All times are in seconds. "Interp" means interpreted,
"Slow" means compi@1KHAEUhAkg%]NA+U≡[YS9WfH@
CghλA[KC9fAG←αkC'3.!β←'&AβS#*αVV<hS3';←→βK↔εcπ∂↔ β eβ&KK↔∂"β#W7π→9$∀Ph(4(HH$%↓ααCK?≡+GO?⊂h*CK};Kπ∀HH&.1i⊃AY@HH&.%i AY@hP%↓↓∧K;S↔↔&O3␈8%↓α6 OP%α↓↓↓αNsS↔KI↓αOd{\$&6 OP4Ph*~J∧z2ehhQα≠K.)h$$J↓EAAβ↓A8$K9UAAαp4)#⊗+;∂ J↓A9] I-A↓α↓↓↓As QI-IA9A#→-@%α↓↓↓↓∩qYI][%↓As)]Y-α↓↓↓↓β↓9Ea
Y@4)α↓I$%β↓9Y]:YA↓↓α↓↓A9 !I-@K↓9AQ:Y@%↓α↓↓↓Is1Ee-I↓A9+!U-Aα↓↓↓↓αqEYa[4*≠O∪OP%β↓9Y]:YA↓↓α↓↓A9 !E-@K↓9AQ∩Y@%↓α↓↓↓Is1ea-I↓A9+AA-Aα↓↓↓↓αqEYY[4)β⊗+OW3 I↓A93A]-Aα↓↓↓↓αqEQA[%A9β!M-@HH%↓As1EI-α↓↓↓↓β↓9EU*Y@4!∃RjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUQRjjUQPU&
~& Jε¬c;βe6ααα∧∧βαs⊗f"[⊗¬cβ356Jα∧∧αβ∩fWβ*[↓∀βαsf6α[α∧∧ααβ¬f#+26↓PRπ,↑7.gA∀βαsε6α[α∧∧ααβ¬f∪#"6↓∪αsεf2[∀∧αααε!c;Kα
l↓∀ MF⊗
lλ∧∧λλ ¬FLMjf↓ ¬∧P ↔≠X→
X⊂⊂⊂λ⊂_↔_M→∃X∧L↔_≠→
X∧P⊂λ⊂⊂→↔
YYUXαP_↔≠∞ZUX⊂λ⊂⊂⊂_ →~Y∃Lε@
0.700+0 0.142+0 0.065+0 0.%93+0 0.215+0
=========================================≥============================
(bench 5.88+0 1*166+0 0.343+0 22.25+0 4.384+0 1.451+0
5) 5.696+0 1∞102+@∩`\fTjV`@@@@dDXpnVβ%↓Qq!QI-α↓↓↓↓β 1IE:Y@$(h
.9z∧P
U≠X≠λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂_W146+0 0.338+0 4&7DrV`@@@@b8j``V@~∀Ae∃ckYH$∩@@@@b\b`V`∩`8fjbVβ4(∃P %U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+#"JM~<Y↓∀
+Fπ⊗*lλ∧∧λλ %fm jf↓, M&&jhλ∧H⊂⊂⊂→ W_~∃L∧P~π∞[~∃Hλ⊂⊂⊂⊂ ↔_≤[JXεE⊂≤2yzv≥∧P~W∞≤_∃Xλ⊂⊂⊂⊂ Tε38∪+0 0.51+0 21( lh,`∩@J8`phVβ↓↓↓↓α↓I9A3)-@4PI↓U9AAQ-Aα↓↓↓↓λqMAUY%A→+⊃I-@HH%↓Uq↓eM
α↓↓↓↓β⊃1AQ@Y@ (αB"$∧λλλε∃β→Z1+0 0.514+@~∀%kiuuUhπSkkUP∂'W-+ ≡O↑X
=tzz`5hπSkkβ+ ≡O↑X
-tzzjzβiuu@UP∂'W,ε↑@===0~ZβiuuUhπSkkβ+ ≡O↑ZFE
12w1Z∧XY2,∧dVB8b@@@HjThp,bP→A⊂∧αβBβH →JXW⊂~αTVP⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊗FBP⊂⊂⊂ XW≤XJ====≥====≥====≥====≥==5=tzzjztzzzzβiuuuiiuuThQ# ↔v≠ %↓αi4%↓α↓↓Meq⊃I-Ipε∪ $ ,KFW*lKFεα+#!∀λλλ¬U "+%Q Hλε⊗αTDDBP⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂_I ≤X∃I α06
Firs@P~∀%h¬RjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUURjjUQRjJUURjjQQ%&F≡,@Jα¬QPJα∧∧β#~βH
YS_≤λ_[W22+3.⊂2 -- -- ↓-
resuld 17( jPαYM)A(h %UiiuuUhπSkkWP∂'W-/ ≡O↑Z↑@===5-tzzjzβiuuUhπSkkWP∂'W-/ ≡O↑Z↑@===5=tzzjzβiuuUhπSkhQ!PDv|LS@$λ∃~ T≤Y<n]≥≤h∞ 9Y4N 9λ∃
t_8h∞M→(⊃M≡\⎇∞2yzv≥⊂4yP≥42P)→yzv*λ5q0∀ained
as The f@%` OQ¬3π3W*βK↔S-∪;↔⊃ε∪eα
,r∞!9ααS#'~β'Mβ&C∃β[∞cW* 8 m↑≥=→,D≥<r-lc"R-n→9y.∧_{p∩YαficIents. The resUlpλAe∃MKee∃HAi↑↓CfAi!JAiQ%aHAe∃ckYhαβ'Mβ&C∀4 &C'K⊃∧εf∞g\Tπ,=→0→≠2r⊂ "y BENAH (for real number↓G←KMα3'∂',sSM∃`λ∧
0r( M<|β! ≠y4d
Xπr have the @ SO]k4AaCG-C@∨∃¬≠=β' ∧ε≡␈]H ∧
Yx
compUte the se@
←]H~)aKgk1hAeKβ#WKlX ∧ ↑(⊂~~2P!"SαC@ RoutiNe*¬
λ---
---
λ∞`@ ¬Tn∂∃P∞ε∀λλ →L≠qg\αrei@IBAC@ ∧¬-∧Xε⊂*5αXX@ U@)1∪' A K]GQ5Ce@/~↓↓↓hR∪πS+Q↓↓Q∧kπe↓λπ∪C
≡Bβ T⊂
EXq∃β!(\[{'∧_{p→≤αeaba at UTEP⊃βLZbb@4⊃'kE)KGht↓+)2M~Aβ ,s∂#7∂∪ ∨_Q*F{R∞.ε*ε≤¬⊂≤zVptCE1q]λ1wy9→ty0FB∧@
Hi! A @!CmJA KK@9¬3↔Ke∧∧'/∨α(⊂↔Yα late so I was onl@dACEY∀Ai↑Aα;↔Qβ&yβS#(h# ↔v≠#7π⊗[Eβ3∂#∃β3∂≠Qβ←,+ ~r∧ ∩εF≡h $∞~≤Y,T→Z0⊗→yP:7H9rw2λ0s2∩P;wz[2εE&~urP*≠P5w7]P;t2]42y∩P9t7]v2⊂ 3end Thee direc@QYrAi<AsOJ↓←dAi<~∃→∪M!)β≠%_
=4εC!! ¬_TH0p∞ Overf@%KnA←_A+)→%' @j8bAC]⊂AiQJ↓_∞MαJβπ5β↔+;+'v9βS#*β ↔;≤¬εn∂->0hW]lF/∩¬
U"k(A∩`hαC"F%(≥~ T≥~;-≥Y|h Mβy⊂)Pah ⊗βE
3) the timings For FRPODY.
~∃M←ee@Jβ'Qβ&{?-β≤yβ3?v9βS=∧∧v/" ≡&␈.l@λ∞MβP4j ∧AεEαD@DDTts1b\2v<VβEDDBD`v#≤αed Correip¬B4Ri555ji44(hR; ?-\⊗fgα(⊂~~2|P0\2P9r[:⊂:7H&$ih∃) g)S j'i∀T⊂;t~qt⊂4_yP:4→P2s#→qzεE≠q⊂3wXp∧ing othep translators into Doifgthei@HAU←ELB~∀∩$∩SeA≤Z~∀_⊗`J5≠CrZ`b@@`Xhf∪G=` K↔O∪¬βπ αVR⊗D
M5E
↓&N≤~BAα&K7'≠?→β≠?⊂αVR2M~A↓hR∪πS+Q↓↓U∧kπe↓λπ∪C
≡Bββε6Rl≤JAPT7-⎇SRε=z'ε.≡,∩ε∂D
U$-λ~2k ∀↓PU∨\-&.∨G$¬≤≤:
α¬&≥]⊗v?4 f␈∩λ¬5 I4tβ!*≠nH
M<|∃∞ 9\{ ≡≠|\d =λ≤nU8:#!!"QSmM≠⎇z-lh_<LT≥~→$∞~;:-l|h→M}H⊂ aPh(⊂3≠y⊂ ∃TLISP 5.1.Because oF local αinteractive dield length (= core size) restrictions, adl rqns were
submitted as batchjkbc. "ru@9iS[JλAI←KLA]←h↓S]GYUIJ@E≥GiS[∀D\~∀4∀∩∃∪9iKeaIKiKHβP4(Q$ααπ.X D7Hλλ∧∧λλλf∀λλλ∧∧λλλf$λλλ∧∧λλλf4λλλ∧∧λλλfDλλλ∧∧λλλfQ"C"N∞αw:4[p¬0∀@@@@b`Xbj@@@@b`Xbn@@@@b`Xdj@@@@b`Xdd@@@@B`Xdl~(AOGi%[@∃@$∧ααα∧ε∩c≠D∧ααα∧ε∩c≠t∧ααα∧ε∩c≠D∧ααα∧ε∩c≠T∧ααα∧ε∩c≠AQ hU.X D =λ Fε λ ∧¬≠xu ≥λ(⊂∪~pr2≠2s3z~⊂;tj~≥⊂∩5300.words kf Fp¬KJAMaCGJ4⊂@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@f@f`LA]←eIf↓←DAMUYP⊃β∨βπ∂∀hRS#↔⊗)βO↔⊗)βS#⊗+∃β∨∂∪ π∨*β∂?3d+∂S'|sEβ≠|ε"ε.≤9απ↔]` AQ@εEεB!wvx~v2r:
~∀@Aekαq¬i↓α↓↓↓↓α→E↓↓α↓↓↓↓α→I↓↓α↓↓↓↓α→M↓↓α↓↓↓↓α→Q↓↓α↓↓↓↓α→T4(hSC@.nM⊗n,¬⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂→Kα95 4,∧`r@@@@@PX AYα↓↓↓↓β!0∪ ∧∧ααα∧εB`& c"D x⎇~-\αX
,97 ,82 ,∧ph@@@@@Xpd@@@@@Xpf~(~∃%KαqβπQβ⊃AAAα∧αF@x⎇_-E(→P∀Yv2⊂ ,ength sith8 45524. Wordc ob f@IK@∃β≥βπ∂∀hQ↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓I@⊗Vr`$≥{p→→9P7`& ful@0AgaC
J~¬)!KeJAβ;↔K∃∧εFG⊗\Tε <<XX,\(_p↔[4∧ec@QS←]f↓MP∨I∧∧V∞≡∧
'.raQ"jjUQRjHβ"C!↓AβX∩VSp|VL P⊂_≠
→Dqg\αreiRa ad↓+) ⊃¬&Rbb@∪
¬A∨→2AQS[C]≥bAM←β⊃αVRdJNAhR∪πS+Q↓↓U∧kπe↓λπ∪C
≡Bββε6bl≤JAPD↔-ySBε=x N2pq0H0z⊂*U hλAS-11
λ¬'kE)KGht↓
%!∨12A)S5S]Of↓H ?$
U$dα4t↓QU≠nD
~<p_≥90w9[0z7`2pεAC@ ∧π>+8:!Q@εE#≠v67`7ing @¬aJAi!JAeKMkYiF↓H ?$λe∃∧βs⊗$∞8π22\α U@)1∪' @TX E9ααS#∃∧ε'.w4λ↔ HαM`~L__⊂∀≠qz0v
P;ri→P9:`. iftep¬CGi%mKYRlAiQJ↓aK[C%]IKd↓o@↔K*β@∨.-]↔'→9β!0yP!_z1t h¬P∨ α5bα↔,X NM99(D ≠y4d Su
≥X{∃,L(λYl>~;9$%C"C! 8π:2\αpreTed:
beNch 2~ (ru@9iSKJ-KGiS5JR
∀4⊃$`)α↓↓↓↓λqEI@¬2ααα∧∧β
@L-N¬6λλλ∧∧ +@_M≤UX⊂λ⊂⊂⊂_K_Z≠EL∧¬∃$Hp ↓↓α↓E 3↔α∩[α∧∧ααβ∃` &@→∃X⊂λ⊂⊂⊂_K_[XEL⊂⊂⊂⊂λ_W_KM∃XεE∀→]⊂⊂λ⊂_W14ε`∃-α↓↓↓↓β 1E]αYA↓↓α↓↓E9 9E-Aα↓↓↓↓λ¬c ≠∃0 ↓Q@εE "enchjt@QIk]iS5JA←Mα+@∩ε|:FNnU⊃P@@ TND∧λλλπ∃L∧XHλ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂≤W910∞@@@@@@dX aYβλ∧∧λλλ∧π+J,εAα@
.156 .Dhj@@@@@@X EU⊂∧ααα∧∧αααd⊂
π↓ ¬) ∞α 5*237 5.∩4∧b@@@@@@TX IQ*↓↓↓↓α↓↓U9∪→\4)α↓↓↓↓α↓↓9E3⊃↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓q UI↓α↓↓↓↓α↓1EU8∧ααα∧∧αααd∩S0H*&3Bα∧∧βJSα,l∧∧λλλ∧∧∞+Fπ↔(λλ∧∧λλ∞%g-Lλ∧∧λλλ∧π+N,FQ"Hλ∧∧λλλ∧¬LlLd∧λλλ∧∧λ Lf⊗(λλ∧∧λλλ¬fl, ∧∧λλλ∧∧ Llε↓ ¬εE_2w1`( 10:
αR: 2⊃3.160
4,20%
λR2: 7∞136
.⊃4∧p~∃Hft@@HbfLLT`∩)α↓↓↓↓α↓M9EK 4(Q(λL]Xzε$_;Y∧ Y;Xm∧
(⊂≠Yy2P)≥w⊂0zλ0P3 )eld @1K]OI @PzAα≠?K∃¬≠'k∃Jβ?_∀S9UAAα↓# >>L⊗bJ∞⎇w,≤h⊂≠Zz4≥⊂λ392`% space of 50
``8Ag←e⊃b~∀@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@↓I`↔∪bβGCπ≤)β >dε#+C5`λ∞⎇|Y≤aQXY;L=λ @⊂≤2xz`)p¬KHA9↑AOCIECOJ↓G←YY∃GiS←9bvAE∃]GP@LAeKcUSeKHα↓Qβ∨∂∪ π∨(h#∂?dc↔∂SN{;Mβ6{Aβ↔∞≠!βK,q8$(hS ↔;≤¬αβ ∧∞v∂~∞.Vrε≡@λ ∀→Z1-Lλ≠⊃-l⎇~
|HλDεε λ¬
βqz0[∀P;w\29P+Zz4≥εB⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂3)→pP9x_qrP7Yα 41↔06. Words
fUlhλAgACGJA=H ↓Y3AU)β>{C∪LhS ↔;≤¬αβ ∧λ L↑=:0→→p⊂→\λ3pq1_pπe @
←YYK
iSO]LX∩*4¬w$≠x]M≥⎇<h∞,88p↔[9P I didnot @Ik\AE∃]GP@Dj\4Ph (αPp↔[x4v %d:¬
λ¬EK]
P@dt4⊂⊂∀
⊃Q↓↓↓α↓↓9E9→↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓pε∪≠J∧∧ααα∧∧α`&-(h∧∧λλλ∧∧ Hλ@49
∀@@@@@`\@@@@@@@@`\α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓0∪ ¬λ∧∧λλλ∧ελπεE∀→_
.⊃4∧j@@@@@@Xblnα↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓→α⊂
&Dλλλ∧∧λλ F⊗,β"D∧λλλ∧∧ @∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ¬@_XZPλ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ_⊂∞ 0.
R3: ,155 &!Th@@@@@@@8b`→Uα↓↓↓↓α↓↓9EC_4)↓α↓↓↓↓β↓1↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓Ad∧ααα∧∧αααε¬bαα∧∧ααα∧∧βαpQ!PF⊗]l6BβTεC!∧@
R: 1( h`X@@@@@@b\β→QE↓α↓↓↓↓β 0∪≠T4ααα∧∧αβ
f6# 1"Hλ∧∧λλλ∧¬LlF∧∧λλλ∧∧λ DfVHλλ∧∧λλλ¬@→[∪⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂∪⊃\
FA) ∞α .097 ._4εd@@@@@@X aU8∧ααα∧∧αααβJ≠ F@
.159 .Hjf@@@@@@X IU8∧ααα∧∧αααβH 60λ
*⊂ε3@$λλλε∃β~→Xλ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂_W34εd@@@@@@DX Ma⊂∧ααα∧∧αβ
d∧mfQ ¬⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ↔→P∩T@@@@@@@\β→e@*∧∧ααα∧∧α`&n-H∧∧λλλ∧∧λπ⊂∩Xr~(hS ↔≠≤¬αβ ∧εC!∧¬∃$h@@@@L`\`@ ε2αα∧∧αβ≠¬` επ(λλ∧∧λλl¬F -C!⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊃W∞\≤P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂ W_λ ,X@@@@@@h\β↓E@4U⊃Ii↓α↓↓E9⊂ε∪Jα∧∧ααα∧⊂ F⊗βY⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂ Tε21_
,∧bhf@@@@@@@9α⊂
g∀λλλ∧∧λλ F⊗αZFE∀→]⊂⊂λ→X↔490
@@@@@F@Xj`R@@@@f`@9αV#@@ ¬⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂
↔_⊂@5f 1554. words
benc@ @dAe∃ckSe∃H@`A=d@bA≥CeEC≥JAG←1YKGi%←]fAAKdAeU\vAE∃]GP@T~∃eKEkSeK⊂@nAi<@pAO¬eECO∀AG←Y1KGiS=]fAa∃`Aek8\~∀~)EK]G @b`A¬]HAE∃]GP@DjAoKIJAek8AChA∧AMSK1HAYK9OiPA=L@d`@```@!←GiC0R~∃o=eIfA]SiPtAMeK∀AgaC
JA←LhdrbL\Ao←IIf~∀@@@@@@@@@AMk1XAga¬GJA←_@lpjd\Ao←IIf~∃ K]GPb`Ae∃ckSe∃H@fn↓OCeE¬OJAG=YYKGQS←]f↓aKdAIk\vA K]GPbjAe∃ckSe∃H~∀lLAOCe COJA
←YYK
iS←]L\~∀~)βfAs=jAGC8AgKJ↓Me←Z↓iQJAHdAeKMkYif0AiQKIJACe∀AiS[∃fAoQ∃\AB@X`AESPAo←e⊂~∃gSiJAGC8AG←[∀AS\A!C]Ir8~∀ZZ4ZZZZ4∀~∀_⊗`J5≠CrZ`b@@`Xhf∪G=` K↔O∪¬βπ αVR⊗D
M5Eλ↓&¬∧εFG.\-f∞Nβλ⊂→Zpz1tλ4πf UTLASP
Date: 5 May !dpbACP@`pdD[π (4∃¬e←4pAG←β∪@⊗.≤,∩ε∂D
U$-α⊂4eV,(β!)zq5→qz≥⊂⊂P:4:[q30t[⊂9ur]1t⊂'Yα U@)1∪' ~))VtAαc'OC'∪π;Od∧↔&@|Xh ≡λ≤u%\8#"AQPY3
}h~4d (≤r
}]λ⊂∩→yqy4\:4wgλ5s⊂*U&$ihλ0s2 the OS @∩Aα 5βK,¬fvNlpλ∞M→#"L,;Xp∀≠py5yH8s22\⊗⊂8)≠{4r2Y⊂37`2 tho@MJA←L↓s←j@!oQSG ASfAAeP∨ ∞∪3eβTεW∂ Q(λ,-⎇= ↑Y<↑,-y_ TH;t7P→tz42\α have ne@YKdAgα+↔9β&C'MαdJNAβ&Kπ3↔≤εBε←!Q'>F}<Rε}mH∞$ >≤∪nzy2P~0yP![w9t`3ted @=H β∪,s'∨K∂#?Ke∧∧6}n\X NNh≤pn4q16→rεE /n bathrgoM p∂CY1`
0Q!PD∞Lj&.αλ9w.Y:0→_FAεE TVVFKVVVFKTVVFKTVVFKTVVFKTVVFKTVV@--)--
-)--4ZRZZ4ZRZZ4ZRZZ4ZRZZαi5$Q!PE-II∃≥α
_ d (∪∩*:λ→~,≥→8p~λ30∂r↓∂?;'∪?1α& S¬α≤¬w.≠x] ≥8πw 4∧``@αaα∂@≤,W!αA≠H ⊂0w2λ!x bep∧@bn@AGYCM`
β7∞≠#'lX e@⊂ `(αβ'Mβ≤εW.Y;]
O(≤]-mβ0w3H0z⊂ /ver
50 s@%iKfA¬hAg←αk∃β3-3↔1↓F3C >T∧¬-$β∩4jεhλ⊂~≠P⊂ ∃TLIS@5,1) and unde@H~∃mCIS←kfAWaKβ∪πS'v9↓βOM≠S↔↔~↓↓"iz2bα iu~@pQ+∧∧⊂p 'SαOS, SCOPE(λ@Aα ;⊂4Tε6/6↑,⊗bε
x ,U8\Y.}hε⊂ )ncl`+α#';≥∧{WIβd¬v≡∞βλ∃*E,Q∀Kα @+Q→∪'↓Sf@Aα∪πO↔ h ⊗@{Hλλ4∧ue B`∨←αY↓αM_ nπh≥~ T→Z0→≤βt c@Ik@∪∃∧¬⊗oεLX ,]]_=
≥{H⊂∪[p¬s @ CGVAβ#<4&⊂∞&@≠P0yH0P8 2ojec@PAga←αs@≡␈,X ∧ ↑(∃e@⊂+W B`→Kα#@≡}U`λ∧∧⊃>≥ ]\z0≠→P⊂92]4VFE≤βi`∨]L@AoKβ∪∃↓βn ∪∃↓∧¬⊗rα∞Mε*α
Hλ.L(λ
F∞hλ⊂⊂[2⊂2`!p¬P∪@∀εsπ~ /∩∧≤K@⊂⊃Tε M8~∃∂@⊗+↔;πα|⊗gλε⊂ !nd by B`∨Dααπ7Od∧W%λ∩P↔[0z40[⊂)v /cu`~X↓C]HA5CEe@J↓αS@≤∧p↔[⊗εE #ulmi@9CiS]≤@AS\α↓α[↔↔≠'?9α↓Q9↓¬3↔KOL¬vrβTλ
l≡h≥~ T≤≤[lNαqz o` A[dAKLZ4⊂ ≠∨α.G4~;@⊂ \[\VL\Xλ 8@A)Q∀AGkeIK]hAβ≠gOS,¬Rε≡⎇n6O∨L4αε@yHλ∞M→(λ
≥]→0→ F@
`@IKiKdαa↓β¬∧∧6}o
_ ↑Kλ∪λ~λε⊂ !nd runp S[∀Agkaββ?KQ∧εW&Nβ~0~~p¬s.A≠@?≤εBε@yC"JZα ISP i`&↓oe@'αNF.r
_ Dλpπfh⊂iiP∀≥42P !pπgK[ YrAYα ;∨W∞;∃↓β|∧bαπM Rα∧8H0hVβ8:-l\X;,↑h∧P⊂_v:47]pπh much↓←@→β&C∃βKαX NM8εrP≤βupp@=` @"∞8
∞\β3⊂ 2elease`λ~∃β;'S!¬3↔KOL¬vrβTλ
.P1w`$e`λASαqα2~:α`$λ⊃~ T_{p⊗\4p e@HASf@↓C\@Aα{3⊃D∧ε≡∞βK#!∞α0w5Yy0∂`+β→1↓β∞s⊃β?↔≠∂WK*β7πO&+@∩|h∀∞4πje@
hAMe=ZAC@⊗{W;⊃β e@;∀λ
=λ⊂∀\β
αnot frequently uSed -most pegp@1JAoQ<AcgJ↓+)2M~A↓β&+C↔; ∧αε}d∧π&FQQ'∂ε\XBαε|dπ&FT∞Vv&↑-GNNlpλ
<Y≥l≡Y(∃
t≠8:lT≥<λ mβy⊂*~4yWλ*j&$Th⊂4iCE0∞o@PAcgKα!β7W≤¬αε6} λ∞|yz2[T¬buIlding8εA¬Y∃Ig←J≥`
βSF+?K↔h↓βCK⎇3↔I↓¬;πL4T∧⊗⊗←↑@απε Tεf∂>@λ -9h∀∞
zY0nD≥|Z.Nα2w in ETLISP that↓∩AW]=nA←L0AC@; h#'Q∧εv∂~ 9vw6↑.F."∞Mr¬,9→DM≥∧ ⊗.∂.4ε∞{h⊃∞\(≥≠d∞~→(∞∞X;:.M=Y(
l=_
`2e
αoF UDLISP at that tiMe and the ma`≠←β∪eβ∂|¬g∨',≥⊗w'4 ⊗oε|8V"ε-∀ε␈/!Q$m~aQ hT≤¬≠m↑h~0↔λ*j&$Th⊂0y→P≠⊂⊂_4z⊂ 1uantities, inc@1kAS]≤@fZ@ Aβ παDαε6≤YF'_Q%∧
%Dα∧≤J%Bα∧::"Jα∞
G/~ mF∞~ -↔'~d∧¬&FTλ4
∩∞↑7.∞MO∩πε⎇≥g'~ ≡Bπ& QPV∂M⎇RεON8 -LH≠p→λ:7P8≤2{4g]yP;0[8ryP≠s⊂:4→P0z7[P⊂∀4K2W⊂⊂≥0r0∃epε@ACIJ~∃[¬S]iC%]KH@↓Cf@AMiCGWL@A←\↓iQJA¬iW[f↓iQK[MKYmKLAeCi!KdAi!C\AE∃S]N~)acgQ∃HA←]Q↑AiQ∀Aek]QS[JAMiCGV$XA)Q∀Aπ $↓H '↔d∧Bπ∂>\⊗fGα(λ∞
z;]∞∀λ_=↓Q]~→$∧_⎇4N2w:⊂λ90v:YP⊂7`& the atom afd↓iQJA
'$AMαK↔3⊃∧εε}NnN2ε∂Dλ
#"P⊂]4πm's properti list∞ Thus UTLASP usEpε@Ag!CYY←β9↓β Ls∪';8∧αε6}!PW∨Mz&Nvuz&/'-_W6Nlpλ∧ =≠{$∧≥X;∞\αyWλ*42i→P0q2H70∂ @ SO]k5b@@#∞cS#?.; 4 &C↔O∃ε K∃βv{QβW≥+π33Jβ;↔∂/≠GπKJβπ;g> eβ←M#!β¬β1Aβ M!↓β←⎇∪⊃↓β≤¬↔V*⊃Q&␈∩∧∞6n∞MMg.j∧¬εNw]↑2bα ↑F~r∧¬Rαε∃lR`$λ≠[d∧→;Xm|~;Yd∧≠yH
n;8Y.∞h~;AQ\≠r-n→<H @4rv"≤TW⊂*~2P3p\10srH1wv&→qz4w[⊂9qt→vrP4\β mari and sweEp,
the mark pHase ipεAECMKHA←αqαπ∪>{C'SFiα¬βL¬b∧≡ ≡π&/$ε"ε↑d 6w∂M↓`hPβ"U*I∩4t∧ε+L
<h∪-}⎇λ⊂↔Yα the traditiona`_@↓CGG←β+SK↔n+;SMα↓#CK⎇β↔KSβ⊃PFF≡>G
@λλ_.∞X>4eDλ→U-l<Y|d∧≥~_.Dλ≥{n
iλλ
\8|[n5α⊂92Xp∧'`@IS]hAαkπ∂K⎇→04 -#
9%bβC3W~β¬↓β⊗+π&↑$απ>≡MααεmH /
8[⊃$∧≠→6
≤x;λ∧ {_<n<<kλ∧∞X8]∞\;β"M\αp
oRy that allh∂of↓Cki←5CiSF↓eKie%KmCX↓←LAGα{∪∃β4ε&}j M↔∞Z iw$~;C!Q]→4N∞Y=→,D→]3L>~;{N5α⊂7k→y20|\T⊂4g≥2y0∩upts, etc. It @¬Yg↑AαCπM↓¬##∀∀T∧W>y;]
≤9λλ∞∞αs:4[p¬ @Mkaa←β∪SMiαβ↔∪'&{A1α∃∩⊗ε-bβ¬αX→4,4→HRπε≤96∞y+β! →;⊂_ ⊂⊂2<[0p
i@ @A[Kαk?KeαβGWC∧{@↔λε⊂⊂→z1W The edi@Q←dX@↓
J⊗ Y1↓β∞s⊂$)X∀\,i→D*α¬λE≤\zZBJα∞λλ,=x9y.P⊂:`3e the c@=` K↔≤εε}vM_ L@P32`!tp eKβ→β'aQ%,≤α3∩*:λ_<d
αp∂dels (in particu@1CdXAβ##∃ααZDdM8∧ε.ε≤Mw$~<h ∀≤{⊂∀Yβhtl@d~∃gGα 3↔⊃n#?←9αβ[↔Kα8
-⎇H≠p∪λ842P∃a` LISP e@⊃Si←d$X ↓α-"2&Nαβ3π∂←→`∩ε≤-w.αεE %p¬eO@⊂∧π,8{p≠→y<V⊂⊂iaddH∀2|1Yx:⊂ &or the @⊃KαcAβOM≠S↔∃JaβOS⊗K;∨Mb↓β↔→hh#≠'≤¬⊗.wD∧π6.>Mwπ~βλ⊂⊂H10 nap¬rAYα{π&↑ λ @4πr @
←[aSαc↔↓β≤¬v&*D D-Eλ∧TeD→=_e@∧¬∃+Q→∪'↓IP∨↔~βCK∨αh
,L(→0≤≥2s9`)ve e@I` ?%\6F.==⊗v: h n⊂:42H0y3z[p¬`≥iLAP∨_hS@∨O>LVjεnX L>~;p↔≤β(λAC9HAeC9IP∨5∧∧⊗v" -⊗v∂,ε( ∃β`∂.
λ∧⊂∀)∀π>Nβ≠λ
\αp∞tion o@9YrAi!JA>~βS#πα@λ ∀_; ⊂≤αp @;vK;≥β&C∃β ,¬f≡F\≡&@>h≠p↔λ⊂⊂
UPλ@5α(B`$λλ∃*E,Q⊂λ4yP⊂_P⊂47[p¬-grown Lπ&@Aβ##πQαβ@↔8π9P≠w⊂0@ Dp CX↓∂g ,ε hS⊗p ¬VβZP⊂ pπsgi∃ZP→↓∧+π∂!∧≠g ↔⊂∧εF∂4ε#+6αh≠l@⊂⊂1b[:90vλ⊂6rf[y<P⊂_w2⊂⊂ _εE 0era`!!KeCX@Aae=GKgg=` M9α↓↓αSF+e↓↓∧≠?77.s'∂π&)↓βSG∪?W∨B↓↓Qe⊗Y↓β?0h+↔c&+;∪↔ ¬V≡␈,Tπ∨&},⊗>*d
FF/,Tε∂⊗Tε2βCFES"εM≡6Jπ?≡7&.↑4αCKVpαεn\|∩hh,=ε∂⊗≤>F/↔4∧ε.∞=↓∩αε≥lBαβ$∧βCCT∧ε&O=0λ∞∨<⎇→-↑h
FVNλ≠,\x8z ≡X8u ↑\c"L\8z
%Dλ⊃0,=λ⊂t
T~_<d ( ∧ε∧≠X;M}y8smlλ_},=→(∃
≥9(∃m≡~λλ ∀λ≠8/
;=;!Q]_ 0[9s2`2 rate o@_A←]J↓o←eH↓KCGPj`A]¬]←gKα≠?;∪≠Yβ7↔n{CeβLε2ε␈,|⊗rhQ(
/,9λ∩-n≠h⊂∩Zst:⊂~w22h→w22g≥⊂10w~yP∞ Some disK numbers: av@∃` π∨(h+O↔,¬2απM→V*α
xbαβ6∧αεo<X2bεmz"π& TβC#N4ε∞vDε#*ε↑<V~r iwαπM RβCε↑2`h.N&∞w<hW$λ≤X.L(λ≠lDλ
KFF(λ≠,\x8Z.Nk|q,4λ→[n∧λ≥~ Tλ∞¬εNhλ_-lλλ∞%f.β"M\9x8M≡≤k|l\kHλ m|Hλ∞M→(λππ
<kD∧λ∃5¬VQλλ
≡≤y; D~<h
m{K< ≤y9β∧
[{K!Q]Z<NN8;λ ≥↑=~
≥YkH∧
≤[yn,;<h ≡Y(≤L↑⎇≤Z,>→9∞Mh $G
h_X.Lzλ_-lλλ f-c"Z-n→<X,>~=Y$∞≤Y<l]]≠≡$ ;_
4≠zst⊂≥42P4[:2y0Xz4{2H6rvw\<P9t↑2P4iH2:rFB:7P4[1y2p\rP:7H_Y≤5H:44iH9zvvYy⊂;t]4⊂:4→P4w9]0r60]4ww⊂≠s⊂9w[rP72]FE9r[tqww→:qz7\⊂6rv[y<P9→x60qZw3P:~2P1z\92w:λ2|:2[22r-core storage.
The systemt-¬
@1r@@A¬GGKgβ≠';≥α↓βC#*↓↓β≠L∧Vf'4∧αε@yHλ∧ (λλ I4pλ∧∧_8
7[Tε The CP@*4⊂ C'∧+3'lUvNw>N'.∨M_ mdλ≤p~_quP )pεAYCIK@∃β∞s⊃↓β≤¬F␈:∧λ
tλ_p⊗→py⊂⊂→8y4g→FE5*[x9V⊂≥t4qtλ*j&$Th⊂27YyP3 2equeNth `%∧∧⊗v"∞⎇↔&B
\⊗"ε≤,⊗v&⎇a`hPβ"U*I∩4t∧
<h_.l8;⊂,-α2P*≠P0v&λ;t7P≥pw:⊂~z∪⊂⊂∃42P⊂≥yry communaty i`&4∃ISm%IKH@↓aeC[¬aSIRAS]i<@AGYα @∨∨-yvjπ↑8 $∞≠h⊂~→pqt∪$ih↔PdP1`/ncep@Qb~∃C9HABAα3π'I∧¬g.n,Z"ε@yH∀m≡→<h∞|;]~-lh⊃5 I4tλ
≥H≠p→→2y⊂ 4o re@8@AiQ∀@A*~)←@→ααX
≥ |h
(αb*aQP9|`3te`~\4⊂⊂∀λhP4)5hi555hh $λ0 ;&eTn∂∃P∞ε∀λλ∞&⊗@∧cr[y3rP∩↔⊂!`\92z:→P≡#e⊂β a`(αα6&Qlj
yL∧&.v=
V∂⊗αk@⊂λ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ→≠⊂&X|P⊂@981 "β⊃`∪ eXT% Q(gε@{.Hλ|9xYlT⊂K@⊂⊂βarretp J@q∂∃εA¬hA≠∪P[∪ε@ph"OW⊗S↔∂QRβ ↔;≤¬εn∂-5`hUMw"¬∃λtε∂" Y∃"lX1PPH(h
-L<nH∧ 0jS _Q∪pga"g!R⊂∨⊃εB⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊃&P])ad⊃fbUiP`fP∨λ∧¬
"MC*SAHEME8ππ↓ Iβ⊂@|λ~∀4U#↔OQ∧¬vr∧X4εO~
→bα∀X7%≤≤λYT+]88∀j∧9F∪α⊂Q!P@)){⊂⊗λ40s % a LISPE And NIL teSt so@=\Ai←<Xλ (!Q hP λ∞`@JjπW≥iAE↓↓λπ∪ ⊂~*∧:α∧
fN
λ9U*@,L⊂d↓5X8l≡~;p↔λ⊂⊂εE∃7]⊂⊂λ64q`0tiei@9H
βπα@λ
:+02$∧λβ"I≥H_p⊂\p¬ s@=[@∃β|∧bπNβx
P_y2P 7onde@IS]NAβ;#πQ∧¬↔4≥<λ∞⎇=~⊂≥42P&~yx⊂*~vtw3CE897Z2qzελ4z⊂ )pεAiK5aP∨K∂∪'3@∀λ md≥X8l≡~;p↔λ;t4`,e @∩Aα 5βπα@λλd¬U @]←e@/L¬f 4≠{@⊂∀TXP&~yx↔εBαI`≤Aβ##∃β4∧⊗fBβλ⊂⊂\80P )pεAaCIiSCYαceβ≠,¬f&Nlpλ∞M→(⊃,@33q:λ0p∞d↓∩AoS1XAQCYJABAα;@⊗∞AQ'∨'\LVwα∞Mrππ,≥g≡f≤LRεN≥o∩ε↑dλ
(_Y-lz≠8.
|h⊃M}H≥~ T≥X<M≥⎇<h∞≥=→4ea ¬)rYP8wjH4w⊂*~2P3 !lh ≤~(∩∩α[IaNJ~(~∀_⊗d`5≠GhZ`b@@bβ)I\&eJ:∞!ε QαV≤→6&NL⊃& ,s∂#7∂∪'Mβ4¬w$∩;] ↑Xε4y\⊗k lλ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ→_⊂'Xz⊂_@981 "β)II6∧"P4
4ε&}k$ ELT9ε∂"
Z4
L~9∀⊂@"T⎇,-Y8⎇π∧⊂Y;L=≠8<M≡h→[n∧∩;] ↑Y~4n¬5P6↓QU≠nD∧λ∀Z-l→[⊂∩Zyqt_z⊂ dSV⊂#2Zsrw1_zvP0]⊂ dfK⊂)(#H0z⊂)Pdf⊗εB*7]⊂λ⊂(90]:⊂0zλ dfVλ&pyt[:2y⊂_z⊂( T!V⊂!_v=2yλ0z⊂$Tdc⊗εB*7]⊂λ⊂1y{_|↔3 ]2vpwλ0z⊂!⊃i%bf⊃lV⊂!P!⊂0zλ&dj⊗SaV⊂;_w6rf≠2P0zλ dfVβE*7]λ⊂⊂)qZ7rw⊂_z⊂ dSV⊂!iQ↔'7{_uP0zλ)agi⊃FE1qNα DDyer RBates$ VorecK, Saunders, Li@9GP~∀4∃∪g\≥hAiQ∃eJABαβGW?&)βO?n+←#↔⊗)βπ ␈+Q↓ fK↔M1∧#π7≠,∧Bεf≤↑2ε∞l@π∂&≤M↔∂&≤>2∪xQ(&.v=
V∂⊗α|h
|H_p↔[x64aXz2r prggramei@9JAK]YSeO]5K]if↓YSGJ↓→Sg`↓CeJ@4∃ae← CEYr↓S\AC8AKmKαqβ#↔∨→β'∪g+OSKL{WMβ∧{@≡OM→vrr∧
v*πMyv@1"]~ T∃⊂2d ];XnM9{@ ≥Yλ∀L≥H~0~λ7w⊂']y⊂$w≥2y6$\βp%@-¬0AM←β⊃βS#*↓EE=;AAβ←*4+#∂3∃β#-∪∃βπ α&N%p∧α∧&≤lR∧'ook 10.5 SecondpεA←L↓β!*Aβ#'7∀hSS :∞.Vrεmx D∞~→( <<y(
H2j_N↔⊂⊂@2,∧@l\$X ↓αF)βC#,¬bπ⊗↑λ ≤y9⊂⊃i"`j⊃i(⊂!≡F@
IGR@ β)∃% AC9HASH↓iP∨?X↓U 3∧λ l\{{Y∞∃β⊂⊂*~0z⊂ )pεAoQ¬hASHαβ∪'⊃∧εF}ε≤ε+AQUy( ≡Y(⊂∀[⊂:42H897`#ess @=H β∪|¬⊗v: ⊂λ ={<∪ ↑→(⊂→→{y4`4e of the @
←[aSαc↔HQ%π&FTλ /
<⎇~-lh≠p↔→P;pyH27w2H4s⊂ ! hurry wi@QPAiQ∀AC@'h∧ε}H→y.Nα4w3H9wvr]44w3CE:x⊂≤zp c@,AaQCPASf@ G←e@⊗+∂Q Jβπ;⊃∧∧WGε\8
∧∞{{9$ x:0↔≤β in↓KqKGβ+S'⎇`λ↓Q\|⊂∩Yp∧ to be @5C@∪∃∧εvF.dλ
.D~8 P→4πne. CAn p∂JAβ#W;∃∧¬↔"πMtεn∞αy(
H2h⊃mq"[=,=λ→P⊂\z2y∨H⊂)z`2e! But we proBabdi won't iake that speCib`∪F4⊃CiI∃[ah\A/QCPASCiQKefAQ↑Aae=KeC[5Kef↑A'aKα+⊃β?∩β#π O#π 'dKSe@qQ%&FTλ⊗w∨|Z"εO4
v $_{p~\9r]⊂_7z4↔λ⊂$idH40yP_trr`$ fgr↓QCESQCESY%ir
∃α ;⊃β≤{7C3-#↔;↔∨→β≠π↔≠Q9↓¬:∃βπα,Rε∞-zW"πM W⊗*d∧∧f@⎇h⊂≠YP3wP→4πr @MaKKH8~∃)Q¬hAoS1XAiC-JABA1←]NAQS[JA¬fACY0AgsgQKZAI∃mKY←AKefA-]←n\4∃¬Od↓∪]iKIYSg`↓←\Ai!JA-β`AiQKβ∪∃β'~βS#∃∧K@∨∨\Tε}2
↔6Nlpλ
≡β"PL]_9P∩H⊃;rv≠⊃⊂4`. the tiee@MQCeS9JAK]YSe←]5K]hAα Mβ?¬β?O↔ h+S=¬#π/'v9β?[-⊃βS#*β←#?f)β7π≡C';∃εK9β¬∧ε6Nv⎇LRπ/<Z"ε.nm↔ε}m\Vw"aQ$∂"∞MεO~∞
vNwD
v*ε ≡f*ε≤⎇f␈⊗\Dπ&F≡@λ
≡|⎇9$¬_8|n]99λ∞M→(≤m≥Y{→$∞<y<AQY;]M≥|[[,]]
( ≥Yλ→/∞→8u∧∞~_=∧∞~→(
M⎇9→.>λ_|M≤<h→N-{(≠L↑h≥<l↑\c"N⎇;≠λ ={9( n[{(∞M→:<D \Y=
<Y;D∞z≠h ≡Y(≥-m≥8zo∀→;[n\zλ≥
t_Y#!-{H≥
(≤x-\(≠8,=~;Y$∞z=~∧∞~→3$ =λ≥
(≤x-\(≥~-\+Hλ m⎇λ_.A ¬0v≠⊂:w6~urP:~2P1j\92w:λ9tz:Xz4wwλ;tz4λ("(⊗LX9V⊂→t∨FEβE"7r\P0w<[w2P;Zyt⊂:≠P77fZw0z2H0P9r]εA7sλ6rpw~w3s:[⊂12w_t6py~yP:4_z⊂6w\z⊂7sλ:yP1Xw⊂1`/de up
and run|@A∨d↓oSIX↓iQKr↓KCGP↓OK]KICiJA5←eJAEkCgi%←]fAQQC\@4∃CMg]Kef↑4∀~∃ ¬\@~∀4ZZZZ4Z~∀~(_⊂≥Iαj7∂QiAE↓↓λεc _Mw.h∪⊃-l=λ∂λ~q SλYβ j⊂_z⊂)jKiagi⊃←⊂∧iX{2P*~2P"7[844w≤P⊂εE⊃0z2]λ→_⊂'Xz⊂_LN_P⊂⊃Xbf[∧"P4
4ε&}k$λF␈.t F.v≤Dβd≥8Add,h~Bε∂D
5*M89u∀ aQ%∨.-(V∨#$
6∂6Tλ
(⊃≠mN~~0↔≤FA*7Nα pratp at SU-HPP ≠4
a1β⊗ 3k↔⊂∧ε∂"λ¬4hT¬ISI, masinte@HAChAAβ%ε[5β1εX4⊂@@@↓Ys@;≤¬αε∂D
U≤~β24i_Kλ⊂∪→tsr`.baum↓ChA≥*6⊗@¬X∀LJDλ M≥Y→P⊗→tyq`( at SUH @¬T LUAPBα∧∧π.→h⊂⊂]⊂)`∃-AI, @
`∂"mmw6∞αh⊂.D∀p
VTaci"CE1q]λ1yr.lefat at SU)SCORA¬
λAftep carebul@1rASG=YCiS9JA[sMKYLA→` >Tλ
(⊃≠mN~~3D∞Y<\n↑h⊗⊂λ1ww:≤4πveRpπr
∃β+AβWw#'1βv{]1αJβ∪↔↔bα%β7/≠Qβπ ∧εf.≡>Bπ≡]lBε
.&N.d
f␈&T vrε,]ε∞fd v $≥~→!QXy5 ≤αqr`[9S⊂⊂βE
First↓←DAC1XXAo!ChASβ→βS#Lε2ε↔↑8
-l<|h
|H_p↔[x0q4[3P⊃9→x7y:→r⊂1`0u tiMe" o@8~∃@3∂∪∨*
\⊗≡F≥lW
π⎇~FBε]Hλ.∞y9⊂≥4rrP≠w⊂9vXv6⊂'[2y←Pλ+t0zλ40x 0ened↓iP≤4TεFNnTλf␈∩ |↔,X9y$ {{⊂⊗→qz4`/n, cHangiNdεAmSβ∪S@.≥DεNn≤|W
@λ→0~_U⊂7`. phe big
machines >4⊂⊂∀*8V≡}l@λ
|H_;
Eλ≥z ↑Y(⊃
t⊂∧P 'o to buy @QS[JAα{9β¬β⊃AYA∧εvO&∧λ
|9λ⊂⊂]3P7`& 10≡~)≠←gh↓←@→β&C∃β L9β'π≤C';↔~α%β/v{]β∂⊗{←↓β-↓βS=∧εFF*∞ vNwDλ
m <Y(∞M→>( ≡Y#"M∞αyz bare@1rA]←β!β@/<≤&f* h n⊂ g,H$s:2\αh SGβ↓β+∨↔→β∪W⊗K;≥β&C∃β∪∂I0⊂HαC"JM~8Y∧
βs⊂ !lhλ@1∧εvF/,Tε&@h≡0↔]P9x %nd yOur typical da`3β#'7∃∧¬V}n]nG1 ¬0↔hen c@=IS@;8πrαβ⊗TRε@yH⊂⊗↑P:4`-e go@∃`
β'w#=β↔&KS'lp ∧ \[p≠\βi`≥NαβS#K|εV =β"P↔[2⊂3 5ncti@=]f@1∧∧F.↔\|vNvtλ /∀_{p∩→P7w ti`≥r5Gaj[QS[J[U`∂π∨*β∂πMH d
{C"HZβ f⊂
8¬su@¬YP∪@∀λ N4πm @]SiQSαqβC#*β↔β'&{@∩b∞⎇εN≡∧λ
.P9w`-ethi@9H 4
l
≤@⊂∧ihλ4∧ac@-`
"
x D {x
`2pπ@∃%p∧α∧Xπq all @=H βSF+G* ≤7&Om_
≤αyV⊂≥42FE⊃4πlp@!S\AQ¬`
βC⊗{[↔9∧¬↔'≡]H D∞≠h⊂⊗YP⊂λo@YKdAi!JAaCMhAcK¬`RAi<AEJ~)ChAY∃CghAα @~ε⎇x lD_8h ≥H≥3MMβpr2Y⊂→_≠ ⊂∀<r\β( I caf Find Thee At ni@≥QhBX4⊃C@; ∧εNr
\⊗wJ∞|↔O~∞:Wε/-_ n↔⊂⊂)]x2y4[y0 `)dAG←[∃`
β≠⊗{5βSLseβCd ∂πLhQ# ≤pπ<|Y0∩[⊗⊂8 ,us deceftwi`≥I=nAaC
P∂π∨-→1β7,∧⊗rεLZ7
ε|-wεNlpλ ≥Yβ"N,9~4n
_8 `)ng), drgm the Compl@∃iJAC gKMGα)β/→¬#'7↔≡CπK≥lrαD∀ f/6↑!PW≡\Tε
εL]F∂J NWεNlpλ \~=~-lh≠{D (⊃∪mN~~0↔ ⊂1:`4 I really dk notice
λkne when↓∩AO↑↓ECGV↓C]HAUgBABα↓IAYα¬Bε/lX D∞z=~∧
≠x9∧ =Y`⊂~w⊂:4→P_V@2 range),
and Fp¬P∨5¬##∃βπ∪↔∪'≥#π πdKSeβ|∧bπ& Tπε/> vw≡T
v $≥~→$
88z
≥Y(
∀≠Y=L↑C"R ≡Y(≥
t_{s,T~;H ≥Yλ_L];x;D∞~→( L8⎇λ∞M_=∞M→(≤o≡⎇→;$
<h→
}{Kλ
}C"U
=λ~.D~<h >Y⎇y \λ≠=,=λ≠;n,+{→.≡h≥~ ≥H∩( ←≤→8nL9 λ ↑_kJ!QA"QM}<]~∧
yH_-M λ∪ml(_p-d→y=∧∞≠h∩mm⎇h≥m =λ∃
;Y|d∞_:y$ (≠∪mlh≥~-\#"Smd⊃≠{∞
~;\d¬≠8:m≥Yh_-lλ≠≠l≤α4w3H34v2\T⊂9:[74w3H4w:2\892z→r⊂1gY2TFE_w2⊂6Zw0vt↑2P27Zw3P:~2vW⊂λ'w2P_x897Xqt⊂$\β to type AHEANUP! @)kgh~)EKM←IJAO←αK;≥βF{7* Xλ,=λ≠Z,@t:↔ I have l@∃H AβoIα∪?eβ#'→¬∪W;m_ LQ"YSn⊂9r`6eral dayc and Nights straight doiNe co@5aciCQS←]f0AoSi A]N~)o←eedACE←UhAiQ∀A[CG!S]JA
` πOFK;≥β|qβ'∃p↓↓"π ∧εf.≡:Bb∧∀λ
l≡{I⎇↓QX{sL<<[Y,D∃3U →λ∪_..↑(∪,≡z;] ↑H≥x.∀~;<∞,<|q,D≥~_.D∩(⊂⊗~{2P&~urP*~0z⊂DCE w<]p|V⊂≥42P7[6<P)≥w9P;Z2y2P≠w2P!Xy2yP≠{2y6]qt⊂0X5zz_x:P*~vrFE_ps⊂1→P27w→P7w_wvx4[2r⊂![p2Wλ#wy2≠w⊂'7]0qu@ th∂YHαβ7*∞Mε∂"
↔1"X :[⊂;pyH27w2H7w⊂$[8∧erppeteD code,∧A)Q∀AMeC
iS@?ph#'≠&+CA↔↔+; 6≥lro&≥\R`<{{<
≥→9⊗\8¬`≥]%]NKi%[@∃βLε2ε@=8p∀λ4∧a`%≥KdAMα{@⊂@ ¬"7[844`.pεAiQ¬\AM←β⊃β/SF+@∩ε\≤6FNβY0→K⊂9wP~z⊂4`3 j`∨@ ∧π><Xλ 2ising phat
a @1CeOJ↓S]iKβ∪CK↔&+⊃βC⊗{⊂∨⊗≥Pλ
L8π3zZyt2`3 kn @QQJA =YaQSαq0$!Q$6NnMαb∧α(⊂∀_{2P!→pp∞ @¬[CuK⊂AChAβ##∃β⊗+@∨ε⎇n6O6]lW>h≠p∪λ&pqd[82yελ)t2`)l,
@¬]HAi!JA←i!KdA∪9iKeY%`∂AX@ε >Xπr`0 fglk, when face` with
@
←[aYα ';S~q↓αSF+eβ#∂3∃β αX
-Nα⊂:xλ0P;"\αy hidπPAGβ∪↔β'⊗K3'SJβ←'S@β7(β"P⊃≡P77`7, and I tai`
Ai!KSdAββC↔∪L∧7&Nβ{\d 8[p~]⊂3:`4ure ImproVementpε~¬@∂+'S∃∧ε6/⊗α;p~\v8 .A)QJ↓ P∨3∧¬εNr
↔4→x 7]w⊂6zXt⊂12]8∧er↓←mKdαβS#∃∧π⊗.∂!Q&␈∩∞8 d )x % p gKα!β'Qp∧α¬& Tπ=≠⎇{L↑|h⊂↔Yα the i`≥i∃` CK,εF/∩
_ d
{Y(
|β
@QQJAaI←E@3,k@~πM WJε≥nF.vDλ
t_{p→≤αectZP∃β∞s⊃βSF)βO3|εrε&\≥FNv|4π>OM↓P@,Z;⊂∩\β should @ JAC[∃YS@?α,↔&.Dλλ.P;rf≠↔αEεBαSihth, what i@LAaQSβ→β≠W≥→βπ ⎇+Qα∞|rO'lp∂d∧⊂∧P $on'`(αβ⊂≡=λ⊂__tr⊂ "y the
si@iJA←L↓iQJAα#πS¬∧ε7'↔\8
∞↑Y<h ∀≤≤[lNαqrVλ1:z with↓iQJAα CCK|επ-88
2[2yyFB4πf @QQK@'α λ ={]→-nα9W M`∨@≤εBε@yH⊂⊗↑P:4`-e i`&↓`∂C↔w!β∪?L¬f 1 ¬#bU⊗⊂ ⊂UT, CAR, CDR, and lo@≥SGCX↓←aKe¬iS@?w→↓#'v≠3@.M_ L@P!gg⊃∀WεE∪p|q2H4πnl@d@dZ@ ∧πε/$λλl]]λ⊂↔Yα my ti`≠J↓SfAgββ↔;Q∧¬⊗r∧9ye≡NβY`↔βE*42H1wvx≠0p nt abo@UhAgYα{]β≠,¬f∨&≥x D x;⊂⊗~w3P )pεAmC1S@⊃Dλλ-lλ~0→H0p∞o@QQKd~)SiKZαβ;↔πα λ∞M→(⊂~≠x⊂7`& phe Dh∂Y@∧¬εNr }&␈/∧}2π∨L≤6@5β
λ¬'Kmα+;@&∧λ
.P6pqZ4p∞e p¬KISα 'M_
∂∃β⊂⊂ )t ic. Ac I said, I use @%h⊂∀,h n⊂82`2iod`&↓←@→β& gMβ∂!β¬β&K7* ,W'y90↔λ9x `'α{WSM∧εvO&↓Q&fOL¬≠ T≥{p→≤αy. Mi`≥J↓QCfAαs↔[↔⊂∧ε↔⊗βzy-d→≠p≠[⊗⊂77\α has a`≥s=]JAKβ3↔HQ(λm⎇990↔≥2r⊂ 4o me tha`(αβS#↔Lε'4~_<e@⊂⊂!:Yβs i@8A∪@;&+@⊗@~8p_ b⊂4`4pπ@↔LaPGy<Y$ {{;-⎇H_ ⊂≡p¬a`$αβπ>uDε
π|X -v8 @=GGkeIK]GJ↓`∂'a∧¬V}wM∞2ε∞⎇u@hV≥lBπX∧p∩tua`→YβIβ 6β{Y/
<⎇→-nα⊂77]Tε There is a↓ECHAββ#↔mx ,]XπwεBαcal@1K@⊃β≤ ;∪ ∂∪@⊗NβY`⊂≥40p∀↓←GGCMS←]C1YrAgαc?←Mtes @]QKeJ↓H >M>2ε>M_&gJ X .\=→( @⊂"7`,phins to @∧~∃↔_D`A←d↓B@d`X`vAM%H∂WK~β? αpπS∪*
x Dε λ∩ ≡Y(⊂⊃→ps⊂&Yw:4`/ned.
λ@
@?⊂∧εoJ
]vv/∃Dε∞vDλ /∀≥~;,Uλ_ @4szi→P7s⊂_q3rjλ'≡YP~yP94Yt:↔εB∧¬αDou`∞A→∃]Ch~(~∃!&hA∩AG=kYHAβ≠WCCdπ∩π&≥]⊗v: L↔&
x Dλ=<Z.≥{kλ∞t7{t[3P4`4 to @Ik\
∃α ?W β¬β≠∞≠S ?$λ l@⊂~⊗@5 pimepεAgYα{←/$λ md_(⊃
⎇≤~~-d≥~_-d≠{@⊂_P→_≠ ⊗εE "ut that would @QK]HAβ#=β?↔≠∂WK*βS#∃∧¬V∞Vβx 4]<P7`& p QJpAa←αK;CM∧ ?[*`4+πv!βO?,¬F"εLX LD_;@ ≡=~→-n~8p∀]<P0w→⊂;rdYβht @Q↑AiQ∀AP∨SF+@∩π,Xλl]]β"D12w1Z4pq5\Q⊂:4_z⊂:4→|P27H73r→2yr`2ve. It's not @QQChAαk';∃¬;?W3 h# ∃∧k?K∃∧ ∂∂W⊗ S∃1∧SWOQ¬##πQ∧r>*∃ε{⊂∩πM Rπ&↑>G4≥y)n,(→≠m≥Yh~.1"X8l><X= T→;[n\βt⊂⊗KP:yt[3P24Y32y2[:⊂3&_qP7h≥4ww9H:7P*~2P1`/mpilep αhaq produced runtime diffeRence sof over @¬\A←e⊃KdA←_A[CO9SikI∀~∃O]∧@@d`X`AS\↓` G;&K7*
xbπ& Tε&Nl≥Bε≡⎇↑εNf\@λ =y→+AQK+#%U++#!↓"@↓AlL )|⎇ &ε∀λ %fFα<≤L≡≥⊂⊃
≤8[≠d¬∀⎇3L↑
(α( ;Xp∀≠py5yH37y∩w:2y≠4yx⊗U lεE⊃0z2]λ→_⊂'Xz⊂_\N_P⊂KN→[≥→
⊗h"*βE#97[]⊂89_z:⊂ ]⊂"4pX67FE∃7]⊂#→tsrw_0zv`⊂dfV⊂∪,g!d⊂*iaVRidaελ)(#`∀`df⊗λ)4w2→62tiXt dSV⊂10[=2y ~yts⊗βE⊂⊂⊂λ1q3 ≠qV⊂!\r↔77]0u`9Xwy2Vλ1y{0↑↔30z→vpw _2y5r[2|V⊂≠pytw≥2y 8_y1VεB⊂⊂⊂⊂≤qt7r[ 0tvK⊂;0w≠rv62P0tvFB)zq5→qz≥⊂⊂2w1t≠py5yH37y⊂∩w:2y≠4yx⊗U lεE⊂q]⊂"⊃<ry ≥yqVt\tq⊗⊂∀!0z2\`:yqKtytq ⊂)pz[22y9P:yqVZytq⊗λ+7y2Xu`:yXVtytXεEεE⊂P92qYw:⊂)Xwy2P_17py→⊂6ry\psrP≠s⊂6t[2P22\qy4q~w3P:~2P92\zv:9H7s⊂9[vrPεB12w1Z6py5\P40rλ0P9zX52qzλ64w2H7s⊂⊃∪4ryVλ20vw→r⊂64YyV⊂0[2⊂12[1t6p\5yW⊃βE!2w_t6py~yV⊂6~urP:_|2yP_w2⊂2↑0vyVλ0y2P≥w5:y]⊗⊂:w≤7x:v_y⊗⊂1≥z⊂:w_{7tr_q62WβEεE$→y2P4\P0w⊂→|1ry≤:⊂39≠vP0P≠7z2P∩P9rw≥⊂0P3→{P20↑yP0s[P:7P≥42P)]0w37\2⊂!w[x:z2\⊂εE)Xtrw1YP"2x_y:6r[:⊂!w[x:z4[3P#0Xtv4z~ryP![vvtj≥2rV⊂≤x2v&~w3P7]z⊂:4→P1y4]2y4pHεE$P_x86<H:7P1→w1t6Xy1yWλ⊂'7`4e that the criteria are not meant To yield the
"universal bencHmark, ∧AoQ%GPAI=KfA]=hAKq%ghXA khAe¬iQKd↓iVAs%KYHAββK?∨⊗ 7MhS←#?≡)β ↔F ['?∩β?9βλ∧εn∞=
⊗v*∞⎇⊗fB ,Rπ∨\|v/∨M≡f*ε|dπ&F≡@εn∞=
⊗v*}4ε&∂∃↑FznL∨∩h. Wε6}-V∞v<U`hPQ(λL\z;H ←_y4N∞β"K%U+++%U+++%U+++%Q"C"I <Y( ≡Y(≥
(_p→~z2y4XP$P$_{2P1→rw⊂:\ts3@ tk date i@8AGQ←=cSMN↓→Sg`4∃EK]
Q[Ce-f\~∀4∀b\AQQJAE∃]GQ[¬eVAg!←kYH↓c←Ym∀ABAaI←EYK4AoQ←MJAG←5akiKHAg←YUiS←\↓SfAMIKckK9iYb@4∃GCY1KHAM=d\~∀4∀d\AQQJAaI←OeC5[SMN↓gisY∀AkgK⊂AgQ←UYHAE∀A←]J↓iQCh↓QKYaLA[CW∀Aae←≥eC[f↓[←eJ~∃oe%iCEY∀XAeK¬ICEY∀XA[C%]iCS9CEYJ0AC]H↓a←ei¬EYJ\4∀~∀f8@A'k UKGh↓i↑AGISiKe%←\@d0AiQJ↓EK]G![CeV↓cQ←k1HAS[AYK[K9hAC\↓KMMS
SK]h~∃g←1kiS←8Ai↑AQQJAaI←EYK4AShAβ≠?3[/→84λhR∂K'&+C'?r↓Eβ'~βS-β∂3?'⊃¬##∃β≤¬voεL≥⊗w" =vnn⎇mGJε\≤F*ε≤-w/"∞9vn
,Vv≡
\↔⊗←4↓PW~_=∧∞~→0≤H27P'≠z⊂:2\z⊂92Xv⊂;w\4∧d @AeWEY∃[f@9ααπK≤¬→.
9{@⊂ ⊂0r:→vx:9H87P ,ive Up ∃I<AgiC9ICeILAeKG=[[K]⊃KHAEdAg←MQoCeJ↓K]OS9KKe@~β πO,∧Bε}d∞&.f≡M↔6* 8 n≡≤h∪l@εA0"[x62P_w2⊂4_y2;p\2V⊂ ! ratio that programmers continua to hav@∀AISM→SGkYQr~∃E∃YSKm%]NAS8AC]H↓CAUkMiS]N↓i↑L@↓πeSI∃eS←\fAgkAaYK[∃]ifA
aSiKIS←\@DAErA]KKIS9N~∃←UhAae=OeC[LAiQCPAo←k1HA]←PACeSMJAS\↓aeCGQSGJA=\ACG
←k]h↓←LAE∃S]NAQ←↑~∃%]KMM%GSK]PX ↓↓D3?Iβ&C∃β7|ε7"π,\⊗fO>M⊗~ε,]f≡F\≡&O~Dλλn
=→4M≥{H d∞z≠⎇-Lλ≤Y,<:9Q!Q]~→$∞x;9$ →9|L\(≠p∪λ2vx4_ytyP_yP4gλ:<p4Xpr⊂ 0rkgbamming9 si@9GJAi!SfAKαkC#π≤¬↔4~8c!-~9z
O(≥X.-88[ T≥~→$ |Z= ↑Z;{D
8>(∞≤9Y3∂∀_Y(
≥]→4N∞Y=→,D≤{s,↑z_=∧∞X9⎇,]≤+@∀CE
Customer benchmarks can afdh∂eH↓iP≥βn+↔Qβ∨∪'S↔⊗K?9↓λ∧εn␈,Tεv∂,-w>g∀λ
;H→l]Y<X-A ¬12[1t6p\5yV⊂~w⊂:4_z⊂⊃;Zr2P:\pQ⊂!Xw⊂12H1ww9]9:rbλ:7P&Ypw⊂⊃~2p{4[<P:iYr⊂1<H:42FB1zyj≠vryπλ⊂⊂*4≥yP3'\α H@!@Aake
QCgKβ→β'Q∧¬V∞↑↑4π∞;\y$∞≠h⊂~\pP$(∀⊂897Yy0vyH0yFE_2w1`(marks, at↓YKCGPAc`AQ↑ABAββ?'≠"q↓α∂-∪@⊗.nD∧E¬∧
πε@yx 0[yP3t]2P0wλ0qq`5pate
esTimate fgr↓S[KKα#'πS*βπCCdK∂πSN{;M1∧∧'/"∞MεO~ ≤6∨/,≤7Jπ>L↔↔'4∞FzεL-⊗7α ≡2h,∞&}?,≥W~b∞∞&}?,≥Vn/.5Bε∞l@ππ⊗|}&∞n]_ Lt≤⎇≡-L<h_m ;Yy%Dλ∃~∞↑h→[n∧≠≠{Lu<X;L|(β"N∞Y9~,>~;{N5λ≤≤M||X;.4≠yH |;Y4L≥λ≥=
≥~=≡%D~;H∞ <]~,>;_<D∞≤[yn,9<h∞M_=
=Y(↓QY[⎇-lλ→\L↑=93ND_<∀
M8x=
≥{H≠nl<H⊂⊂H82y4[r⊂7sλ6pw<H<rpy≤P4w⊂≠pw<P≤60qr\β and can
be expeCted To coNtinue to @MQ←nAβ+Aβπ~βOW ⊗{WS'v+Eβ'rβ7π;JβCK??∪π7Mbβ7π∂*β≠ ?$↓PVN|,Rπ≡≡M↔∞X8u
}↑(⊂⊃→w1t6Xy0 s.
~∃∧ASCG!S]JAQQChAβ∪↔GWLε&/~ ,Vv≡
\↔ε←4 f␈"
\V/&≥lrε∨-~F/⊗≥ybβ
_ D
|Y→.⊂:7P≠4πok
gooD is Not tuned for real worh HAββK/ f+7Md∧∧NH_ ⊂≤93sy_vrt`.e style that
defeAts c@ISiKe%←\@dαβ'Mβv+↔∪↔ ∧ε&←$λ∩εn≤=εNvT f␈"∞Mrεf⎇y2εf≥<Rε
Mv*ε=x . <Y9∧↓"Y≠d
⎇~→.∧≠88m
;Y0→H:42`. that macHine IpεA]←PAak]∃HAM←β⊃βS#*β↔∂?v{7'∂~β? β&{∪πe?→4 ≤{7CW&K;≥βnK3'↔*q↓α∪,3↔πSNs≥β∂⊗KS↔KL{9↓Mπ#=βK.#W∂∃π##∃βε+C≠?⊗kπ;∂*β↔πAh+ ↔';↔↔→εkπ∂#Ns↔MβO→β3'↑)β#?f#';≥∧{3g↔εK
βS⊗ ∂-β/3↔;S~β'9βn{3πO≡+E(4Ph)55ji555ji555ji544T+;⊃β-C∂↔K¬ 4(∀TIβ←?,c⊃βπ&!βS=¬##↔O*β∂Kπ&+C'¬π##∃β4¬vff}⎇⊗v: ≤G6N<Tε}r
_ NL<\⊂→→z4w3H12w1Z6py5HεA:4[ts3yN∧@
1( @A⊃←\OhαβSπ<Tε∞w∀
FNnT
6/⊗≥}W≡g∀λ nM→<@∞M_;@∞2pv⊂
8πalL-cloChεRAi%[@∃9αα'2∂≥w(h,≡&*ε⎇`ε
πM→V*O= ↔⊗.Dλλm⎇<≥5 ↑Kλ⊂≤[zP40]2P:;[P;0y~pq6"\β to contend with: Real
tiee and devaation fp¬←ZAQsaSG¬XAY←¬H\@A∧A←]J5ICiK4AEK]
Q[Ce,AoSY0A[KCMkeJ~)aKCX↓iSKJ↓k]IKHAisA%GCHAαc?π⊃∧≠?;∪M#'?;~aβ≠?⊂∧εn␈,Tε&/L≥⊗bπ≥}Rε≡≥`πεf}@πε.≥DhWM≥V*ε≤|⊗Nw>Dεf@x9 @0qz7\↔⊂⊂(→y9wg_v⊂1`/mputeps are si@5aQKdαβ←'S@β?;∪Jβ?;∃h#@6≡-⊗∞⊗LTπ&@h≥{n∞↑(⊂,-⎇=β∧∞Y8;∧∞~;9%AαEεE ↔⊂⊂"≠w∪z treat facTors Od∧@dAβ≠↔Kπ⎇+G3E∧∧f␈∩ ⊂λ∞tp∞gle benchmari( @Ae←jAGα 94T+πO'eIβ≠πv!βKπ⊗KπS'|s@~ε|dπ&F≤4εn∞⎇m↔'9→( ≥Yλ∪-}Y(∩-d≥~→$∞X=~-t≠yH∞M→(β!∞→<YM}Xεpw_pP7`& pwo machines, by c@!C]OS9H
βC⊗{⊂∨⊗≥]V/∩Dλ ≥Yy0,\+λ⊂⊂[2↔wiλε@
benchmapk& DiffEpefc@∃`
β -#←↔↔p∧εn∞=
⊗v/4 vvg∀λ nL<Y⊂≥4π become pπSO]%ISGC9h@~∃]QKLAe←jAQ¬mJA←α∪GπKαh ,D≥~→-T≤}4nL8εpz~qpv&≡P7s"\α a @IKaeKMK]iCQSmKYdAEe←¬H@~∃β∪π;∨*β? β⊗+;∂#n @⊗←5DεF}LM⊗v: 8 mn⎇_;ND≠{[∂∀≥~≠np¬ thingc you @¬aJAC
i`↔πd¬GJQ(
∞<p ng po @5KCgkβ∪∃↓∞>V≡B ≡2πε Tεn∞=
⊗v*
_
∞p¬`→L0AWdAβ##∃βn ∂#'v)βπl@λ ∀β"P__y:4a]v0q compIler).
~∃QQeKJ↓`∂'↑
F*ε,Yf≡F\≡&@>h∩(
=Y( ,9;@
Mβwut[3P0zλ92qb[:6<P≥py2P_t7qb[⊂397[P:42H∧@
areas od∧ACY≥KEeC%FA[C9SakYα S'?paβ≠∨⊗kπ1βd{⊂≡N5Dε∞vD
6␈↔M≥f:R∧
FF*∞,W∂ε\8
≡Y(β!,];XnM9{\d <Y.AQ@εE_Kα depiv(exp! @]QSGPαβ∂?7π+S↔M¬##∃β&+C'[∂#'[∃¬;'S!¬∪↔OC,∧7"πMt¬Bε|dπ&FT↓PW⊗≡M⊗}v≥Dε/G∞,W∂≡≥⎇bαy>≤∧tλ_ ⊂≤αati@=]C@1∧∧WGπ,Z7=8πw is oNe involviNdεAmCISCEY∃`
!hS∂?;∨#π;S~aαB∩-→1α∩L2~-(Yd *D
DL@10 Vλ0p∞d↓# ⊗>$J⊗ 5E∃Bπ>≡Mε␈/Dλλ.Nα2vx≥4s3@ any
λsimplifiCation kf The reqult≠
~∀H\@AI9HQoM_RAoQ%GPAG=]mKeQbAiQ∀AoKYαa7≠∨α-V." h n
=;⊂⊂H∪{s# P⊂1`/nsisting od∧@~∃AeWa←MSiS←9CXAm¬eSCE1KfAG=[ES]∃HAoSQPA≥∨PXAβ≥⊂XAC]⊂A∨$X↓oQKe∀Aβ≥λ↓C]HAr than arrays
tk hold iNtermediate values.
I Have codedup my own Macliqp and Interlisp implemeNtatiOns oF theSe and stoRed
Them On <CSD.PBATT> at ScOp¬JXA]SiPAIKgaK
iSmKαce↓~bβπ;⊃αr&!β∨+≠≠'F+M↓β≡yβS#∂ 4+∃v91βSF)α'≠&+K &≡:απ≡}.BεO4 6∞fL\B¬≤z*B`)3
+D∧∩)y∧ Y(~-n→<Y.>→9⊂~w⊂9bYts3FB∀0TP≥42ybH2|0q]⊂897Yy0vyH:4vrY⊂7w≠z42iλ&4yx≤FE∀1
P7z4→y⊂4f\42vr[:0r4[w9P'Yα thes`
AMU]GiS=]fAg%[S@3∂∪3eβ&K7.EaPU& Tεn␈M~f∂&≥ybε⊗]
⊗v"¬ "Jε≡4π&@h≤Y,N8y(∞M→(⊃/∞α2w:λ:7P 7hichthe Benchmar`↔f↓CeJ~)[@↔π≥+C'≠8∧εn(_<d∞y;⊂⊗λ0yP 4he machinepεAC]⊂AG←[ASYKeLX@A)!JAeK%[aYKαk↔;S∂#'?;_h#O#⎇+3⊃β⊗)βKWp∧ε}r ≥Fbε\≤6FNβY0→H0s2 compilerc being benchiarked&
I @]←kYH↓CYg↑↓YSGJ↓iP≥β≡+∃βC⊗{C?O,!β?SF+Aβ .s∂#7∂∪ ∨~∞Mε∂"
\V/"
←∩π&∞,V*ε>-↔&/-≤⊂hV≤-w6*d∧¬&G,XRε⊗]l6Fn≡-7~ε≡4ε
π>L↔↔"Dλ'/" Mrεv}@ε⊗.⎇≥bπ&t
7ε∞d
FF*∞,⊗v>T
v H,,V∞b↑⎇w⊗FD FO∨∧ ↔πεM≤6∂&≥⎇g~R∧ f␈&T
FF∂Dλ
(∃_-<=8p∀~P3:g_z4wwλ30tf≤β two kf my
cRiteria: !↓IP∨I∧{ ['␈+@~π,\↔≡}n5Bβ~ ,V≡∂↑8Rπ& X LT~<h ∀_{⊂↔\p¬d @→←e@5∧+cCK-≠G'⎇aPV6| π&F≡4ε .αp∞c@QS←\\α↓αS#*βWOW∞aβK↔≤εW.z=Q$
9<∪ ]9;] ≡~;sD
βs⊂#~q0∂nacci(n) woUld f@¬SX~∃β##∃β≤ 7*∞Nvzε>-↔&/-_λ%D→X:-M8π3@ cr`∪@&+@⊗Nβ{@⊂ P10→ being p o↑↓Kqa←9K]iS¬YfAgαc?←↔⊂∧π&F≥aPF
⎇v}α ≥F =|Z5
+C"AQR9∞⎇⎇;⊂∩λ12P'~qrP*≠P4w1[8¬de qome very large benchiarks( @AQQJA[¬S\A←α∪OSπ≤c∃β#,ε&*ε≤∧c!∞~→(
9z =|⎇
|H≤∪n84w3H40p∩ge proerams betwea`≤Aβ##∃βn ∂#'v+Eβ ,¬⊗v: 9voε≤,V"r∧
Fxh.Mε*ε←∞F.wDλ
=λ⊂~~4yP'X9z0q[2P1`!n be overcome, large benchiarkq abe m`∨Gβ!βO↔d∧6}nUaP@HαB5L≡9z_-d∀≤X.Nβ"C!↓αAεEβE
λ∞db5_∂∂Qhπβ
α∧ε∪βH~*∧:α↓_7-=→0→~ww⊂_H⊂⊂εE∃5]⊂⊂λ+)(⊂_z⊂ ∪U-AI, ∧G)∪5∪⊂~≥tjN≡nαI∀j@⊂ε)h↔Q⊂0zλ)jV`RP⊂εEβE$P $oubd↓iQC@ ∧ε∨⊗α8
2\αi`∨\α↓Eβ#∂→βπo∀π>→8p∀Xv⊂92[2{0w_p¬ e@aGCah↓iP≤4Tε6␈.βY⊂→βood(h∂dAβ#=βG,∧⊗fNo∀ε&@|H⊂∩\zpv⊂≠x87`2tp @;LεGJε]↑εf@|∧vr[8⊂3 5nds).
He@IJOfA]Qr\A]QChAα#?πM∧∧⊗wNβ{Y$ x8 2H47s@≠4πng↓iQJA⊃Ke@'αh↔&OlTε .αp∞c@QS←\AQCWKf|~∃¬K
CkgJ↓QJ@Q1KhOF↓`∂πeJβ←π;'→βS=∧∧Fzπ=_ -≥_8@⊂≥44w3\P4w his Ppkgbam* Ghat
Simalap∧AiQ%]OfA
C\ABαβC↔K≤¬vrπ|≥g"πMtε&{$
G,=Y0→≤p¬ l@%`∂Qβ≤εG.αqz:\2V⊂ -ake
a co@ArPAC9HAie¬]gM←β∪5β' ∧εNr∞9vn(≥x/∃β⊂ ∀he interes@QS]NAα≠?7C|¬f.wL4ε}⊂β"P~~4yP \2P:9_{2y9Xv⊂ @
←a`'Ls∃ " ≥f"πLX nM9Y`↔λ*90{→y9pvλ4p∞vOlp
Kf↓GCdAα ;⊂4T∧6'∩ ≤6≡∂>8 .T∧ c@=as@'v9β'≠6{3@6↑4ε≡}n5Bπ→<p~~w3P )nrgl@YKfAKβ β/I∧∧∩ππ≤∧⊂∩H82yj α ∀~)'S@;≤∧RεVβh⊂↔[2P;p[89P*≠P27P→2y4k_z4{ %pεAMe=ZAgGβ∪πS∂@¬Bπε Tε/F≤:Bε⊗]l6FN≡-2εO1Q&O↔,X ↑X;]∧∞8π6 %pπfASβ!β'M¬#?SπdceβSLεεN≡≥Dε␈∩ ≡f/⊗≤|Rb∧≤@εO~
↑V≡B ,W'→<C!∞≠h∀∞-⎇Z1 T≤≤[lM9→<d
yH⊂L]Xz≠,≡Xy0∩λ7y⊂ [0r0→Zed primitives op∧A←a∃aCiS=]fL~)
←dA∃qCKa1JtAG=]fXAα≠πIβ∞≠∂↔O~aβ∂∪⊂∧ε∞≡<X n5λ→R/
β:v@_y0r4≠rz4aK⊂36 /num
aradhmatic, bignum arithmetic, function call, frame reTentiOn (InterL@%`∂A∃APDLuDε∂↔,∨∩ε∞<8 .yP @¬aeCr↓GeKCQS←\X↓CeeCdAcaI¬iSMNαaβπK⊗ eβ∂|επNNβY`⊗λ;2q`4or~∃α ∂∂↔∨→1β[,≠S ?$λλn2pz4[w⊗⊂+→qz7iλ8x20]4s3@, rec@Q←dAGβ∪↔πSL{91β4 3@.T∞ε∂∨=→f:`Q)W.gM~εf*∞h⊗g9(∀ ≡|z3LUλ≠[me;≠pl≥λ_smn≤[p⊗λ9z9:Xz:y2\T∧ variable access,
p
Ce%CEIJ↓kaICQS]NX↓H G≠≤εFN}d F}∞M≥f:@λ≤| \z8;∧ 8xp∩\yR⊂ ,ocal acce@MfXAE%]IS]≤~∃iS5KfHAα;πK ∞;∃β∂|c3↔∂&K?9β|∧bε≡⎇n2ε≡]IG~B ≡'⊗∂≡5Bε6∨
g.o5Dε6F⎇nVo~βλ⊂⊃~sw:v\VεE!Y9⊗qwY4w3@ effi@
SKMGβI1βC∞;';≥¬#'7∃bβO←π∧εεNvt∞FNnUDε≡}↑
⊗fNlpλ∞M99+∧ {{<
≥→9β! {y→$∞|→1,D≥Y4N≡<h∩-n→<\∞,=→1∧ {y→$∞|→1,Eλ~~,↑X<Xm∂(→P⊗_z:2w~w3P*~vrVεB864i]⊂0qqYyyV⊂≤64yjλ8x20]4s3@, functigncedl lh∂←WU`XACMcSO]5K]hX↓giCG,AMeC5J~¬GIKCiS=\AiS5JXAKβ#
8∀Ph"CK|;Cπ↑4εfN<Tε&/-≡bε}mH∞$∞→<u∧ελ≠qD∞~→0→YP4w_w⊂:w≥4s::Zz4{2H4p h8A)CV0AChA1KCgh0~∃C@~β';?>qβS=∧εF/∨Dε∩π&
≥f:ε⎇mGKR∞>F∞≡4 wε/,≡FN}n4ε∞vD∞FF*∞|↔JπM Rε≡⎇↑εNf↑!PV@8;X,|<h≤n\zλ≥
;Y|ed∩9λ
]9z≥∧ 9≤{d∞Y=Q,≥λ≠t∞M;:6L≡~;{N4≥~_.D≥~→$ {{<
≥→<C!,x;@ MiH∃ ≥iλ⊂≤[zP1`,aie, is uninteresting. YEt it tells more infOriation
@ KGCkβ≠∃β'"βC';ε{';S~β'SMπβ?';"β?→βNkCπ∂"qα∪↔⊗KY1αJ;⊃βO∂I1β↔∨≠↔;SN 33DhS∪?↔≠Qβ'QεKEα∞|rMβ'w#↔;OM3∃84Ph*%β&{9∨Qε{ +↔∨!βS=πK?WI∧∪↔;∂FkπK/~qα'Q?→β+W∨!βS#∂!α%β&C';-πK?Uβ&yβ¬β≡c'∨# h+∪'∨≠↔K[N≠∃βSzβS#∃π;#?3*β↔;∪. [?Iε∪eβ∂d '7'v9βS#∂!βg?*βπK∃ε≠#??≡K;≥β/C∂↔3f+;P4V∪↔;∂FkπK/~β←#↔rβg?Uε K∃β≡K7C3JβC'∂↑K;≥β≡{;[↔vK↔;Q∧{;↔Mε{AβO}k↔S#Ns≥84Ph*O'v≠∃βSF)βπW&K↔;∂*βS#π β←∃β∂∪∃βπNk';≥ε QβOF{W3∪r;Qβ *βO?36K;≥βπ∪? 3.kL4+&CπQβ∂∪∃β∂}k7?;gIβO?g3↔⊃1¬;∃βOF{W3⊃∧k↔πO/∪∃βSF)β[π⊗K?WMε≠?7C|s↔;S_h+π≠"βC?O≡K 3eπ∪π;-π##∃αfKGCMε ;⊃βn ∂#'v+Mβπ≡≠?K∪Ns≥βSzβ¬β←.c17∪.3';↔ h+7↔∂≠WK∃ε≠?7 Ns';≥ε 31β∂≠C↔∂'→84(HH%7Kε944(hP0=E:j?∂QkAE↓↓∪→Q@'π∪πSR∧#'π fy↓"O,s↔Q%J≠π'⊗s↔OLhR∪πS+Q↓E]∧{∂Q↓ IaE↓∪→iMUS→a6B% 4*≠⊗{5iβπ∪πSQε Qα∪N 3<hRS=iε+GW'αaβ∨↔v+O↔K/#"βO≡{K∃1εs?[π\βG∂?⊗(4*O.∪+↔∂#Qα≠πO∪;↔O_h(4)E##∃β4{33?>K;≥βO→β'9π∪↔OC}sO∃β&yβS#*αSπ//+
#!zK%β .s∂#7∂∪-β≠⊗{5αJ∧99$∀Ph*#↔⊗)βπK*βS#∃ε≠K'S/∪'¬αJβ#π[*β ↔↔rβWO'v9βS=ε#πS∃εK9β∂F{?O'v9α3'∨4+ .s∂#7∂∪/M_hP4)EpαS#∃ε∪↔;∂FkπK
π≠#?Wf!βO?g3∃β¬πβK? f+5β←F{O¬β≡{7CW&+IβO}cWS'}qβ'Mε3C↔G,+;S3J4+∂∞c3↔⊃ε3?I8hP4)IrαS#∃πβK?∨⊗ 77'v9βOSNc∃βW≤+⊃βOF{W3⊃∧∪∃β?v)βS#∂!β#↔eβMβ7∞[∃βC⊗{∨Kπo→β7?⊗)4+?∪'Sπ⊗c∃1β⊗+πβπ⊗c∃1βn ';S∞K;π f)1βπv!βC?↔#π 3*p4(∀S→9↓α≥+ +↔∨!βS=ε≠K'S/∪'?9β⊃1βSF)β ↔v≠#7π⊗YβO#␈+3⊃βNkC3↔n+;Qβ∞qβ↔≠6K∂'↔w!4 ≡{3GSN{9βSzβS#∃πβK? f+5β'"βO?36+M84Ph*∂KO#↔K'}q↓EβO→βS=ε [?'"βS#∃ε≠?7Cd ';Q∧∧6}n]x MO(≠8,L(_8M}=λ∀m⎇9(_L]Xz≠,≡Z|h↓Q]~_.D≥~→/∀→≠h
m⎇λ≥ ↑⎇λ≤L\;λ≥m}[→λ∞∞[x[ ]<kH∧λ|Z= ↑Z;{DεH_=∞L;<≥∞4≥≠h
M=Y(∞↑β"]
t≤⎇_-l_<Y∞4≤Y8m⎇;93LL9λ_O∀≤{yNNx<Y$ ;Yz-l9<\d X<q,D≠{H∞,;_=
≡Y(_m}⎇≤h
|C"\ ]|≠→$ ;Yλ
<Y≥l≡Y+λ ∀≤X=
≥h≥~ ≡λ≤≤M||X;-\<\h ={]~-n9(≥
t~_=LT→~9LM8⎇;∞O#"XL]~9=M≥Yh~-d_;Y∧ 9~].>~;Yd∞≠kH∧λ|Z= ↑Z;{Dεh≤⎇.∞≠→;,]]≤h >Z=→.-;{Hε∀_↑(∞|99~-lc"[n↑λ≤≤M||X;.4≥~_.D≥{⎇-Lλ≠[nD_<Z.<(~;D∞≤X8nM8y(
⎇H_8l=⎇;]∧
yH_L];Yh∞M{c"M≥Y9YM≤z9;NEHλ
λm|H≥
(≠;n>λ≤Y,≥~<⎇
≤h_Y-lz≠8.-|kλ >Z=→.-;{Hε4≤z≠n]→λ∀L\y:0≠→FE:4→P9pvYP22s\2rP7Yα emphasiS as in typical programmi@9NvAg%]GJAQQSfA∃[aQCMSfASL~∃AS≥QYrAYCeCC YJAi!JAGe%iKeS=\A[CdAgCM∃YrAE∀AS]i∃aaeKQKHAg=[CoQ¬hAmC≥kKIr8R~∀~)πkgi=[KdA K]GQ5CeWf↓GC\A¬MM←e⊂Ai↑A5KKhA
eSiKIS←\@DA[←e∀A]CeI←oYr↓iQC\↓OK]KICX~∃ K]GQ5CeGf0AS\AQQCh@ oSIJ↓kgJD↓GC\A JAG←9giek∃HAi↑↓[@↔πr↓β#↔∂3'3e∧εW≡.D 'JπM PhV>↑7&}\↑"r∩∧
FG/4 f␈∩
¬απ∞Z&≡F≡<W~ε≡Dεn∞<Z2π≡]n6*πMtπ/≡T ¬¬α∞∞&}?,≥W~ε≤1PV⊗]l6Fn≡-7~b ≡Bεf\≡7"π↑∧π&@h_(∞
z;]¬dλ⊂⎇..Y;]∧ ∀∀λ∞∞[y|L≥<h→m≡Y(_-d_8xn↑X=→$↓ Y<nM98= T→[tD
;;9,M8=→$ <≤∪
≤x=~-⎇\kλ .=λ∃
<h_,<⎇<X,?(≤u ≡]_h∞Mh→≤M≤]λ⊂.4β"T∞-y|X-↑hε⊂ 0rh∂OE¬[[KeLXAC]⊂Aae←≥aC@7nK;≥β∨#g3↔~β∂#πv;∃)↓¬##WM∧3?Iβd{;≥7⊗ ;∨∃h+CKe satisfacth∂er↓EK]GαC7πK←→84λhR¬β7∞≠#';*βS#π ∧π⊗/≡Y↔⊗/4 &.v=
V∂⊗α|h
m⎇λ≠,\=~;Lt_|Z.L<Z;md (∩-d≠|Y ↑H≥≠d
≠{zaQY{{lD~<h
m⎇λ≥∞]Y9λ m|H∀L\;λ∃m}[→λ∞∞[x[ ]<kH∧ 9H_$∞≤[yn,9;:-lh≤u∂≥→(≥
=λβ!,→9P∩Xz9P1\αiterion 2 is needed for a machine not To looi like a Dog cOmpabed
to other machines then that machine is not tuned fop the economics of todai's
computing milieu. Defeating criterion 3 tk reduce the performance gap
between machines is like holding Olympic track events in molasSes.
With thesa criteria in mind, I'd like tk defendmyseld against the objections
that havE beeN raised about One oF my Lisp benchmarcs consing excessively.
That it was consi@⊃KeKH↓KqGKMgSmJ↓gkeaISgKH↓[BAg%]GJA$AiQ←UOQhA$AQCH~∃C[AYK[K9iKHA⊃SMMKIK]iS¬iS←\↓S\AB↓aeKiQrAgi¬]ICe⊂A→Sg@Agis1JXAC9HAae∃iab@4∃KMM%GSK]QYrACPAiQCPXA[K∃iS]N↓CYXAQQeKJ↓←LA[dAGeSQKeSB8~∀
∃Q↑AgK∀AoQCPAQCaββ↔;↔"β'9β&C∃↓ ⊗+π1β>{K &D ∧Jπ|]g"ε}lWαπMt∧n∞>?⊗n
≥f"πM⎇v@4≥~→$↓ Y→.-=X=
≡Y(≠l@⊂:42H9pvrH2|89→yytg[⊂:yrY⊂4w⊂≠|P12[1t6p\5R⊂→J<∃4∃XU<∃,
q∃<∃MW⊂⊂εB&pqy↑vpP8→y37y≠pr⊂0\7zw2λ→X_⊂_ww9r\V⊂7sλ;t4aZ⊂9wvY{t2y→P12z≥rrw⊂ X¬0 and 200
@¬aaKCIKHAi<AEJA¬iieS kiCE1JAi↑↓CGik¬YYbAQCWS]≤AiQJ↓IKeSYCiSm∀XAiQ∀AeKgPAEKS9N@~∃⊃kJAi<AaCeMS]NA¬]HA←QQKdA=mKeQ∃C@\@↓≠rAaI←OeC4AaKe→←e[K⊂A←]Yd@lbA
←]gKβ→1βSF)4+f{←↔IεsW7 /⊃βCK}∪π 3Jβ ↔'v9βπS'∪' W& 3∃π#=β7Jβ;?Qε SS↔oβS';8βπ;eh+O'oβ3'≠N≠πS'}qβ?→π##∃β⊗+OW3"p4(∀T≠?;∂g+O'?sQα%β≡+∃β;zβOWO& ';π⊗c∃β?⊗S↔∂SN{9βSzβ7eβ⊗+;∂#n K-8hP4*%εk'∨#"βπ∪⊃¬##πQ∧Iβ∂#␈≠∃β'"aβπ3}s≥β←O#!βS>yβ?SF+Iβ .s∂#7∂∪/M1πβWK↔gIβWONs≤4+oIβS#⊗+∃β∂⊗KS↔KN 9↓αJβ#π⊃εs=βC⊗K?Iβ/CC↔∂& S'?w→βS#∂!β'Qπ;?W3"β↔c↔⊗≠'O∃ε{;∀4UβπKQε{⊃α3O≠Aβ7␈∪∃βSF 9βπv{S#↔∩aβπ3&C?W∨Bα%βπg≠=β∪N!β;?"β↔cC.≠QβSF Qβ'"β←?Wf 4+O/∪[∃β∂→β¬β.s'[↔↔≠π1β⊗+;∂#n K-9ααS#↔⊗)β'Mεs=βO.≠!βSFK;≥β∂→β¬β.s'[↔↔≠π1hS ↔;≤¬εn∂-72ε∂D &/∨D ⊗␈* 8λ-d≠{[∂∀~≠| T≥≠h
=Y( ∀_\[l≤λ≤X-ly(≠lD≤Y<∞,<y;NL=~=LTβ"PL]Xz≠,≡X|kD∧∃~~.4~<h∞⎇≡(∩$
_9λ∞M≤Y9$ Y;Xm
8<Zn4≤{{∞m;Y`∞∞[x[ ]<h→N-{#"NM≤Y9$ ~<⎇
≥X⎇λ ≡Y8<eD_;→l\\X:,4≠8;M≡≥;_.M;{K∧
≠yz,5λ_;LD≤{|NM;Y`↔λ⊂&0qZP7s⊂≥4vrFB40yP≤92{2[:2r⊂≠pP39≠vP1g]2y4w→P8rzλ6wy2H:2y9~z7y<K⊂0w2λ$P0vH3y0z→s:v⊂→5y⊂0[6εE1[w:94X:z2rλ12w1Z6py5\P397[P7z4→y⊂9w]y1ryK⊂⊂$7]r{2yλ4s⊂<[zy⊂![w:94X:z4w[⊂εE1[vryP≥tz4⊂≥42P9→vpy5H:40zλ$P0vH12tw→P:w3_ty⊂4[⊂77zλ40{ )ng a sufficiently
broad range of bencHmarks (as did the TakeucHi benchmark) I will be rather
piQuad; I just don't have the resourceq to produce a sufficiently
representative range of benchmarks on my own.
I do not think that oNe should Strive forfaarness in benchmarkifgby
trying to distribute problems accoRding↓iVAQ=nAoK1XABAACeiS
kYCdαβ7π∂FK;∃hSC↔K6{C'Mr↓α≠πM∪;↔O~β∪?↔~β;?Q∧k↔π9π##πQ∧+[↔KL{;∃β≡C?W3"β∨πQ∧ βCKOS∃1β↔+QβK∂##↔HhSS#π ∧ε}vT
'.ε|Tπ/≡≥lrεn↑Mε}'4∞FF∂D F.∞D∞Fzε≥lf␈⊗\≡FO6T ⊗v" ≤6∨/,≡F*ε.\F>n]nG~pQ)⊗2ε≡Dπ'∂-n2ε␈↑Dπ&F≡@λ ∀≤y=∧
yH_L]Xz≠,≡Z|h∞,<≤Y.<αw:4[3P0P≤ztz0X6<P"~{2y9YPεE 2ange of applications runs pooRly o@8ABAO%mK\A5CGQS9JAS\↓G←[a¬eSg←αqβS=∧{S#↔∩4+↔∞≠#';,ε2b∧∀λ
⎇I⎇⊂_ww9tY2y⊂ )t faip to thenattempt to put that↓[CGQ%]JASαqβ¬hS∨??"β3'∨G!β e∧c??/Ns∃βOε+∂'≠L≠π33Jβ∪ ?$λ&.v=
V∂⊗α|h∞M_=⊂→αavo@HAiQCPA[CG!S]JX~∃C]dA[←e∀AiQC8A∩Ao=kYHAα≠?;OL∧F/∩
_
∧ X:4D∞≠h∪
⎇zh⊃M}H_Y-lz≠8.-|h∃
=λ⊂⊗XurP:~2PεE≠pqt4[2P82\αform poorly relative to otheR machines.
~∃%\AiQ∀AGCgα)β?→¬##∃α& /↔W≤¬εJε,]f≡F\≡&J∧∀λ l↑λ≥~ T→Y1-M;Y`⊂≥40r it waq chos` \A5←eJ~)EKGCUgJASβ!β∪' β;=β≤¬vw≡≥lrε∂Dλ⊗fB ≥f"π|≡2π& X L\YxY$
~:y-O(≥≠d∞→<YM}XεP!→z:2iλ∧A7gλ:42P⊃4πlpHin than becausE kf Any c@=]gSI∃aCiS=\A←L↓eKae∃c@↔≠& S'[,¬f/∨5`αh*⎇ε/& ↑"ε␈$λ M}λ≥~
≡h≥x.4_8u∞\9≠⊗$∞~→( <<y+∧ (_p⊂[⊂0z leasT raiSe the pec@!]SGC0@~¬← UKGi%←\Ai!ChAi!SfAE∃]GQ[¬eVAM¬SYfA5rAGe%iKeS∧@bAC9H@f\@Qπe%iKeS=\@fA→CSIF~∃EK
CkgJ↓iQKe∀ASfA∧AGY←MKHKMα{C * X∞∞∞Y<|m≥{H⊃M}H⊃_-<=8p∀~SyP3≥w1z4[w⊗⊂(→y2t`4ting~∃C@"βS-β⊗)β∂?oβWS↔ ∧εNr 8 mn⎇_;ND≥~;,T≤X=
<H⊂~~0s⊂$[⊂;t0]⊂0p(→py9P≥4π be
αexponential time.)
One way to come up with a benchmark that meeTq my three criteraa but That
should do as Well as Takeuchi in making Dolphins lkok eood would be to
implement ASSKC straightfoRwardly* This would not make me any hap@ASKdA¬E←kh~∃KC%]iCS9S]NA∧AgaSIShA←_AeKaIKgK]QCiSm∃]Kgf0AEkh↓ChAY∃CghA%hAo←UYHAI%ca←g∀A←L@4∃[rAQKGQ]%GCXAα{ +↔∨#'?;~βS :∞Mε*¬L≥6/.=
∩ε⊗]l6Fn≡-2ph!Q$Nv=≤F.wL≥FgJD
FF*
L⊗↑/\8
∀_Y;L=≠8<M4_{sN>;90→H→↔_P≤pqwg→9P:yZw3P#≤0p∞z Lisp on
Diablo,∧@@QI!∞Of↓iS[Sαs∨Mβ>+K∃↓qAMβ≠|ε"¬≡≥≥BbβEb∩ε6} π&FTλf}}mO∩bε≥lBβ ∃b"ε6} hWM R∧&⎇NεFNea∩α∧m}"π> ≡BεOD}2π>}.FBε∀λ2π6↑.6N}d
v $~=λ∞ 9H∩-d +@→MP9ra[w29P≠w⊂εE≥42P+_|⊂0w→⊂_W9 sec@=]IfA=\AiQ∀A'k\8~∀4PJSπW>Cπ8∀Ph 0-EBj7∂QkAE↓↓⊃ QD'π∪πSR∧#'π dy↓"O,s↔Q¬J≠/I¬;#πQεKQ?4∞v␈↔Mααα↓Q$&∂LW"β ∧ v∨"ε↔∪C
ε"∪S#π&βBmλJ@hTn-vkR∞∞&∂'D ↔"∧M≤⊗⊗fqQ%&{$
%∧≤
<⊗NbDλW∂.≡λ∧$L_)Dxh*>V⊗V\>CR∧m}"π> ≡BεOD}2π>}.F@h!Q L7-⎇SR∧M≤6J∧|≤'⊗N]Dβe∃λtε∂"
:Rl ↔aPPM>\&V.>G"∧6}$π>F≡DεO"}4π>␈.MhP~MsRα∧ W∂.≡∧ε∂"λI∀ ∀Itαh!⊃PPLHZ$M∩ 9vNv=≤F.wL≥FgJ∞|↔~ε∀
f/↔∀λ4|@Th~-n→;\m≡Y(≤∞-y|X-UH⊃⊂)1"B:.P3:w_z4wwλ1pv6λ4w:2[9t{2H0s2~0yP7≠P!gg∀tw3@≠s⊂0w≡P5tg→↔εE∧Pαy `Fairneqs' I meant that it is rare i@8ABAA9Cike¬XFA→%`∂Aβ¬∪?∂K∞h4(≤Mε∂"λ9te≡≥lrεO4 F}vT ⊗rπ>X6Bε
≤vBπ ↑&≡.nL⊗>/5dhPβ"S/∀⊂εpq\|rp@ datadidn't sway p∪←TAiQK8}@AβIJAc←TAgCsαK;≥β&CπQαn ∂OGn β'LhSπ9β.s;πS-∪π1αfK@∨α∞∞&}?,≥Rε␈$λ∩π⊗≡,Rε}lWphPQ!∀N∩λ¬⊂)4~;HλP7w⊂≥42P)Ug⊂0w→⊂+ lλ0y2P~w:2i→yz4w→V⊂47]P0q7]z⊂* RP4wεB∧c dS⊂7w⊂∀`df∨NεA∧DK~→[⊂≤p¬coNds
Usi@9JAae∃i`∪E¬≠SKπN;#C≠⎇∪←πK"βπOO,k 3E∧cπ;∨. ∨∃β|¬bπ& T¬∨.d ∩εn\≡7/⊗\Dαs;∧↓PW≡\8 ml≤k@∧ ){(∞≡<\∀M≡y9∞M→(∀l≥9 tn]H→x.∧~<h∞≥h≤{,≥≠ λ ∀≥~≠n\z≥λ 9 ,,∧}h≥y.,(β"N><≤∪n<9λ∃
t_Y( -~;Y
≥Y{≡$ X<⎇¬Dλ∩( <<Y_-≥[≡(∞|<{@∪]⊂2|8→qz4w→P:42H)zw≥5P12H≠→∩FB7s⊂0H%f⊗HL⊂37iλ0P3*[1z4w[⊗qpv≠⊗tw:→w9t`6e benchmari!¬
Sevepad Points:
∀∩DXA≠C
cs[Bαα&Mβ
β;πS-∪π1βπ∪?∨K∞iiβ'"β∪'⊃ε β3? β?→α≤z2O'v91β ,ε@hT∀λF␈..Dπ&F≡@λ∞M→(≤ ↑Xy3NL9y(
|H⊂siJz;Yd∞≠h∪nM→<H∞M~;Yn4~<h ≥↑=z ↑Y#"Ml8<H ≡h~~,]λ_<d
;H∃J* |hλH4R5D∞≤[yn,8εW⊂∃44yP~yP12XpzyrH&`aiVf`P"≠ryP0H67zεB5s⊂9]:s3⊂≥t4v"H:0ut[3P22\4{0z~{2yP
37y example, displAyifg↓iQJA¬]goKHRT
∃$AoeSQJA[k
PA→SM`AG←α#∃1β∞s⊃β7Jβ∂?∪*β∂↔KαL⊗NvO∀ε&↑↑4εv␈D V.wM≥vrπ<↑f/⊗≥APF≡⎇n6/~∞λWαεM≥f*b ≡2¬π,≡G"|h⊃λZR5H n;Xu
≥{H→
|<kH
M→(∪,≤|};,∀→→<M≡X=~.l#"R.∀≠[⎇∧
≤X=∞D|kC!!"P;O∀_Y;L=≠8<M4≤⎇8m∧_<hλ~∀⊃3HD_;Y∧λ⊃4R*d~<h∞ =~≠mMyz8l≥ H∩$
Y=Y.∧≤y9$∞⎇8z↓QX{y T⊂4h
I⊃(∪IzS+H ∀≤y9'$≥≡< T≥→<nM;Yk∧ 134$}kλ⊃*∀|kλλ9sQ n5λ≠_-\Y_+,-;Y~-lkβ"L≡\X>%}Y8⎇
}H_8l<<|kl≡|z9mm9;]¬D→];L>~;{D x;≠∞5H∃~ T≤≤[l}X;<d (→→,≥λ≥z.Mβ"Y
t_(≠
}λ≠yDλssTm≥Ykλ .=λ≠M}λ_=∧∞~→(∞,=→(∞M_=
∞X=≥∧}h→≠l↑kH∩,d~~<dλ⊃4R*a"Z<d
X=≥.,9 λ∞M→;H∞M→(⊃
⎇≤~~-d~<hε&Lλ≥
≥9<h∞=≠⎇y.$≥~_-d∀p2)EH∪[d
{Y( ]≤y#!.Y<≠n.≤h≥
= H
_1 C!!"B,Ed∃~→$ _<]∧t≠yH ,;Xz
\<Zz-lh~<d∞⎇8]
L+H⊃M}H→> ≥<≠→%Disp, and I used the timing mechanism I always do to
time things (to be consistent). The mechanism for measuring times
on SAIL is the RUNTIM UUO, which is known to measure a quantity related
to actual EBOX execution time. I'm not sure what it measures, since it
appears to count as EBOX time for my job the code run at interrupt level
while I am active (such as interrupts for character input from any user).
It may count cache filling time. Recall that the memory on SAIL consists
of 256k of 900 nanosecond memory and 1 meg of 3 microsecond memory. Until
the cache is filled I'm losing. Of course, I get charged for the execution
of RUNTIM. With a benchmark so short, this is significant.
The timing methodology counted several Lisp function calls, so
I eliminated that, redid it, and got 380 milliseconds. Even at that
I don't know what I measured. When I write up the Lisp Evaluation
results, I will read the system code, study the hardware, and try to
relate my results to some reality. Now that you know what I know
about my measurements, what did Pratt measure?
-rpg-
∂18-Oct-81 2254 RPG@Sail (SuNet) Several points:
Date: 18 Oct 1981 2246-PDT
From: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Several points:
To: equip at DIABLO
1. Macsyma IS a natural program: it did a lot of CONSing, but
I doubt that the percentage of CONSing to other things is anywhere
near as high as in VRP's DERIV program. This is because MACSYMA does a lot
of stuff while taking derivatives (for example, displaying the answer).
I write much Lisp code, and my code certainly does not mention several
conses per line, as Pratt's DERIV function does. The Macsyma derivative
is not Pratt's.
Any benchmark such as APPEND and DERIV is pathological. I never see such
code AS THE NORM. I see: type testing, MEMQ's, EQ's, COND's, lambda-binding,
array/vector access/assignment, function calls. The programs I deal with
do a lot of CONSing, but not at the rate that Pratt's does. If his DERIV
is natural, then the Dolphin is 260 times slower than SAIL. No one else
reports that. QED.
2. The `art' of benchmarking is subtle. For example, what does it
mean to ``time'' a benchmark? The assembly language code I wrote was
loaded in MacLisp, and I used the timing mechanism I always do to
time things (to be consistent). The mechanism for measuring times
on SAIL is the RUNTIM UUO, which is known to measure a quantity related
to actual EBOX execution time. I'm not sure what it measures, since it
appears to count as EBOX time for my job the code run at interrupt level
while I am active (such as interrupts for character input from any user).
It may count cache filling time. Recall that the memory on SAIL consists
of 256k of 900 nanosecond memory and 1 meg of 3 microsecond memory. Until
the cache is filled I'm losing. Of course, I get charged for the execution
of RUNTIM. With a benchmark so short, this is significant.
The timing methodology counted several Lisp function calls, So
I eliminated that, redid it, and got 380 milliseconds. Even at that
I don't know what I measured. When I write up the Lisp Evaluation
results, I will read the system code, study the hardware, and try to
relate my results to some reality. Now that you know what I know
about my measurements, what did Pratt measure?
-rpg-
∂19-Oct-81 0935 RINDFLEISCH@SUMEX-AIM (SuNet) FYI - Other Lisp Timing Thrashes
Date: 19 Oct 1981 0926-PDT
From: Rindfleisch at SUMEX-AIM
Subject: FYI - Other Lisp Timing Thrashes
To: Equip at SU-HPP-VAX
cc: [SUMEX] at SUMEX-AIM, ETHERNET at SUMEX-AIM, DEV at SUMEX-AIM, GRP:
1 18 Oct Masinter at PARC-MAXC some more races out of the past
2 18 Oct Masinter at PARC-MAXC timings - fyi
1 -- ************************
Mail-from: ARPANET host PARC-MAXC rcvd at 18-Oct-81 1249-PDT
Date: 18 Oct 1981 10:12 PDT
From: Masinter at PARC-MAXC
Subject: some more races out of the past
To: Rindfleisch@sumex-aim
---------------------------
Mail-from: Arpanet host MIT-MC rcvd at 26-FEB-81 2243-PST
Date: 26 Feb 1981 14:42:52-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: CSVAX.jkf@Berkeley, jlk@mit-mc, lisp-forum@mit-mc, rz@mit-mc
Cc: CSVAX.fateman@Berkeley
←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←←
| | UCILISP | INTERLISP | MACLISP |Franz/VAX|
|-------------+---------+-----------+---------+---------|
| Interpreter | 57.0 | 26.0 | 22.8 | 65.0 |
|-------------+---------+-----------+---------+---------|
| Compiler | 2.90 | 15.0 | 0.69 | 1.1 ** |
|-------------+---------+-----------+---------+---------|
Times are for (TAK 4 2 0), where TAK is an interesting function
defined by Mr. Ikuo Takeuchi.
(DEFUN TAK (X Y Z)
(COND ((GREATERP X Y)
(TAK (TAK (SUB1 X) Y Z)
(TAK (SUB1 Y) Z X)
(TAK (SUB1 Z) X Y) ))
(T Y) ))
(**) 5.3 with (1- x) etc [no other declarations, so greaterp is closed comp.]
4.1 with local function declaration (fast subroutine call)
1.1 with > open compiled
times on a VAX 11/780 at Berkeley, Feb. 26, 1981
------------------------------------------------------------
2 -- ************************
Mail-from: ARPANET host PARC-MAXC rcvd at 18-Oct-81 1249-PDT
Date: 18 Oct 1981 09:55 PDT
From: Masinter at PARC-MAXC
Subject: timings - fyi
To: LispGroup↑, Rindfleisch@sumex-aim
Reply-To: Masinter
---------------------------
Mail-from: Arpanet host MIT-MC rcvd at 1-MAR-81 2221-PST
Date: 2 March 1981 00:55-EST
From: Charles Frankston <CBF at MIT-MC>
Subject: timings
To: CSVAX.fateman at BERKELEY
cc: LISP-FORUM at MIT-MC, masinter at PARC-MAXC, RWS at MIT-XX,
guttag at MIT-XX
It is rather obvious that the timings you distributed are wall times for
the Lisp Machine, whereas the Vax and MC times count only time spent
directly executing code that is considered part of Macsyma. Ie. the
Vax and MC times exclude not only garbage collection, but operating system
overhard, disk i/o and/or paging, time to output characters to terminals, etc.
I submit comparing wall times with (what the Multics people call) "virtual
CPU" time, is not a very informative excercise. I'm not sure if the Lisp
Machine has the facilities to make analagous measurements, but everyone
can measure wall time, and in some ways thats the most useful comparison.
Is anyone willing to try the same benchmarks on the Vax and MC with just
one user on and measureing wall times?
Also, are there yet any Lisp machines with greater than 256K words? No
one would dream of running Macsyma on a 256K word PDP10 and I presume that
goes the same for a 1 Megabyte Vax. The Lisp Machine may not have a time
sharing system resident in core, but in terms of amount of memory needed
for operating system overhard, the fanciness of its user interface
probably more than makes up for that. I'll bet another 128K words of
memory would not be beyond the point of diminishing returns, insofar
as running Macsyma.
Lastly, the choice of examples. Due to internal Macsyma optimizations,
these examples have a property I don't like in a benchmark. The timings
for subsequent runs in the same environment differ widely from previous
runs. It is often useful to be able to factor out setup times from a
benchmark. These benchmarks would seem to run the danger of being
dominated by setup costs. (Eg. suppose disk I/O is much more expensive
on one system; that is probably not generally interesting to a Macsyma user,
but it could dominate benchmarks such as these.)
I would be as interested as anyone else in seeing the various lisp systems
benchmarked. I hope there is a reasonable understanding in the various
Lisp communities of how to do fair and accurate, else the results will be
worse than useless, they will be damaging.
------------------------------------------------------------
-------
∂19-Oct-81 1045 pratt@Diablo (SuNet) Several points:
Date: 19 Oct 1981 10:43:49-PDT
From: pratt at Diablo
To: RPG@Sail, equip@DIABLO
Subject: Several points:
[Seems to me benchmarking generates more debate than information. -vrp]
From: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
1. Macsyma IS a natural program: it did a lot of CONSing, but
I doubt that the percentage of CONSing to other things is anywhere
near as high as in VRP's DERIV program. This is because MACSYMA does a lot
of stuff while taking derivatives (for example, displaying the answer).
The measurements I made of Macsyma's differentiator did not include the work
done during display, nor during parsing. Nor should it if you are just
comparing differentiation programs. What is the "lot of stuff" Macsyma does
WHILE taking derivatives?
I write much Lisp code, and my code certainly does not mention several
conses per line, as Pratt's DERIV function does.
Ok, let's see your version of DERIV. I'll be interested to see how you manage
to use fewer conses per line. No fair merely spreading the code over more
lines.
The Macsyma
derivative is not Pratt's.
Your argument here seems to be that because you do something Macsyma does it
too.
We can resolve the question of what Macsyma does by looking at the Macsyma
code for DIFF, a copy of which I have requested from Jeff Golden. (Maybe I
should have asked Fateman, on the principle that one goes to the Soviet
embassy to make casual inquiries about US military secrets. I heard Moses
was rather upset that Fateman had ported Macsyma to Franz Lisp.)
2. ...[on the meaning of time]...
.
.
.
Now that you know what I know
about my measurements, what did Pratt measure?
Depends on the machine, but in all cases my wristwatch is the final authority.
Sun and Dolphin: wristwatch time over a large number of runs. (On the
Dolphin this seems to agree with the time returned by
InterlispD's TIME function.)
Vax: user cpu time as returned by the 'times' kernel call.
The user cpu time has the following two properties:
(1) I have observed little variation of this parameter
over a wide range of system loads, cache usage
considerations notwithstanding.
(2) For very low system loads I have seen it
come to within 90% or so of wristwatch time.
These two observations together imply that the 'times'
kernel call is a reliable indicator of user cpu time.
∂19-Oct-81 1143 RPG@Sail (SuNet) Long, silly response to Vaughn Pratt
Date: 19 Oct 1981 1135-PDT
From: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Long, silly response to Vaughn Pratt
To: equip at DIABLO
In this message I reply to the cogent parts of Pratt's comments. The
non-sequitars in his message, which will be obvious when you briefly read
this, will be ignored, unless misunderstandings persist. Most
of you may want to delete this message now.
Ok Vaughn. Let me state this simply, so that you can understand it.
1. Your DERIV program has a higher percentage of conses than `natural' code.
2. `Natural code' means code that occurs naturally in the day-to-day
work of actual Lisp programmers.
3. `Natural code' does not mean the `natural' codefor DERIV. (Which is
EQ to yours, and which I stated to you on several occasions already in
private).
4. Since you stated the fact that Macsyma differentiation took more conses,
I assumed that meant that it used a different program (and possibly did other
things too).
5. I never stated that your DERIV took excessive CONSes in the sense that
it was programmed badly. It, like APPEND, requires CONSes to copy the
structure, which I assume would be part of the specification.
6. Here is some `naturally' occurring code, written by Guy Steele and
myself. It was randomly taken from pages 31, 41, and 59 (3.14159) of
ANALYZE.LSP[NIL,S1] I will point out the CONSes. Of the approximately 153
lines below about 12 have CONSes on them. Most data structure operations
here are vector references and assignments. There are a lot of lambda's
(disguised as LETs) and control structures. The rest of you can delete
the remainder of this message as I assume you understand my point. Vaughn,
read on:
∂19-Oct-81 1545 Jeff Rubin <JBR at S1-A>
Date: 19 Oct 1981 1544-PDT
From: Jeff Rubin <JBR at S1-A>
To: rpg at SU-AI
∂19-Oct-81 1141 RPG via SU-AI RUNTIM
can you give me the poop on what RUNTIM UUO measures on SAIL? How much
of other users, context switching, etc, do I get charged for there.
Technical details welcome.
-rpg-
It measures EBOX milliseconds. You might possibly be getting charged for
somebody else's spacewar or interrupt level. I don't really remember.
You get charged for some amount of context switching and scheduling
(possibly even figuring out that it should just run you again next).
--jeff
∂21-Oct-81 1325 RPG Wall time
To: pratt at DIABLO, "#TIMING.MSG[TIM,LSP]" at SU-AI
You state:
-----
1. Don't take any time seriously other than real (wall-clock) time. If you
are on a time-shared computer, you have two variables to contend with: real
time and deviation from typical load. A one-datum benchmark will measure
real time under typical load conditions, for more detail you can plot real
time against load factor. Personal computers are simpler with only one
variable to worry about, real time.
-----
There are, as usual, a number of points that you slough over in this statement
which strikes me a having been given in the spirit of a aged philosopher to
young upstarts.
First, one can and must take every time reported seriously as long as there
is sufficient other material to evaluate the meaning of that time well.
For example, consider Tak(18,12,6). Suppose that there is no way to increase
the duration of a single run (for whatever reason). Since the run is so short
(on a reasonable machine) the only way to gather time via `wall clock' is
with multiple runs. In this case, unless an analysis is done on the cost
of the multiple timing control structures, you have no idea what else you
are measuring.
Second, on a timesharing machine, the absolute cpu time (including typical
memory usage [cache misses]) along with an independent analysis of the
impact of load on real time and memory contention will provide more and
better information than a compendum of real time versus load for each
benchmark. A further piece of data would be cost of context switching
and other interrupts (and spacewar processes on SAIL). Without all of this
the timing are useless.
Third, you have included in your objective advice some personal opinion.
Namely, that personal computers are inherently better than timeshared ones.
This is under the guise of `real time' being the only serious measurement
coupled with the statement that the personal machine is simpler to measure here.
Doug Lenat made the same mistake that everyone seems to make, which is that
the personal machine is more available, and that downtime doesn't affect
them. Since you want to consider the load as impacting the worth of the
timeshared system, let me propose that the following `wall clock test' on
a normally populated personal machine environment versus a normally populatd
timesharing environment. We consider 100 random times. In each case the test
subject stands outside the door. On a signal he is to enter the room with
the terminal or computer, logs in, and runs the program. We measure transit time,
login time, loadup time and subtract them from the measurements. If someone
is at the personal machine, you wait and the clock ticks. If you
cannot log into the timeshared machine, the clock ticks. Neither may say anything
to anyone. We do this so that all time slots are represented appropriately.
I won't complicate the matter by including the incremental funding situation
when ARPA comes to see the demo of your system, and in case Ohlander watches
the one cylinder personal machine stagger though its paces while the huge timeshared
machine, with everyone gratefully off while the money is being considered,
15 MIPS' its way through the demo.
In this sense, real time on a personal machine means real time when you have
the machine in your hot little hands. So what is different about CPU time
when it is simply the measure of real time when you have the CPU in your
hot little hands? Only the scale is different. And you CAN get the timeshared
machine to yourself at critical times, and at night (which is when the average
grad student gets to use a Dolphin). If you are considering that everyone
get a personal machine, then with economics in mind, we ought to calculate the
CPU percentage of a very powerful timesahred machine as an exercise.
Lenat flames about availability. The man hours of availablility of a mainframe
is much higher than a normally populated personal environment.
-rpg-
∂22-Oct-81 2009 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> timing tests and benchmarks.
Date: 22 October 1981 20:40-EDT
From: George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC>
Subject: timing tests and benchmarks.
To: RPG at SU-AI
Thanks. I'll give these a try. The Franz LOCF declaration
is a total crock only put into the language for use in benchmarks
it seems as you get ridiculously poor debugging if you use it.
One thing I am curious about, either quanitatively or just your feel,
is how many Lisp users (of average color) with how much memory is
the maximum on a 780 running any reasonable Lisp. I assume that NIL
will be the first reasonable Lisp on a Vax, so perhaps you can answer this.
-rpg-
Thanks for your help.
∂10-Dec-81 1050 Jerry Roylance <GLR at MIT-AI> LISPM Array Timings
Date: 10 December 1981 13:26-EST
From: Jerry Roylance <GLR at MIT-AI>
Subject: LISPM Array Timings
To: BUG-LISPM at MIT-AI
cc: GLR at MIT-AI, GJS at MIT-AI, LISPTiming at SU-AI
John Batali and I have made some simple measurements that
are given here for general information.
;; On CADR-2
(setq array ; takes 1738 seconds
(*array nil 'fixnum 5000000))
(do ((i 0 (1+ i))) ; takes 1019 seconds
((>= i 5000000))
(setf (arraycall fixnum array i)
(- 5000000 i)))
(sort-grouped-array array 5 #'<) ; takes 6077 seconds
On CADR-8 we made a loop similar to the 1019 second one above
except it had explicit calls to PAGE-IN-ARRAY and PAGE-OUT-ARRAY
every 10000 elements and only changed every 5th element by
writing a random number into it.
Without the explicit paging, the loop took about 1100 seconds;
with the paging, about 150 seconds. The times are approximate
because the calls to RANDOM (about 350 seconds) have to be
subtracted.
We should get some more timing information in the next few days.
∂11-Dec-81 1215 David A. Moon <MOON at MIT-MC> LISPM Array Timings
Date: 11 December 1981 15:13-EST
From: David A. Moon <MOON at MIT-MC>
Subject: LISPM Array Timings
To: GLR at MIT-AI
cc: BUG-LISPM at MIT-MC, GJS at MIT-AI, LISPTiming at SU-AI
It is a known bug that arrays larger than the size of main memory
don't work very well, in particular they have to be paged in at
least twice to create them. Fixing this requires remodularizing
part of the microcode, which is why it hasn't been done yet. This
has been discussed over (bug lispm) several times in the past.
I don't see what purpose is served by timing things that are known
to be broken.
∂16-Dec-81 0937 Guy.Steele at CMU-10A TAK for S-1
Date: 16 December 1981 1214-EST (Wednesday)
From: Guy.Steele at CMU-10A
To: rpg at SU-AI
Subject: TAK for S-1
Message-Id: <16Dec81 121440 GS70@CMU-10A>
Attached is the S1C file for TAK. Maybe you can adapt the code
to run on the Mark 1?
--Q
--------------------------------------------
;Dribble file from S-1 LISP compiler for function TAK
;See user-supplied code?:
(LAMBDA (X Y Z)
(COND ((NOT (<& Y X)) Z)
(T (TAK (TAK (1-& X) Y Z)
(TAK (1-& Y) Z X)
(TAK (1-& Z) X Y)))))
;See initial alpha-conversion (*INITIAL-VERSION*)?:
(LAMBDA (X Y Z)
(IF (<& Y X)
(IF 'T
(TAK (TAK (1-& X) Y Z) (TAK (1-& Y) Z X) (TAK (1-& Z) X Y))
'NIL)
Z))
;Trace optimizer?:
;***** Optimizing this form:
(IF 'T
(TAK (TAK (1-& X) Y Z) (TAK (1-& Y) Z X) (TAK (1-& Z) X Y))
'NIL)
;*** to be this form:
(TAK (TAK (1-& X) Y Z) (TAK (1-& Y) Z X) (TAK (1-& Z) X Y))
;***** courtesy of META-IF-LITERAL
;See result of optimization (*META-VERSION*)?:
(LAMBDA (X Y Z)
(IF (<& Y X)
(TAK (TAK (1-& X) Y Z) (TAK (1-& Y) Z X) (TAK (1-& Z) X Y))
Z))
;There are 33 TN's.
;See TN packing?:
;RT registers:
;RTA: #4 [12:13/12:13] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=21 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASON=RT PREFS=(5) CONFLICTS=()
; JUMP ISTN of OWNER=(<& Y X)
; #32 [71:72/71:72] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=22 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASON=RTPREF PREFS=(33 31) CONFLICTS=()
; SWFIX ISTN of OWNER=(1-& Z)
; #24 [48:49/48:49] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=23 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASON=RTPREF PREFS=(25 23) CONFLICTS=()
; SWFIX ISTN of OWNER=(1-& Y)
; #16 [25:26/25:26] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=24 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASON=RTPREF PREFS=(17 15) CONFLICTS=()
; SWFIX ISTN of OWNER=(1-& X)
; #33 [68:69/68:69] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=28 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASON=32 PREFS=(32) CONFLICTS=()
; SWFIX WANTTN of OWNER=Z, son of (1-& Z)
; #25 [45:46/45:46] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=29 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASON=24 PREFS=(24) CONFLICTS=()
; SWFIX WANTTN of OWNER=Y, son of (1-& Y)
; #17 [22:23/22:23] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=30 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASON=16 PREFS=(16) CONFLICTS=()
; SWFIX WANTTN of OWNER=X, son of (1-& X)
;Scratch memory: none.
;Pointer memory: none.
;Scratch registers:
;I: #8 [8:10/8:10] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=31 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=I REASON=ANY PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; SWFIX WANTTN of OWNER=X, son of (<& Y X)
;J: #6 [5:9/5:9] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=32 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=J REASON=ANY PREFS=() CONFLICTS=(8)
; SWFIX WANTTN of OWNER=Y, son of (<& Y X)
;Pointer registers:
;A: #5 [14:15/14:15] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=26 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=POINTER-REG ISLOC=A REASON=ANY PREFS=(4) CONFLICTS=()
; JUMP WANTTN of OWNER=(<& Y X)
;Arguments:
;* #0 [0:75/0:75] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=2 WEIGHT=4 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=ARGUMENT ISLOC=0 REASON=ARGUMENT PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; Random TN of OWNER=(LAMBDA (X Y Z) (IF # # Z))
;* #1 [1:78/1:78] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=1 WEIGHT=4 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=ARGUMENT ISLOC=1 REASON=ARGUMENT PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; Random TN of OWNER=(LAMBDA (X Y Z) (IF # # Z))
;* #2 [2:97/2:67] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=0 WEIGHT=4 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=ARGUMENT ISLOC=2 REASON=ARGUMENT PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; Random TN of OWNER=(LAMBDA (X Y Z) (IF # # Z))
;Stack locations:
;* #12 [16:87/16:87] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=20 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=0 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN/ISTN of OWNER=TAK, son of (TAK (TAK # Y Z) (TAK # Z X) (TAK # X Y))
;* #14 [18:34/18:34] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=19 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=6 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN/ISTN of OWNER=TAK, son of (TAK (1-& X) Y Z)
;* #15 [27:35/27:35] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=7 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=12 REASON=STACK PREFS=(16) CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN of OWNER=(1-& X)
;* #19 [30:36/30:36] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=18 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=13 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN of OWNER=Y, son of (TAK (1-& X) Y Z)
;* #20 [33:37/33:37] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=17 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=14 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN of OWNER=Z, son of (TAK (1-& X) Y Z)
;* #13 [39:88/39:88] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=8 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=6 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN/ISTN of OWNER=(TAK (1-& X) Y Z)
;* #22 [41:57/41:57] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=16 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=7 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN/ISTN of OWNER=TAK, son of (TAK (1-& Y) Z X)
;* #23 [50:58/50:58] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=5 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=13 REASON=STACK PREFS=(24) CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN of OWNER=(1-& Y)
;* #27 [53:59/53:59] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=15 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=14 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN of OWNER=Z, son of (TAK (1-& Y) Z X)
;* #28 [56:60/56:60] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=14 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=15 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN of OWNER=X, son of (TAK (1-& Y) Z X)
;* #21 [62:89/62:89] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=6 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=7 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN/ISTN of OWNER=(TAK (1-& Y) Z X)
;* #30 [64:80/64:80] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=13 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=8 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN/ISTN of OWNER=TAK, son of (TAK (1-& Z) X Y)
;* #31 [73:81/73:81] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=3 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=14 REASON=STACK PREFS=(32) CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN of OWNER=(1-& Z)
;* #35 [76:82/76:82] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=12 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=15 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN of OWNER=X, son of (TAK (1-& Z) X Y)
;* #36 [79:83/79:83] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=11 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=16 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN of OWNER=Y, son of (TAK (1-& Z) X Y)
;* #29 [85:90/85:90] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=4 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=8 REASON=STACK PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN/ISTN of OWNER=(TAK (1-& Z) X Y)
;* #11 [92:93/92:93] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=9 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=0 REASON=STACK PREFS=(10) CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER ISTN of OWNER=(TAK (TAK # Y Z) (TAK # Z X) (TAK # X Y))
;* #10 [94:95/94:95] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=25 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=RESULT REASON=3 PREFS=(11 3) CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN of OWNER=(TAK (TAK # Y Z) (TAK # Z X) (TAK # X Y))
;* #37 [98:99/18:19] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=27 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=RESULT REASON=3 PREFS=(3) CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN of OWNER=Z, son of (IF (<& Y X) (TAK # # #) Z)
;* #3 [100:102/96:98] SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORDER=10 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=STACK ISLOC=RESULT REASON=STACK PREFS=(37 10) CONFLICTS=()
; POINTER WANTTN/ISTN of OWNER=(IF (<& Y X) (TAK # # #) Z)
;TN locations by ID number:
; #0=ARG 0 #8=I #16=RTA #24=RTA #32=RTA
; #1=ARG 1 #10=STACK RESULT #17=RTA #25=RTA #33=RTA
; #2=ARG 2 #11=STACK 0 #19=STACK 13 #27=STACK 14 #35=STACK 15
; #3=STACK RESULT #12=STACK 0 #20=STACK 14 #28=STACK 15 #36=STACK 16
; #4=RTA #13=STACK 6 #21=STACK 7 #29=STACK 8 #37=STACK RESULT
; #5=A #14=STACK 6 #22=STACK 7 #30=STACK 8
; #6=J #15=STACK 12 #23=STACK 13 #31=STACK 14
;TN locations by order of packing:
; 0=#2 ARG 2 9=#11 STACK 0 18=#19 STACK 13 27=#37 STACK RESULT
; 1=#1 ARG 1 10=#3 STACK RESULT 19=#14 STACK 6 28=#33 RTA
; 2=#0 ARG 0 11=#36 STACK 16 20=#12 STACK 0 29=#25 RTA
; 3=#31 STACK 14 12=#35 STACK 15 21=#4 RTA 30=#17 RTA
; 4=#29 STACK 8 13=#30 STACK 8 22=#32 RTA 31=#8 I
; 5=#23 STACK 13 14=#28 STACK 15 23=#24 RTA 32=#6 J
; 6=#21 STACK 7 15=#27 STACK 14 24=#16 RTA
; 7=#15 STACK 12 16=#22 STACK 7 25=#10 STACK RESULT
; 8=#13 STACK 6 17=#20 STACK 14 26=#5 A
;See code?:
(S1LAP TAK)
(DEFINE %SETUP (%FUNCTION-NAME)
((ALLOC 6) T2 (SP 24))
(MOV (SP -24) (REF (@ (QUOTE %FUNCTION-NAME)) (SQ *:SQ-SYMBOL-FUNCTION-CELL) S)))
(DEFINE %CALL (%TYPE %NARGS)
((MOVP P A) FP (PR SP (- 128 (+ (- *:FRAME-ARGUMENTS *:FRAME-RETURN-VALUE) (* %NARGS 4)))))
((MOVP P A) CP (PR FP *:FRAME-SPARE-PC-SLOT))
(MOV RTA (? (POINTER %TYPE %NARGS)))
(JSP (PR FP *:FRAME-RETURN-PC) (@ (REF CP (* *:PROCEDURE-CODE 4)))))
((JMPZ NEQ Q) RTA-Q0 (@ (REF SQ *:SQ-WRONG-TYPE-OF-FUNCTION)))
;Jump if other than single pointer value desired
((JMPZ NEQ) (? -3 RTA) (SQ *:SQ-WRONG-NUMBER-OF-ARGUMENTS))
;Error if not exactly 3 arguments
((SKP LSS S) (FP -100) (FP -104) L0018) ;Branch if (<& Y X)
(MOV (FP *:FRAME-RETURN-VALUE) (FP -96))
(JMPA NIL L0019)
L0018 (%SETUP TAK) ;Set up to call TAK
(%SETUP TAK) ;Set up to call TAK
(DEC RTA (FP -104)) ;(1-& X)
((PUSH UP) SP RTA)
((PUSH UP) SP (FP -100))
((PUSH UP) SP (FP -96))
(%CALL 0 3) ;Call for (TAK (1-& X) Y Z)
(%SETUP TAK) ;Set up to call TAK
(DEC RTA (FP -100)) ;(1-& Y)
((PUSH UP) SP RTA)
((PUSH UP) SP (FP -96))
((PUSH UP) SP (FP -104))
(%CALL 0 3) ;Call for (TAK (1-& Y) Z X)
(%SETUP TAK) ;Set up to call TAK
(DEC RTA (FP -96)) ;(1-& Z)
((PUSH UP) SP RTA)
((PUSH UP) SP (FP -104))
((PUSH UP) SP (FP -100))
(%CALL 0 3) ;Call for (TAK (1-& Z) X Y)
(%CALL 0 3) ;Call for (TAK @ @ @)
((POP UP) (FP *:FRAME-RETURN-VALUE) SP) ;Store away result of call
L0019 ((MOV D D) T1 CP) ;Function exit:
((MOVMS 3) TP (FP *:FRAME-OLD-TP)) ; restore TP, CP, and FP for caller,
(RETSR T2 (T2 *:FRAME-OLD-TP)) ; and return, saving spare PC slot in T1.
()
;See statistics?:
; 35 number of internal-format program nodes created
; 0 CASEQ of a literal reduces to a clause
; 0 CASEQ of a PROGN becomes PROGN of a CASEQ
; 0 CASEQ of a LET becomes LET of a CASEQ
; 0 CASEQ of an IF becomes IF with CASEQ as one arm
; 0 CASEQ of an IF becomes IF with clauses for both arms
; 0 CASEQ of an IF becomes a single clause
; 0 IF of an IF is involuted (anchor pointing)
; 1 IF of a literal has dead arm eliminated
; 0 IF of a PROGN becomes PROGN of an IF
; 0 IF of a LET becomes LET of an IF
; 0 statements eliminated from a PROGBODY
; 0 statements eliminated from a PROGN
; 0 PROGN of one statement simplified to the statement
; 0 one PROGN within another is flattened out
; 0 a CALL to a primop with literal arguments is folded
; 0 a call with one argument is reduced to that argument
; 0 a call with a literal idempotent argument is reduced
; 0 a literal identity argument is eliminated from a call
; 0 a call with some literal arguments is partially folded
; 0 a call with a literal nilpotent argument is reduced
; 0 a call with one argument is reduced to a nilpotent
; 0 a call with more than two arguments is reduced to dyadic calls
; 0 FUNCALL of a known PRIMOP is made a PRIMOP CALL
; 0 a CALL to a known function with literal arguments is folded
; 0 &OPTIONAL parameter of a LAMBDA in a CALL is made &REQUIRED
; 0 &REST parameter of a LAMBDA in a CALL is made &REQUIRED
; 0 unreferenced &REQUIRED parameter is flushed
; 0 unreferenced argument with no side effects is flushed
; 0 ((LAMBDA () FOO)) becomes FOO
; 0 substitutions of an argument for a parameter
; 0 attempts to propagate substitution into a LET body
; 0 successes at propagating substitution into a LET body
; 0 replacement of a SETQ of an unreferenced variable by the SETQ body
; 0 the statements of a PROGN are permuted
; 0 PDLNUM relaxation reanalysis of a CALL-LAMBDA
; 38 number of TN's generated
; 5 number of TN's removed by REMTN
; 32 number of instructions and macro calls emitted
; 2 number of tags emitted
; 8 number of S1LAP macro calls emitted
; 17 number of XOP instructions emitted
; 3 number of TOP instructions emitted
; 3 number of JOP instructions emitted
; 1 number of SOP instructions emitted
;End of S-1 compiler dump file PS:<S1LISP.COMPILER>TAK.S1C
∂18-Dec-81 2112 Earl A. Killian <Killian at MIT-Multics> tak
Date: 19 December 1981 0007-est
From: Earl A. Killian <Killian at MIT-Multics>
Subject: tak
To: Guy Steele at CMUa, RPG at SAIL
CBF said you were compiling TAK for the Mark IIA, so I thought I'd send
you Amber's Pascal's code for it. Here it is:
;;; START BLOCK
00000004 tak:
00000004 6203 0140 3713 ALLOC.7 r24, (sp)13*4
00000010 6172 3774 0377 ENTRY (sp)-4*4, (pc)-1*4 ; ., tak
00000014 5343 0160 0040 MOV.S.S r28, r8 ; x, .
00000020 5343 0154 0044 MOV.S.S r27, r9 ; y, .
00000024 5343 0150 0050 MOV.S.S r26, r10 ; z, .
; LINE 3
00000030 0253 0154 0160 SKP.LSS.S r27, r28, L61 ; y, x, 44
00000034 L96:
; LINE 4
00000034 5343 0054 0150 MOV.S.S r11, r26 ; tak, z
00000040 4111 0000 0023 JMPA L66 ; 154
00000044 L61:
; LINE 5
00000044 4267 0040 0160 DEC.S r8, r28 ; ., x
00000050 5343 0044 0154 MOV.S.S r9, r27 ; ., y
00000054 5343 0050 0150 MOV.S.S r10, r26 ; ., z
00000060 4177 3676 7765 CALL (fp)-2*4, tak ; ., 4
00000064 5343 0144 0054 MOV.S.S r25, r11
00000070 4267 0040 0154 DEC.S r8, r27 ; ., y
00000074 5343 0044 0150 MOV.S.S r9, r26 ; ., z
00000100 5343 0050 0160 MOV.S.S r10, r28 ; ., x
00000104 4177 3676 7760 CALL (fp)-2*4, tak ; ., 4
00000110 5343 0140 0054 MOV.S.S r24, r11
00000114 4267 0040 0150 DEC.S r8, r26 ; ., z
00000120 5343 0044 0160 MOV.S.S r9, r28 ; ., x
00000124 5343 0050 0154 MOV.S.S r10, r27 ; ., y
00000130 4177 3676 7753 CALL (fp)-2*4, tak ; ., 4
00000134 5343 0050 0054 MOV.S.S r10, r11
00000140 5343 0040 0144 MOV.S.S r8, r25
00000144 5343 0044 0140 MOV.S.S r9, r24
00000150 4177 3676 7747 CALL (fp)-2*4, tak ; ., 4
00000154 L66:
00000154 L58:
00000154 5414 0140 3671 MOVMS.5 r24, (fp)-7*4
00000160 6173 3677 3671 UNCALL (fp)-1*4, (fp)-7*4
;;; END BLOCK
.END
∂07-Jan-82 1311 RPG
xcon.reti@dec-marlboro for benchmarks on Franz, InterLisp, NIL.
∂13-Jan-82 1015 Kalman Reti <XCON.RETI at DEC-MARLBORO> Re: Benchmarks
Date: 13 Jan 1982 1129-EST
From: Kalman Reti <XCON.RETI at DEC-MARLBORO>
To: RPG at SU-AI
Subject: Re: Benchmarks
Message-ID: <"MS5(2020)+GLXLIB1(1056)" 11791941549.33.300.4495 at DEC-MARLBORO>
Regarding: Message from Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
of 7-Jan-82 1852-EST
I am in the process of doing the benchmarks; JONL was referring to some VERY
preliminary info. I expect write a report on my results and will include you
in its distribution. I expect to be done within about a week, but my
schedule is very hectic and I can't guarantee it.
--------